One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 15, 2010, 05:10:54 PM
-
Melbourne
B: James McDonald, Matthew Warnock, James Frawley
HB: Cameron Bruce, Colin Garland, Lynden Dunn
C: Jack Trengove, Aaron Davey, Clint Bartram
HF: Brad Green, Ricky Petterd, Nathan Jones
F: Colin Sylvia, Matthew Bate, Rohan Bail
Foll: Mark Jamar, Jack Grimes, Brent Moloney
I/C (from): Joel MacDonald, Jordie McKenzie, Tom Scully, Jamie Bennell. Michael Newton, Kyle Cheney, Jake Spencer
In: Sylvia, Cheney, Spencer
Out: -
Note: Richmond, Melbourne, the Geelong Cats, Port Adelaide, St Kilda and Fremantle will confirm their final sides (22 plus three emergencies) from 5pm AEST on Friday.
-
Richmond v Melbourne
Sunday April 18
MCG, 1.10pm
B: Shane Edwards, Alex Rance, Matthew Dea
HB: Mitch Farmer, Kel Moore, Matt White
C: Dustin Martin, Brett Deledio, Trent Cotchin
HF: Troy Taylor, Jack Riewoldt, Mitch Morton
F: Ben Nason, Jayden Post, Richard Tambling
Foll: Troy Simmonds, Daniel Jackson, Shane Tuck
I/C (from): Ty Vickery, David Astbury, Jake King, Graham Polak, Robin Nahas, Tom Hislop, Andy Collins
In: Farmer, Astbury, Dea, Taylor, Nahas, King, Polak, Hislop, Collins
Out: Daniel Connors, Luke McGuane, Dean Polo, Ben Cousins (all club suspension), Chris Newman (inj - leg), Relton Roberts
-
sylvia always kills us , must keep him quiet
-
sylvia always kills us , must keep him quiet
Sacrifice Kingy for 6 weeks.
A short right to the chin before the siren. :lol
-
i would have moore at fb
post at chb
astbury at ff
rance at fb could be costly
centre line looks great
time for deledio and tambling to start owning games
fwd line looks much better
have a feeling we just may turn it on
-
sylvia always kills us , must keep him quiet
Sacrifice Kingy for 6 weeks.
A short right to the chin before the siren. :lol
bring back scotty turner lol
-
sylvia always kills us , must keep him quiet
Sacrifice Kingy for 6 weeks.
A short right to the chin before the siren. :lol
bring back scotty turner lol
LOL - Then the media would be able to report on some real serious drinking :cheers
-
For mine, the three to miss out would be: King-Hislop-and either Nahas or Collins. Keep bringing those kids in Dimma :thumbsup
-
From what Astbury did last week, i dont think he is ready physically to play a full game.
He didnt play the last qtr against Nth Ballarat so i would say he needs more conditioning before he plays seniors.
-
Rance at Full Back...
*sighs*
I suppose with Taylor and Astbury in that pushes Rance out of the forward line. His opponent will probably be Newton who isn't a footballers shoelace so should be a good match up that he should win.
Side looks pretty good. Anyone think Deledio could be tried as a Goddard/Shaw/Hodge/Kennally type off half back as a quarter back type player. Seems that all the really good sides have there best player running out of defence. Think it was tried before in one of a million roles tried for Deledio wouldn't mind seeing him try it for 4 weeks straight.
-
it's Dea and Taylor that are playing.
if they are named in the starting 18, they are playing!
this thread should be changed!
well done Dea and Taylor!
:)
-
Please don't tell me they will end up selecting the three miniature Musketeers again in King, Edwards and Farmer or I will throw something at my TV.
Great to see Dea and Taylor in, please boys make the most of your chances.
I/C : Ty Vickery, David Astbury, Graham Polak, Andy Collins
-
Would have to go back a long time to see a worse Tiger half back line than that.
-
I/C : Ty Vickery, David Astbury, Graham Polak, Andy Collins
At least with those 4 we add badly needed height, structure and flexibility with our talls.
Hopefully we don't see Kingy ever again and he plays out his final year at Coburg.
That backline the way it is named is highly skilled by foot isn't it :help.
-
Would have to go back a long time to see a worse Tiger half back line than that.
Surley White and Farmer won't line up on opposite flanks... :pray
-
I/C : Ty Vickery, David Astbury, Graham Polak, Andy Collins
At least with those 4 we add badly needed height, structure and flexibility with our talls.
