One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: wayne on April 21, 2011, 05:00:52 PM
-
B: Chris Newman, Alex Rance, Reece Conca
HB: Brett Deledio, Luke McGuane, Jake Batchelor
C: Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Jake King, Tyrone Vickery, Shaun Grigg
F: Matthew White, Jack Riewoldt, Bachar Houli
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Nathan Foley
I/C: Shane Tuck, Daniel Connors, Robin Nahas, Matt Dea, Ben Nason, Dylan Grimes, Brad Miller
In: Luke McGuane, Shane Tuck, Daniel Connors, Alex Rance, Matt Dea, Ben Nason
Out: Will Thursfield, David Astbury, Bradley Helbig
-
North Melbourne
B: Brady Rawlings, Nathan Grima, Scott Thompson
HB: Michael Firrito, Robert Tarrant, Cameron Richardson
C: Daniel Pratt, Daniel Wells, Brent Harvey
HF: Liam Anthony, Lachlan Hansen, Ben Cunnington
F: Leigh Adams, Drew Petrie, Lindsay Thomas
Foll: Todd Goldstein, Andrew Swallow, Jack Ziebell
I/C: Scott McMahon, Cruize Garlett, Samuel Wright, Jamie Macmillan, Ben McKinley, Shaun Atley, Cameron Pedersen
In: Daniel Pratt, Jamie Macmillan, Ben McKinley, Cameron Pedersen
Out: Aaron Edwards
-
I'm actually really happy they kept Grimes.
I thought he'd be dropped before Astbury because he may have taken precedence in development.
I was wrong and they picked the player that has had the better form.
Well done RFC.
Brad Helbig stiff. Might be for a rest and some decent game time. (This is why the sub rule is garbage, the guy hasn't played more than a half of football yet lol)
-
B: Chris Newman, Alex Rance, Reece Conca
HB: Brett Deledio, Luke McGuane, Jake Batchelor
C: Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Jake King, Tyrone Vickery, Shaun Grigg
F: Matthew White, Jack Riewoldt, Bachar Houli
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Nathan Foley
I/C: Shane Tuck, Daniel Connors, Robin Nahas, Matt Dea, Ben Nason, Dylan Grimes, Brad Miller
In: Luke McGuane, Shane Tuck, Daniel Connors, Alex Rance, Matt Dea, Ben Nason
Out: Will Thursfield, David Astbury, Bradley Helbig
You'd expect straight like-for-like swaps based on the outs.
Helbig ----> Connors
Astbury ----> McGuane
Thursty -----> Rance
Helbig has been the sub for a few games this year so probably needs to get a full game under his belt and Astbury was struggling (off his feet last week). Hopefully they both go back to Coburg and put in a couple of good games to get them back into the seniors.
No Postie on the extended bench so the coaches obviously want him to back up that form again.
-
I reckon huge pressure on Connors this week.
Needs a BOG game i reckon
-
Some good changes. I agree Astbury needs a run in the twos and can come back in a month. Helbig needs game time - he'll go back and work on some things and come back again at some stage this year.
i have a feeling Dea will come in this week. Dea was playing as a tight marking defender last week, maybe a chance to mark one of norths dangerous smalls?
Pretty peeved edwards survived the chop - how many chances?
-
Helbig ----> Connors
hoping that it's Tuck that comes in instead of Connors.
Pretty peeved edwards survived the chop - how many chances?
Surely this has to be his last one. Shouldn't even have played last week.
-
Pretty peeved edwards survived the chop - how many chances?
Staggering decision to be honest
4 rounds in 2011 and has been poor in 3 games (average in the other only be casue he was the sub ;D)
Sends a poor message I reckon
The cynic in me says all coaches have their favourites ;D
-
Uncle Ox was right...now he'll kick 3 and play well.
-
Pretty peeved edwards survived the chop - how many chances?
More than he should have. Maybe we are trying to maintain some trade value :whistle.
-
Helbig ----> Connors
hoping that it's Tuck that comes in instead of Connors.
Not saying Connors is the answer but there's no room for Tucky in the side with Dusty and Jacko ahead of him on the inside. Tucky lacks polish as well. To be a modern midfielder you've got to be more than just get it and bomb it blindy forward. Tucky also gets burnt on the opposition spread.
-
Uncle Ox was right...now he'll kick 3 and play well.
Can I presume your talking Miller? If so we'll see.
I'll be happy if he does don't get me wrong, would be a massive effort for him though and only against a very average team at best.
-
Edwards is still in?
(http://www.gaychristian101.com/images/i-came-across-this-website-by-accident-and-am-shocked-21330324.jpg)
-
Uncle Ox was right...now he'll kick 3 and play well.
