One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: yellowandback on September 12, 2011, 08:41:40 PM
-
The one caveat, it excludes our untouchables which include Dusty, Cotchin, Lids, Jack, Bacher, TV and The Pantsman.
Be fair dinkum, which of our players would other clubs want?
What would be a fair trade?
Is that worthwhile in a shallow, compromised draft?
I reckon we will struggle to move anyone from the club unless they are de-listed.
-
Maybe Nahas but I doubt we would trade him away after just resigning him.
A club also might look at Edwards but once again I doubt a club would offer what we would want for him though.
-
I agree, we dont have an excess of even servicable players really. Jackson, Morton, McGuane, White, Conners could be offered up as sweetners in trades involving draft picks.
I think our compo pick is probably our best bargaining tool. Sides may pay overs for a pick like that.
-
I have said this many times there are players we as supporters view as list cloggers that other teams in the comp for whatever reason think are decent players. What we think of them becomes irrelevant ;D
So with that in mind I reckon
Foley
Jackson
Edwards
Morton
have some value
So IMHO
Reckon you'd easily get a late 1st round pick for Foley if you looked to a GWS, N0rt, Saints, Port or Bulldogs to deal with.
Jackson for reasons that totally escape me would get you a very late 1st round pick off a Sydney or a 2nd round pick of a GWS or GC
Edwards would get you something from either of the SA teams - what? too hard to guage
Morton - can see GWS or Brisbane wanting someone like Mitch
-
So with that in mind I reckon
Foley
Jackson
Edwards
Morton
have some value
That's about right. I'd like to ad Connors, Graham & White but reality is they're not worth much.
-
With the possible exception of Foley, I don't think any of those players would be traded. I wish we could bet this stuff on sports bet!!
-
I have said this many times there are players we as supporters view as list cloggers that other teams in the comp for whatever reason think are decent players. What we think of them becomes irrelevant ;D
Your right there. I know there's alot of tiger fans that rate him high but I didn't think last year anyone would be willing to do a trade with us for Andrew Collins.