One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: TigerLand on July 11, 2011, 12:53:37 PM
-
Jackson for McIntosh + exchange of same round draft picks
Foley for Goldsack and 1st round (Pick 30)
Edwards and Pick 30 (from Coll) for Jackson Trengove
Morton to GWS for a 2nd round compo
Bank both Morton and Tambling compo picks for 2012 draft as it looks to be a beauty.
2011 Draft draft best midfielder available as we have lost Edwards, Foley and Jackson. List is quite tall now, need some runners. Midfielders develop quicker. No point drafting KP players as it will take twice as long to develop.
Would be good addition to the list McIntosh (26yo) and Goldsack (24yo) and Trengove (20yo)
McIntosh has 5 years left. That will allow us to draft a ruckman and give him 5 years to develop before taking number 1 spot.
Round 1 vs Carlton 2012.
B: Newman Trengove Rance
HB: Grimes Goldsack Houli
C: Grigg Deledio Conca
HF: White Vickery Nahas
F: Griffiths Riewoldt King
R: McIntosh Martin Cotchin
Int: Astbury, Batchelor, Helbig, (1st round pick - Midfielder)
Maybe a little tall? But with Helbig and Batchelor to add run to defence if need be.
Want to see Deledio in the middle with Martin and Cotchin. Will only happen when we get a better list.
Our ball use from defence may be an issue with Deledio not there. But Newman and Houli need to take responsibility.
Big 3 in the forward line Vickery, Riewoldt, Griffiths. Vickery helping out in the Ruck with Big Mac.
Defence cattle has improved with Goldsack and Trengrove taking big forwards with Rance taking 3rd tall and Grimes playing a Maxwell closing speed role to be 3rd man up and spoil everything.
Genuinely love this side.
:gotigers
-
Who the stuff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
-
Sorry Popestar but you lost the plot IMHO :lol
-
Who the eff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
Bit confused with what you're trying to say. Are you suggesting the trades aren't fair?
McIntosh is in the 2s. Jackson and exchange of draft picks is likely to land him. Goldstein is there future. McIntosh is not. Jackson is a leader North have very few of.
Goldsack is playing in the Collingwood 2nds and is frustrated. Foley is a B-A grade midfiedler with A grade pace. Collingwood will snap this up.
Trengove wants to come home and we're in the box seat, Edwards is a runner which Port have few of.
-
Sorry Popestar but you lost the plot IMHO :lol
Haha, as in that the players I'm trading in are rubbish or my offers to trade them in?
-
Id rather send Foley to GWS for a 17yo pick which in effect is a top draft pick and gets you an O'Meara, a Kennedy, a Grundy etc.
I would only trade for 1 ruckman this trade period in terms of other clubs. Dawson Simpson from Geelong wouldnt come all that expensive IMHO.
Other than that just stick with getting high quality kids through the draft.
-
Who the eff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
Bit confused with what you're trying to say. Are you suggesting the trades aren't fair?
McIntosh is in the 2s. Jackson and exchange of draft picks is likely to land him. Goldstein is there future. McIntosh is not. Jackson is a leader North have very few of.
Goldsack is playing in the Collingwood 2nds and is frustrated. Foley is a B-A grade midfiedler with A grade pace. Collingwood will snap this up.
Trengove wants to come home and we're in the box seat, Edwards is a runner which Port have few of.
:lol
Mc is playing twos because he's just back from injury. Jackson is a leader they dont have many of? So what? The fat bloke that lives next door to me is in the leadership group for his clubs 3rds...do North need him too? Jackson for a top ruckman :lol
How do you know Goldsack is frustrated? Did you ask him?
Edwards for Trengove :lol
You have indeed lost the plot.
-
Like I said in another thread, I liken Jackson to Clint Jones of St. Kilda.
Taggers, battlers and poorly skilled.
Would you trade anything for Jones if he was available?
If somehow North are stupid enough to rate Jackson that highly, it will overtake our pick 19 for McMahon trade as the worst trade in history.
-
Who the eff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
Bit confused with what you're trying to say. Are you suggesting the trades aren't fair?
