One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on November 22, 2011, 10:25:05 PM
-
Brett Anderson from Inside Football is doing a tweet-by-tweet phantom draft on twitter tonight. I've put it altogether in descending order:
Pick 1 – GWS – Stephen Coniglio (Swan Districts)
Pick 2 - GWS – Jonathon Patton (Eastern Ranges)
Pick 3 – GWS – Dom Tyson (Oakleigh Chargers) ... Others in mix - Will Hoskin-Elliott, Matt Buntine (could go any order)
Pick 4 – GWS – Matt Buntine (Dandenong Stingrays) ... Others in mix - Will Hoskin-Elliott, Dom Tyson (could go any order)
Pick 5 – GWS – Will Hoskin-Elliott (Western Jets) ... Others in mix - Matt Buntine, Dom Tyson (could go any order)
Pick 6 – PA – Chad Wingard (Sturt) .... Others in mix - Liam Sumner, Devon Smith, Billy Longer.
Pick 7 – GWS – Adam Tomlinson (Oakleigh Chargers)
Pick 8 – Bris – Toby Greene (Oakleigh Chargers) .... Others in mix - Adam Tomlinson, Billy Longer, Taylor Adams.
Pick 9 – GWS – Liam Sumner (Sandringham Dragons) ... Others in mix - Devon Smith, Billy Longer (could go any order)
Pick 10 – GWS – Devon Smith (Geelong Falcons) ... Others in mix - Liam Sumner, Billy Longer (could go any order)
Pick 11 – GWS – Billy Longer (Northern Knights) ... Others in mix - Liam Sumner, Devon Smith (could go any order)
Pick 12 – Bris – Sam Docherty (Gippsland Power) ... Others in mix - Taylor Adams, Nick Haynes.
Pick 13 – GWS – Taylor Adams (Geelong Falcons) .... Others in mix - Nick Haynes, Hayden Crozier.
Pick 14 – GWS – Nick Haynes (Dandenong Stingrays) ... Others in mix - Hayden Crozier.
Pick 15 – Rich – Brandon Ellis (Calder Cannons) .... Others in mix - Sam Docherty.
Pick 16 – Frem – Daniel Markworth (Calder Cannons) .... Others in mix - Brandon Ellis.
Pick 17 – WB – Hayden Crozier (Eastern Ranges) .... Others in mix - Clay Smith, Elliot Kavanagh.
Pick 18 – NM – Elliot Kavanagh (Western Jets) .... Others in mix - Brandon Ellis, Josh Bootsma.
Pick 19 – Ess – Tom Sheridan (Calder Cannons) .... Others in mix - Elliot Kavanagh, Todd Elton.
Pick 20 – Frem – Shane Kersten (South Fremantle) .... Others in mix - Josh Bootsma.
Pick 21 – Syd – Tom Mitchell (Claremont) - F/S
Pick 22 – Carl – Todd Elton (Dandenong Stingrays) ..... Others in mix - Jordan Murdoch, Julian Dobosz, Shane Kersten.
Pick 23 – WCE – Michael Talia (Calder Cannons) .... Others in mix - Sam Frost, Josh Bootsma, Tom Sheridan.
Pick 24 – GC – Joel Hamling (Claremont) .... Others in mix - Sam Frost, Henry Schade.
Pick 25 – STK – Sam Kerridge (Bendigo Pioneers) .... Others in mix - Tom Sheridan, Jackson Merrett, Brad McKenzie.
Pick 26 – Rich – Sam Frost (Sandringham Dragons) ..... Others in mix - Henry Schade, Shane Kersten.
Pick 27 – Adel – Alex Forster (Norwood) .... Others in mix - Michael Talia, Sam Frost, Sam Kerridge.
Pick 28 – WCE – Murray Newman (Swan Districts) .... Others in mix - Jordan Murdoch, Brad Hill, Josh Bootsma.
Pick 29 – Frem – Andrew Boseley (Geelong Falcons) .... Others in mix - Waylen Manson, Alex Browne.
Pick 30 – Bris – Henry Schade (North Hobart) .... Others in mix - Tom Downie, Tom Curran, Alex Woodward.
