One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 12, 2010, 05:01:20 PM
-
Richmond
B: Chris Newman, David Gourdis, David Astbury
HB: Brett Deledio, Kelvin Moore, Daniel Connors
C: Mitch Morton, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Ben Nason, Jayden Post, Jake King
F: Matt White, Jack Riewoldt, Ben Cousins
Foll: Angus Graham, Shane Tuck, Daniel Jackson
I/C: James O'Reilly, Andrew Browne, Robbie Hicks, Andrew Collins
Emg: Robin Nahas, Alex Rance, Dean Polo
In: Collins, Gourdis, Post, O'Reilly
Out: Luke McGuane (virus), Will Thursfield , Mitch Farmer (knee), Jeromey Webberley
New: Jamie O'Reilly (County Down, Ireland)
Carlton
B: Aaron Joseph, Michael Jamison, Marcus Davies
HB: Jordan Russell, Paul Bower, Dennis Armfield
C: Heath Scotland, Chris Judd, Kade Simpson
HF: Jeff Garlett, Lachie Henderson, Bryce Gibbs
F: Shaun Hampson, Jarrad Waite, Eddie Betts
Foll: Robert Warnock, Andrew Carrazzo, Marc Murphy
I/C: David Ellard, Shaun Grigg, Richard Hadley, Mitch Robinson
Emg: Joe Anderson, Setanta O'hAilpin, Andrew Walker
No change
-
Will dropped again...
Maybe he'll be the trade bait?
-
Don't know if he'll be trade bait but I'm sure he'll be all offers considered.
-
RFC site says McGuane has been omitted
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/100234/default.aspx
-
Don't agree with dropping Will. Good to see Gourdis get a chance.
-
RFC site says McGuane has been omitted
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/100234/default.aspx
Whether or not he plays for coburg will tell.
-
Why is Gourdis not listed as New?
-
Infamy...he was listed as new when he was promoted and given an emergency spot after round 11 or 12 earlier this year.
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
I'm sorry WP but talking in riddles make you sound like Jackstar.
If you have something to say, say it FFS.
:thumbsup
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
could only be talking about post id say.
regardless of form id play post at chb for the rest of the yr orielly and gourdis good ins along with collins. getting games into these kids is what its about.
would also have looked at dropping one of white or nason . white nason cuz and king still means its a very small forward line. would have looked for a third tall option or strong medium sized player forward. we still fail to get structure right.
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
I'm sorry WP but talking in riddles make you sound like Jackstar.
If you have something to say, say it FFS.
:thumbsup
Post shouldnt have gotten picked- Is that direct enough?
-
Post? Intersting. I've read what wp has said about him. Last time I was in Melbourne I caught up with an old mate who has a connection to the TAC league. In a football conversation he said he thought Post was lazy. I spoke to him again yesterday and asked him what he meant. He said that when he coached against him as a junior he would put a hard working player on him to test him out, and he never really rose to the challenge. Said he had heaps of talent but....
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
Post is only in to take some heat off Jack! I can't believe that Will got dropped, he rarely loses to his opponent! Good to see Goo get a go!
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
I'm sorry WP but talking in riddles make you sound like Jackstar.
If you have something to say, say it FFS.
:thumbsup
1965: Anyone who's followed my posts during the season would know exactly who I am talking about ;D
could only be talking about post id say.
Well done Claw ;D
Post shouldnt have gotten picked- Is that direct enough?
Cheers Ramps
Post? Intersting. I've read what wp has said about him. Last time I was in Melbourne I caught up with an old mate who has a connection to the TAC league. In a football conversation he said he thought Post was lazy. I spoke to him again yesterday and asked him what he meant. He said that when he coached against him as a junior he would put a hard working player on him to test him out, and he never really rose to the challenge. Said he had heaps of talent but....
Yeap that's how it looks al from the games I've seen this year
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
Post is only in to take some heat off Jack! I can't believe that Will got dropped, he rarely loses to his opponent! Good to see Goo get a go!
is post a good contested mark? / goal kicker ?