Can I presume your talking Miller? If so we'll see.
I'll be happy if he does don't get me wrong, would be a massive effort for him though and only against a very average team at best.
nah he's talking about edwards - he called it earlier this week that he wont b dropped
-
Edwards still in :banghead :banghead
Surely it must be his last chance.
I think Miller will stay in. Give's us another forward target and helps out Jack
-
Let me be the first to introduce the Titch Edwards drinking game
* For every kick which resembles a Trevor Chappel under arm ....scull a shot
* For every turnover which directly results in the opposition kicking a goal.....scull a shot.
* For every time he puts a team mate under immense pressure....scull a shot.
-
Let me be the first to introduce the Titch Edwards drinking game
* For every kick which resembles a Trevor Chappel under arm ....scull a shot
* For every turnover which directly results in the opposition kicking a goal.....scull a shot.
* For every time he puts a team mate under immense pressure....scull a shot.
What if I dont want to get peeed this weekend :( ???
-
Let me be the first to introduce the Titch Edwards drinking game
* For every kick which resembles a Trevor Chappel under arm ....scull a shot
* For every turnover which directly results in the opposition kicking a goal.....scull a shot.
* For every time he puts a team mate under immense pressure....scull a shot.
What if I dont want to get peeed this weekend :( ???
Probably more like alcohol poisoning anyway
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
-
Let me be the first to introduce the Titch Edwards drinking game
* For every kick which resembles a Trevor Chappel under arm ....scull a shot
* For every turnover which directly results in the opposition kicking a goal.....scull a shot.
* For every time he puts a team mate under immense pressure....scull a shot.
gold! :clapping
-
I reckon huge pressure on Connors this week.
Needs a BOG game i reckon
u r wrong again, just like your predicted selections through the wee
u see jack, dimma knows where the boys are at, however you have no idea
seems u were so fos again
which is so routine for you
btw, i see edwards and vickery are still in lol :sleep :wallywink
-
Pretty peeved edwards survived the chop - how many chances?
Staggering decision to be honest
4 rounds in 2011 and has been poor in 3 games (average in the other only be casue he was the sub ;D)
Sends a poor message I reckon
The cynic in me says all coaches have their favourites ;D
many o you guys see edwards totally wrong, he has so much upside, he could have kicked 4 goals v the pies and dimma knows this, its only just around the corner where his composure will settle and so will his kicking
if he had of kicked straight on friday everyone would be saying he gave daisy a bath
-
Edwards still in :banghead :banghead
Surely it must be his last chance.
I think Miller will stay in. Give's us another forward target and helps out Jack
nope
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
good to see some intelligent ppl on this forum :thumbsup
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
good to see some intelligent ppl on this forum :thumbsup
question then "coles boy"". what are you doing here then ??? ::) ::) ::) ::)
-
I reckon huge pressure on Connors this week.
Needs a BOG game i reckon
u r wrong again, just like your predicted selections through the wee
u see jack, dimma knows where the boys are at, however you have no idea
seems u were so fos again
which is so routine for you
btw, i see edwards and vickery are still in lol :sleep :wallywink
if Connors cant play consistent footy, which I doubt, will be gone at years end, no room for passengers, accordingly to D. Hardwick
-
Morton could also be in trouble at years end if he doesnt start to fire - can see him being put up for trade.
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
good to see some intelligent ppl on this forum :thumbsup
question then "coles boy"". what are you doing here then ??? ::) ::) ::) ::)
lmao poop shute boy, whover ever said im a manager at coles anymore lol, that was just a passtime job tool, back in business for me stooge :wallywink
-
Morton could also be in trouble at years end if he doesnt start to fire - can see him being put up for trade.
not could be , is
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
good to see some intelligent ppl on this forum :thumbsup
question then "coles boy"". what are you doing here then ??? ::) ::) ::) ::)
lmao poop shute boy, whover ever said im a manager at coles anymore lol, that was just a passtime job tool, back in business for me stooge :wallywink
where did i say you were the manager.?
Dont let your dreams cloud reality son
-
Edwards is one of our few players who tries to be proactive.
Dimma can see that despite his kicking woes this season.
I would rather we persevere with someone like Edwards over a stodgy Tuck or Thursfield.
good to see some intelligent ppl on this forum :thumbsup
question then "coles boy"". what are you doing here then ??? ::) ::) ::) ::)
lmao poop shute boy, whover ever said im a manager at coles anymore lol, that was just a passtime job tool, back in business for me stooge :wallywink
where did i say you were the manager.?