McIntosh is in the 2s. Jackson and exchange of draft picks is likely to land him. Goldstein is there future. McIntosh is not. Jackson is a leader North have very few of.
Goldsack is playing in the Collingwood 2nds and is frustrated. Foley is a B-A grade midfiedler with A grade pace. Collingwood will snap this up.
Trengove wants to come home and we're in the box seat, Edwards is a runner which Port have few of.
:lol
Mc is playing twos because he's just back from injury. Jackson is a leader they dont have many of? So what? The fat bloke that lives next door to me is in the leadership group for his clubs 3rds...do North need him too? Jackson for a top ruckman :lol
How do you know Goldsack is frustrated? Did you ask him?
Edwards for Trengove :lol
You have indeed lost the plot.
Sigh... How about make a suggest Einstein. 3 players that we need.
How would you get them?
-
Pope, it always makes for interesting reading but to quote a famous Simpsons episode - I think you are in Chocolate Land
"[Homer wakes up from a dream about The Land of Chocolate]
Homer: Not dreaming, not dreaming, not drea- Wha-? Dammit, I was dreaming! Why is life so unfair? All I want is the ability to eat everything in sight and turn into a giant ball! Is that too much to ask?! Damn you, reality!"
-
Who the eff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
Bit confused with what you're trying to say. Are you suggesting the trades aren't fair?
McIntosh is in the 2s. Jackson and exchange of draft picks is likely to land him. Goldstein is there future. McIntosh is not. Jackson is a leader North have very few of.
Goldsack is playing in the Collingwood 2nds and is frustrated. Foley is a B-A grade midfiedler with A grade pace. Collingwood will snap this up.
Trengove wants to come home and we're in the box seat, Edwards is a runner which Port have few of.
:lol
Mc is playing twos because he's just back from injury. Jackson is a leader they dont have many of? So what? The fat bloke that lives next door to me is in the leadership group for his clubs 3rds...do North need him too? Jackson for a top ruckman :lol
How do you know Goldsack is frustrated? Did you ask him?
Edwards for Trengove :lol
You have indeed lost the plot.
Sigh... How about make a suggest Einstein. 3 players that we need.
How would you get them?
Monky was probably right about you. How are you supposed to be involved with a TAC club again man?
Would love McIntosh but Jackson won't get it done unless Brad Scott is a fool. Trengove would be beautiful too, but Edwards? WTF are you thinking, 'Einstein'?
-
I'm happy getting McIntosh and Trengrove.
Trade Graham and Thursfield to GWS for 3rd Round pick. Trade 3rd Round pick and Tuck for McIntosh.
Trade Moore and 2nd Round pick for Trengrove.
Delist Hislop, Miller, Westoff, Hicks
So we gain McIntosh, Trengrove
We lose Graham, Thursfield, Tuck, Moore, Hislop, Miller, Westoff, Hicks
In the draft we gain 18 year old midfielders(2), ruckman and small forward
-
I don't mind it Popey, but I think it would probably take Jackson and a reasonable pick for McIntosh.
I think the Edwards/Pick 30 scenario for Trengove is reasonable, Luke Ball went for 30.
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Yeah but if Trengove walks they get nothing and he goes into the pre season draft where we have plenty of cap room to set him up with a front loaded contract.
They wouldn't want another Nick Stevens situation.
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Dead right JT and thats why we need him at the RFC, may have to trade Edwards and McGuane and Jackson... ;D
-
We need McIntosh more than we need Trengrove. Assuming we got McIntosh, he'll be pretty handy for 3 years if he stays fit. Browne can improve his jumping at Coburg. Derickx and an 18 year old ruckman will be the others. Graham to be traded or delisted. McIntosh is 203cm and 26 years old. Would be like Stafford filling a hole while our other 3 young ruckman improve. Our team would something like:
fb batchelor rance newman
hb grimes post deledio
c edwards cotchin conca
hf morton griffiths king
ff nahas reiwoldt vickery
foll mcintosh martin foley
int astbury helbig midfielder(1st round) grigg(sub)
-
these are all short cuts IMHO especially McIntosh.
-
Let's get Goldstein.