-
Pleased on one hand = O'Reilly & Gourdis finally getting their deserved opportunities
Speechless on the other regarding one of the INS
Post is only in to take some heat off Jack! I can't believe that Will got dropped, he rarely loses to his opponent! Good to see Goo get a go!
is post a good contested mark? / goal kicker ?
He could/should be!
-
I'm just happy Goo got a game and good on O'Reilly as well. :thumbsup
Means Grimes is the only one who has not debuted this year.
-
lol cant think of a better chop at the selection table in McGuane & Thursfield for thier crap performance against Melbourne.
Moore was very lucky too
Good luck to Gourdis because this lad is the next generation backline :thumbsup
-
lol cant think of a better chop at the selection table in McGuane & Thursfield for thier crap performance against Melbourne.
Moore was very lucky too
Good luck to Gourdis because this lad is the next generation backline :thumbsup
You like the Goo going forward Monky?
-
lol cant think of a better chop at the selection table in McGuane & Thursfield for thier crap performance against Melbourne.
Moore was very lucky too
Good luck to Gourdis because this lad is the next generation backline :thumbsup
You like the Goo going forward Monky?
I do too! Has the athletism to go with anyone in the competition and has improved his desposal skills dramatically running out of defence. Hope he can pull it together over the next few weeks. :thumbsup
-
I think the only time I saw Gourdis play was in the NAB Cup.....Is he an upgrade on McGuane/Thursty/Moore ? OR is he "cut from the same cloth".
-
I think the only time I saw Gourdis play was in the NAB Cup.....Is he an upgrade on McGuane/Thursty/Moore ? OR is he "cut from the same cloth".
Taller, faster and has become a very high posession defender at VFL with regular games of around 30 disposals.
If he can adjust to AFL level over the next year or two like he has VFL we'll have a ripper on our hands, there won't be a forward in the league he can't keep up with.
-
I think the only time I saw Gourdis play was in the NAB Cup.....Is he an upgrade on McGuane/Thursty/Moore ? OR is he "cut from the same cloth".
Taller, faster and has become a very high posession defender at VFL with regular games of around 30 disposals.
If he can adjust to AFL level over the next year or two like he has VFL we'll have a ripper on our hands, there won't be a forward in the league he can't keep up with.
Thanks Infamy....your report on Gourdis has me a little bit aroused. :thumbsup
-
Great stuff to see two more new faces in the team!!
-
If Post is going to play up forward he has got to kick goals and not just be a foil. Given that we have quite a few defenders in the team maybe Astbury should play in the forward line. Would like to see how Gourdis goes against Waite if Waite plays in the forward line.
-
lol cant think of a better chop at the selection table in McGuane & Thursfield for thier crap performance against Melbourne.
Moore was very lucky too
Good luck to Gourdis because this lad is the next generation backline :thumbsup
You like the Goo going forward Monky?
Defender
-
Gourdis
Astbury
do you like they'll develop into a decent combo down back?
-
Gourdis
Astbury
do you like they'll develop into a decent combo down back?
anything would be better than Thursfield & McGuane ;D 2 of the dumbest footballers in the AFL
-
Gourdis
Astbury
do you like they'll develop into a decent combo down back?
anything would be better than Thursfield & McGuane ;D 2 of the dumbest footballers in the AFL
I feel sorry for Moore because IMO he can play and having to play slongside these 2 would be hard.
These 2 dont even look like footballers. Thursfield the size of a stick after what 5 years in the system.
We need to find 2 more backmen because these 2 are duds.
-
Gourdis
Astbury
do you like they'll develop into a decent combo down back?
anything would be better than Thursfield & McGuane ;D 2 of the dumbest footballers in the AFL
I feel sorry for Moore because IMO he can play and having to play slongside these 2 would be hard.
These 2 dont even look like footballers. Thursfield the size of a stick after what 5 years in the system.
We need to find 2 more backmen because these 2 are duds.
l cant beleive how many times l seen both try to outmark elite forwards :lol
your right about Moore they pull him down which makes him play bad