One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Andyy on August 17, 2013, 05:13:23 PM
-
Fire away.
McDonough out (omit)
Petterd out (omit)
McGuane out (omit)
Riewoldt out (if injured)
Conca (rest)
Ellis out (rest)
Vlastuin out (rest)
Maric out (rest)
Titch in
Whitey in
Newman in
King in
Lonergan in (just to cover resters)
Helbig in (just to cover resters)
McBean in
Stephenson in (cover Maric)
- Tuck full game
- Helbig sub
Astbury, McBean + Vickery forward.
Rance, Grimes (needs game time) + Chaplin back.
-
Mcgaune
Grigg
Pettard
Jackson
Chaplin
Mcbean
Helbig
Newman
ShaneEdwards
SomeonElse
-
Out: Riewoldt (rest), Petterd (inj... again), McGuane
In: McBean, Edwards, Newman
-
I don't get McBean. Have you all watched the highlights from Coburg? The pressure is nothing like AFL level. He'll be ineffectual just like McDonough was today.
-
I don't get McBean. Have you all watched the highlights from Coburg? The pressure is nothing like AFL level. He'll be ineffectual just like McDonough was today.
gotta reward the kid for his efforts in the 2s. Id play him at Full Forward and move jack to CHF. The Bean leads good has good speed and can catch the footy. He'll be ok.
-
Hell be better for the game in two three years time even if ineffective
He's a tall half forward flanker / forward pocket like franklin - not key position IMO
If play jack + Vickery and mcbean hff
If we want a Chf Elton or Griffiths would struggle to less worse than mcgaune. If they want someone smaller ohanlon.
The Aaron Edwards / mcgaune experiment isn't good
-
Out:
Riewoldt (rest), Cothcin (rest) McGuane, McDonough, Astbury
In:
McBean, Edwards, Edwards, Newman, Griffiths/Elton
-
Today we proved we are not in position to be resting players.
The players not selected today we missed terribly
INS: Newman, Edwards S
OUTS: Astbury, McDonough (not ready for AFL right at the minute)
-
INS: Newman, Edwards S
OUTS: Astbury, McDonough (not ready for AFL right at the minute)
X 2
-
Missed White's pace terribly today. S Edwards has butchered the ball a lot lately. I'm not hurting for him to come back. Newy would be nice though.
-
Missed White's pace terribly today. S Edwards has butchered the ball a lot lately. I'm not hurting for him to come back. Newy would be nice though.
Was Whitey injured?
-
Yeah I heard he was not sure what with though. Maybe hammy tightness?
Has had a good year Whitey. Didn't think he had it in him...
-
I don't get McBean. Have you all watched the highlights from Coburg? The pressure is nothing like AFL level. He'll be ineffectual just like McDonough was today.
Maybe not O but you have to expose the kids to that senior tempo so they understand it and can work on raising their game to the level required. Next weeks game would be ideal to blood a couple of newbies and put a healthy fear of mortality into the ego-centric bunch of front runners that donned our jumper today.
-
Missed White's pace terribly today. S Edwards has butchered the ball a lot lately. I'm not hurting for him to come back. Newy would be nice though.
Was Whitey injured?
Yes tightness in the upper hamstring
If he is fit White should come straight back in
But the last 2 players we said had hamstring tightness King & S Edwards have missed 3 and 2 weeks
-
I don't get McBean. Have you all watched the highlights from Coburg? The pressure is nothing like AFL level. He'll be ineffectual just like McDonough was today.
Maybe not O but you have to expose the kids to that senior tempo so they understand it and can work on raising their game to the level required. Next weeks game would be ideal to blood a couple of newbies and put a healthy fear of mortality into the ego-centric bunch of front runners that donned our jumper today.
:yep
-
Missed White's pace terribly today. S Edwards has butchered the ball a lot lately. I'm not hurting for him to come back. Newy would be nice though.
Agree on the White bit. Missed his link running with the mids his defensive pressure off half forward and his goal kicking ability today. After quarter time Whitey would have been invaluable for us today.
Out McDonough, Petterd, Astbury
In White, Newman, King
-
Today we proved we are not in position to be resting players.
The players not selected today we missed terribly
INS: Newman, Edwards S
OUTS: Astbury, McDonough (not ready for AFL right at the minute)
Agree with this take this game lightly and we will loose it and confidence shot .
-
Out: Riewoldt (inj), Petterd (inj), Maric (rest), McGuane, McDonough
In: McBean, S.Edwards, A.Edwards, Stephenson, Whitey
-
FFS....
-
Petterd made of playdough.
-
Petterd made of playdough.
Honestly, the whole team is, don't just pick one player.
-
Why not? He's injured first game back. Again.
(http://i1264.photobucket.com/albums/jj489/dwwaino/D5868B82-1FD2-4BEF-A72E-25D8ED81E4FA-3395-0000079B30E7E1DE_zpse3b1a654.jpg)
-
Why not? He's injured first game back. Again.
(http://i1264.photobucket.com/albums/jj489/dwwaino/D5868B82-1FD2-4BEF-A72E-25D8ED81E4FA-3395-0000079B30E7E1DE_zpse3b1a654.jpg)
What about the other 21 players?????
