One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 25, 2010, 11:55:13 PM
-
Fire away :help
-
We need to FORFEIT!
-
Out Injured , Tambling and Taylor ( would of dropped both anyway ) :banghead
Dea
Reiwoldt.
Ins, Polo , Morton, and the other two dont matter, as we have been playing 2 short by playing Dea and Reiwoldt anyway
-
Jack deserves a rest for that effort Dea gets a week back and where was astbury tonight? not an insider so how far away are Will and Jackson?
-
OUT: Tambling(inj), Taylor(inj), Dea(omit), Riewoldt(omit), Astbury(omit)
IN: Jackson, Polo, King, Thursfield, Webberley
-
OUT: Tambling(inj), Taylor(inj), Dea(omit), Riewoldt(omit), Astbury(omit)
IN: Jackson, Polo, King, Thursfield, Webberley
Wut?
Please show me our forward line for this week after those ins and outs. :-[ :-[ :o
-
Well for a start we really never did have a forward line but il give it a shot.
HF: Nahas McGuane Nason
F: King Rance Cousins
-
Well for a start we really never did have a forward line but il give it a shot.
HF: Nahas McGuane Nason
F: King Rance Cousins
Lord help us all.
I really don't want us to be beaten by 150+ points again.
-
Morton has to play, King sounds like he has earned it at Coburg and without Polak Jack stays in so too Astbury
-
eff jack - he's had it too easy.
We're gonna get pumped in the behind anyway so wgaf?
Take solace in the fact tha the little red heaired at coburg.
If hARDWICK MEANT WHAT HE SAID THEN there is no argument for the underachieving,spoilt,bad attitude son of a to play
-
Richmond - In the mix
Richmond must make at least two changes this week, with Troy Taylor and Richard Tambling both missing through injury.
Dean Polo and Mitch Morton have both been flying for Coburg and could slot straight in, with Morton kicking 3.4 and Polo two - including the goal that got them over the line - in Coburg's first win of the year. Polo played in a variety of positions for his 24 touches, while Jake King also booted three.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/93154/default.aspx
-
Out Injured , Tambling and Taylor ( would of dropped both anyway ) :banghead
Dea
Reiwoldt.
Ins, Polo , Morton, and the other two dont matter, as we have been playing 2 short by playing Dea and Reiwoldt anyway
agree although I only think Jack really let us (and himself) down with his petulent effort on the w/end.
-
Out Injured , Tambling and Taylor ( would of dropped both anyway ) :banghead
Dea
Reiwoldt.
Ins, Polo , Morton, and the other two dont matter, as we have been playing 2 short by playing Dea and Reiwoldt anyway
yep
-
Ins: Polo, White, Morton, Thursfield (if fit if not debut Webberley)
Outs: Tambling (inj), Taylor (inj), Dea, Astbury
-
In Polo Morton Webberley
Out Taylor Tambling Farmer
-
Ins: Polo, White, Morton, Thursfield (if fit if not debut Webberley)
Outs: Tambling (inj), Taylor (inj), Dea, Astbury
Give Astbury Jak me offs job and ditch the monga.
-
whats a monga?
do u mean mongaloid? if so who r u referring too?
-
Out: Taylor (inj), Tambling (inj), Simmonds (don't think they will drop him though), Dea
In: Polo (better show something), Morton, Browne, Thursfield, Jackson, Roberts
If Thursty and Jackson are fit they may come in but if not than the rest of them. Would love to see Goo get a go but I am not sure they will elevate him at the moment, needs to show consistency IMO.
-
Out: Taylor (inj), Tambling (inj), Simmonds (don't think they will drop him though), Dea
In: Polo (better show something), Morton, Browne, Thursfield, Jackson, Roberts
If Thursty and Jackson are fit they may come in but if not than the rest of them. Would love to see Goo get a go but I am not sure they will elevate him at the moment, needs to show consistency IMO.