Pick 31 – Ess – Clay Smith (Gippsland Power) .... Others in mix - Sam Kerridge, Jackson Merrett.
Pick 32 – Geel – Brad McKenzie (Sturt) .... Others in mix - Tom Curran.
Pick 33 – Haw – Alex Woodward (Sandringham Dragons) .... Others in mix - Brad McKenzie.
Pick 34 – Geel – Tom Curran (Oakleigh Chargers) .... Others in mix - Jordan Murdoch.
Pick 35 – STK – Jackson Merrett (Geelong Falcons) .... Others in mix - Tom Curran, Jackson Paine
Pick 36 – Melb – Waylen Manson (Waratahs/Claremont) ....Others in mix - Alex Woodward, Jackson Paine, Jai Sheahan.
Brett Anderson: "Will end the mock draft there. Went to 36 to make sure all 18 clubs were included. For Saints fans Tom Downie or Daniel Pearce could be 37!"
Edit: Last but not least...
Pick 50 – Coll – Fraser Dale (Calder Cannons)
-
I have been super keen for Ellis at 26. I guess that's the reality of it if Adams and Docherty are gone by 15..
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
-
So for us he has:
15. Brandon ELLIS (Calder Cannons)
DOB: 3/8/93. Ht: 182cm. Wt: 83kg.
Pos: Medium defender.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d9mlgowvmA8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCSJRJMfSLY
26. Sam FROST (Sandringham Dragons)
DOB: 28/8/93. Ht: 194cm. Wt: 87kg.
Pos: Tall defender.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBLsyENGftA
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
-
I asked him about Grigg for those interested and if he is now going to be a late pick. Anderson replied: "Looking likely. Could still go in 30s but most likely 40s+"
-
Where can one find more info on Frost? Haven't seen anyone really talk about him. And more importantly, can he keep as cool as the other side of the pillow?
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
-
Where can one find more info on Frost? Haven't seen anyone really talk about him. And more importantly, can he keep as cool as the other side of the pillow?
Frost is anything but cool. Goes 120% at contests.
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
Frost would be a good get at 26 depending on how the other selections go. I would be disappointed if we took Ellis at 15.
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
Patterson, Meyer, Polo, looks like we drink from the same keg!!!!!
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
Patterson, Meyer, Polo, looks like we drink from the same keg!!!!!
lol going back 7 years to find examples of poor drafting :lol
-
6 years. 2005 was just as bad.
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
Patterson, Meyer, Polo, looks like we drink from the same keg!!!!!
lol going back 7 years to find examples of poor drafting :lol
Yeah but those guys were 17/18 so they would be in their prime now.....why is that a bad example of poor drafting... :huh :huh
The only decent drafting we have done and I am talking stars is Lids, Cotch and Martin, maybe Riewoldt.........so how have we drafted well in the past.
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
Patterson, Meyer, Polo, looks like we drink from the same keg!!!!!
lol going back 7 years to find examples of poor drafting :lol
Yeah but those guys were 17/18 so they would be in their prime now.....why is that a bad example of poor drafting... :huh :huh
The only decent drafting we have done and I am talking stars is Lids, Cotch and Martin, maybe Riewoldt.........so how have we drafted well in the past.
Because it was 7 years ago. Who cares now? It's in the past. We recruit well then and do a bit better but then miss out on Cotchin and Martin etc. Not to mention the selections were made by a different recruiter (Miller)
-
WAT's making excuses already
-
That would be a hugely disappointing draft for us IMO.
And that differrs from our other drafts how....... :thumbsup ;)
lol.... You really are an idiot! You say we have drafted poorly in years gone by yet you expect us to finish top 4 "no excuses" ?? I told you that light beer from the other pub will poison you :lol
Patterson, Meyer, Polo, looks like we drink from the same keg!!!!!
lol going back 7 years to find examples of poor drafting :lol
Yeah but those guys were 17/18 so they would be in their prime now.....why is that a bad example of poor drafting... :huh :huh
The only decent drafting we have done and I am talking stars is Lids, Cotch and Martin, maybe Riewoldt.........so how have we drafted well in the past.
