One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 24, 2010, 04:52:17 PM
-
Fire away .... :P
-
Literally about 15 blokes in the firing line but would have to wait to se who is in the best for Coburg.
You would think its only leadership group and blokes key to the structure who are certain to retain spots. Of the fringe players, I would hope that the blokes who actually had a dip (Rance, Morton, even Webberley) get rewarded for their effort and the blokes who didn't work hard enough (Connors, Post) get at the very least a rocket.
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
-
All I can say is Daniel Jackson is a walk up start next week.
-
tambling will come back in.
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
Bad Call.
12 career games over not even 2 seasons...
He's 14 months younger than Jack. If we traded Jack Riewoldt last year and he came out and had his year at another club the RFC would blow up.
Never trade/delist a KP player mid development under 22 years old, otherwise don't even bother drafting them...
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
Bad Call.
12 career games over not even 2 seasons...
He's 14 months younger than Jack. If we traded Jack Riewoldt last year and he came out and had his year at another club the RFC would blow up.
Never trade/delist a KP player mid development under 22 years old, otherwise don't even bother drafting them...
Agreed 100%, too many chicken little's in the RFC "supporter" base
Don't think he should have got a game this week, but we should judge him in 2 years time, not in his 2nd year
-
you would have to be surprised if Post or Browne would be dropped.
They should play for the rest of the year to let them get settled and see how they go.
Post didnt get great supply today, sure has some ground to make to be able to play regular senior footy but let him have a crack atleast.
Look at Ben Reid from Collingwood, now in his 4th year and starting to look pretty solid as a KPP. It takes time.
Same goes for Browne, he is only second year also.
Dean Polo is the one who i would think may get the chop. Does far too many silly things for a 4th year player. If he switched on all the time he could be ok.
-
Think Dimma might give the duds another week to show if they're any good. Maybe Hicks to come in for Nahas.
-
Dean Polo is the one who i would think may get the chop. Does far too many silly things for a 4th year player. If he switched on all the time he could be ok.
Polo is a 6th year player actually, which makes it even worse
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
Bad Call.
12 career games over not even 2 seasons...
He's 14 months younger than Jack. If we traded Jack Riewoldt last year and he came out and had his year at another club the RFC would blow up.
Never trade/delist a KP player mid development under 22 years old, otherwise don't even bother drafting them...
Agreed 100%, too many chicken little's in the RFC "supporter" base
Don't think he should have got a game this week, but we should judge him in 2 years time, not in his 2nd year
Post has shown nothing, hes average. Hes shown nothing when playing senior football infact according to coburg watchers he shown nothing their either. Trade him before its too late!
-
The obvious change is Polo for Jackson
I'd like to see Gourdis in the side, perhaps for Post, but we may see Thursfield or Moore return
Morton & Rance deserve to keep their spots
Calls for Post to be delisted or traded in his 2nd year is ridiculous
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
Bad Call.
12 career games over not even 2 seasons...
He's 14 months younger than Jack. If we traded Jack Riewoldt last year and he came out and had his year at another club the RFC would blow up.
Never trade/delist a KP player mid development under 22 years old, otherwise don't even bother drafting them...
Agreed 100%, too many chicken little's in the RFC "supporter" base
Don't think he should have got a game this week, but we should judge him in 2 years time, not in his 2nd year
Post has shown nothing, hes average. Hes shown nothing when playing senior football infact according to coburg watchers he shown nothing their either. Trade him before its too late!
Insanity.
-
tambling had a shocker today, never touched it, lol drop him lol lol lol
:rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
:wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink
-
Out: Nahas, Polo, Post
In: Jacko, Thursty, Moore
Collo may be rested for a week with that corked thigh.
Rest depends on how those at Coburg do.
-
You'd expect the two "legs" white and Moore back in as well as Jackson
Nahas is possibly on the chopping bloke but wouldn't be surprised to see him to get one more game.
Would expect Polo to get at least another two games in which he will probably playing for his career at tigerland.
Post may find himself back at coburg next week
-
Jackson Moore and Will in. Out Nahas McGuane and Polo. Morton and Rance should not be dropped. Would like to see them try Taylor Gourdis and Hicks if possible but would mean more wholesale changes
-
tambling had a shocker today, never touched it, lol drop him lol lol lol
:rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
:wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink :wallywink
oh okay well if thats the case he shouldnt come back in. surely a player that has been giving the amount of chances and games like he has he should be at the very least ripping it up in the reserves.
-
Ins: Moore, Jackson,
Thursfield oops forgot about White ;D
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj)
-
Post should be traded before everyone else works out that he aint no future star KPP. Trade him out whilst hes worth something IMHO. As for changes It doesnt matter- Adelaide will flog us as well.
maybe we'll put you on the ground and see how hopeless you are instead 8)
-
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield oops forgot about White ;D
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj)
Actually I've changed my mind ;D
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield, White
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj), McGuane
-
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield oops forgot about White ;D
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj)
Actually I've changed my mind ;D
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield, White
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj), McGuane
Suddenly our side looks a lot better.
Add in Foley, Cotch, Griff and Dea and next year's full strength team looks OK
:thumbsup
-
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield oops forgot about White ;D
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj)
Actually I've changed my mind ;D
Ins: Moore, Jackson, Thursfield, White
Outs: Nahas, Post, Collins (inj), McGuane
Suddenly our side looks a lot better.
Add in Foley, Cotch, Griff and Dea and next year's full strength team looks OK
:thumbsup
And thats before we factor in any improvement in Taylor, Graham and Browne. Also a new group of draftees. We're getting there, slowly, but getting there.
-
McGuane deserves to be dropped for his performance against the pies.
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
There were no apparent injuries out of the huge loss to Collingwood, and no outstanding performances at Coburg, so this week should mainly see the return of injured or suspended players. Daniel Jackson will no doubt be desperate to make amends for another suspension, this one costing him three weeks on the sidelines, while Will Thursfield, Kelvin Moore and Matt White are all good chances to return from injury.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/99124/default.aspx
-
Good to see Johncock being suspended.
-
Hardwick interviewed after training today...
The Tigers host Adelaide at the MCG on Sunday with Hardwick confident he will regain defenders Will Thursfield and Kel Moore for the match.
Hardwick said Daniel Jackson and Matthew White would come into calculation at the selection table, with the former available after serving his second suspension for the season.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/99222/default.aspx
-
In: Tambling, Moore, Jackson, Thursfield
Out: Nahas, Post, Collins(inj), McGuane
-
In: Thursfield, Moore, Jackson
Out:McGuane, Polo, Nahas