-
I wasn't aware they were all injured (again) :banghead
-
Newy's ankle is worse than has been reported. Won't play this week or next. Will have to have some luck to be right for the first final. Not good news for him or us.
-
What's wrong with it? That's seriously not fair.
-
Gameday saying Cotchin (knee)? :huh
-
Rest whoever needs it. It wouldn't matter if we lost the next 2 games. It would matter though if we limped(injury wise) into our first final.
-
Rest whoever needs it. It wouldn't matter if we lost the next 2 games. It would matter though if we limped(injury wise) into our first final.
I actually agree with, depsite my better judgement saying we need momentum and confidence going into finals its not gonna happen with plenty of our better players not right and other down on form who wont make up for the slack
-
gws will beat us
unless they want to tank for 1st pick
-
In (OUT)
Griffiths (Riewoldt - Knee)
White (Cotchin - Knee)
A.Edwards (Petterd - Hamstring)
Stephenson (Maric - Rest)
S.Edwards (Chaplin - Rest)
King (Jackson - Rest)
DO IT RICHMOND!
Team v GWS
Morris, Astbury, Grimes
Houli, Rance, Vlastuin
Ellis, Tuck, Grigg
A.Edwards, Vickery, Martin
King, Griffiths, S.Edwards
Stephenson, Deledio, Conca
Int: McDonough, White, Foley
Sub: McGuane
-
In (OUT)
McBean (Riewoldt - Knee)
White (Cotchin - Knee)
A.Edwards (Petterd - Hamstring)
Stephenson (Maric - Rest)
S.Edwards (Chaplin - Rest)
King (Jackson - Rest)
DO IT RICHMOND!
Team v GWS
Morris, Astbury, Grimes
Houli, Rance, Vlastuin
Ellis, Tuck, Grigg
A.Edwards, Vickery, Martin
King, McBean, S.Edwards
Stephenson, Deledio, Conca
Int: McDonough, White, Foley
Sub: McGuane
Not bad Torch but I don't think King or S. Edwards will play either soooooo:
Morris, Astbury, Grimes
Houli, Rance, Batchelor
Ellis, Tuck, Grigg
A.Edwards, Vickery, Martin
Hellbig, McBean, Vlaustin
Stephenson, Deledio, Conca
Int: McDonough, White, Foley
Sub: McGuane
-
King and Edwards trained the house down yesterday morning. also both ran over 10k ,
Both are right to go for next week.
In next week will be White, Edwards , King and Newman
Outs .McDonough, Petterd. McGaune and possible Grimes/Astbury
-
King and Edwards trained the house down yesterday morning. also both ran over 10k ,
Ok....so we must be playing 'funny-buggers' with selections - and that's ok by me. Go into the first final with a fresh side I say :thumbsup
-
King and Edwards trained the house down yesterday morning. also both ran over 10k ,
Both are right to go for next week.
In next week will be White, Edwards , King and Newman
Outs .McDonough, Petterd. McGaune and possible Grimes/Astbury
they wont be dropping Grimes, Astbury will go first (rightly way too tentative and indecisive for mine)
Reckon they wont risk Reiwoldt next week either, even though they had no problems risking inthe last 10 minutes yesterday :-\
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
and King who was being held together with duct tape ::)
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
and King who was being held together with duct tape ::)
and Lids when he had that bad hair do ::)
-
And Pettard when the play doh started breaking up.
And Cousins when we were 10 goals down at 3/4 time.
And Richo when the hamstring was off the bone.
And Polak when he decided to take on Metro Trams.
But when Hislop gets delisted we re instate him.
Yep we are a funny footy club. :huh3
-
And cogs when he was half dead
Oh let's put him back on the ground and root our best player in a generation so he is fully dead
:clapping
-
I wasn't aware they were all injured (again) :banghead
(http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/z/air-head-1431797.jpg)
I'd be giving donuts another crack. Blazed away a lot but against GWS just let him have a go and make sure whoever needs a rest gets one
-
funny to read that people think we are good enough to rest players even against gws.we do like delusion at richmond.
-
Claw are you equating what we say here on the forum with what RFC will actually do?..You really give us too much importance
-
funny to read that people think we are good enough to rest players even against gws.we do like delusion at richmond.
We can afford to lose.
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
and King who was being held together with duct tape ::)
and Lids when he had that bad hair do ::)
And Nahas when his third leg was digging trenches in the f50 ::)
-
Petterd inj
McDonough omit
Mcguane omit
Maric rested
Newman
Edwards of the S variety
King
Griffiths
Morris Rance astbury
Houli Chaplin Newman
Grigg Deledio Martin
Edwards Griffiths king
Foley reiwoldt white
Vickery cotchin Conca
Ellis Jackson vlastuin
Sub grimes
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
:banghead Scapula
-
Would like to see Helbig play and play a full game in the middle. I think he will be a good player for us when he gets his body right to play week in week out.
