One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 13, 2013, 08:10:02 PM
-
Fire away ...?
-
Out
White
A Edwards
Grigg
King
-
Tuck must come in, Houli too.
outs: not Arnott please
-
In Mcbean Tuck
Out A Edwards King
White to sub
-
Out
White
A Edwards
Grigg
King
Did you watch tHe game white had it on the end of a string ...last one to be dropped
-
Out
White
A Edwards
Grigg
King
Did you watch tHe game white had it on the end of a string ...last one to be dropped
White was remarkably average.
Deserves to be dropped for a month alone of his effort during the OMera goal.
-
Cant see White being dropped, unless you can point out enough reasons before anyone else.
I wouldnt be pleased if we went in unchanged next week, I would have king and grigg and A edwards out
Bring in houli, tuck and either mcbean or for backs astbury/griff. Would have to rejig some possies but arnott replacing king, houli on hbf, newman to wing, tuck in midfield, mcbean straight swap for azza. They may try to stretch us with talls now they have sandilands back, hence maybe another tall back.
Thoughts?
-
Tuck must come in, Houli too.
outs: not Arnott please
X2. I also wouldn't mind McBean for Aaron Edwards. Don't think the beanstalk would be play worse than Edwards did tonight
-
yeah id love to see the bean in too, but maybe freo isn't the best team to debut him against?
-
Cant see White being dropped, unless you can point out enough reasons before anyone else.
I wouldnt be pleased if we went in unchanged next week, I would have king and grigg and A edwards out
Bring in houli, tuck and either mcbean or for backs astbury/griff. Would have to rejig some possies but arnott replacing king, houli on hbf, newman to wing, tuck in midfield, mcbean straight swap for azza. They may try to stretch us with talls now they have sandilands back, hence maybe another tall back.
Thoughts?
Agree
King 4 houli
White 4 tuck
Bean 4 Aaron Edwards
Grigg 4 helbig / bachelor / MDea / astbury
Griffiths needs a go too. Aaron Edwards dud
We are missing grimes / knights bigtime
-
Conca had his pants pulled down by Bennell. He had a shocker.
.... I wouldn't drop him though.
-
In Mcbean Tuck
Out A Edwards King
White to sub
Forgot about Tabouli, Tabouli in for King, Conca to the forward line and maybe Tuck in for Biscuit
-
Geez Geez can t drop arnot
-
White due to play his 100th game next week- wont be dropped was one our better contributors tonight.
We had a few who had real shockers this game and the wont get dropped
Hopefully Houli is right for next week, we miss his run and delivery from the back half
-
White sub or nothing
Just not good enough 4 quarter
-
Would drop S. Edwards and Grigg before others.
I actually thought A. Edwards was ok before being subbed today. He uses it well.
-
Can't we just bugger White off?
I demand satisfaction >:(
-
In: Tuck
Out: Grigg
-
Out:
A Edwards
Grigg
King
In:
Tuck
Houli
McBean
-
Tuck and Houli in. Out Grigg and possibly Vlas but not 100 per cent sure
-
We know what Freo will dish up here at the G,probably a close checking,low scoring affair,as is their want.
Do we go into the game playing like for like.If we do then I think Tucky comes straight back in.If we decide an alternative game plan ,then maybe not.
-
Perhaps one thread on this would do..
-
Houli comes in for either shane edwards or grigg
-
bean for Jackoff :thumbsup
-
Shane Edwards should not be dropped. Clearly best 22
Grigg. King. A.Edwards.
White also must be first in line.
-
At this point in time Houli is the no brainer..comes straight back in
-
Edwards is best 22, when he is in form. He is not in form.
Out: Grigg, S. Edwards
In: Tuck, Houli
-
Houli straight in
For team balance Arnott unfortunately out, for team balance
Newman plays on a wing and not down back.
-
Would like to see; McBean get a go, Tuck and Houli come in to.
Outs; Maybe King, White and A Edwards or Grigg.
-
Houli straight in
For team balance Arnott unfortunately out, for team balance
Newman plays on a wing and not down back.
