One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 29, 2010, 06:53:34 PM
-
Any after a good win?
Fire away ....
-
Browne has to play, he was sensational today for the Burgers and adds to his recent good form.
Post was also fantastic playing up forward, he was grabbing everything that come his way. Probably needs another week or two to prove himself at Coburg though.
Thats probably about it.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Gee Ramps, hard to knock Collins game today.
-
You don't take out a guy like Collins after he laid 13 tackles.
Out: Polak
In: Browne
Foley could also come in, but not sure for who.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Well its Simmonds anyway who will come in for his farewell. Hopefully for Griffiths as I said.
Foley is one for inclusion also as Ramps said but I am finding it hard to omit someone just now.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Gee Ramps, hard to knock Collins game today.
Yes I know but I feel that Collins can do better - hes not producing what I think he can and Hardwick needs to send him a message. Itll be for his own good anyway.
-
If Foley is still unavailable maybe Morton may be a chance for inclusion.
-
Yes I know but I feel that Collins can do better - hes not producing what I think he can and Hardwick needs to send him a message. Itll be for his own good anyway.
Second game back in for a mid who has more of a receiving/finishing role and he got in and under and tackled like he was a hard nut inside mid today. What more does he need to do in those conditions to keep his spot next week? I'll be gobsmacked if he is dropped.
-
If Foley is still unavailable maybe Morton may be a chance for inclusion.
I doubt we'd bring Morton in after only 1 good game at Coburg. Make him do it again.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
surely you jest.Bling was good today
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
surely you jest.Bling was good today
Not sure of his stats but i hardly seen him from half time onwards.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
surely you jest.Bling was good today
Not sure of his stats but i hardly seen him from half time onwards.
Possibly because he was at the bottom of a lot of packs !!
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
surely you jest.Bling was good today
Not sure of his stats but i hardly seen him from half time onwards.
Possibly because he was at the bottom of a lot of packs !!
Yep, that would be the reason. Unfortunately, that is not a good reason for some.
-
Maybe take a cautious approach with Griffiths especially against St Kilda and bring in Vickery or Browne.
Agree with Tucker on this. Id also bring back Foley and take out someone like Collins.
Foley in Tambling out.
no way blingers will be dropped, great game, put his body on the line at every contest he was in, dimma loves that. blingers did some fantastic work in close today
wayne ur a waynker
-
Has King earned his spot? I would like to see him line up on Milne and earn a 2 year suspension before the ball is bounced.... but I'm a bad person!
Does Will come back? he might be a good match for Goddard? even Polo for montagna?
A job on Koschitszke for Polak? Can he stay in with Simmons coming back?
Imagine if Foley and Jackson were to return after such a win!
-
Have someone take out Milne and early in the game.
-
Have someone take out Milne and early in the game.
But not Goddard Julz, he is too important to my Dream Team and SuperCoach Team!! ;D
-
Is Farmer the man for Milne?
-
Is Farmer the man for Milne?
No, wouldn't stick close enough to him or get under his skin (distract him) enough. I have to say that I would go with King, but I know many others will disagree.
-
Yeah I was thinking of King too
-
Thursty killed Milne last year. I'd bring in Thursty, Post and Simmo and out goes Polak. I'd like to see Moore rotated out this week and Post given a run. I like Moore but we have an undersized defence and Thursty, Mcguane and Farmer have had a game off, so I'd give Moore a week off. Pretty hard to make a change this week but Simmo will be in for his farewell game and Polak is the obvious player to make way
-
Moore! thats crazy talk he's a star!
-
Has King earned his spot? I would like to see him line up on Milne and earn a 2 year suspension before the ball is bounced.... but I'm a bad person!
King won't be at the club next year. In round 17 he'll go out with a bang when we play the Pies. He'll wear some steel armguards under the long sleeve guernset that day and continually smack Cloke, Didak and Maxwell for fun. :lol :rollin :lol
-
what about no changes ? and consider browne to play dont want to demoralize him when the saints march in :p wait till we play a less punishable team :)
Has King earned his spot? I would like to see him line up on Milne and earn a 2 year suspension before the ball is bounced.... but I'm a bad person!
King won't be at the club next year. In round 17 he'll go out with a bang when we play the Pies. He'll wear some steel armguards under the long sleeve guernset that day and continually smack Cloke, Didak and Maxwell for fun. :lol :rollin :lol
Especially Didak :)
-
Is Farmer the man for Milne?
:clapping maybe then i might think farmer was worth playing after all :thumbsup :lol
-
Tough to drop players after an effort like that
However you'd assume that Polak will come out for Simmo's farewell and someone will have to go for Foley
-
Farmer plays reasonably loose. Remember that. Not sure if he'd be better on Schneider or Milne.
-
wouldnt be surprised to see Nason rested. How bad was Griffiths corkie? He could make way for simmonds if the corkie is bad enough.
A lot of the players will be sore today and the club have already shown that they are prepared to be cautious and rest sore/slightly injured players.
I could see Martin getting another rest before the season is out, but whether or not it is this week?
-
Morton, perhaps Post and Browne could be in line. Will bring in Simmonds of course but can't can't see them making too many changes unless going to rest players. Would not bring in Foley unless they are 100 per cent he is okay to play. Absolutely no point risking players.