-
you understand they played cotchin after he nearly broke his leg?
and tucky with a busted collar bone ::)
and King who was being held together with duct tape ::)
and Lids when he had that bad hair do ::)
And Nahas when his third leg was digging trenches in the f50 ::)
Talk about an underrated post. Nearly 24 hours this little gem has snuck through. :clapping :clapping
-
Petterd inj
McDonough omit
Mcguane omit
Maric rested
Newman
Edwards of the S variety
King
Griffiths
Morris Rance astbury
Houli Chaplin Newman
Grigg Deledio Martin
Edwards Griffiths king
Foley reiwoldt white
Vickery cotchin Conca
Ellis Jackson vlastuin
Sub grimes
Agree but would like to see Helbig get a game
-
Actually would have thought it would have made more sense to play Helbig last week ahead of McDonough.
Only because Helbig would be one of those players that for finals would in the "next" group, the emergencies behind the first choices if that makes sense
-
In: Gerks
Out: Some flog from Mt Druitt
-
Missed White's pace terribly today. S Edwards has butchered the ball a lot lately. I'm not hurting for him to come back. Newy would be nice though.
Was Whitey injured?
Yes tightness in the upper hamstring
If he is fit White should come straight back in
But the last 2 players we said had hamstring tightness King & S Edwards have missed 3 and 2 weeks
Must be our heavy training finals load ;D
-
In: Shane Tuck to not start as a sub
-
The Barometer - Round 22
Herald-Sun
Tuesday, August 20, 2013
RICHMOND
ON THE BLOCK: Some injury issues but none are too serious. Jack Riewoldt hyper-extended his knee when he landed awkwardly in a marking contest late in Saturday’s loss to Carlton, but scans have cleared him of any structural damage. Trent Cotchin suffered a bruised shin and Ricky Petterd hurt his hammy in his first game back from a groin injury. First-gamer Matt McDonough struggled to adjust to the pace at the top level, Shane Tuck started as the sub again (but was good when he came on – again), and Dustin Martin played arguably the worst game of his career.
ON THE CUSP: Shane Edwards (hamstring) and Jake King (hamstring) are both ready to go and Matt White should be right after he was a late withdrawal on Saturday with hamstring tightness. Coburg was smashed by Box Hill with few standouts, although Robin Nahas, Aaron Edwards and Sam Lonergan remain in contention for a senior call-up. The worst news from the VFL was a likely season-ending ankle injury to promising big man Liam McBean. But scans cleared the young forward of bone damage, Tigers say he'll be ready for the start of preseason.
AL PATON’S FORECAST: Richmond is not only getting used to the idea of playing in finals again, it is also trying to get the hang of late-season player management. Coach Damien Hardwick indicated the Tigers won’t be taking any risks with players who have slight niggles, so it would be no surprise if Riewoldt, Cotchin, Newman and even White were given a rest against GWS this weekend. Meanwhile, the coaching staff need to figure out what’s happening after quarter-time – in the past two weeks the Tigers have kicked a combined 14.4 in first quarters and 14.21 for the rest of the match. Not something they will get away with in September.
http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/the-barometer-your-clubs-latest-injury-list-in-the-lead-up-to-afl-round-21/story-fndv7pj3-1226699981232#mm-breached
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
Jack Riewoldt will have to pass a fitness test on his knee and is in doubt although scans have cleared him of structural damage. Trent Cotchin (bruised shin) is more likely and Ricky Petterd (hamstring) will be monitored throughout the week. Chris Newman (ankle) and Matt White (hamstring) will have tests while Shane Edwards and Jake King are expected to be available. Given the Tigers are playing Greater Western Sydney, there isn't likely to be a push to play anyone under serious duress. Liam McBean won't get a senior debut in his first year after injuring his ankle in the VFL but Robin Nahas put his hand up for a recall with 31 disposals, as did Brad Helbig (27) and Matt Dea (26). - Jennifer Phelan
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-08-20/afls-in-the-mix-round-22
-
Would love Helbig to get a crack in the midfield this week.
-
Wonder how close McBean got to getting a game this year. :(
Helbig in midfield :thumbsup. But they always seem to send him back when he gets a recall
-
send Flossy to HB and Biggy can take his spot in the guts
-
send Flossy to HB and Biggy can take his spot in the guts
:thumbsup
-
Rest whoever needs it. It wouldn't matter if we lost the next 2 games. It would matter though if we limped(injury wise) into our first final.
Couldn't agree less ! The next two games are vital. I wouldn't be resting anyone unless they're injured. Have a look at what flirting with our form did to us in the second qtr on Saturday.
You need to hit the finals in some form. We'll win this week but if we were to lose to Essendon in round 23 that'd be 1 win from our last 3 games with losses against very ordinary teams in Carlton and Essendon. We will go straight out of the finals if that's the case.
Win the next two and we go in having won 4 of our last 5 games. Then we can make an impact.
Changes -
In - King , S.Edwards
Out - Petterd , McDonough ( both omitted )
-
The Tigers are expecting to welcome back a host of key players this week with Chris Newman, Shane Edwards, Jake King and Matt White all in line for possible recalls.
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/afl/jack-riewoldt-a-chance-to-play-against-gws-despite-knee-injury-fears/story-fni5f9jc-1226701854371