Hopefully we don't see Kingy ever again and he plays out his final year at Coburg.
That backline the way it is named is highly skilled by foot isn't it :help.
Hardwick just needs to take a gamble on this game and not try to bandaid the holes with players like King that just have not got it with our structure. You are dead right about the backline, could be the difference with the amount of turnovers that lot could generate.. :scream
-
We've got to hope Rance at FB doesn't have another Launceston implosion :-\. The Dees don't have any star tall forwards so I'd guess we're hoping we can get away with just Rance and Moore in the key posts and the rest smalls. Posty may have to go down there if Alex and Kel struggle. Edwards and White should not be playing in defence. They are HFFers at best.
-
We've got to hope Rance at FB doesn't have another Launceston implosion :-\. The Dees don't have any star tall forwards so I'd guess we're hoping we can get away with just Rance and Moore in the key posts and the rest smalls. Posty may have to go down there if Alex and Kel struggle. Edwards and White should not be playing in defence. They are HFFers at best.
Rance really has the chance to stand up here doesn't he, agree with you on Edwards and White but IMHO Edwards should really be making hot dogs.. ;D I hope Dea can show a bit too. If anything maybe rotate Edwards and White through the forward line at some stage during the game.
-
We've got to hope Rance at FB doesn't have another Launceston implosion :-\. The Dees don't have any star tall forwards so I'd guess we're hoping we can get away with just Rance and Moore in the key posts and the rest smalls. Posty may have to go down there if Alex and Kel struggle. Edwards and White should not be playing in defence. They are HFFers at best.
Rance really has the chance to stand up here doesn't he, agree with you on Edwards and White but IMHO Edwards should really be making hot dogs.. ;D I hope Dea can show a bit too. If anything maybe rotate Edwards and White through the forward line at some stage during the game.
Blingers and Dea off the HBFs for mine.
-
We've got to hope Rance at FB doesn't have another Launceston implosion :-\. The Dees don't have any star tall forwards so I'd guess we're hoping we can get away with just Rance and Moore in the key posts and the rest smalls. Posty may have to go down there if Alex and Kel struggle. Edwards and White should not be playing in defence. They are HFFers at best.
Rance really has the chance to stand up here doesn't he, agree with you on Edwards and White but IMHO Edwards should really be making hot dogs.. ;D I hope Dea can show a bit too. If anything maybe rotate Edwards and White through the forward line at some stage during the game.
Blingers and Dea off the HBFs for mine.
Now MT listen to this then, while I was watching Tony (I am a stuff wit) Shaw tonight on Fox League Teams Live tonight he said; He has no idea why Tambling plays out of the bacline because he can't play there and he is no good in the backline. He also said that Tambling should be played on the wing, through the centre and forward...I agree with you, I think he has played some of his BEST football as a rebounding back flanker...... Shaw is God though.. ::) :whistle
-
We've got to hope Rance at FB doesn't have another Launceston implosion :-\. The Dees don't have any star tall forwards so I'd guess we're hoping we can get away with just Rance and Moore in the key posts and the rest smalls. Posty may have to go down there if Alex and Kel struggle. Edwards and White should not be playing in defence. They are HFFers at best.
Rance really has the chance to stand up here doesn't he, agree with you on Edwards and White but IMHO Edwards should really be making hot dogs.. ;D I hope Dea can show a bit too. If anything maybe rotate Edwards and White through the forward line at some stage during the game.
Blingers and Dea off the HBFs for mine.
Now MT listen to this then, while I was watching Tony (I am a eff wit) Shaw tonight on Fox League Teams Live tonight he said; He has no idea why Tambling plays out of the bacline because he can't play there and he is no good in the backline. He also said that Tambling should be played on the wing, through the centre and forward...I agree with you, I think he has played some of his BEST football as a rebounding back flanker...... Shaw is God though.. ::) :whistle
Yep someone remind Tony where did Richie play his best footy last year ::).
-
Leave out Hislop, King and Farmer. A big blow Will not back in. Agree take a risk play the first gamers. It gives fans some hope. Play edwards up forward. Need to keep bates quite. Brett needs to dominate this game. He needs to impose himself. Trent hopefully will have a blinder. Agree with comments playing Tambling off backline. Play Polak at Centre Half Forward and put Post in the backline.