Offer him a massive front loaded deal and make him want to leave Naught Melbourne. Then give them Foley and Morton. :thumbsup
-
Trade Graham and Thursfield to GWS for 3rd Round pick. Trade 3rd Round pick and Tuck for McIntosh.
Trade Moore and 2nd Round pick for Trengrove.
Be logical.
1 - Tuck has ZERO value. He takes a list place at north, more chance of getting it over the line just for the draft pick. Which obviously isnt enough anyway.
2 - Moore has ZERO value. He takes a list place at Port, more chance of getting it over the line just for the draft pick. Which obviously isnt enough anyway.
Imagine us trading Griffiths for a broken down aging port player and a 2nd round pick. You would be tearing the club to shreds.
These arent in the ballpark of what would be required to land either.
-
I know we need a ruck and key defender, but we should also try and get some compo picks and go sick at the 2012 draft.
Morton to Gold Coast for one of their compo picks.
McGuane to Brisbane for one of theirs.
-
Dear RFC List Manager,
Please hand in your resignation.
I shall contact your replacement with further recommendations shortly.
Kind regards,
gerk feltcher
-
Maybe we could trade Morton and Edwards to Port for Trengove..
-
Dear RFC List Manager,
Please hand in your resignation.
I shall contact your replacement with further recommendations shortly.
Kind regards,
gerk feltcher
PMSL :lol
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Yeah but if Trengove walks they get nothing and he goes into the pre season draft where we have plenty of cap room to set him up with a front loaded contract.
They wouldn't want another Nick Stevens situation.
Trengove won't be leaving Port unless Port get something worthwhile out of the deal. He wouldn't ditch them like that
-
Who the eff do you think we're trading with? Have Wallet and Miller got their own club with all these players you want???
Bit confused with what you're trying to say. Are you suggesting the trades aren't fair?
McIntosh is in the 2s. Jackson and exchange of draft picks is likely to land him. Goldstein is there future. McIntosh is not. Jackson is a leader North have very few of.
Goldsack is playing in the Collingwood 2nds and is frustrated. Foley is a B-A grade midfiedler with A grade pace. Collingwood will snap this up.
Trengove wants to come home and we're in the box seat, Edwards is a runner which Port have few of.
:lol
Mc is playing twos because he's just back from injury. Jackson is a leader they dont have many of? So what? The fat bloke that lives next door to me is in the leadership group for his clubs 3rds...do North need him too? Jackson for a top ruckman :lol
How do you know Goldsack is frustrated? Did you ask him?
Edwards for Trengove :lol
You have indeed lost the plot.
Sigh... How about make a suggest Einstein. 3 players that we need.
How would you get them?
Monky was probably right about you. How are you supposed to be involved with a TAC club again man?
Would love McIntosh but Jackson won't get it done unless Brad Scott is a fool. Trengove would be beautiful too, but Edwards? WTF are you thinking, 'Einstein'?
Stupid post..
3 players we need, how do we get them?
Make a suggestion instead of replying 3 times that my suggestion is rubbish. stuffing hell.
-
Pope, it always makes for interesting reading but to quote a famous Simpsons episode - I think you are in Chocolate Land
"[Homer wakes up from a dream about The Land of Chocolate]
Homer: Not dreaming, not dreaming, not drea- Wha-? Dammit, I was dreaming! Why is life so unfair? All I want is the ability to eat everything in sight and turn into a giant ball! Is that too much to ask?! Damn you, reality!"
Lol Happy to be in Chocolate land, I think these 3 players would be attainable in the trade period, meaning clubs would be willing to listen to a trade and wont ask overs as they all have reasons to leave
McIntosh = Playing 2's, no longer number 1 ruckman, behind a very in form Goldstein.
Goldsack = Can't play regular senior football in the best team in the comp. Premiership Player.
Trengove = Wants to come home.
All attainable, I maybe asking for to much with my suggestions. What would we give up for them?
-
Dear RFC List Manager,
Please hand in your resignation.
I shall contact your replacement with further recommendations shortly.
Kind regards,
gerk feltcher
Craig Cameron is very unimpressive. Agree.
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Is irrelevant if he wants to come to Victoria though?
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Yeah but if Trengove walks they get nothing and he goes into the pre season draft where we have plenty of cap room to set him up with a front loaded contract.
