One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 01, 2012, 07:21:56 PM
-
The countdown to Mike Sheahan's No.1 player of 2012 starts tomorrow.
The first 10 names on Mike's highly anticipated Top 50 list will be unveiled in a special SuperFooty sneak peek at 7pm Tuesday.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/mikes-top-50-who-will-be-no1/story-e6frf7jo-1226486061320
How many Tigers will make it and where?
-
Lol
Cotch number 1?
-
Players 50-41:
50 : Nathan Jones (Melbourne)
49 : Harry Taylor (Geelong)
48 : Eddie Betts (Carlton)
47 : Lewis Jetta (Sydney)
46 : Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
45 : Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
44 : Jack Riewoldt (Richmond)
43 : Corey Enright (Geelong)
42 : Ivan Maric (Richmond)
41 : Daniel Wells (North Melbourne)
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos
-
Players 50-41:
50 : Nathan Jones (Melbourne)
49 : Harry Taylor (Geelong)
48 : Eddie Betts (Carlton)
47 : Lewis Jetta (Sydney)
46 : Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
45 : Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
44 : Jack Riewoldt (Richmond)
43 : Corey Enright (Geelong)
42 : Ivan Maric (Richmond)
41 : Daniel Wells (North Melbourne)
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos
Cyril top 10?
-
Daniel Wells at 41 ahead of Nathan Jones at 50? He can't be serious. I never get the love for Wells who is one of those players that will let you down when you need him most, time and time and time again.
-
Players 40-31:
40 : Rhyce Shaw - Sydney
39 : Joel Patfull - Brisbane
38 : Shannon Hurn - West Coast
37 : Sean Dempster - St Kilda
36 : Steve Johnson - Geelong
35 : Taylor Walker - Adelaide
34 : Scott Thompson - Nth Melbourne
33 : Brett Deledio - Richmond
32 : Josh Gibson - Hawthorn
31 : Andrew Swallow - Nth Melbourne
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos
-
The senile old prick has lost the plot. Rhyce Shaw higher than Lids. LMFAO
-
Rhyce Shaw is a premiership player...Just saying
-
Rhyce Shaw is a premiership player...Just saying
O'keefe is a premiership player, Kennedy is a premiership player, Hannebury is a premiership player. Shaw is a premiership passenger sitting in the back row of the bus with Morts.
Shaw's playing style always reminds me of someone running out of a burning building like George Costanza in that Seinfeld episode.
-
i :lol when saw he was doing his TOP50
who cares the guy is a dinosuar, get someone
more relevant Rupert.
-
Rhyce is lower than Lids
-
WOULDN'T be reading into this to much his a journo needs to stir the pot a bit and get people talking and reading the papers, we all could do our own top 50 and people will still disagree.
Cotchin will be rated around the 7-10 mark
1) buddy
2) Ablett
3)watson
4)Pavlich
5)swan
6) pendelbury
7) cotchin
8) judd
9) murphy
10) dangerfield
Know that top 10 will stir people but in saying that people will look at it
GO U TIGERS
-
8) Judd
-
8) Judd
8) Juddy
(http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b228/mollusc/308288_282168788549236_199939233_n.jpg)
-
8) Judd
8) Juddy
(http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b228/mollusc/308288_282168788549236_199939233_n.jpg)
Dinner
-
(http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m5y4baJctV1r3jsrko1_500.jpg)
-
WOULDN'T be reading into this to much his a journo needs to stir the pot a bit and get people talking and reading the papers, we all could do our own top 50 and people will still disagree.
Cotchin will be rated around the 7-10 mark
1) buddy
2) Ablett
3)watson
4)Pavlich
5)swan
6) pendelbury
7) cotchin
8) judd
9) murphy
10) dangerfield
Know that top 10 will stir people but in saying that people will look at it
GO U TIGERS
Swap Judd for Nic Nat
-
8) Judd
8) Juddy
(http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b228/mollusc/308288_282168788549236_199939233_n.jpg)
Dinner
her or the dog.
-
8) Judd
8) Juddy
(http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b228/mollusc/308288_282168788549236_199939233_n.jpg)
Dinner
her or the dog.