Agree with points 1 and 3 but not 2, leave the kid in and he can replace pushup or titch who are out of sorts at the moment.
-
Shane Edwards should not be dropped. Clearly best 22
Grigg. King. A.Edwards.
White also must be first in line.
i reckon they will want white's run against the blockers.
king looks like he needs a rest and arnot can prolly play his role across half forward, so he could make way for houli.
not sure if there will be too many changes, though
-
The Barometer - Round 17
Herald-Sun
July 16, 2013
RICHMOND
ON THE BLOCK: Shaun Grigg might be nervous after starting as the sub and picking up just three kicks when he was activated. He replaced Aaron Edwards, who was taken off as part of a pre-game plan to make the most of the tropical conditions in Cairns, so back Edwards to play against the Dockers on Sunday. Not many worries at Tigerland, but Jack Riewoldt is overdue for a big game.
ON THE CUSP: Bachar Houli will come back after missing two weeks with a hamstring problem – he trained on Saturday and pulled up well. No game for Coburg in the VFL but Saturday’s emergencies Liam McBean, Matt Dea and Sam Lonergan are waiting for a call-up. Shane Tuck is also ready to go.
AL PATON’S FORECAST: Damien Hardwick was clearly happy to get out of Cairns with four points and write off some poor skills to the wind, rain and humidity. Although he did conceded goalkicking coach Mark Williams would be under the pump this week – the Tigers have registered 14.35 in their past two outings. Richmond controlled Saturday night’s proceedings from early in the second term and should have won by more, but it’s a whole new ball game against Fremantle. Richmond went close to knocking off Ross Lyon’s mob in Perth in Round 5 and will be desperate to claim a serious scalp to stamp itself as a legitimate finals contender. After that it’s Sydney (SCG) and Hawthorn (MCG) – lose all three and Richmond will be right back in the pack. So this week is huge.
http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/the-barometer-round-17/story-stuff-1226679695127
-
Just a crazy thought, how about dropping Jacky R and give Tuck a go in the forward line. I know he is only 189 tall as opposed to 195 jack but it could be an interesting trial. He's a pretty good kick and mark when he gets a sniff and couldn't be worse than Jack (whose attitude and performance matches his name) - Revolting.
It would also give Jack a good boot up the backside which he needs big time.
As always, however, I would bow to the knowledge of the great brains trust on OER and would be keen to read your thoughts on this option.
-
if you're gonna smoke breakky bongs, pass em around MintOnLamb
The Barometer - Round 17
Herald-Sun
July 16, 2013
Although he did conceded goalkicking coach Mark Williams would be under the pump this week – the Tigers have registered 14.35 in their past two outings.
This Mark Williams flog from Melbourne is an absolute dud, our forward line has been rank since he got his grubby mitts on it. Give him the ass and get Michael O'Laughlin in.
-
if you're gonna smoke breakky bongs, pass em around MintOnLamb
The Barometer - Round 17
Herald-Sun
July 16, 2013
Although he did conceded goalkicking coach Mark Williams would be under the pump this week – the Tigers have registered 14.35 in their past two outings.
This Mark Williams flog from Melbourne is an absolute dud, our forward line has been rank since he got his grubby mitts on it. Give him the ass and get Michael O'Laughlin in.
:thumbsup
-
Give him the ass and get Michael O'Laughlin in.
Is Mickey O looking at getting to coaching full time at club level gerks?
I know he's involved in the AIS academy and will be going over to Ireland but hadn't heard much else
WOuld be a fantastic get if he was
-
He is very keen and is very highly rated. Short odds to be the first ever Indigenous Senior AFL Coach.
(http://caama.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/IMG_3688-600x400.jpg)
:cheers
Will probably end up at Carlton, Collingwood, or Essendrug
-
Defender Bachar Houli trained strongly on Tuesday, showing no sign of the injured hamstring that kept him out of last weekend’s win over Gold Coast, and appears in line to come back into the side.
"It's all on him at the moment. If he can get through the week of training and have no issue with the hamstring, I'm sure he'll be putting his hand up to play," White said.
