One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on March 28, 2024, 07:17:54 PM
-
In: M.Rioli, Naishmith, Broad, Sonsie, Young
Out: Clarke (omitted), Trezise (ankle)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
Richmond squad
B: Dylan Grimes Nathan Broad Nick Vlastuin
HB: Jayden Short Tom Brown Daniel Rioli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Tim Taranto Marlion Pickett
HF: Seth Campbell Shai Bolton Rhyan Mansell
F: Noah Balta Dustin Martin Tom Lynch
R: Toby Nankervis Jack Ross Liam Baker
Int (from): Tyler Sonsie Thomson Dow Sam Banks Maurice Rioli
Mykelti Lefau Sam Naismith Ben Miller Tylar Young
Richmond will confirm its final Round 3 team on Friday night at 5.00pm AEDT.
The Club will then name its substitute 60 minutes prior to the first bounce on Sunday.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1516573/
-
I don't understand why McAuliffe wasn't picked to debut!
-
In: M.Rioli, Naishmith, Broad, Sonsie, Young
Out: Clarke (omitted), Trezise (ankle)
Source: RFC twitter.
This is worse than Dimma FFS. No McAuliffe and Banks kept for Clarke. FMD
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
-
Absolutely laughable
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
Apart from Dusty and Grimes; Newman wasn't a team mate to any of the current list
-
So Broad and Young will definitely come in, I wonder if Sonsie comes in for Lefau?
-
No matter how bad we go, I am we do have Daniher at our club
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
Apart from Dusty and Grimes; Newman wasn't a team mate to any of the current list
McIntosh.... :shh
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
Apart from Dusty and Grimes; Newman wasn't a team mate to any of the current list
McIntosh.... :shh
He didn't play a game with Kmac so he wasn't a team mate ;D
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
Apart from Dusty and Grimes; Newman wasn't a team mate to any of the current list
McIntosh.... :shh
He didn't play a game with Kmac so he wasn't a team mate ;D
They played 17 games together in 2015.... :shh :shh
-
You guys are truely unbelievable. A pick 40 had one good game, their first game, and you want him
Picked ? Kane will play this year, just let him get some confidence at vfl level
-
You guys are truely unbelievable. A pick 40 had one good game, their first game, and you want him
Picked ? Kane will play this year, just let him get some confidence at vfl level
You seen how we're travelling? Think it's just about McAuliffe? (not sure why you keep bringing up his draft position either)... :shh
-
We are officially tanking - it’s the only explanation why Dow hasn’t been omitted.
-
Strongly suspect there's still a few people from the Hardwick era with too much influence....Yze needs to clear them out at the end of they year...even if it's blokes like Newman & Lambert who are probably loathe to give any negative feedback regarding old team mates... :shh
Got a feeling Tim Livingstone having to much influence.
-
I'll be livid if Miller is dropped to.
-
Me feel so sad
-
Not one senior player dropped :banghead kids taking the wrap for there poor form.
-
Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.
-
Martin ruled out of Swans clash
Coach Adem Yze has this ruled Dustin Martin out of Sunday's Round 3 clash against Sydney in this morning's press conference.
By Richmond Media
2 hrs ago
Dustin Martin has been ruled out of Sunday's Round 3 clash against Sydney with calf soreness.
Coach Adem Yze confirmed to media on Friday morning that Martin was still managing a recent calf issue, which saw him miss the Tigers' Opening Round clash against Gold Coast.
"Dusty's going to miss this week," Yze said.
"He's had an interrupted week, he's had an interrupted couple of weeks with his calf. He didn't train the other day. He will only do a little bit today.
"We've got to break the pattern of him getting through week to week.
"We're going to break that cycle this week and give him a light week so that he's pain free.
"His first half last week was terrific but you can see that he still gets a bit sore."
Yze said he expects Martin to be available for next week's Gather Round clash with St Kilda.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1517082/martin-ruled-out-of-swans-clash
-
Just watched Yze's presser
He mentioned the Grimes is a little sore and needs to get through training like Broad
-
Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.
Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.
Not one senior player dropped :banghead kids taking the wrap for there poor form.
People know the last 3 or 4 seasons ive been adamant we play kids over oldies and that has not changed.
I still say its time to get games into as many kids as possible regardless of current form. We need to find out who is worth keeping.
Truth is most of our kids are not producing enough to demand or warrant constant selection when they have got games.