-
Post has to be the luckiest bloke in that team. Some of his efforts last week looked worse onthe replay than they did live at the game ;D
I would think he survived only because of the forced suspensions
Anyway I'd play Polak because he can play down back in a pich but more important as a forward will straigthen us up and give us a big body
Will confess to being staggered that Collins has made it to the extended I/C - he wasn't great last week disposal wise at Coburg. Nahas is the same, actually in Nahas' case was he playing last week at Coburg :rollin
-
Richmond
B: Shane Edwards, Alex Rance, Matthew Dea
HB: Mitch Farmer, Kelvin Moore, Matt White
C: Dustin Martin, Brett Deledio, Trent Cotchin
HF: Troy Taylor, Jack Riewoldt, Mitch Morton
F: Ben Nason, Jayden Post, Richard Tambling
Foll: Troy Simmonds, Daniel Jackson, Shane Tuck
I/C: Tyrone Vickery, David Astbury, Tom Hislop, Andrew Collins
Emg: Graham Polak, Jake King, Robin Nahas
In: Hislop, Collins, Farmer, Taylor, Astbury, Dea
Out: Chris Newman (leg), Luke McGuane (club susp), Dean Polo (club susp), Relton Roberts, Daniel Connors (club susp), Ben Cousins (club susp)
New: Troy Taylor (South Alice Springs/NT Thunder), Matthew Dea (North Ballarat), David Astbury (North Ballarat)
-
Melbourne
B: James McDonald, Matthew Warnock, James Frawley
HB: Cameron Bruce, Colin Garland, Lynden Dunn
C: Jack Trengove, Aaron Davey, Clint Bartram
HF: Brad Green, Ricky Petterd, Nathan Jones
F: Colin Sylvia, Matthew Bate, Rohan Bail
Foll: Mark Jamar, Jack Grimes, Brent Moloney
I/C: Joel Macdonald, Jordie McKenzie, Tom Scully, Jamie Bennell
Emg: Jake Spencer, Michael Newton, Kyle Cheney
In: Sylvia
Out: Michael Newton
-
I think we're still a fair chance at our first win.
Melbourne's team doesn't look much better than ours.
-
Gee, I don't know, I just can't do Farmer and Edwards in the backline together, two small, love the rest though, about time we tooks some risks and played our future!!!
-
Gee, I don't know, I just can't do Farmer and Edwards in the backline together, two small, love the rest though, about time we tooks some risks and played our future!!!
Dont forget Matty White ::)
-
why did we keep Polak on the list if he cant break into a weak team :banghead
Richmond is the only club that feels sorry for players & keeps Duds or broken players who give nothing back
-
why did we keep Polak on the list if he cant break into a weak team :banghead
Richmond is the only club that feels sorry for players & keeps Duds or broken players who give nothing back
Dead right, said it ages ago, why the hell did we promote him if we wern't going to play him from round one, should have waited or promoted Gourdis IMO.
-
Gee, I don't know, I just can't do Farmer and Edwards in the backline together, two small, love the rest though, about time we tooks some risks and played our future!!!
Dont forget Matty White ::)
:thumbsup
-
why did we keep Polak on the list if he cant break into a weak team :banghead
Richmond is the only club that feels sorry for players & keeps Duds or broken players who give nothing back
Dead right, said it ages ago, why the hell did we promote him if we wern't going to play him from round one, should have waited or promoted Gourdis IMO.
Would have prefered Gourdis his a backman
-
Certainly a worry that Polak can't break into a side with 6 Outs
-
Post has to be the luckiest bloke in that team. Some of his efforts last week looked worse onthe replay than they did live at the game ;D
I would think he survived only because of the forced suspensions
Anyway I'd play Polak because he can play down back in a pich but more important as a forward will straigthen us up and give us a big body
Will confess to being staggered that Collins has made it to the extended I/C - he wasn't great last week disposal wise at Coburg. Nahas is the same, actually in Nahas' case was he playing last week at Coburg :rollin
Yep I agree with this WP, Post is going through a reality adjustment in regards to what it takes to play at senior level he's blowing up under pressure, just like Rance blew up in Tasmania. It looks like they are out of their depth and in reality they are, but ground time and more games and good development they will become accustomed to the speed of the game and this will enable them to find more time and space and relax more.