The dog
-
Rhyce Shaw is a premiership player...Just saying
O'keefe is a premiership player, Kennedy is a premiership player, Hannebury is a premiership player. Shaw is a premiership passenger sitting in the back row of the bus with Morts.
Shaw's playing style always reminds me of someone running out of a burning building like George Costanza in that Seinfeld episode.
:lol Coach, is on :thumbsup
-
What a bloody joke, with the exception of lids, jack is a mile ahead of any of those bums featured ahead of him....lol, like dempster or patful are better players :lol
-
Sheehan meh. Top 50 regurgitated stereotypes.
Irrelevant puff piece opinion that anyone here could do.
-
30-21:
30 : Grant Birchall - Hawthorn
29 : Brent Reilly - Adelaide
28 : Jordan Lewis - Hawthorn
27 : Beau Waters - West Coast
26 : Cyril Rioli - Hawthorn
25 : Nic Naitanui - West Coast
24 : Ryan O'Keefe - Sydney
23 : Scott Selwood - West Coast
22 : Brad Sewell - Hawthorn
21 : Luke McPharlin - Fremantle
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos/30-21
-
30-21:
30 : Grant Birchall - Hawthorn
29 : Brent Reilly - Adelaide
28 : Jordan Lewis - Hawthorn
27 : Beau Waters - West Coast
26 : Cyril Rioli - Hawthorn
25 : Nic Naitanui - West Coast
24 : Ryan O'Keefe - Sydney
23 : Scott Selwood - West Coast
22 : Brad Sewell - Hawthorn
21 : Luke McPharlin - Fremantle
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos/30-21
I wonder if ROK would have made the top 50 if he hadn't played in the GF?
-
I wonder if ROK would have made the top 50 if he hadn't played in the GF?
And Brad Sewell.
-
Mike just doesn't rate Deledio. Maybe he will if we make finals?
Scott Selwood's 2nd half of the year was ordinary.
-
20-11:
20 : Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
19 : Ted Richards - Sydney
18 : Lenny Hayes - St Kilda
17 : Tom Hawkins - Geelong
16 : Dane Swan - Collingwood
15 : Kieran Jack - Sydney
14 : Sam Jacobs - Adelaide
13 : Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
12 : Darren Glass - West Coast
11 : Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos/20-11
-
Cotch top 10!! :clapping
-
Lmao Ted Richards
-
Mike just doesn't rate Deledio. Maybe he will if we make finals?
Scott Selwood's 2nd half of the year was ordinary.
Agree. Deledio is well ahead of many names further up the ladder.
-
30-21:
30 : Grant Birchall - Hawthorn
29 : Brent Reilly - Adelaide
28 : Jordan Lewis - Hawthorn
27 : Beau Waters - West Coast
26 : Cyril Rioli - Hawthorn
25 : Nic Naitanui - West Coast
24 : Ryan O'Keefe - Sydney
23 : Scott Selwood - West Coast
22 : Brad Sewell - Hawthorn
21 : Luke McPharlin - Fremantle
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos/30-21
Wat an absolute joke, like any of those bums are better players or more highly regarded than jack or lids :lol
-
Here's the complete top 50 ...