They wouldn't want another Nick Stevens situation.
100% Exactly right.
This is why we shouldn't pay overs for him.
-
It's not my job to suggest trades. I dont need to suggest anything to know that what you have posted is no chance at ALL. Post a more realistic scenario and your suggestions won't get shat on, dude. Leave this stuff to Craig Cameron (as worrying as that is) and the club. ;D
Dont mean to be a prick but that's just my opinion. I don't see why we should get worked up about it...whatever happens will happen
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Is irrelevant if he wants to come to Victoria though?
i reckon JT will make sure Port get something worthwhile if he is to leave.
-
these are all short cuts IMHO especially McIntosh.
I disagree Ramps,
What is the correct ruck solution?
- Wait 4-5 years for a 2011 Draftee becomes AFL standard?
- Shop around for a mature age ruckman in state leagues ie Derickx?
- Hope that Graham comes good?
- Hope that Browne will come good?
- Trade for a mature AFL standard ruckman?
-
Trade Deledio.
If u wanna get serious about picking up some quality-Trade deledio,otherwise,
enjoy circle-jerking.
-
It's not my job to suggest trades. I dont need to suggest anything to know that what you have posted is no chance at ALL. Post a more realistic scenario and your suggestions won't get shat on, dude. Leave this stuff to Craig Cameron (as worrying as that is) and the club. ;D
Dont mean to be a prick but that's just my opinion. I don't see why we should get worked up about it...whatever happens will happen
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Is irrelevant if he wants to come to Victoria though?
i reckon JT will make sure Port get something worthwhile if he is to leave.
Yeah thats fine JT, no issue with me being told I'm wrong, but if your going to have a crack have a crack and say "What you suggest is crap, we'll need to offer first round pick and Edwards for Trengove?"
It's just some open discussion to see what we can do during trade period, as I'm sure we'd all agree we're haven't enjoyed the last few weeks.
-
Trade Deledio.
If u wanna get serious about picking up some quality-Trade deledio,otherwise,
enjoy circle-jerking.
Whats wrong with circle jerking?
-
harder.
Trade Lids-Get 2 really talented players+
I love Lids but if u wanna get real...
The duds who will be arseholed at years end will be going anyway.
We all know who they are.
Beter still-Lids and Foley
-
Pope, it always makes for interesting reading but to quote a famous Simpsons episode - I think you are in Chocolate Land
"[Homer wakes up from a dream about The Land of Chocolate]
Homer: Not dreaming, not dreaming, not drea- Wha-? Dammit, I was dreaming! Why is life so unfair? All I want is the ability to eat everything in sight and turn into a giant ball! Is that too much to ask?! Damn you, reality!"
Lol Happy to be in Chocolate land, I think these 3 players would be attainable in the trade period, meaning clubs would be willing to listen to a trade and wont ask overs as they all have reasons to leave
McIntosh = Playing 2's, no longer number 1 ruckman, behind a very in form Goldstein.
Goldsack = Can't play regular senior football in the best team in the comp. Premiership Player.
Trengove = Wants to come home.
All attainable, I maybe asking for to much with my suggestions. What would we give up for them?
Pope
McIntosh is currently injured and has barely played in the magoos let alone the seniors in the last 18 months. Hence the rise of Goldstein.
Goldstein - you don't trade or deal with Collingwood. They'll yada yada yada and tell us he's a premiership player and even if he doesn't play till his contract expires Collingwood on the above info will argue he is worth a first rounder or minimum second rounder. On that I'll pass and let someone else pay overs on him. Premiership players are great but not when they are fringe players and will be overpriced. If we pillage their stocks as revenge for Cloke and Raines in 1982 it won't be for Goldstein.
Trengove I would like and I think the good will between the clubs in recent drafts can continue assuming we can get the right deal done for him.
Jako Edwards Morton are probably our most tradeable players and all this trade talk from the media about what we need will have already got the alarm bells ringing from other clubs which would make it as difficult as possible to get these players to us. Furthermore these gypsy poor loser clubs like Naught, Dogs and St Kilda can only dream of
FTF and would only love to see us squander it on overpriced picks to wallow in the depths we are in.
