One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 22, 2011, 12:15:59 AM
-
Fire away ....
-
Port in Darwin :-\ :-\
Reckon Tuck is under pressure. Helbig struggled tonight.Perhaps they'll bring Miller back in...
-
Out: Grimes (inj), Farmer, Tuck
In: Astbury, White, Webberly
Probably only one of the last two will happen.
-
Miller back in for Helbig, Astbury in for Grimes! White? Well he just got injured at the wrong time!
-
Post -> cover grimes
griffiths -> CHF
funky.
-
In: Astbury, Webberley
Out: Grimes (inj) Tuck
-
Out: Grimes, Farmer, Tuck
In: Astubry, White, Webberley
Think the coaches got it wrong bringing in Farmer over Webberly. When Farmer was subbed on I honestly thought he'd do more harm than good, I like Farmers work but just don't think he's there yet. Webberly has been in form in the 2's and deserves a go.
-
Yeah I thought Farmer made some errors when he came on but I think White will be rested until after the bye so for the time being he will stay in the side.
I liked Browne's combativeness also bar that awful interception in the centre in the last quarter.
-
Out: Grimes, Farmer, Tuck
In: Astubry, White, Webberley
Think the coaches got it wrong bringing in Farmer over Webberly. When Farmer was subbed on I honestly thought he'd do more harm than good, I like Farmers work but just don't think he's there yet. Webberly has been in form in the 2's and deserves a go.
Fully agree Pope. Farmer struggled to pick up the pace of the game. Needs a couple more weeks at Coburg to get some serious run back in his legs.
-
Outs: Grimes (inj but was going to say time for a rest and to work on decision making = marking), Helbig (really struggled), Tuck (really struggled when he had to think about things)
Ins: Webberley, Miller (to free up Post to go back to cover Grimes), White (if fit, if not Contin ;D)
-
Maybe Thursfield for Grimes. Would like Webberley to get a game would drop Farmer for that to occur
-
White comes straight back in, his work this year has been fantastic!!!! Very important player for us. Adds some really important pace to our side. He along with many have improved out of site this year.
-
In: White, Webberley, Astbury
Out: Farmer, Helbig, Grimes
-
Im not supportive of dropping Helbig or Farmer after 1 game. Helbig also kicked a nice goal last night, ok he wasnt good, but lets not drop the kid after 1 game. Farmer seems unfit but Id keep him in anyway to get more run into his legs and more game time.
-
Im not supportive of dropping Helbig or Farmer after 1 game. Helbig also kicked a nice goal last night, ok he wasnt good, but lets not drop the kid after 1 game. Farmer seems unfit but Id keep him in anyway to get more run into his legs and more game time.
Would rather him do that in the 2's Ramps. Get a couple of doses of leather poisoning then come back in much better condition. It's not like we are missing much without him there.
-
Can't see them dropping Farmer
Dimma this season ;) seems prepared to give players more than one game in the AFL (except for Will Thursfield ;D)
BTW Helbig has played 2 in a row
Other thing to remember the step up from VFL to AFL is big - takes time to adjust to the tempo - Farmer highlighted that last night as did Post
-
All the players who step up from the two's mention the speed and intensity of the game. All the more credit to BrownE, I reckon. Did a massive job, even though we got slaughtered in the clearances.
I thought Tucky looked very off. Didn't seem to run to the right places, wasn't much interested in spreading from the contest and seemed to get out bustled in packs.
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
-
Word is that they won't bring White in until after the bye
-
in miller and edwards
out grimes(inj) and tuck(pathetic)
post will play in back 50 and miller fwd 50 and they possibly may switch
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
You're a Gus man :lol Your man Bowdo has more courage :lol
-
Hislop -> farmer.
Astbury -> grimes.
poo house effort coburg as per usual
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
You're a Gus man :lol Your man Bowdo has more courage :lol
Gus aint gutless,he's just stupid.
If Brown was fit,no worries but there were a lot of times in the final when we had to cover Browne in the backline because his output was absolute zero.He was rooted.
He was just a corpse,ffs!
Can't have poo like that happening.We were lucky to get out of it.
-
Can't see them dropping Farmer
Dimma this season ;) seems prepared to give players more than one game in the AFL (except for Will Thursfield ;D)
BTW Helbig has played 2 in a row
Other thing to remember the step up from VFL to AFL is big - takes time to adjust to the tempo - Farmer highlighted that last night as did Post
oh no! youve got the jackstar wink! Is it contagious? lol
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
thought BrownE looked puffed too, but if he did that well being stuffed he gets another go
And leave post and his vegemite cheeks in too, he's doing just fine lol
-
Gus aint gutless,he's just stupid.
I usually agree with you Brackets but in this case I can't. He lacks the courage or heart to make it as an AFL player and because of that I just can't support him. He refuses to chase, to contest hard, to make 2nd efforts, and worst of all - he goes down squealing like a stuck pig at the first sign of injury or pain. I hope we never see him in the seniors again.
-
browne looked like a massive improvement on Gus, yes he was knackered but I expect he'll improve on that with some better rotations with posty
-
Hislop -> farmer.
Astbury -> grimes.
poo house effort coburg as per usual
+
farmer -> webberly.
-
In
GUS
Sorry Ox, but based solely on his "efforts" today for Coburg - there no way in hell he deserves to come back into the seniors
He was poor again today, in a game he really should have dominated in
-
In
GUS
Sorry Ox, but based solely on his "efforts" today for Coburg - there no way in hell he deserves to come back into the seniors
He was poor again today, in a game he really should have dominated in
No surprise. Gus has been one of Coburgs better players no more than 5 times in all the games he's played down there.