50 : Nathan Jones (Melbourne)
49 : Harry Taylor (Geelong)
48 : Eddie Betts (Carlton)
47 : Lewis Jetta (Sydney)
46 : Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
45 : Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
44 : Jack Riewoldt (Richmond)
43 : Corey Enright (Geelong)
42 : Ivan Maric (Richmond)
41 : Daniel Wells (North Melbourne)
40 : Rhyce Shaw - Sydney
39 : Joel Patfull - Brisbane
38 : Shannon Hurn - West Coast
37 : Sean Dempster - St Kilda
36 : Steve Johnson - Geelong
35 : Taylor Walker - Adelaide
34 : Scott Thompson - Nth Melbourne
33 : Brett Deledio - Richmond
32 : Josh Gibson - Hawthorn
31 : Andrew Swallow - Nth Melbourne
30 : Grant Birchall - Hawthorn
29 : Brent Reilly - Adelaide
28 : Jordan Lewis - Hawthorn
27 : Beau Waters - West Coast
26 : Cyril Rioli - Hawthorn
25 : Nic Naitanui - West Coast
24 : Ryan O'Keefe - Sydney
23 : Scott Selwood - West Coast
22 : Brad Sewell - Hawthorn
21 : Luke McPharlin - Fremantle
20 : Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
19 : Ted Richards - Sydney
18 : Lenny Hayes - St Kilda
17 : Tom Hawkins - Geelong
16 : Dane Swan - Collingwood
15 : Kieran Jack - Sydney
14 : Sam Jacobs - Adelaide
13 : Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
12 : Darren Glass - West Coast
11 : Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
10 : Scott Thompson - Adelaide
9 : Dayne Beams - Collingwood
8 : Dean Cox - West Coast
7 : Patrick Dangerfield - Adelaide
6 : Trent Cotchin - Richmond
5 : Joel Selwood - Geelong
4 : Jobe Watson - Essendon
3 : Sam Mitchell - Hawthorn
2 : Josh Kennedy - Sydney
1 : Gary Ablett - Gold Coast
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mikes-top-50-eos
-
Kennedy #2. :lol
-
Sheahan is and will always be a complete stuffing derp
-
Kennedy #2. :lol
:lol
-
must say to see Kennedy at 2
was great shock value Mike "the duffer"
Sheehan
-
Cotch is ahead of all in front of him but maybe not Ablett. Maybe..
-
was expecting to see Cotch no further down than 3...might not have the track record of Ablett yet but is rocketting up with a bullit.
-
I reckon Sheahan goes out of his way just to schitt people, me in particular.
-
I reckon Sheahan goes out of his way just to schitt people, me in particular.
Of course he does because he helps sell papers
The other thing re lids, mike bases his ranking on several years performances I think so if lids can back up 2012 performance next year then expect him to sky rocket up his top 50.
-
The other thing re lids, mike bases his ranking on several years performances
If that was genuinely the case then how does he rank Josh Kennedy, Ted Richards, Nic Nat, Scott Selwood and Beau Waters to name a few, above Deledio?
-
The other thing re lids, mike bases his ranking on several years performances
If that was genuinely the case then how does he rank Josh Kennedy, Ted Richards, Nic Nat, Scott Selwood and Beau Waters to name a few, above Deledio?
I recently shared a beer with o'l mate Mike, and I can assure you he doesn't rate Lids in any way shape or form! The theory behind his madness is he thinks Lids is to soft and doesn't get enough of his own ball :lol :wallywink true story :cheers
-
Nathan Jones FMD.
-
happen to know lids' family, apparently there is a little more to the story, a vendetta that has been running for a few years by Sheehan. Mike (who I now have no respect for) Sheehan apparently took exception to a question about another journos credibility to critiscize players when he had never played AFL. It would seem that journos don't like questions about their ability to assess players but frequently judge players abilities. It would appear that most players find it amusing how little journos are actually in touch with the modern game and SHEehan is well past it.
-
Where is Mitch Morton FFS he played ina premiership
-
Where is Mitch Morton FFS he played ina premiership
:biglaugh :biglaugh :biglaugh
-
Where is Mitch Morton FFS he played ina premiership
Yep Lewis Roberts Thompson surely should have made the list based on being a two time premiership player. Top 25 at least.
-
I reckon Sheahan goes out of his way just to schitt people, me in particular.
Of course he does because he helps sell papers
The other thing re lids, mike bases his ranking on several years performances I think so if lids can back up 2012 performance next year then expect him to sky rocket up his top 50.
Lids.#9 coaches APOTY. Not top 30
-
NicNat couldnt make the top 10 at the West Coast best and fairest.
Obviously Mike and the eagles coaching staff have different views on his efforts.
-
Thought Coach would be up in arms no B.J Miller there , its a conspiracy !!
-
Thought Coach would be up in arms no B.J Miller there , its a conspiracy !!
Obviously Sheahan does not value the nice handball out the back often followed up by a perfect block!
:wallywink
-
Sheahan doesn't value some of the best things in life or footy. Perhaps he didn't put Miller there because he retired...well I hope that was the reason.