-
Thankfully we get Milne on his 199th game.
-
Darcy on OWAAT reckons he's heard a whisper that Browne may play this week.
Btw the only three players we haven't used yet is Browne (as he's raw), Grimes (been injured) and poor old Jordie (whose papers are stamped).
-
Darcy on OWAAT reckons he's heard a whisper that Browne may play this week.
Btw the only three players we haven't used yet is Browne (as he's raw), Grimes (been injured) and poor old Jordie (whose papers are stamped).
Would love to see BrownE get a game but I can't see it being this week with Simmo playing his farewell game
The following week agaisnt the Eagles is the one IMHO
-
i wonder how much those atrocious conditions would have taken out of those young legs
-
(Out) In:
(Polak - Omitted) Simmonds
(Graham - Rested) Browne
(King - Omitted) Foley
(Nason - Rested) Morton
(Edwards - Rested) Post
(Farmer - Rested) Thursfield
Team v St Kilda
B: Moore, Thursfield, Tuck
HB: Webberley, McGuane, Newman
C: Collins, Martin, White
HF: Astbury, Post, Deledio
F: Morton, Griffiths, Riewoldt
Fo: Simmonds, Cotchin, Foley
I: Nahas, Browne, Tambling, Cousins
:)
-
rested.......against st.kilda ??
just say,"drop"
-
Ins: Simmo, Foley
Outs: Polak, King
(Out) In:
(Polak - Omitted) Simmonds
(Graham - Rested) Browne
(King - Omitted) Foley
(Nason - Rested) Morton
(Edwards - Rested) Post
(Farmer - Rested) Thursfield
You want to "rest" Graham after 3 games :-\
And I don't understand why people want Post back in after 1 good game at Coburg. He needs to string some decent footy together not just 1 game IMHO.
Bottom line is no one should be dropped after the win but some one has to
-
Doubt they will drop King
-
(Out) In:
(Polak - Omitted) Simmonds
(Graham - Rested) Browne
(King - Omitted) Foley
(Nason - Rested) Morton
(Edwards - Rested) Post
(Farmer - Rested) Thursfield
6 changes to a side that won by 47 points?
Are you high?
-
Ins: Simmo, Foley
Outs: Polak, King
(Out) In:
(Polak - Omitted) Simmonds
(Graham - Rested) Browne
(King - Omitted) Foley
(Nason - Rested) Morton
(Edwards - Rested) Post
(Farmer - Rested) Thursfield
You want to "rest" Graham after 3 games :-\
And I don't understand why people want Post back in after 1 good game at Coburg. He needs to string some decent footy together not just 1 game IMHO.
Bottom line is no one should be dropped after the win but some one has to
There you go trying to be logical again - LOL
-
No changes.
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
It's tough to get your head around, but the Richmond match committee will have a bit of a dilemma on its hands this week. The inclusion of Troy Simmonds for his final AFL match should see the struggling Graham Polak make way, but with senior midfielder Nathan Foley expected to be passed fit to play, Richard Tambling could be the player to make way, which is unfortunate after the side collected its first win.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/95471/default.aspx
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
It's tough to get your head around, but the Richmond match committee will have a bit of a dilemma on its hands this week. The inclusion of Troy Simmonds for his final AFL match should see the struggling Graham Polak make way, but with senior midfielder Nathan Foley expected to be passed fit to play, Richard Tambling could be the player to make way, which is unfortunate after the side collected its first win.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/95471/default.aspx
I could live with that change...
-
Tambling out, are they serious, did anyone wanting Tambling out actually watch the game, he was hard at it all day. Why arn't they calling for Collins to come out for Foley, again Collins was caught out again second guessing!!
-
Tambling out, are they serious, did anyone wanting Tambling out actually watch the game, he was hard at it all day. Why arn't they calling for Collins to come out for Foley, again Collins was caught out again second guessing!!
Yep, no way Tambling will get dropped unless it's for injury. Collins is the one that will go.
-
Tambling out, are they serious, did anyone wanting Tambling out actually watch the game, he was hard at it all day. Why arn't they calling for Collins to come out for Foley, again Collins was caught out again second guessing!!
Yep, no way Tambling will get dropped unless it's for injury. Collins is the one that will go.
Tambling wont get dropped based on his game last week and nor should
As someone has to make way for Foley, I suggested King but think Collins is the other obvious one IMHO
-
Tambling out, are they serious, did anyone wanting Tambling out actually watch the game, he was hard at it all day. Why arn't they calling for Collins to come out for Foley, again Collins was caught out again second guessing!!
Yep, no way Tambling will get dropped unless it's for injury. Collins is the one that will go.
Tambling wont get dropped based on his game last week and nor should
As someone has to make way for Foley, I suggested King but think Collins is the other obvious one IMHO
blingers is safe, played his part in the team and thats what dimma wants
collins is safe also, didnt he have 14 tackles also or something like that
if foley is fit king will make way for him
-
Tambling must play need to keep building up what currency he has left.
Once a hack always a hack and 1 descent/average game wont change that
-
Tambling must play need to keep building up what currency he has left.
Once a hack always a hack and 1 descent/average game wont change that
JD, the word is decent not descent (which means going down)
:thumbsup