One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: pmac21 on March 29, 2018, 10:32:23 PM
-
You can merge this later but changes for next week
Bolton, Conca, Grigg, Castagna all out
Prestia, Soldo, Miles, Moore
-
Really hope Hardwick makes changes so that players realise you have to fight to keep your spot. Conca has to go, CEllis doesn't contribute much and Bolton too worried about featuring in the highlight reel. Whatever statistic they use to measure player performance will tell the story but at least 4 changes for mine.
-
See enough of Bolton
-
Conca, MacIntosh, Bolton and Cellis out
Prestia, Miles, Higgins and Moore in
-
I can't understand what's the love for Conca from Dimma.Our Vfl team plenty of depth there and players in form Miles,Higgins,Chor,Moore.
I think we a one tall short need to mix it up a bit Dimma.Either Chor or Moore to help Nank and play forward aslong as there contributing play one.
-
Out of the three mosquitoes, Bolton did better than Butler and Castagna and impacted the scoreboard unlike the other two more seasoned premiership players.
Jack was worse than all of them though.
If I was dropping any of them it would be Castagna
-
Miles never ever shirks, wtf is he not in. there were so many of ours were squibbing it up made me angry. No point saving yourself if you are losing ffs. Lloyd as well. If some of ours think they are prima donnas now they got a medal, time for some vfl, let the unlucky ones have a stuffing run and we will see some friggen effort.
-
Jack wouldn't be happy with some of his efforts. Back to the sooky days tonight
-
Hooter me old China, Miles is slow, doesn't tackle and Lloyd's as unnaccountable & selfish as they come...
Out: Bolton, CEllis, McIntosh, Conca
In: Moore, Prestia, Garthwaite, Higgins
EDIT: forgot about Vlastuin...swap him for Garthwaite...
-
Take ya pick of plenty cos I can't be stuffed makin a call on any of them.
Too many costly errors, UNFORCED ERRORS at that :banghead :banghead
-
Out: Conca. Macintosh. Castagna.
Ins: Prestia. Vlaustin. Any one of the M’s dependant on team balance (Miles, Moore, Menadue, Markov).
I still don’t know why many want Bolton dropped when he was better then the other three,
Jack included.
-
Season's over.....play the kids....
-
Sack the coach...who's training well?
FFS i hate Adelaide, Tex Walker looks like a VW with 2 open doors, you would think they won the granny.
Out B Ellis, in Lloyd, out Conca, in Miles, happy with Bolton, but if you need to change in Stengle.
Gee i hate Adelaide....sorry I already said that.
-
INS: Vlastuin, Prestia, Higgins or Miles (cant decide)
OUTS: Conca, Bolton, C Ellis
Would actually like to see Balta come in for Castagna
-
Out: c Ellis, Bolton,
Double out: conca
In: Prestia, vlastuin, Higgins
-
Can we tell the AFL to get stuffed and bring Broad back in?
:lol
-
INS: Vlastuin, Prestia, Higgins or Miles (cant decide)
OUTS: Conca, Bolton, C Ellis
Would actually like to see Balta come in for Castagna
Totally agree
Especially with Bolton
Gets lead into the contests by his opponent
Can play , but doesn’t read game well at the moment
-
Not sure who needs to make way but man we need vlastuin Prestia back in asap. Wouldn't mind another contested ball Winner in miles also
-
In: Vlastuin, Prestia
Out: Conca, CEllis
-
Vlaustin Prestia and maybe Stengel
-
Stengle would at the very least be an upgrade on CEllis.....would pick Menadue first though....
-
Stengle needs to be given a good run of games
-
As does Menadue....and Moore....
-
Honestly, these players need to be dropped;
Grigg
B Ellis
Conca
C Ellis
McIntosh
Bolton - has played less than 10 matches ...
Not enough coming out of Butler or Castanga
OUT - IN
Caddy (suspended) - Prestia
Conca - Vlastuin
C Ellis - Balta or Moore
On notice - Townsend, 3 smalls
i would risk Higgins for Bolton ...
-
You can drop players all day and agree with Bellis and Conca, but i think that the game plan suffered against Adelaide.
When playing against a TALL team we need to bring the ball in LOW and we kept playing the ball high.
I think Bolton needs more game time, he does some nice things and is lively.
We will have a massive test against Hawthorn which will really test us.
Team selection is critical as we want to tell all our players that their selection needs to be earned.
-
Small worked last year and we were the perfect storm, but we need to develop talls ASAP.
Cows played it well and we weren't to clever, interesting game coming up against the hawks.
I would cut the Broad suspension by a week, don't say nothing no one will notice. :shh
Prestia straight back in
-
Can we tell the AFL to get stuffed and bring Broad back in?
:lol
We can certainly tell them to get stuffed but seeing they weren't the ones who suspended him; we were then no he wont be playing
-
I love a good over reaction to a loss, a few more and we should even get some of the lurking doctors back and posting again.
LMAO @ Townsend on notice
-
I love a good over reaction to a loss, a few more and we should even get some of the lurking doctors back and posting again.
