One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 07, 2011, 08:55:48 PM
-
Any positives today?
Lids' game?
Rance and Vickery continuing to develop as young talls?
-
none
-
Rance was great.
I liked what Dea did, even though he may have been on Nicoski?? He's already way ahead of Farmer.
I thought the guys wouldn't show any fight for the rest of the season, but they were switched on for this one.
-
They had a go.
-
Jacks 2nd half was a positive. Rance, Houli, Edwards, Deledio, Martin and I thought Foley was mainly good
-
Rance was great.
I liked what Dea did, even though he may have been on Nicoski?? He's already way ahead of Farmer.
I thought the guys wouldn't show any fight for the rest of the season, but they were switched on for this one.
Farmer was on Nico. Dea was on Darling I think.
-
They both swapped during Rotations .farmer and. dea has 10 goals kicked on them combined.neither are up to AFL standards
-
They both swapped during Rotations .farmer and. dea has 10 goals kicked on them combined.neither are up to AFL standards
agree :thumbsup
ive seen enough get rid of them both.
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
-
They both swapped during Rotations .farmer and. dea has 10 goals kicked on them combined.neither are up to AFL standards
agree :thumbsup
ive seen enough get rid of them both.
Seen enough of Dea, have you?
:thumbsup
-
Don't post with that "brilliant" man Willy. You are Slick but he will drive you insane...
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
because they never have before
JON
Cleve Hughes
no matter how you sugar coat it is, a dud is a dud no matter what age
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
thats the problem, no other club would of even picked him in the draft after playing 3 TAC games, we WASTE a 3rd pick, and people at Punt Rd are trying to justify there decision.
This kid is hopeless.
Even to the extent that Rance gave him the biggest spray today about trying to keep body on body of his opponent :banghead
this club has failed to often.
We on earth we have players on an elite list that we are trying to teach them to play football ,is BEYOND belief.
Funny watching JPod yesterday, he trained at Punt Rd a few years back and was told quote"" clearly not up to AFL standard and good luck for the future ""
:banghead :banghead :banghead
Then we go and rookie Miller ( who had a crack today but really isnt up to it )
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
because they never have before
JON
Cleve Hughes
no matter how you sugar coat it is, a dud is a dud no matter what age
Thanks Daniel
Staff at Punt Rd try and justify there decisions
-
Thought 2 positives were Rance and Thursfield.
Also, they need to play Lids forward of the ball, not behind the ball
Forget about playing him off half back, is a waste
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
because they never have before
JON
Cleve Hughes
no matter how you sugar coat it is, a dud is a dud no matter what age
He has played 5 games and is going nowhere next season. never said I rate him dan
-
The club won't get rid of a 19/20 year old 3rd round pick.
because they never have before
JON
Cleve Hughes
no matter how you sugar coat it is, a dud is a dud no matter what age
He has played 5 games and is going nowhere next season. never said I rate him dan
fair enough
-
Thought 2 positives were Rance and Thursfield.
Also, they need to play Lids forward of the ball, not behind the ball
Forget about playing him off half back, is a waste
Do you see any hope for Rance? I have to admit hes made a very fair improvement this year and can hold his head up high IMHO.
-
Thought 2 positives were Rance and Thursfield.
Also, they need to play Lids forward of the ball, not behind the ball
Forget about playing him off half back, is a waste
Do you see any hope for Rance? I have to admit hes made a very fair improvement this year and can hold his head up high IMHO.
Problem with Alex is his height, all things being equal next years with Grimes and possibly Astbury to take the bigger forwards, he would get the 3rd tall, which would help his game, Problem is that McGaune still has another year of his contract, current form saysd that he couldnt possibly be traded is form is so poor.
Will T was good today and actually took contested marks which is a good sign
-
Personally if no one takes McGuane in a trade the club should pay him out and leave open a place on the list for a new kid imho. Grimes, Astbury and Rance is a start in terms of developing a defence, admitted it has a long long way to go.
-
Maybe some playing or coaching careers are heading towards their end.
Nahas's will to fight.
-
Jack's second half was good. Tuck was good. Thursfield plays well on small forwards that should become his specialist role
-
Thought 2 positives were Rance and Thursfield.
Also, they need to play Lids forward of the ball, not behind the ball
Forget about playing him off half back, is a waste
I agree with Thursfield. He's nearly a keep in my books, because he does well on the small/mediums. We could carry him if we get rid of McGuane and the quality of the backline around him is better.
-
The first half was good with the expection of the final 10-12 minutes of the 2nd qtr where we lost the game
Ball movement was a lot quciker and more fluent this week
Third qtr was very pleasing to get back within in 4 goals simple because we moved the ball fast and direct like we did in the first half of the season.
The last 15 minutes of the 3rd qtr made the final qtr all the more disappointing IMHO - all the momentum and not a yelp in the first 20 minutes of the fianl qtr - extremely disappointing
Individual positives - Rance by a long way, showing greater leadership qualities at the moment, can tell he is bleeding for the cause.
Liked Vickery - problem we had though the 3 tall forwards (Jack, Ty & Miller) worked really well in the 1st but because Gus was well Gus we had to keep taking Vickery out of the forward line.... have to say we looked much better when Vickery was in the ruck - competed really well againsr Nic Nat
Houli was better this week
Best game THursfield's played in over 12 months IMHO
Agree with Jack - wasting time having Lida playing HB - not needed with Houli able to play that role
-
agree with the lids thing, he needs to exploited to his full potential further up the ground.