Yes i agree with the sentiment, older players are putting in horrid performances as well and are keeping their spots.
I agree It is here where we are constantly going wrong. Surely for where we are at on the clock the kids have to get priority.
Play a poor performing senior or play the under performing kid that is where we are at. This is what its come to.
For where we are at, imo we are not going to make the 8, and even if they some how manage that miracle they are not going to win anything. Most likely bottom 6 is the reality imo.
Rather than play older blokes who we can already make a call on who consistenly fall below the required standard, back the kids in and find out what they are made of. Yep it will probably mean a few beltings.
Trouble is we can honestly ask what quality juniors do we have? that is kids aged 18 - 21. We have just 12 and all of them fall into the
0 - 20 games played bracket.
Imo At this stage only Gibcus does not have question marks about him and a few others do look likely who have good attributes for the game. Kids like Sonsie Clarke Brown McAuliffe and others should be given every opportunity to play seniors.
The next tier is our 22 - 24 year olds. This is where our problems begin.
You can say only Balta is high quality to date. With only Ross being able to properly establish himself.
Even he has people, me included questioning what his role is. Is it wing or is it mid. Does he do enough in either Role. They are the only two who have 50 plus games to their names from this group..
Ralphsmith Koschitzke and Mansell are the only others who have managed to reach 30 games thats just 5 of 13 and the latter three have huge question marks about them going by most discussions around here.. The obvious question is are we putting games into blokes who will take us nowhere or even make it?
This is supposed to be the group who are most expected to push out the mature players and vets and most are struggling to establish themselves.
Imo the 22 - 24 group is the one we need to focus on. The following unlike the juniors don't have a lot of time.
Okay 22 - 24 yr olds
MRJ - 29 games.
OH-B - 0 games.
Colina - 0 games
Dow - 20 games.
Mansell - 34 games
Ralphsmith - 32 games
Ryan - 16 games
Miller - 26 games
Cumberland 18 games
Koschitzke 48 games plus 1 with us
Coulthard 4 games.
Leaving Balta and Ross from this group none have managed to establish themselves as permanent fixtures in the seniors.
They all have serious questions about their long term viability. All are at an age/development where they should be getting regular games or are absolutely banging the door down and neither is really happening.
A genuine question. If the 11 players in the list were cut, say over the next two seasons. who could honestly say they would be surprised given form consistency and obvious deficiencies.
Atm imo at best we have depth or role players who we should be aiming for upgrades on.
Any way this week.
B: Vlastuin - Young - Grimes
HB: Rioli - Miller - Mansell
C: Pickett - McAuliffe - Broad
R:Nankervis - Martin - Bolton
HF: Campbell - Balta - Sonsie
F: Naismith - Lynch - Cumberland
Int: Taranto - Ross - Baker - Short - Lefau.
-
Surely it is McAuliffe time No hopper No Dusty even no Prestia who is short in stature but as solid as they come.
Nope it will be a skinny flanker you can just see it happening.
-
No Dusty, no Grimes.
-
No Dusty, no Grimes.
McAullife and HRS into the extended squad
-
Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.
Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.
With Grimes out, they probably both have to play, but IMO it's sub-optimal. You want at least one of your KPDs to be an intercept marking guy. Neither Miller nor Young are that. The Sydney small forwards will have a field day. Papley to kick 6+.
-
Round 3 squad update
Richmond has made two changes to its squad of 26 for Sunday’s Round 3 match against Sydney.
By Richmond Media
3 hrs ago
Richmond has made two changes to its squad of 26 for Sunday’s match against Sydney, including a potential debutant.
Dustin Martin was ruled out on Friday morning with calf soreness, while Dylan Grimes has been withdrawn from the squad with an injured wrist.
Exciting young talent Kane McAuliffe comes into the squad of 26 after an impressive outing at VFL level last weekend.
Selected at pick 40 in the 2023 AFL National Draft, the 19-year-old has had a strong start in the Yellow and Black, collecting 31 disposals and a goal in the Tigers' win over the Gold Coast.
"He had an outstanding game as an inside midfielder and drove the ball inside 50 on a number of occasions," VFL coach Steve Morris said.
"He used the ball well on the day and hit the scoreboard."
McAulife joins Hugo Ralphsmith in the updated squad to replace Martin and Grimes.
22-year-old Ralphsmith played 13 games at AFL level in 2023 and was instrumental in last week's VFL win, gathering 25 disposals and nine marks.