Because it was 7 years ago. Who cares now? It's in the past. We recruit well then and do a bit better but then miss out on Cotchin and Martin etc. Not to mention the selections were made by a different recruiter (Miller)
Be interesting to see the players that were picked before the players I mentioned and see where they are now, that's the difference. The picks we make now will matter in 7 years won't they......
-
WAT's making excuses already
Excuses for your stupidity..... :bow
-
WAT's making excuses already
:lol
-
Be interesting to see the players that were picked before the players I mentioned and see where they are now, that's the difference. The picks we make now will matter in 7 years won't they......
Here is a list of the players picked before the above mentioned just to put it into some prospective for you..........
2...Jarryd Roughhead (136 games)
3...Ryan Griffin (143 games)
4...Richard Tambling (traded to Adelaide)
10...Chris Egan (Retired)
11...Adam Thomson (Retired)
12...Danny Myer (Retired)
14...Angus Monfries (132 Games)
15...Lyndon Dunn (80 games)
16...Adam Patterson (Retired)
18...Cameron Wood (58 Games)
19...Ryan Willets (Retired)
20...Dean Polo (Delisted picked up by St Kilda 71 games)
Clearly those player before our pick are making a huge difference :lol :lol And to put it into even further prospective for you.......
Picks 1-10.....8 players remain
Picks 11-20...3 Players remain
Picks 21-30...2 players remain
Picks 31-40...4 players remain (Inc 1 Father son)
Picks 41-77...3 players remain
So out of a total of 77 picks in the 2004 draft only 20 players are still running around today!
The one glaring mistake we made was taking Tambling over Buddy but apart from that the draft was that weak I don't think it would have matter who we took the year class just wasn't up to it!
-
The only bad draft pick of recent years that springs to mind was Troy Taylor, and that was pick 51 so by no means a wasted pick. On pure talent was a great pick up, just never got on because of his attitude.
Redundant to start bringing up drafts from before the new era started, was out of their control. I actually think the drafts we have had post Dimma have been very successful:
2009
Martin
Griffiths
Astbury
Dea
Taylor (Delisted)
Webberley
Nason (Delisted)
Dylan Grimes in PSD
2010
Conca
Batchelor
Helbig
MacDonald
Derickx
Bachar Houli in PSD
Not to mention the trading in 2009 with offloading Raines to Brisbane for #44 and then in 2010 with robbing Adelaide in the Tambling trade and picking up Grigg who finished top 10 in the B&F for Collins who wouldn't have got a game this season for us.
This year already looks promising with the trades done to bring Maric and Stephen Morris to the club, while also gaining a second 1st round pick (26).
-
The only decent drafting we have done and I am talking stars is Lids, Cotch and Martin, maybe Riewoldt.........so how have we drafted well in the past.
Maybe Riewoldt? Don't be a fanny.
-
Cake as a rookie pick was alright.
-
18...Cameron Wood (58 Games)
19...Ryan Willets (Retired)
20...Dean Polo (Delisted picked up by St Kilda 71 games)
Ryan Willets - who the hell was Ryan Willets and who did he play for... did he actually play any games? ;D
-
18...Cameron Wood (58 Games)
19...Ryan Willets (Retired)
20...Dean Polo (Delisted picked up by St Kilda 71 games)
Ryan Willets - who the hell was Ryan Willets and who did he play for... did he actually play any games? ;D
lol.....Ryan "Bruce" Willets was a 198cm Power forward darfted by port with pick 19 in the 04 draft.
He tore the league a new one with his 3 games and 1 goal ;D ;D
And for the record, Port had 5 picks in the 04 Draft (11,19,34,35 and 51) and don't have a single player from year left on there list ;)
-
Big Fabian Deluka could have been something
-
Big Fabian Deluka could have been something
Better than Gus........ :outtahere
-
Fabba could have been the greatest.
-
Big Fabian Deluka could have been something
Davey, its refreshing to finally have someone on this forum who sticks up for players who's names are so often spelled incorrectly. :clapping
On another note we need to recruit this kid just for our game in Cairns.