Dont let your dreams cloud reality son
u didnt say it but i was , but as i said it was just a passtime, now im back being my own boss, something u will never be
-
back to the topic.
Think Tuck might play although not suited by quick surface at etihad
-
would never leave before you, you know why :shh
backs to the wall
u know what i mean :rollin
-
X, its about time you grew up.
How old are you ??
-
X, its about time you grew up.
How old are you ??
no wont grow up i like being short and still looking down on you :wallywink
-
see u sunday gayboy
-
grow up.
you are acting like a 2yo
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
-
How many chances does Edwards get? Too inconsistent! Would prefer Edwards to play in a Forward pocket where he "could" sneak a few goals.
I thought Vickery is lucky to be still in! Has lost his contested marking abilities. If Post has another 7 contested match against Box Hill on Sunday, Post will replace Vickery, or should!
Graham, seriously, a giant slow turtle! Would love Jackson Trengove to be at Richmond in 2012! Derrickx, there is a Ruck position waiting for you!
Morton has been disappointing. However, what happened to Morton playing on the Wing? Play him high Half Forward at least. Hopefully Morton can string great matches with Coburg!
Connors? Heading backwards and needs to find a position!
Helbig unlucky!
If Grigg and Jackson are in the team, Tuck will not be playing!
Miller in the team is depressing for Richmond. Basically there aren't any young tall Forwards ready to take that CHF position Richmond has been asking for! Griffiths is possibly the answer, hopefully he is not far away! Miller "The Insurance" needs to prove he is worth the time. I will go further to say Miller needs to kick more then three goals against North Melbourne to be worth the time for this week!
-
Well back in Oz now so I actually get to watch this game.. :). Although I was lucky, or unlucky enough to watch the games aginst the Pies because DSTV Africa replays all Friday night games only.
So some good in's, must be Edwards last crack at it though and surely he must realist that. Good to see our backmen are in.
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
ooh davey you beat me to it.
Who could forget X and his Tambling/Dimma comments throughout the year of 2010.
"Dimma is happy with Tambling or Tambling is playing the role that Dimma wants him too" LMAO
hahahahahahahaha
X in denial once again.
-
Found this on Twitter:
@AFL_PKeane Patrick Keane:
Matt Dea withdrawn from Rich squad,rd 5 v N Melbourne. Replaced in squad of 25 by Jeromey Webberley. Final 22s both teams tbc late today.
Posted on twitter about 2 hours ago
-
Webbers :thumbsup
-
Webbers :thumbsup
for edwards :pray :pray :pray :pray
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
true, i may have been mistaken, granted, he aint a tiger no more so i dont care but if he ends up a gun in adelaide good luck to him
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
ooh davey you beat me to it.
Who could forget X and his Tambling/Dimma comments throughout the year of 2010.
"Dimma is happy with Tambling or Tambling is playing the role that Dimma wants him too" LMAO
hahahahahahahaha
X in denial once again.
not at all princess
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
ooh davey you beat me to it.
Who could forget X and his Tambling/Dimma comments throughout the year of 2010.
"Dimma is happy with Tambling or Tambling is playing the role that Dimma wants him too" LMAO
hahahahahahahaha
X in denial once again.
thanks daniel, you beat me to it
-
X, you were saying the same stuff about Tambling last year. Where is he now ???
ooh davey you beat me to it.
Who could forget X and his Tambling/Dimma comments throughout the year of 2010.
"Dimma is happy with Tambling or Tambling is playing the role that Dimma wants him too" LMAO
hahahahahahahaha
X in denial once again.
thanks daniel, you beat me to it
look at the love b/w u 2, so special mwah
-
yep, there are good people on here, daniel is one of them :thumbsup
-
Final team
In: McGuane, Rance, Nason
Out: Thursfield, Astbury, Helbig
-
No Connors, Ego still hurt, LOL
Nason to be sub ????
