One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 18, 2012, 07:37:00 PM
-
Griffiths most likely out with concussion unless he makes a similar quick recovery as Hawkins did.
Fire away...?
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
-
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
-
Thought Post played his best game for the club today...Did I miss something here?
I still think he hopeless but played with a hell of allot more endeavor than some!
-
I thought Post first quarter was the best quarter he has played for the club.
I'm with you TFT yes he is an average footballer but was by no means shameful today.
-
Yep. I guess even if he kicked 8 people would still call for him to come out
-
Dimma said Batchelor will play next week.
-
Last night Post impacts a contest far more than any other of our KPP. You'd drop Jack before Post with the way we kick into F50 - he'd bring the ball to ground more than Jack and take more i50 marks. Hes field kicking and kicking are poor but avoid giving him a choice by playing exclusively inside 50. "put the ball through hoop chief"
-
Batchelor in for Griff....that's all folks.
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn.
He has been at the club 1 more year than Astbury and Griffiths. You ever heard of getting young talls to 50 games? You'll actually see he has good skills when his confidence is there. Dropping a young tall who needs games is the call of the dumb 8)
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn
Seriously, shut up. I thought Posty was okay but stuff me, you wonder why people give you poo when you get on here chirping off saying your favourite player is "great". You never learn. Bugger off to Big Footy
:cheers
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn
Seriously, shut up. I thought Posty was okay but stuff me, you wonder why people give you poo when you get on here chirping off saying your favourite player is "great". You never learn. Bugger off to Big Footy
:cheers
Stuff you lol
Everyone is wanting our talls to be champions after 20 games. I reckon they should take a look in the mirror
-
Plays a great game and you want him dropped.
Great game? By that I take it you mean by comparison to his usual efforts. He was mediocre.
-
Seems like Posty get's the blame here no matter what.Holds his place for me as does O'Hanlon.Dusty needs a kick in the bum with his poor play and turnovers,seems we turn a blind eye for him.White and McGuane all out to.
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn
Seriously, shut up. I thought Posty was okay but stuff me, you wonder why people give you poo when you get on here chirping off saying your favourite player is "great". You never learn. Bugger off to Big Footy
:cheers
Stuff you lol
Everyone is wanting our talls to be champions after 20 games. I reckon they should take a look in the mirror
Hey, no need to start with the insults. That's just a sign of losing the argument. And I think Jayden was alright last night. Just don't come on here with the "he's great, you're all dumb lol stuff you guys lol " rubbish
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn
Seriously, shut up. I thought Posty was okay but stuff me, you wonder why people give you poo when you get on here chirping off saying your favourite player is "great". You never learn. Bugger off to Big Footy
:cheers
Stuff you lol
Everyone is wanting our talls to be champions after 20 games. I reckon they should take a look in the mirror
Hey, no need to start with the insults. That's just a sign of losing the argument. And I think Jayden was alright last night. Just don't come on here with the "he's great, you're all dumb lol stuff you guys lol " rubbish
For me last couple of weeks have seen a few positive signs from Posty and I think that's cofidence issue with him.He was our best KP player yesterday by a mile.Cant justify having McGuane in the team and dropping Posty.
-
Out: McGuane, Griffiths
In: Astbury, Batchelor
-
AStbury season this year is a right off.Coming back from serious injury.By all reports been turning it over alot at the Burgers.
-
Outs - Post, O'Hanlon, McGuane
Ins - Dea, Batchelor, Derrickx
Ins: Dea, Batchelor
Outs: Post (did I read the Age correctly he was named in the best; please), Griffiths (concussion)
I'd drop O'Hanlon too but I don't hink we have anyone to replace him with unless Arnott gets a go despite having missed 3-4 weeks with a hammy
Post? lol
Plays a great game and you want him dropped. You guys never learn
Seriously, shut up. I thought Posty was okay but stuff me, you wonder why people give you poo when you get on here chirping off saying your favourite player is "great". You never learn. Bugger off to Big Footy
:cheers
Stuff you lol
Everyone is wanting our talls to be champions after 20 games. I reckon they should take a look in the mirror
Hey, no need to start with the insults. That's just a sign of losing the argument. And I think Jayden was alright last night. Just don't come on here with the "he's great, you're all dumb lol stuff you guys lol " rubbish
Nah I'm fed up with the unrealistic demands of our supporters, the blindness and the brainless comments. If he club started giving him games earlier this year and didn't drop him a couple of times last year, he'd be on 50 games and playing really good footy. He's naturally skilled on either foot but as a young bloke who is trying to make it, he is nervous and does the odd mistake. We all should see this by now if we all go to games all year and every year. He has perfect size for a key tall and has a great mark and leap with skill which will come through with another 20 games. But nah, our supporters are dumb. Dud, Delist lol. That's the only 2 words they know. They want him dropped after yesterday rather than improving him with more games and actually filling a hole in defence considering Grimes and Griffiths miss alot of games. He can also play forward and the last time I looked we've only had 1 tall forward for 10 weeks. Reiwoldt. Vickery will be the 2nd tall but we need a 3rd. Post is a vital link in the chain and more games=improvement. But nah. DUD, DELIST. That's what I have to deal with too often 8)
-
Ins .Moore and Miller and Browne
Outs.Nahas McGaune.Ohanlon
-
Ins .Moore and Miller and Browne
Outs.Nahas McGaune.Ohanlon
:huh
Browney's the only one still on the list.
