One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: pmac21 on March 26, 2014, 06:33:34 PM
-
Rance McDonough out
Grimes king in
-
Just read that. What's wrong with the Rancinator?
-
Injured foot apparently.
-
Injured foot apparently.
From going to ground?
-
:banghead
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
-
Rance/grimes/Astbury would of been good to see
No disrespect to chappy
-
the weirdo is back
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
injured foot (slipping over)
Thought one of them might be in trouble. Looks like I was right.
-
Really starting to bug me how they name the team!!
Just put them in their normal starting positions
Are they trying to be smart or what??
-
Really starting to bug me how they name the team!!
Just put them in their normal starting positions
Are they trying to be smart or what??
Yeah they don't want the opposition to know how they will line up
:rollin
-
McDonough out
Woud be no surprise.....fits the mould of Hardwick's favourite convenient scapegoat - the non-first rounder kid who was only average but still better than at least half-a-dozen of his favoured & immune hacks.
-
Richmond
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Morris
C: Grigg, Deledio, Ellis
HF: Petterd, Martin, King
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Vickery
R: Hampson, Thomas, Cotchin
IC: Conca, Foley, Griffiths, Newman
Emerg: A. Edwards, McDonough, Lloyd
In: Grimes, King
Out: Rance (inj – foot), McDonough
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-03-26/round-2-richmond-team
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
injured foot (slipping over)
Thought one of them might be in trouble. Looks like I was right.
Right about what? He wasn't omitted like you predicted one of them would be, he's out injured
-
Carlton
B: M.Watson M.Jamison A.Everitt
HB: C.Yarran Z.Tuohy K.Simpson
C: E.Curnow B.McLean B.Gibbs
HF: T.Bell L.Henderson J.Garlett
F: D.Ellard J.Waite M.Robinson
R: R.Warnock M.Murphy D.Thomas
INT: M.Kreuzer K.Lucas T.Menzel S.White
EMG: D.Buckley J.Cachia S.Rowe
The match will also mark a milestone for Jeff Garlett, who will run out for his 100th AFL game.
http://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/2014-03-26/blues-make-two-changes
-
McDonough out
Woud be no surprise.....fits the mould of Hardwick's favourite convenient scapegoat - the non-first rounder kid who was only average but still better than at least half-a-dozen of his favoured & immune hacks.
Yes it's bollocks
Donuts was no worse than houli Grigg petard and co.
Dimma favourites
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
injured foot (slipping over)
Thought one of them might be in trouble. Looks like I was right.
Right about what? He wasn't omitted like you predicted one of them would be, he's out injured
I see a pattern when senior players get dropped under Dimma. Told you 4 wouldn't play and they aren't. You do the math.
-
Carlton
B: M.Watson M.Jamison A.Everitt
HB: C.Yarran Z.Tuohy K.Simpson
C: E.Curnow B.McLean B.Gibbs
HF: T.Bell L.Henderson J.Garlett
F: D.Ellard J.Waite M.Robinson
R: R.Warnock M.Murphy D.Thomas
INT: M.Kreuzer K.Lucas T.Menzel S.White
EMG: D.Buckley J.Cachia S.Rowe
The match will also mark a milestone for Jeff Garlett, who will run out for his 100th AFL game.
http://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/2014-03-26/blues-make-two-changes
Looks like a winning team
-
Newman shouldn't even be on the interchange.
It's stuff#n Bull5h!t
-
Cant understand how Petterd keeps getting a game offers nothing we must be seeing something different to Dimma thats a joke.It's starting get me upset players not in the team on merit..Knights should be there ahead of him.
-
Newman shouldn't even be on the interchange.
It's stuff#n Bull5h!t
McDonough has passed him
-
giving games to players who aint standing up will result in another loss. :banghead fml
-
Foley. ;D
Wtf.
-
Hard wick has a history for overlooking promising youth, for the tried and tested c graders
At least he talks to them unlike wallace
-
Foley. ;D
Wtf.
add S Edwards ;D
-
Foley.....
Newman......
Pettard..............
Grigg.....................Vickery?
I'm unsure how Knights doesn't get a game?
Hmmmmmm.
-
Def would play McDonough ahead of Newman. Seems Chris is one of the untouchables after all.
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
injured foot (slipping over)
Thought one of them might be in trouble. Looks like I was right.
Right about what? He wasn't omitted like you predicted one of them would be, he's out injured
I see a pattern when senior players get dropped under Dimma. Told you 4 wouldn't play and they aren't. You do the math.