LMAO @ Townsend on notice
I miss the conferences/conventions that we could stage with all those docs! :)
-
Is Chol ready?
Him and Nank could swap between ruck and FF.
:cheers
-
Is Chol ready?
Him and Nank could swap between ruck and FF.
:cheers
Close ? Probably needs one stand out game
-
Out:
C. Ellis
Conca
Caddy
In:
Vlastuin
Menadue
Chol or Moore
-
Miles in for Caddy
Vlastuin in for either Conca or C.Ellis
Also is Prestia fit?
-
Miles in for Caddy
Vlastuin in for either Conca or C.Ellis
Also is Prestia fit?
is conca or has he ever been?
half a leg meatball is better than that spud
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
Good changes!
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
Good changes!
Do we not want Tigger back in the side?
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
Good changes!
Do we not want Tigger back in the side?
Yes we definitely do! Takes menadues place as an in.
-
Outs for me after 3-4 days would b:
Caddy (susp)
Conca
Bolton
Castagna
In
Miles
Vlastuin
Prestia
Soldo
Need some grunt back in. C Eliis very lucky but play him as a mid not a defender....
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
Good changes!
Do we not want Tigger back in the side?
Yes.
He comes in for MacIntosh.
-
I’d be wary of making too many changes
In: Vlas, Prestia, Moore
Out: Conca, Cellis, Caddy
-
I’d be wary of making too many changes
In: Vlas, Prestia, Moore
Out: Conca, Cellis, Caddy
I know what you are saying BUT those players mentioned have not played well at all this year. We must reward form showed in the seconds (albeit in practice matches). Also those mentioned all have senior experience except for Higgo.
I love Macca but he has been awful so far this year. Menadue would be an upgrade. We were thrashed in conrested ball now in both games. Bring in both contested ball beasts in Miles and Prestia. Bolton needs a run in the seconds. Bring in a debutant. We are one of the few sides who haven't done so so far.
-
Sicily can accept a week
-
Could be wrong but pretty sure Conca's only ever lost his place in the seniors through injury or suspension - can't recall him ever being dropped on form?
-
Could be wrong but pretty sure Conca's only ever lost his place in the seniors through injury or suspension - can't recall him ever being dropped on form?
Well if that's the case we cannot go to the next level as a team carrying players like him and Dimma can't go back tohis old ways gifting games.We have got better players in form who I rather see.Miles,Menadue and Markov.
-
In the mix: round three
Jennifer Phelan
afl.com.au
Apr 3, 2018 5:12PM
RICHMOND
Get them in: It's getting harder to ignore small forward/midfielder Jack Higgins with the first-round draft pick from last year catching the eye again in a VFL hit-out on the weekend. Higgins had 22 disposals, took six marks, laid five tackles and kicked a goal to cap off an impressive summer. With Josh Caddy out, Higgins, who was an emergency last week, could get his chance, or Callum Moore or Ivan Soldo if they want to maintain a bit more height. Connor Menadue has also shown good form in the VFL off half-back.
Under the pump: There'll be one enforced change with Caddy suspended, but others could pay the price for the Tigers' loss to the Crows. Shai Bolton has been quiet in his two games this season with just one goal while Reece Conca and Corey Ellis could be in the gun for the second week running after limited contribution.
Medical room: Nick Vlastuin should play provided he gets through training and passes fitness tests after missing last week with delayed concussion symptoms. Dion Prestia played two and a bit quarters of a VFL practice match in his first competitive hit-out for 2018 and is over the hamstring injury that derailed his pre-season. Given his lack of summer training, he's likely to need more minutes at VFL level. Caddy is out for a week while Nathan Broad has one more to go on his club sanction.
Verdict: They've got to make at least one change – too many more could appear a kneejerk reaction to their first loss since round 21 last year. Two seems plausible, with Vlastuin and Higgins to come in for Caddy and Corey Ellis.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-04-03/in-the-mix-round-three
-
In:
Miles
Prestia
Menadue
Higgins/Stengle
Out:
Caddy
Bolton
CEllis
Conca
Good changes!
x2! Good call
I especially want to see more of Higgins, very exciting young fella.
-
Out
B Ellis
Conca
Caddy
In
Miles
Prestia
Stengle
-
Expect Nick Vlastuin to play this week after missing with concussion symptoms and Daniel Rioli is looking to be available within the next month, having resumed running. Dion Prestia got through a game in the VFL and should be available for selection this week pending match fitness.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/04/04/orazio-duncan-and-wingard-get-the-latest-injury-news-here/
-
Higgins is in!
-
On the RFC website
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2018-04-05/higgins-to-debut (http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2018-04-05/higgins-to-debut)
:cheers
-
Expect Nick Vlastuin to play this week after missing with concussion symptoms and Daniel Rioli is looking to be available within the next month, having resumed running. Dion Prestia got through a game in the VFL and should be available for selection this week pending match fitness.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/04/04/orazio-duncan-and-wingard-get-the-latest-injury-news-here/
At the Rioli clinic Nick said he is playing this week.