Just slot him in the forward pocket for the two quarters that are into the wind and we are set to tear the Gold Coast a new one!
What Wind??????
(http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/742/sebhenderson.jpg) (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/7/sebhenderson.jpg/)
-
wtf?
-
:o :o :lol :lol :lol Love the matching Bum Fluff under the chin ;D
-
Big Fabian Deluka could have been something
Davey, its refreshing to finally have someone on this forum who sticks up for players who's names are so often spelled incorrectly. :clapping
On another note we need to recruit this kid just for our game in Cairns.
Just slot him in the forward pocket for the two quarters that are into the wind and we are set to tear the Gold Coast a new one!
What Wind??????
(http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/742/sebhenderson.jpg) (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/7/sebhenderson.jpg/)
Are you threatening me? Jay Shultz was my favourite player so just leave me alone :(
-
Are you threatening me? Jay Shultz was my favourite player so just leave me alone :(
A day in the Life of Davey....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnfXvPBV1dA
-
LMAO @ Dookie getting his kit off at 4.10
-
I thought Dookie was a real live chocolate dog that could type :huh
-
Snip!
Back on topic pls people! ;D
-
Snip!
Back on topic pls people! ;D
Which was?? rattling Davey's cage or the kid with a wind break haircut??
-
Be interesting to see the players that were picked before the players I mentioned and see where they are now, that's the difference. The picks we make now will matter in 7 years won't they......
Here is a list of the players picked before the above mentioned just to put it into some prospective for you..........
2...Jarryd Roughhead (136 games)
3...Ryan Griffin (143 games)
4...Richard Tambling (traded to Adelaide)
10...Chris Egan (Retired)
11...Adam Thomson (Retired)
12...Danny Myer (Retired)
14...Angus Monfries (132 Games)
15...Lyndon Dunn (80 games)
16...Adam Patterson (Retired)
18...Cameron Wood (58 Games)
19...Ryan Willets (Retired)
20...Dean Polo (Delisted picked up by St Kilda 71 games)
Clearly those player before our pick are making a huge difference :lol :lol And to put it into even further prospective for you.......
Picks 1-10.....8 players remain
Picks 11-20...3 Players remain
Picks 21-30...2 players remain
Picks 31-40...4 players remain (Inc 1 Father son)
Picks 41-77...3 players remain
So out of a total of 77 picks in the 2004 draft only 20 players are still running around today!
The one glaring mistake we made was taking Tambling over Buddy but apart from that the draft was that weak I don't think it would have matter who we took the year class just wasn't up to it!
Great run down there TFT, very interesting to see the comparisans...cheers.. :thumbsup
-
Great run down there TFT, very interesting to see the comparisans...cheers.. :thumbsup
The bottom line is it was a very shallow draft very similar to this season :o
Our recruiting department back then was probably the worst in the league (Yes that includes you JackStar ;D) and I am very confident we have our crap together now days, the last couple of season shows we seem to know what were doing (With early picks anyway). I think Huge the recruiting mistakes like JON, and Fiona are a thing of the past :pray :pray
-
Great run down there TFT, very interesting to see the comparisans...cheers.. :thumbsup
The bottom line is it was a very shallow draft very similar to this season :o
Our recruiting department back then was probably the worst in the league (Yes that includes you JackStar ;D) and I am very confident we have our crap together now days, the last couple of season shows we seem to know what were doing (With early picks anyway). I think Huge the recruiting mistakes like JON, and Fiona are a thing of the past :pray :pray
Yeah we did make some bad mistakes and it shows in your list, lets hope its all over now, we definitley have improved in the last few years, lets hope that trend continues.
-
wtf?
Ewok.
-
wtf?
Ewok.
i thought it was Bobcat Goldthwait's nutsack
-
Here's Anderson's final predictions:
(http://s1-02.twitpicproxy.com/photos/large/454719983.jpg)
http://twitpic.com/7iq86n
-
I really hope Brisbane take Docherty like I've heard a few times, as then I don't have to worry about "what if..." in the future :(
-
No Grigg listed there up to pick 43. I wonder if he could slip to pick 55 :pray.