AFL website link (http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-16/no-pav-but-tigers-wary-)
-
if you're gonna smoke breakky bongs, pass em around MintOnLamb
:lol :clapping
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
Bachar Houli is expected to return from the hamstring tightness that has kept him from playing since round 14. Coburg had a bye at the weekend but Shane Tuck has two games behind him now in his comeback from a fractured scapula. Luke McGuane has kicked five goals in his past two VFL games but Aaron Edwards is keeping him out. Edwards was subbed out on Saturday in Cairns but has no injury concerns and was praised by the coach for the role he played in defence. Liam McBean, Sam Lonergan and Matt Dea were emergencies on the weekend. - Jennifer Phelan
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-16/afls-in-the-mix-round-17
-
if you're gonna smoke breakky bongs, pass em around MintOnLamb
The Barometer - Round 17
Herald-Sun
July 16, 2013
Although he did conceded goalkicking coach Mark Williams would be under the pump this week – the Tigers have registered 14.35 in their past two outings.
This Mark Williams flog from Melbourne is an absolute dud, our forward line has been rank since he got his grubby mitts on it. Give him the ass and get Michael O'Laughlin in.
If we were to play the 'unconventional card' I'd probably go with Deledio as FF. Sure his set shots haven't been the best, but he has a cannon of a right leg. I'd imagine he'd have the tank to lead, and lead all day
-
surely shane tuck is a must inclusion against the big bodied mids of freo. this is not subi where run and pace rule this is the g where contested ball and structure reign.
dont let johnson or mcpharlin just peel of and do as they please down back,make em accountable give em a like opponent to look after. bring in mcguane cant believe i said that, or god forbid a kid like mcbean.
bring in the third tall defender, pav may be out it means they will play a ruckman there i would not be surprised to see them keep silvagni down back and mcpharlin play forward.
-
Ballantyne is out for Freo with a hammy :cheers
-
if you're gonna smoke breakky bongs, pass em around MintOnLamb
The Barometer - Round 17
Herald-Sun
July 16, 2013
Although he did conceded goalkicking coach Mark Williams would be under the pump this week – the Tigers have registered 14.35 in their past two outings.
This Mark Williams flog from Melbourne is an absolute dud, our forward line has been rank since he got his grubby mitts on it. Give him the ass and get Michael O'Laughlin in.
SPOT ON!
He has been horrible since arriving at Richmond!
SACK HIM ASAP!
-
In (OUT)
Houli (Grigg)
-
surely shane tuck is a must inclusion against the big bodied mids of freo. this is not subi where run and pace rule this is the g where contested ball and structure reign.
dont let johnson or mcpharlin just peel of and do as they please down back,make em accountable give em a like opponent to look after. bring in mcguane cant believe i said that, or god forbid a kid like mcbean.
bring in the third tall defender, pav may be out it means they will play a ruckman there i would not be surprised to see them keep silvagni down back and mcpharlin play forward.
Agree completely need to keep Johnson accountable. He killed us last year at the G.
-
Mcpharline won't play. Calf isn't it?
Keen to see what jack has got against a more fancied opponent in Silvagni and Dawson
The big head should bag at least 5 against those 2 spuds
-
Hardwick said Bachar Houli and Shane Tuck were a chance to return to the side while ruckman Ivan Maric would play.
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/afl/richmond-coach-damien-hardwick-says-his-men-havent-been-too-bad-against-quality-teams-this-year/story-fni5f9jc-1226681367887
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bachar Houli trained on Thursday and will return from a two-week hamstring while Ivan Maric pulled up well from his first game back from a groin injury last week against Gold Coast.
Shane Tuck is in the mix after two games back in the VFL.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-18/tigers-using-roos-as-defensive-lesson
-
Some talk about bringing back Tuck, anyone else hear this?
-
not sure about tuck. dimma seems happy to not have him in the side. :-\
will we bring in an extra tall backman?
anyone know if the dockers have been playing 2 or 3 talls in their forward structure?