FHO
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
You're a Gus man :lol Your man Bowdo has more courage :lol
Gus aint gutless,he's just stupid.
If Brown was fit,no worries but there were a lot of times in the final when we had to cover Browne in the backline because his output was absolute zero.He was rooted.
He was just a corpse,ffs!
Can't have poo like that happening.We were lucky to get out of it.
Browne knackered > Gus fully fit
-
BrownE with alittle help from Post was up against Hille Ryder and Bellchambers so no wonder he was R00ted. I would give him another.
Farmer as stated I think Dimma is giving a couple at least. otherwise I think he would be out, just looked out of his depth. Post same and provides a contest in the ruck at least.
OUT : Helbig Grimes
IN Hislop White
Tuck survives on Coburg losing to Frankston FFS :banghead Webbs had an opening there and didn't take it.
-
In: Edwards, Miller, Hislop
Out: Grimes, Helbig, Tuck
-
In: Edwards, Miller, Hislop
Out: Grimes, Helbig, Tuck
Agree with this :thumbsup
-
I Edwards is right would much rather see Farmer go out than Tuck. Think tucky would relish playing against the powers
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
Nineteen-year-old defender Dylan Grimes picked up a hamstring injury in the Dreamtime at the 'G win over Essendon and won't be fit to take on Port Adelaide in Darwin. David Astbury looms as a likely replacement. Brad Miller was a late withdrawal with a virus last week and could come straight back in. Matt White missed with a shoulder injury, but will also be close to making a return.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/114629/default.aspx
-
The only changes I would make is:
Astbury for Grimes
White/Hislop for Helbig
Gee then we have Hislop, Edwards (needs another rest... ;D), Tuck...
-
OUT
Browne - out- not fit enough
Post- Just really gay.... and a poo kick
Farmer - too keen
In
GUS
White
Miller
You're a Gus man :lol Your man Bowdo has more courage :lol
Gus aint gutless,he's just stupid.
If Brown was fit,no worries but there were a lot of times in the final when we had to cover Browne in the backline because his output was absolute zero.He was rooted.
He was just a corpse,ffs!
Can't have poo like that happening.We were lucky to get out of it.
Browne knackered > Gus fully fit
hell, even Nahas rucking on his knees has more chance of winning a hitout then Gus!
-
The only changes I would make is:
Astbury for Grimes
White/Hislop for Helbig
Gee then we have Hislop, Edwards (needs another rest... ;D), Tuck...
Astbury is terribly out of form WAT and watching him on Sunday for Coburg palying with no confidence
-
The only changes I would make is:
Astbury for Grimes
White/Hislop for Helbig
Gee then we have Hislop, Edwards (needs another rest... ;D), Tuck...
Astbury is terribly out of form WAT and watching him on Sunday for Coburg palying with no confidence
I thought he was named in the bests??
-
Nup. Seriously, who the stuff do we bring in? Gourdis seems to have a line through his name according to those Dan 'The Man' Jackson nut riders. Astbury doesn't deserve anything atm and who else is there? WTF happened to Thursty ???
-
Bring Pia Miller's hubby back in and then play Posty in defense.
-
Goes to show the lack of depth we don't have regarding tall backs..
-
Bring Pia Miller's hubby back in and then play Posty in defense.
Bang on Willis.
-
Not a bad theory Slick Willy (so god damn slick and big).
-
Footy Barometer - Round 10
Staff writers
From: Herald Sun
May 24, 2011 4:06PM
RICHMOND
INJURED: Dylan Grimes (hamstring) TBC, Shane Edwards (fractured cheekbone) TBC, Matthew White (shoulder) test, Daniel Connors (hamstring) test, Shane Tuck (ribs) test, Matt Dea (leg) test, Will Thursfield (leg) test, Jamie O'Reilly (foot) 1 week, Kelvin Moore (hip) TBC
ON THE BLOCK: Jayden Post, Brad Helbig, Mitch Farmer, Shane Tuck
ON THE CUSP: Brad Miller, Matt White, Jeromey Webberley, Tom Hislop, Ben Nason
AL PATON’S FORECAST: A replacement for Dylan Grimes is the priority and the Tigers' defensive stocks are thin with Moore and Thursfield hurt. Possibles David Astbury and David Gourdis both played forward for Coburg on Sunday with little impact. Jayden Post, who filled Brad Miller's forward role against Essendon, might be switched to the other end of the ground as Miller returns from a virus, or Damien Hardwick might prefer an extra runner on the big Darwin ground. Farmer should get another chance after coming on late as the sub against the Bombers, but Helbig might need a run in the twos. Webberley and relisted rookie Hislop were again Coburg's best in an underwhelming loss to bottom side Frankston. The best news from the VFL was injury-plagued key forward Ben Griffiths got through his first senior game for the year.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/footy-barometer-round-10/story-e6frf9jf-1226041482103
-
Footy Barometer - Round 10
Staff writers
From: Herald Sun
May 24, 2011 4:06PM
AL PATON’S FORECAST: A replacement for Dylan Grimes is the priority and the Tigers' defensive stocks are thin with Moore and Thursfield hurt. Possibles David Astbury and David Gourdis both played forward for Coburg on Sunday with little impact.
Gee you'd wish these journo's could get their facts right :banghead
Both Astbury & Gourdis played back for Coburg
The only bit he got sort of right was they had little impact
Certianly as forwards they had NO impact ;D