-
North Melbourne
B: Brady Rawlings, Nathan Grima, Scott Thompson
HB: Michael Firrito, Robert Tarrant, Cameron Richardson
C: Daniel Pratt, Daniel Wells, Brent Harvey
HF: Liam Anthony, Lachlan Hansen, Ben Cunnington
F: Leigh Adams, Drew Petrie, Lindsay Thomas
Foll: Todd Goldstein, Andrew Swallow, Jack Ziebell
I/C: Scott McMahon, Cruize Garlett, Samuel Wright, Shaun Atley
Emg: Jamie Macmillan, Ben McKinley, Cameron Pedersen
In: Daniel Pratt
Out: Aaron Edwards
Richmond
B: Chris Newman, Alex Rance, Reece Conca
HB: Brett Deledio, Luke McGuane, Jake Batchelor
C: Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Jake King, Tyrone Vickery, Shaun Grigg
F: Matthew White, Jack Riewoldt, Bachar Houli
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Nathan Foley
I/C: Robin Nahas, Ben Nason, Dylan Grimes, Brad Miller
Emg: Shane Tuck, Daniel Connors, Jeromey Webberley
In: Luke McGuane, Alex Rance, Ben Nason
Out: Will Thursfield, David Astbury, Bradley Helbig
-
Nason to kick 3 :thumbsup
-
Nason is very lucky for mine. Picked on one quarter of decent footy last week. Looks like he or Nahas will be the sub.
Did Dea pick up an injury at training or something? As he's been replace by Webbs in the emergencies since last night.
-
I've got to admit that I'm surprized with Nason's inclusion. Has he been carving them up at Coburg??? Must be the sub as Jack said but he must be there to offer extra run. I thought Helbig was doing that as seemed 100% tougher around contests than Nason. Interesting :-\
-
The problem with being the sub each week is you eventually lose fitness and conditioning so you either get promoted into the starting 21 or more likely get dropped back to the VFL to play a full game and build up your fitness again. That's why Helbig got dropped.
I'd guess with Nason we are hoping he can produce a similar last quarter as last week at Coburg when he was still running on while others were tiring. Before 3/4 time though he was having an ordinary game.
-
Did Dea pick up an injury at training or something? As he's been replace by Webbs in the emergencies since last night.
Must have see my earlier post
Found this on Twitter:
@AFL_PKeane Patrick Keane:
Matt Dea withdrawn from Rich squad,rd 5 v N Melbourne. Replaced in squad of 25 by Jeromey Webberley. Final 22s both teams tbc late today.
Posted on twitter about 2 hours ago
-
No Connors, Ego still hurt, LOL
Nason to be sub ????
where is tuck lol
-
No Connors, Ego still hurt, LOL
Nason to be sub ????
where is tuck lol
A fair question actually - it doesn't make sense Nason over Tucky.
Nason wasn't great last week - good in the 2nd half but his first half was average at best
-
Did Dea pick up an injury at training or something? As he's been replace by Webbs in the emergencies since last night.
Must have see my earlier post
Found this on Twitter:
@AFL_PKeane Patrick Keane:
Matt Dea withdrawn from Rich squad,rd 5 v N Melbourne. Replaced in squad of 25 by Jeromey Webberley. Final 22s both teams tbc late today.
Posted on twitter about 2 hours ago
Ta WP. Do you know if that was due to any injury or just a change of mind by the coaching staff?
-
Ta WP. Do you know if that was due to any injury or just a change of mind by the coaching staff?
No idea MT, just found it on Twitter
-
No probs WP.
No Connors, Ego still hurt, LOL
Nason to be sub ????
where is tuck lol
A fair question actually - it doesn't make sense Nason over Tucky.
Nason wasn't great last week - good in the 2nd half but his first half was average at best
Tucky hasn't shown an ability to change and adapt to the changing ways of modern footy. He brings a pretty basic brand of inside mid footy to the table and we need players who deliver more than that "going forward" to use a favourite Dimma phrase. That would be my reason why Tucky is continually being overlooked.
I agree about Nason WP. I would've thought we would want to see a full four-quarter performance from those playing at Coburg to earn a promotion. It probably helps Nason that Dimma likes him.
-
No Connors, Ego still hurt, LOL
Nason to be sub ????
where is tuck lol
A fair question actually - it doesn't make sense Nason over Tucky.
Nason wasn't great last week - good in the 2nd half but his first half was average at best
tuck has shown nothing all yr thus far
-
Nason is very lucky for mine. Picked on one quarter of decent footy last week. Looks like he or Nahas will be the sub.
Did Dea pick up an injury at training or something? As he's been replace by Webbs in the emergencies since last night.
A poster from BG (Dougie) said
he had a stress reaction in his shin and will be out for a couple of weeks.
-
Nason is very lucky for mine. Picked on one quarter of decent footy last week. Looks like he or Nahas will be the sub.
Did Dea pick up an injury at training or something? As he's been replace by Webbs in the emergencies since last night.
A poster from BG (Dougie) said
he had a stress reaction in his shin and will be out for a couple of weeks.
Thanks for that tigers4life. A shame as by the sound of it Dea was finding some promising form at Coburg. Hopefully the meds have got to the stress related injury in his shin early so it is something that will heal quickly and for good and he will only miss a couple of weeks all up.