I'm almost inclined to not go for a ruck atm as I would rather get a long term prospect rather than a quick fix bloke who has barely played in the last 18 months. Furthermore the comparisons to Stafford are poles apart. Staff was still a regular at Sydney when he crossed over in 2002 Hamish is all over the shop currently.
-
Whats wrong with circle jerking?
I bloody love a good circle jerk, you know.
Especially when combined with a cheeky game of 'soggy biscuit'.
-
Pope, it always makes for interesting reading but to quote a famous Simpsons episode - I think you are in Chocolate Land
"[Homer wakes up from a dream about The Land of Chocolate]
Homer: Not dreaming, not dreaming, not drea- Wha-? Dammit, I was dreaming! Why is life so unfair? All I want is the ability to eat everything in sight and turn into a giant ball! Is that too much to ask?! Damn you, reality!"
Lol Happy to be in Chocolate land, I think these 3 players would be attainable in the trade period, meaning clubs would be willing to listen to a trade and wont ask overs as they all have reasons to leave
McIntosh = Playing 2's, no longer number 1 ruckman, behind a very in form Goldstein.
Goldsack = Can't play regular senior football in the best team in the comp. Premiership Player.
Trengove = Wants to come home.
All attainable, I maybe asking for to much with my suggestions. What would we give up for them?
Only tradables are Jako Edwards and Morton IMHO and when I mean tradeables players I would trade in a heart beat. Other than our top tier the rest wouldn't get us nothing.
-
Whats wrong with circle jerking?
I bloody love a good circle jerk, you know.
Especially when combined with a cheeky game of 'soggy biscuit'.
:rollin :lol :rollin
-
Alright then, how about this?
Martin and our 1st draft pick for McIntosh, Deledio and Cotchin for Trengove, Riewoldt straight swap for Goldsack.
-
Alright then, how about this?
Martin and our 1st draft pick for McIntosh, Deledio and Cotchin for Trengove, Riewoldt straight swap for Goldsack.
The biscuits will be really soggy if that happens and the circle jerking won't stop. :help
-
Alright then, how about this?
Martin and our 1st draft pick for McIntosh, Deledio and Cotchin for Trengove, Riewoldt straight swap for Goldsack.
The biscuits will be really soggy if that happens and the circle jerking won't stop. :help
:lol
-
You blokes have no idea how highly Trengove is rated at Port
Yeah but if Trengove walks they get nothing and he goes into the pre season draft where we have plenty of cap room to set him up with a front loaded contract.
They wouldn't want another Nick Stevens situation.
100% Exactly right.
This is why we shouldn't pay overs for him.
Problem is, he's highly rated. If we offer up crap, Port will move onto Essendon or whoever else is interested and get a better deal.
-
If somehow North are stupid enough to rate Jackson that highly, it will overtake our pick 19 for McMahon trade as the worst trade in history.
It was a terrible trade. But Carltons Brock Mclean trade for pick #11 is up there with it IMO.
-
If somehow North are stupid enough to rate Jackson that highly, it will overtake our pick 19 for McMahon trade as the worst trade in history.
It was a terrible trade. But Carltons Brock Mclean trade for pick #11 is up there with it IMO.
McMahon trade wins by the length of the Flemington Straight.
-
Whats wrong with circle jerking?
I bloody love a good circle jerk, you know.
Especially when combined with a cheeky game of 'soggy biscuit'.
You don't need to resort to school boy humor to be witty.
Grow up people >:(
-
I disagree Ramps,
What is the correct ruck solution?
- Wait 4-5 years for a 2011 Draftee becomes AFL standard?
- Shop around for a mature age ruckman in state leagues ie Derickx?
- Hope that Graham comes good?
- Hope that Browne will come good?
- Trade for a mature AFL standard ruckman?
Bake as follows:
1. Trade Graham
2. Make a call on Browne
3. Trade in an affordable up-and-coming ruck in the 21-23yr bracket like a Zac Clark or Dawson Simpson
4. Hand no.1 mantle to Derickx
5. Draft a decent 18yr old ruck prospect
6. Rookie list another, either a junior or mature aged doesn't matter
7. Hold butt cheeks together
8. Try and crap out a winner
Then see what real quality we can snag when free agency comes in and our window opens
-
maybe if the recruiters do their job properly then we wouldnt need to pay for Hmac or anyone.