WAT I know things are crook but we can only play 22 ;D
You have 6 INS and only 4 OUTS ;D
-
Out: Taylor (inj), Tambling (inj), Simmonds (don't think they will drop him though), Dea
In: Polo (better show something), Morton, Browne, Thursfield, Jackson, Roberts
If Thursty and Jackson are fit they may come in but if not than the rest of them. Would love to see Goo get a go but I am not sure they will elevate him at the moment, needs to show consistency IMO.
WAT I know things are crook but we can only play 22 ;D
You have 6 INS and only 4 OUTS ;D
Yeah sorry my post wasn't very clear, I meant to say if Thursty and Jacko dont get up then play the rest I have listed. But if they do then Browne and Roberts amy miss..... sorry about that.. ;D But do you think they would notice if we slipped a couple more in.. :thumbsup
-
Tambling out = Thirsty in (If ok) or Polo in
Taylor out = Roberts in
Astbury out = Morton in
-
I would love to see Webberly get a go this week too, I would also rather see Astbury stay in and Dea go out. I think Dea just needs a bit of confidence in his kicking.
-
We can probably afford to give astbury a run at coburg. He'll probably find it pretty tough in geelong. Looks like Tambo and Taylor are out for a couple of weeks. I'd also drop Simmonds. I'd bring in Morton, Robert, Graham and Thursfield
-
We can probably afford to give astbury a run at coburg. He'll probably find it pretty tough in geelong. Looks like Tambo and Taylor are out for a couple of weeks. I'd also drop Simmonds. I'd bring in Morton, Robert, Graham and Thursfield
Browne played better than Graham last week, was actually named in the best, would you give him a shot first??
-
I thought Gus and Browne both played really well last week, but Browne probably just shaded him.
The selectors can't keep persisting with Simmonds can they??? He's just awful.
He didn't do a single thing right on Sunday. He was outrucked, kept getting caught with the ball,spilled marks,and gave away a silly pushing free to Sandilands for a goal.
And on the two rare occasions that he took marks in the forward line, he kicked one into the man on the mark, and one very gettable shot through the points.
If they are fair dinkum about re-building the side, he just has to go.
-
I thought Gus and Browne both played really well last week, but Browne probably just shaded him.
The selectors can't keep persisting with Simmonds can they??? He's just awful.
He didn't do a single thing right on Sunday. He was outrucked, kept getting caught with the ball,spilled marks,and gave away a silly pushing free to Sandilands for a goal.
And on the two rare occasions that he took marks in the forward line, he kicked one into the man on the mark, and one very gettable shot through the points.
If they are fair dinkum about re-building the side, he just has to go.
I think he (Simmonds) is really down on confidence and could probably do with a stint a Coburg, but I would rather see Browne come in for him. I know Graham is young but I am not sure he is going to get any better, he may, who knows. But surley it couldn't hurt to give Browne a shot.
-
whats a monga?
do u mean mongaloid? if so who r u referring too?
Jaks a monga and a petulant wanker who deserves to be dropped indefinitely.
What happens when he duds out again this week - blame Hardwick ??
ffs
-
Is a monga the male version of a minga? :lol
-
whats a monga?
do u mean mongaloid? if so who r u referring too?
Jaks a monga and a petulant wanker who deserves to be dropped indefinitely.
What happens when he duds out again this week - blame Hardwick ??
ffs
Why cant you post with some sort of decency, Ox? What's the point of this sort of personal attack?
-
whats a monga?
do u mean mongaloid? if so who r u referring too?
Jaks a monga and a petulant wanker who deserves to be dropped indefinitely.
What happens when he duds out again this week - blame Hardwick ??
ffs
Why cant you post with some sort of decency, Ox? What's the point of this sort of personal attack?
:clapping
-
Thanks WAT. I just dont understand why he does it. It tells us far more about him than it does about the players, or the club or the game of footy.
-
Out:Jack Reiwoldt
In: Morton
-
Out:Jack Reiwoldt
In: Morton
Look, I realize that Jack is probably skating on pretty thin ice after his petulant display last week. But I can't see the value in depriving our already undersized forward line of more marking power just to make a point. It's not like we're drowning in possible replacements of his size at the minute. Yes, Morton in for the injured Tambling, but let's not go in with a midget forward line again like we did in round one.
