One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: TigerLand on April 16, 2011, 12:01:32 PM
-
Tewry Wallet on SEN
Quote
"Richmond top 5 are obvious Deledio, Riewoldt, Cotchin, Martin and Newman
next 5 are tough Jackson, White, Grigg, Foley and Edwards."
Wow. First sentence spot on. 2nd sentence, Edwards and White are not in the best 10 players at the club.
Popes Top 5:
Deledio
Newman
Riewoldt
Cotchin
Martin
Next Top 5:
Foley
Jackson
Grigg
Moore
Conca/McGuane/Morton
-
Come off it, Conca is hardly Top 10 yet
-
white and edwards wouldnt get a game in a top 8 team. :banghead
-
Come off it, Conca is hardly Top 10 yet
give him 4 more weeks and he will be
watch this space
-
Come off it, Conca is hardly Top 10 yet
In all seriousness, who would be the next best player after those 9?
Tuck I suppose would be but he's in the 2's.
Can't be Edwards or White. They are closer to Coburg than Conca is?
Morton and McGuane have been dropped numerous times.
Houli? Vickery? Graham?
Conca is not a bad call.
-
i can only find 9 and that includes foley who at the moment is ???
-
This may seem ridiculous but after kicking 16 goals in his last 8 games I would have Jake King in the top 10.
Jake King has kicked more goals than Mitch Morton since Damien Hardwick became coach.Shame Mitch Shame.
-
Terry should stop commenting on Richmond games.
No wonder we are stuffed until the kids develop: Its a sad indictment on his legacy which includes smallish flankers like White and Edwards in our top 10.
-
This may seem ridiculous but after kicking 16 goals in his last 8 games I would have Jake King in the top 10.
Jake King has kicked more goals than Mitch Morton since Damien Hardwick became coach.Shame Mitch Shame.
You might be right, not a bad call.
-
This may seem ridiculous but after kicking 16 goals in his last 8 games I would have Jake King in the top 10.
Jake King has kicked more goals than Mitch Morton since Damien Hardwick became coach.Shame Mitch Shame.
You might be right, not a bad call.
If Jake King is a top 10 player then we may as well shut the joint down.
-
This may seem ridiculous but after kicking 16 goals in his last 8 games I would have Jake King in the top 10.
Jake King has kicked more goals than Mitch Morton since Damien Hardwick became coach.Shame Mitch Shame.
You might be right, not a bad call.
If Jake King is a top 10 player then we may as well shut the joint down.
Correct, thats why i said we had a possible 9
-
Kelvin Moore is in our top ten, when he is up and about.
-
Sad when we have such a difficult time picking our best players :( Conca could be in our tope ten soon, hell he could be in our top 5, but I don't think you can after only 4 games. King is a good servicable player but, with all due respect to Kings attitiude and improved ability, if he is in our top ten then we are in more stife than I first imagined.
Perhaps Astbury has now become our tenth best player or even Vickery but otherwise, sadly I guess, White, Edwards, McGuane or Moore would be fighting it out for that tenth position :whistle
-
Plough makes a good point about out total lack of depth (of which he is partly responsibly for) but how he includes Titch and Whitey in our top 10 is perplexing ???.
My current top 10:
1. Lids
2. Cotch
3. Jack
4. Newy
5. Martin
daylight...
6. Moore
7. Grigg
8. Jackson
9. Foley
10. King .... an indictment he is but based on the first month of this season he belongs there.
It probably is also an indictment that a ruckman isn't in our top 10 even for a young side. Melbourne have Jamar, North have McIntosh and Essendon have Hille and Ryder.
You would hope in the next year or two the likes of Vickery, Conca, Griffiths, Astbury, top 12 pick 2011 draft, etc ... force their way into our top 10 and easily go past and replace those in our current lower 10. Until then we'll remain a bottom 4 side.
-
at least no one has said Connors
-
1. Deledio
2. Cotchin
3. Riewoldt
4. Newman
5. Martin
6. Jackson
7. Tuck
8. Foley
9. Moore
10. Morton
-
Plough makes a good point about out total lack of depth (of which he is partly responsibly for) but how he includes Titch and Whitey in our top 10 is perplexing ???.
My current top 10:
1. Lids
2. Cotch
3. Jack
4. Newy
5. Martin
daylight...
6. Moore
7. Grigg
8. Jackson
9. Foley
10. King .... an indictment he is but based on the first month of this season he belongs there.
It probably is also an indictment that a ruckman isn't in our top 10 even for a young side. Melbourne have Jamar, North have McIntosh and Essendon have Hille and Ryder.
You would hope in the next year or two the likes of Vickery, Conca, Griffiths, Astbury, top 12 pick 2011 draft, etc ... force their way into our top 10 and easily go past and replace those in our current lower 10. Until then we'll remain a bottom 4 side.
Agree MT :thumbsup
-
You would hope so MT the majority of our A Graders and B Graders are made up of our players drafted since the Cotchin draft, excluding of course Deledio Newman Jack and Axel.
-
My current top 10:
1. Lids
2. Cotch
3. Jack
4. Newy
5. Martin
daylight...
6. Moore
7. Grigg
8. Jackson
9. Foley
10. King
Pretty much how I see it too MT. I would like to see Griffiths, Conca and Batchelor replace Jackson, Foley and King by season's end - that would indicate a reasonable improvement in our depth.
Having said that, despite the opinions of most posters re: our best key defenders, we have been significantly weakened without both Moore and McGuane so far this season. Not saying they are world beaters but missing them is making a fair difference.
-
11-15 not easy to do.
-
Martin 160 touches.
Deledio 151.
Grigg 150.
Cotchin 144.
Foley. 130.
Houli. 125.
Jackson. 117.
Newman. 112.
Nahas. 103.
Conca. 101.
Riewoldt. 21 goals.
King. 11.
Martin. 10.
Vickery 7.
White. 6.
-
Who'd have picked Nahas to be so good at the beginning of the season. Not me! Go Robbie.