One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: mightytiges on January 07, 2005, 10:38:48 PM

Title: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: mightytiges on January 07, 2005, 10:38:48 PM
Who when they first started did you think would make it but flopped at Richmond?

Mine were:

Craig Smith from around the late 80's/early 90's - skillful as a youngster but didn't do much at senior level.
Barry Young - did alright at the bombers. He needed to play in a good side. Got frustrated at Tigerland.
Paddy Steinfort - injury prone over 5 years  :(.
Dragga - 2 consecutive knee recos put an end to that  :(.
Pettifer  ;D - 3 goals in his first game. Remember the roar from the supporters. It's been a different roar since lol.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Fishfinger on January 07, 2005, 11:12:58 PM
Justin Plapp.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: JohnF on January 07, 2005, 11:25:53 PM
Richo and Ottens.

Thought Richo would be a world beater after 1996. By 2000 I had totally given up on him. Still a very good player but I thought he would be great.

After 2001 I thought Ottens was set to soar. He has done jack schit since and i have already pigeonholed him as an underachiever. A bt premature at his age I know. But I think the die has been cast.

Thought Pickering would be a gun too but he somewhat died in the arrs.
 
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: the_boy_jake on January 07, 2005, 11:47:31 PM
Definitely Ashley Plopp.

For some reason I thought Ashley Blurton was going to make the big time.

Merenda had the talent, but was unlucky with injuries.

Clinton King started pretty well and at that time we looked big winners from that deal IIRC.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: froars on January 08, 2005, 12:00:34 AM
For me, Stephen Ryan.
First season, was on fire - kicked about 45 goals or something playing on wing/half fwd, and a sad reflection on the team at the time was that he was our highest goal kicker for the year.
Second season - dud!
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: LondonTiger on January 08, 2005, 05:36:40 AM
Brett Mahoney - first bloke to be given 29 after KB I think...  From De La Selle and was meant to be a gun.
Richard Lounder - Biggus Dikcus - 6 goals and then a flop
Aaron Fiora - Pick 3..BWAAAHHHH - like an Andrew Walker if you ask me.. Saints problem now.
Matty Dundas - at least he won the lottery, Brodders and Butch were excellent though.
AND JAMIE ELLIOTT - the fiora of the 90s. 
Ty Esler and Pat Steinfort  - the great ruck promises.  Both duds and had to at one stage rely on getting Strawbs O'Dywer from Melb (and Dear - who was fantastic incidently).

- Just on that note the last time we drafted two recycled ruckman was 1994 - Dear and O'Dwyer (I think it was the same year).

We just missed the finals that year, and in 1995 made the prelim with some classic players.

Will this happen again???


Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: julzqld on January 08, 2005, 08:52:16 AM
I was one of the few people excited about Paul Hudson - and Justin Blumfield.  Ottens too looked promising after 2001.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Life goes on on January 08, 2005, 12:59:06 PM
No doubts, Jason Smith.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: HKTiger on January 08, 2005, 02:08:20 PM
Peter Laughlin - Could play CHF, CHB or FB
Ken Stonehouse - gun in the U19's and two who had no fear and tackled everything.  Couldn't get a kick in the ones.
Greg Naylor - sublime skills
Glynn Hewitt - 6 or 7 goals in in his first two games.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Bulluss on January 08, 2005, 07:40:26 PM
Michael Raidis- He was from SA and in his first year played the whole season in the two's. i remember watching him play at punt road before the seniors and he would always be showing plenty of leadership and direction on the field. He also used to contribute well to the team.

After his first season he got delisted.

I thought that he was going to be a future leader of the club.

Others would include:

Plappy, Steinfort and Morrison(currently on the lst)
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Fwoy3 on January 09, 2005, 05:18:09 AM
For me, Stephen Ryan.
First season, was on fire - kicked about 45 goals or something playing on wing/half fwd, and a sad reflection on the team at the time was that he was our highest goal kicker for the year.
Second season - dud!

Was worse Moisie...only about 31 or 32 goals  :banghead
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Fwoy3 on January 09, 2005, 05:20:32 AM
Greg Hamilton...thought he was destined to get a footy card  :lol

And Bruce Lennon too.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Life goes on on January 09, 2005, 07:07:16 AM
Greg Hamilton was the player in the late 80.s/early 90.s who ran onto the ground from the interchange with his tracksuit top on during the game. He ran 100 metres before he realised. He was keen !
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: WilliamPowell on January 09, 2005, 11:12:04 AM
Bruce Lennon by a mile - although he was finally starting to play some good footy and I think Northey or Jeans axed him :banghead - I don't think he dudded out I still reckon he was treated poorly

Wayne Hernamen from W.A. a.k.a Wayne Walkabout :P

Stehpen Mount - what happened to him after 1980/81 :-[

Kayne Pettifer is fast approaching "was gonna road" too :help
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: tiga on January 09, 2005, 03:26:35 PM

I too thought Plapp and Dragga were going to be good things. I also had high hopes for Paddy Steinfort.

Steven Jurica, Mark Merenda, Trent Nicholls from earlier days.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: WilliamPowell on January 13, 2005, 07:43:42 PM
Can I please now add Chris Pym ;D and Stephen Jurica :rollin :rollin

Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: missy on January 17, 2005, 04:32:57 PM
Brett Evans, the birdman really flew a few times, and kicked some good goals.
I also wonder what Justin Charles would've become if he didn't do what he did :-\
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Struggletown on January 17, 2005, 04:42:38 PM
Stevan Jackson
Justin Plapp
and a bit off track I though Mc Kee would become a good player too.
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: The Plow King on January 17, 2005, 04:55:25 PM
Justin Charles was a big dissapontment.I expected him to becomne the best ruckmen in the AFL.

Dragga should've been alot better.Just had bad luck I guess.

Rodan I expected to be alot better than he's turned out to be.Hopefully he's a late bloomer.

Booogieknights is the most dissapointing though.I imagine his parents are rather embarrassed. :cheers
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Life goes on on January 17, 2005, 05:01:37 PM
Yes, I would think that Boogie has somewhat under achieved playing C grade ammo,s ;)

On a serios note, was watchinga tape of Craig Ednie the other night, he should of made although his size was the problem, real live wire
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Struggletown on January 17, 2005, 06:00:18 PM


Booogieknights is the most dissapointing though.I imagine his parents are rather embarrassed. :cheers

C grade ammos is better than C Block Pentridge,they should delighted!
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Life goes on on January 17, 2005, 09:15:42 PM
You can now buy a nice pad where C - Block once stood ;)
I reckon the ammo,s is great footy actually
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: Ox on January 17, 2005, 09:33:37 PM
You can now buy a nice pad where C - Block once stood ;)


LMAOOO@Bringing chicks back to give them a rodgering in the old"Jika Jika"
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: froars on January 17, 2005, 09:37:38 PM
Quote
You can now buy a nice pad where C - Block once stood

Speaking of C Block, Bubba sends his best wishes to Jackstar :rollin
Title: Re: Which players did you think would make it big but didn't?
Post by: JohnF on January 17, 2005, 11:13:09 PM
You can now buy a nice pad where C - Block once stood ;)


LMAOOO@Bringing chicks back to give them a rodgering in the old"Jika Jika"

ROOOOFOFLMFAOOOOOx

Mate of mine bought a pad in pentridge and is starting a life there with a stripper. ROFLFMLFMAOOOOOO@that one ending in tears.

I'll have to ask him if he gives her an old prison-style rodgering.