Incidentally, how far off do people think Griffiths is from a senior game? I'm dying to see this kid in the yellow and black.
-
Out:Jack Reiwoldt
In: Morton
Look, I realize that Jack is probably skating on pretty thin ice after his petulant display last week. But I can't see the value in depriving our already undersized forward line of more marking power just to make a point. It's not like we're drowning in possible replacements of his size at the minute. Yes, Morton in for the injured Tambling, but let's not go in with a midget forward line again like we did in round one.
Incidentally, how far off do people think Griffiths is from a senior game? I'm dying to see this kid in the yellow and black.
Couple of weeks.. defiantly not against the cats maby against port or Bomers .. but did you see the clips of when the coaches were taking to the groups .. he could give a rats arse what was being said Thats why i say put him down a week to make him realize if he dose not listen and preform he cant be apart of teh gorwing side ... we don't want dead weight
-
Yes I did see the clip. To be honest, I thought BT blew it out of proportion just to serve his Richmond-bashing agenda. I thought Jack's worst crimes were actually out on the ground,where some of his efforts at the ball seemed half-hearted. I don't know what set him off, but he just seemed to have the sulks for most of the night.
I hope that Dimma gave him a blast after the game, and maybe warned him that any repeats would see him running around for the Burgers. But I think he earned himself a reprieve with his efforts the week before, where I thought he ran his arse off all day against the Dees, particularly in that 3rd term, when everybody else had stopped to a walk.
-
Incidentally, how far off do people think Griffiths is from a senior game? I'm dying to see this kid in the yellow and black.
Seeing he basically had no pre-season and is currently getting his fitness base up playing COburg resevers I would think a few weeks. I reckon the plan would be a couple of full games at Coburg seniors first before being considered for AFL selection.
Personally I am not expecting to see Griffiths in an AFL Tiger jumper until the 2nd half of the season and that's been my view all the way along
-
Incidentally, how far off do people think Griffiths is from a senior game? I'm dying to see this kid in the yellow and black.
Seeing he basically had no pre-season and is currently getting his fitness base up playing COburg resevers I would think a few weeks. I reckon the plan would be a couple of full games at Coburg seniors first before being considered for AFL selection.
Personally I am not expecting to see Griffiths in an AFL Tiger jumper until the 2nd half of the season and that's been my view all the way along
Hey WP. Reading some of your reports, you were at Craigieburn on Saturday. What in hell happened to Coburg seconds to lose by 100 points, after winning by 130 the week before???
Did Griffiths and Westhoff even play? If so, was it a case of the midfield just couldn't get the ball to them?
-
Hey WP. Reading some of your reports, you were at Craigieburn on Saturday. What in hell happened to Coburg seconds to lose by 100 points, after winning by 130 the week before???
Did Griffiths and Westhoff even play? If so, was it a case of the midfield just couldn't get the ball to them?
RR, I only saw the senior's game. Ressies started at 9.30am and I couldn't get out there until around 12.00pm so sorry I can't help you ;D
-
I don't really see us doing anything surprising this week with two enforced outs. I've got a feeling Hardwick will persist with the young guys for a while yet irrespective of a bad game or two. This year is a write-off and all about the future and getting games into the cubs. If we get pumped we get pumped.
Out: Tambling, Taylor
In: Morton, Polo
-
Tigers wields axe again for Cats match
* Greg Denham
* From: The Australian
* April 29, 2010
RICHMOND coach Damien Hardwick has not been shy in ringing in the changes at Punt Road in his first season, and another turnover of personnel is expected against Geelong on Sunday at Skilled Stadium.
In the knowledge that he is starting his senior coaching career from rock bottom with an ordinary list, Hardwick has had a close look within his ranks, having already used 33 players in five rounds.