Every club seems to have nailed some beauties from VFL level. Duigan, Buckley, Okeefe, Pederson, Barlow, Pods, yet we cant find anyone descent.
How some of those blokes have still got a job is beyond me
-
Every club seems to have nailed some beauties from VFL level. Duigan, Buckley, Okeefe, Pederson, Barlow, Pods, yet we cant find anyone descent.
Jake King ??? We didn't get it right with Jake? He came from the VFL ;)
-
whos got the sao?
-
whos got the sao?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dY29PHC4uIU&feature=related
-
I disagree Ramps,
What is the correct ruck solution?
- Wait 4-5 years for a 2011 Draftee becomes AFL standard?
- Shop around for a mature age ruckman in state leagues ie Derickx?
- Hope that Graham comes good?
- Hope that Browne will come good?
- Trade for a mature AFL standard ruckman?
Bake as follows:
1. Trade Graham
2. Make a call on Browne
3. Trade in an affordable up-and-coming ruck in the 21-23yr bracket like a Zac Clark or Dawson Simpson
4. Hand no.1 mantle to Derickx
5. Draft a decent 18yr old ruck prospect
6. Rookie list another, either a junior or mature aged doesn't matter
7. Hold butt cheeks together
8. Try and crap out a winner
Then see what real quality we can snag when free agency comes in and our window opens
Cameron- Out . Gerks - In. ;D
-
some serious leggo hair in that ad.
-
'The artist formerly known as Owl'
You are still known as Owl? WTF ;D Words can't describe how happy you make me.
Rampsy, not sure I want Gerk in any sort of role within the club. Good bloke, knows his footy...but wouldn't be good for the players to see the kind of poo he gets up to. What has been seen...cannot be unseen
-
Righto, get back on topic you blokes.
It's just a lack of discipline.
-
You're not a mod you prick.
Craig Cameron, please get a hair cut and go back to Melbourne to work your magic.
-
You're not a mod you prick.
I find this comment highly offensive.
Wheres has the neg rep button gone >:(
-
You're not a mod you prick.
I find this comment highly offensive.
Wheres has the neg rep button gone >:(
x2
And I am also offended at being called Craig Cameron.
-
What about Kel Moore :shh and is Connors :cheers gone?
-
Every club seems to have nailed some beauties from VFL level. Duigan, Buckley, Okeefe, Pederson, Barlow, Pods, yet we cant find anyone descent.
Jake King ??? We didn't get it right with Jake? He came from the VFL ;)
wow 1 player WP. that was 5 years ago when GC and GWS was not around.
Facts are other clubs have done their research and when GC was about to come in, more emphasis was placed on finding VFL gems and once again we were found wanting.
Lachie 203cms soccer background, Simon Buckley, Barlow, etc etc list goes on
the best we could come up with was uum let me see. No one.
Someone who is not doing their job down at Punt Road IMO
-
What a load of horse spunk.
Simon Buckley was a Melbourne reject. You'd spew hot rocks if we picked that bloke up.
Derickx was taken from the lower leagues, hasn't had a run at it due to injuries, give him a chance to impress.
-
OH NO!!!!
A gerkin post I think I agree with, life will never be the same.
:lol
-
I agree with your post
Onwards and upwards for your life now :lol
-
Any recent pix of Derickx - i feel like a saint georges bank!
-
Any recent pix of Derickx - i feel like a saint georges bank!
(http://a2.l3-images.myspacecdn.com/images02/44/29bb4199a9ea40cb93f937dee6da9794/m.jpg)
Tom's mood is currently listed as "adventurous"
-
mmm,look....i need someone with an outgoing personality too...
-
, yet we cant find anyone descent.