"He's in fantastic form, he's strung a great month together," Morris said of Ralpsmith's performance.
"He's using the ball really well and his run and carry off half-back is really eye catching.
"His defensive work has improved immensely also."
Richmond will confirm its team of 23 and three emergencies tonight at 5pm.
Richmond Squad of 26 to face Sydney Swans (UPDATED)
In: Maurice Rioli, Sam Naishmith, Nathan Broad, Tyler Sonsie, Tylar Young, Hugo Ralpshmith, Kane McAuliffe
Out: Judson Clarke (omitted), James Trezise (ankle), Dustin Martin (calf), Dylan Grimes (wrist)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1517126/round-3-squad-update
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
-
He was good in the 2’s , hope he grabs his chance
-
Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.
Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.
With Grimes out, they probably both have to play, but IMO it's sub-optimal. You want at least one of your KPDs to be an intercept marking guy. Neither Miller nor Young are that. The Sydney small forwards will have a field day. Papley to kick 6+.
You still need talls to combat the three talls Sydney go with in McDonald, Amarty, and McClean. Which now will be Young, Miller and Broad. We have Balta up our sleeve if it gets out of hand. Its down to the likes of Rioli Vlastuin Broad to combat their smaller players.
along with help from the mids.
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.
You didn’t have him in your “ins”
-
Hope Sonsie has a really good game
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.
You didn’t have him in your “ins”
Nice try.
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.
You didn’t have him in your “ins”
Nice try.
Wtf are you talking about ???
As per the following
YOU DIDNT HAVE HIM IN YOUR INS
:cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers
Ins: Young , Broad, Naismith, Sonsie , Cumberland.
Outs: Dow, Grimes, Banks, McIntosh, Short. Pickett/Short?.
Cmon people what harm can it do Giving Lefau another run. It was not an ideal situation with how he got his debut.
-
Richmond
B: Tylar Young Nathan Broad Nick Vlastuin
HB: Jayden Short Tom Brown Daniel Rioli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Tim Taranto Marlion Pickett
HF: Seth Campbell Rhyan Mansell Maurice Rioli
F: Noah Balta Shai Bolton Tom Lynch
R: Toby Nankervis Jack Ross Liam Baker
Int: Tyler Sonsie Thomson Dow Sam Banks Ben Miller Mykelti Lefau
Emg: Hugo Ralphsmith Kane McAuliffe Sam Naismith
The Club will then name its substitute 60 minutes prior to the first bounce on Sunday.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1517173/four-changes-for-easter-sunday-clash
-
Our senior players are immune to criticism keep on getting picked puzzling. Get the games into the kids with the senior players performing the rest spend time in the vfl.
-
Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.
Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.
Not one senior player dropped :banghead kids taking the wrap for there poor form.
[/quote
Any way this week.
B: Vlastuin - Young - Grimes
HB: Rioli - Miller - Mansell
C: Pickett - McAuliffe - Broad
R:Nankervis - Martin - Bolton
HF: Campbell - Balta - Sonsie
F: Naismith - Lynch - Cumberland
Int: Taranto - Ross - Baker - Short - Lefau.
Surely it is McAuliffe time No hopper No Dusty even no Prestia who is short in stature but as solid as they come.
Nope it will be a skinny flanker you can just see it happening.
In this thread alone. Not sure what your point is
-
Final INS and OUTS
Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT
RICHMOND
Okay i will bite in just about every thread this week ive been talking him up and demanding he play. But a simple brain fade over looking the obvious had me miss him out in team selection and your all over it..
Apologies i thought you were being well a dick head. Seems we have to beliteral and correct with absolutely everything we say around here at times.
In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)
SYDNEY
In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant
Great to see Sonsie get a chance
Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.
You didn’t have him in your “ins”
Nice try.
Wtf are you talking about ???
As per the following
YOU DIDNT HAVE HIM IN YOUR INS
:cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers :cheers
Ins: Young , Broad, Naismith, Sonsie , Cumberland.
Outs: Dow, Grimes, Banks, McIntosh, Short. Pickett/Short?.
Cmon people what harm can it do Giving Lefau another run. It was not an ideal situation with how he got his debut.
as i said i have talked him up at just about every opportunity and i know you have seen myb posts so what is your problem.
Big deal i left him out in one thread an over sight but hey i bet you don't have those moments.