To emphasise just how high the use of 33 players is before the season has reached its quarter-way mark, St Kilda played a total of 30 players in 25 matches throughout the whole of 2009.
Injuries to Richard Tambling (hamstring) and Troy Taylor (knee), as well as meeting a class opposition that is a 100-1 on ($1.01) chance, will force Hardwick into at least another two to three selection changes this weekend after making 17 in the past three rounds.
Tambling will miss at least two matches, while Taylor has a slight medial ligament strain and will be sidelined for three weeks.
Possible inclusions from injury include Will Thursfield, who has overcome a hamstring strain that has kept him out for three rounds, and Daniel Jackson, who missed the Tigers' loss to Fremantle with a buttock problem.
Also under consideration for a recall from the VFL are the inconsistent pair Mitch Morton and Dean Polo.
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/sport/tigers-wields-axe-again-for-cats-match/story-e6frg7mf-1225859633329
-
(Out) In:
(Tambling - Inj) Polo, (Taylor - Inj) Morton, (Edwards FFS!) Jackson, (Farmer) Thursfield
Moore, Thursfield, Dea
Newman, McGuane, Rance
Collins, Cotchin, Martin
Polo, Astbury, Deledio
Nahas, Riewoldt, Morton
Vickery, Foley, Tuck
Simmonds, Jackson, Nason, Cousins
*time to have Astbury playing at CHF! and Riewoldt at FF!
*time to play Deledio half-forward and in the midfield! Polo as well!
*need to leave Nahas and Morton in the forward fifty!
*Collins, Cotchin, Martin, Foley, Tuck, Jackson, Deledio, Cousins, Nason, Newman - rotating in the midfield!
*time to kick goals and apply scoreboard pressure!
>:(
-
Agree with Torch but I don't think they will drop Edwards. Play Polo in the centre see what he does.
-
Moore, Thursfield, Dea
How anyone can suggest that Dea remains staggers me.
I don't want to destroy the kids confidence completely. As a result I don't believe another week in the AFL is going to do the kid any good at all. He should go back to the VFL and develop and learn his craft rather than playng with the big boys and continue to have to put up potshots from unforgiving and more importantly impatient Tiger fans
And on Edwards - cannot drop him this week, he played close to his best game ever last week
-
I don't really see us doing anything surprising this week with two enforced outs. I've got a feeling Hardwick will persist with the young guys for a while yet irrespective of a bad game or two. This year is a write-off and all about the future and getting games into the cubs. If we get pumped we get pumped.
Out: Tambling, Taylor
In: Morton, Polo
Agree with these 2 MT but I think he will also drop Dea for either Webberley or White.
-
Yes I did see the clip. To be honest, I thought BT blew it out of proportion just to serve his Richmond-bashing agenda. I thought Jack's worst crimes were actually out on the ground,where some of his efforts at the ball seemed half-hearted. I don't know what set him off, but he just seemed to have the sulks for most of the night.
I hope that Dimma gave him a blast after the game, and maybe warned him that any repeats would see him running around for the Burgers. But I think he earned himself a reprieve with his efforts the week before, where I thought he ran his behind off all day against the Dees, particularly in that 3rd term, when everybody else had stopped to a walk.
Exactly.
You see a 10 second clip of a change room scene that the commentators obviously want to exploit and then they carry on with a very obvious agenda.
Wake up to yourselves and grow your own view apart from adopting a biased BT's BS.
-
Out: Tambling, Taylor, Dea
In: Polo, Morton, Thursfield
Jackson will probably come in too, but not sure who to drop for him, maybe Tuck but I don't know if that will happen
-
Not only was BT showing his bias, but I thought he embarrassed himself by obviously not learning the Richmond players names from the team list. In the first quarter he failed to call Astbury, Nason, Dea, Taylor and even struggled a couple of times to call Martin's name. The silences in the call said a lot about what he thinks about the Tigers, and his true level of professionalism.
Not impressed, BT.
-
The silences in the call said a lot about what he thinks about the Tigers, and his true level of professionalism.
And here I was thinking my TV reception was playing up