-
Give the other 2 send off games
There been on the beers last few days
That should do the trick
-
Wgaf...rest the stars play the crap now..
-
Wgaf...rest the stars play the crap now..
?? You clearly haven't been watching many games lately have you :lol
We have been playing the Crap for he last 10 rounds :wallywink
-
Batchelor in for Griff....that's all folks.
Agreed. I think Griffiths needs another 1-3 years to mature properly so I would be giving him a rest and prepping him for next year. Needs muscle.
Post played his best game for RFC, I'd give him two last opportunities to achieve a miracle and convince me to keep him at the club after five years.
McGuane clearly had a crap game, should have had 2-3 goals. But he has shown he can kick goals and with Miller now retired I don't know who I'd replace him with. Very little to be gained from dropping him.
O'Hanlon needs more game time. Too early to make any judgement on his career, so with the season effectively over I'd just be giving him game time while we can.
White wasn't super nor shamed. But he clearly had a crack.
-
Bring in Batchelor for Griffiths(injury). Would like to see Astbury play but accept unlikely
-
Footy Barometer - Round 22
Herald-Sun
August 20, 2012
RICHMOND
ON THE BLOCK: Like last week and the week before, the Tigers are looking fairly settled again. Jayden Post played well in the west and should be safe, while the likes of Brad Helbig and Daniel Jackson were also solid. Could Luke McGuane be forced to pay full price after missing three sitters? Griffiths must pass a concussion test to play Friday night but he should be fine.
ON THE CUSP: Tigers fans… look away now. Just like last week, very little. Coburg was more competitive but fell again, this time to Geelong, in its final match of the season. Addam Maric was OK while Jake Batchelor returned to place himself in the mix for a recall.
SAM LANDSBERGER’S FORECAST: The Tigers have a great chance to showcase to the footy world that they have in fact improved this season with a Friday night blockbuster against Essendon. After that it’s Port Adelaide at the MCG, so Richmond should finish the season 11-11, with a strong percentage and the lowest average losing margin in the league. Nice. Brownlow night would become a lot more exciting if Trent Cotchin could finish the year with 70 touches, while memo Jack Riewoldt: Get selfish! He sits four goals behind Pav on the Coleman chart and needs a bag to leap back into contention. You can bet that’ll be the talking point entering the Power match – can Jack mow down Pavlich’s final figure?
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/supercoach-news/footy-barometer-round-22/story-fncufbo5-1226454249161
-
Out: 'Whispers' McG, Greggles
In: Dave, Batchelor
-
With Kingy (toe) and Griffiths (conc.) to miss that's two forced changes. Batchelor will be one of the inclusions. Who will be the other?
-
Out: 'Whispers' McG, Greggles
In: Dave, Batchelor
You know the hammy would go after one lead.
-
Wouldn't mind seeing Arnott given a go just for the sake of it
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
By Paul Daffey
Tall defender Ben Griffiths will miss the match with concussion. His replacement might be Jake Batchelor, David Astbury or Todd Elton. Astbury is yet to play a senior game since returning from a knee reconstruction mid-season. His form with the Coburg Tigers hasn't been brilliant but the Tigers might want to encourage him. Todd Elton's form with Coburg has also been indifferent, but he might be included because he can play at both ends.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/145221/default.aspx
-
Who said Todd Elton can play both ends? Just play him forward!
-
Astbury will play, Coburg report said he was pushing for selection in the Richmond side.