Jake King ??? We didn't get it right with Jake? He came from the VFL ;)
wow 1 player WP. that was 5 years ago when GC and GWS was not around.
daniel I just replied to your intitial comment that we are yet to find anyone decent
key word here was "Anyone"
You didn't say anytwo or three or 10 you said "anyone and I highlighted that in fact we have ONE ;D
And BTW - as mentioned by gerks, there's DerickX, then throw in Webberley & Nason who have come from state based leagues as opposed to the U18 comps. Jury is out on whether thay are good selections yet but we are talking about two 2nd year players and one 1st year - too early to call just
-
, yet we cant find anyone descent.
Jake King ??? We didn't get it right with Jake? He came from the VFL ;)
wow 1 player WP. that was 5 years ago when GC and GWS was not around.
daniel I just replied to your intitial comment that we are yet to find anyone decent
key word here was "Anyone"
You didn't say anytwo or three or 10 you said "anyone and I highlighted that in fact we have ONE ;D
And BTW - as mentioned by gerks, there's DerickX, then throw in Webberley & Nason who have come from state based leagues as opposed to the U18 comps. Jury is out on whether thay are good selections yet but we are talking about two 2nd year players and one 1st year - too early to call just
Nahas come from port melbourne?
-
What a load of horse spunk.
Simon Buckley was a Melbourne reject. You'd spew hot rocks if we picked that bloke up.
Derickx was taken from the lower leagues, hasn't had a run at it due to injuries, give him a chance to impress.
buckley is getting games playing for the premiers. Not bad if you ask me.
Likewise leroy Brown. Would be a dud at Punt Road but mick turns crap into water. He is a magician and our recruiters are the most average in the system.
DX, Nason, Webberley, Dea and anyone else have done minimal or nothing. Still young though.
Nason LMFAO at the way he gets dropped by the opposition. Real find there Cameron and co. King has been good but by the time we are challenging he will be retired or close to.
-
I'd argue King has been patchy at best.
-
I'd argue King has been patchy at best.
i would agree. sheesh nason webberley king nahas derickx in typical richmond tradition in taking older types underwhelming to say the least.the only one of the 5 id persevere with is derickx and that would be next yr to see if he has anything to offer at this level.
-
Wasn't Hislop recruited from Bendigo ? ;D
-
buckley is getting games playing for the premiers. Not bad if you ask me.
I agree, but if RFC had picked up another delisted player that couldn't get games for the Dees you would be doing your tree.
i would agree. sheesh nason webberley king nahas derickx in typical richmond tradition in taking older types underwhelming to say the least.the only one of the 5 id persevere with is derickx and that would be next yr to see if he has anything to offer at this level.
Same. But I reckon they'll all be on our list next year except Webberley. They should trade Nahas now while he has value.
-
What I would like to see from a list management perspective:
Tom Scully for 2 first round picks (compo pick)
Jackson, Tuck & McGuane for GWS mini draft pick giving them muscle & midfield grunt
Edwards for Trengrove (PA)
Morton to Sydney for 2nd round pick
Nahas to GC Suns for compo pick to get it back
This gets rid of the cancerous McGuane, Nahas, Edwards, Jackson & Tuck ang gets us Scully, Trengrove plus a young gun. This draft is horrible anyway so won't hurt too much.
That would be an ambitious yet aggressive trade week!!!!
-
What I would like to see from a list management perspective:
Tom Scully for 2 first round picks (compo pick)
Jackson, Tuck & McGuane for GWS mini draft pick giving them muscle & midfield grunt
Edwards for Trengrove (PA)
Morton to Sydney for 2nd round pick
Nahas to GC Suns for compo pick to get it back
This gets rid of the cancerous McGuane, Nahas, Edwards, Jackson & Tuck ang gets us Scully, Trengrove plus a young gun. This draft is horrible anyway so won't hurt too much.
That would be an ambitious yet aggressive trade week!!!!
would agree with all of this. Adding to that what gerks said. the RFC of old wouldnt think of trading out Nahas/King types but if we are to be successful i would trade out one of those to gain an extra 2nd round pick.
Make it happen.
-
Tom Scully for 2 first round picks (compo pick)
:lol :lol ;D :rollin
Scully there is only 2 possible destinations for Scully & Punt Road aint one of them
And the chances of it being Melb grom slimmer by the day
Which leaves..... Sheeds' rose garden in ;D
-
The one that Sheeds will be pruning or the one that someone will eventually prune for him. :thumbsup