There is no pattern, Rance is injured - you must be Nostradamus.
-
Rance out with his injured foot is a huge lose...I am not sold on Grimes as a player yet.
injured foot (slipping over)
Thought one of them might be in trouble. Looks like I was right.
Right about what? He wasn't omitted like you predicted one of them would be, he's out injured
I see a pattern when senior players get dropped under Dimma. Told you 4 wouldn't play and they aren't. You do the math.
There is no pattern, Rance is injured - you must be Nostradamus.
Righto.
-
Hardwick keeping faith with his boys. They owe him one.
Donut a bit a stiff. Can understand his demotion but doesn't set a great example when you leave certain blokes in the team after the way they played against GC. I think Rance has finally blown his foot out from carrying Troy Chaplin for 12 months.
Edit: Good to have the creep back
-
I see what Magic is saying but I don't agree on this occasion. There is no Arsene Wenger Jens Lehmann elbow injury about this
-
Def would play McDonough ahead of Newman. Seems Chris is one of the untouchables after all.
Yes he is, he doesn't stands up and has been very average for a few years now. McDonough, Knights, Gordon, Arnot & Lloyd should be played before him. Do something Newman.......
-
Def would play McDonough ahead of Newman. Seems Chris is one of the untouchables after all.
Yes he is, he doesn't stands up and has been very average for a few years now. McDonough, Knights, Gordon, Arnot & Lloyd should be played before him. Do something Newman.......
Agree 2 of them can play for Newman and pettard. Liked what arnott had to offer when he played last season
-
Wouldn't mind betting a late change and Newman is replaced by either Edwards or Lloyd.
-
Def would play McDonough ahead of Newman. Seems Chris is one of the untouchables after all.
You've only just worked that out :o
Got to feel for McDonut, granted I am not a fan as such but I thought he was a lot better against GC than a number of others - sends a very poor message indeed (IMHO)
At least they didn't drop Griffiths :-\
-
ffs only two changes and all of the softies survive.
and what inclusions.
adonis grimes to play on one of waite or henderson good luck top em eh, they are gunna get monstered.
and that silky smooth wizard who has the ball on a string and kicks em from anywhere king.
just stuffing great .
-
Yeah but at least king gets heaps of the ball
-
Gee I'm just not sold on this team...really thought Lloyd and Knights could of come in to mix it up a bit and provide some run....Grimes I can understand because he always keeps his fitness and God do we need him down back! Probably on Waite. But hell, I don't think we have the pace... :-\
-
You are forgetting chaplains excellent manoeuvrability and speed
-
You are forgetting chaplains excellent manoeuvrability and speed
Seems to have slowed down with a full preseason under his belt. Maybe we should not train him like last year and he'll speed up! :whistle
-
Yeah but at least king gets heaps of the ball
damn right judge those 11.8 possesions a game last yr are an absolute avalanche of possesion. iknow give him another 5yr contract.
-
Will be interesting to see how this team goes, no real statement here except the wrong one, will be extremely interesting to see what happens if we have another loss
-
on mcdonough. while a bit harsh dropping him after just one game to me he looked out of his depth. personally if chasing a better current option i would have liked to see one of gordon or knights come in for him. id nprefer to see him play in front of some named if for no other reason than the experience.
i see peterd has been named forward again. how a edwards did not get picked in his place is beyond me.
i gotta agree with a lot of posters here. we dont pick players on form or for position we pick players who we like the most. they are usually spineless or lacking in basic skills or both. rfc the club where glass half fulls get long service leave.
terry hardwick come on down son. enjoy your contract while you can. why because its starting to look like your another another in a long line who dont have the balls to see a rebuild right thru.
-
Richmond
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Morris
C: Grigg, Deledio, Ellis
HF: Petterd, Martin, King
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Vickery
R: Hampson, Thomas, Cotchin
IC: Conca, Foley, Griffiths, Newman
Emerg: A. Edwards, McDonough, Lloyd
In: Grimes, King
Out: Rance (inj – foot), McDonough
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-03-26/round-2-richmond-team
thats one pee poor team. how the hell did we win 15 games last yr. was the rest of the comp that bad as well. must have been.
-
Rance's omission is huge. He is our best backman. I'm worried Henderson will towel us up now. I'm pleased to see King back in as he is a huge presence in the forwardline and creates goals through his aggression, pressure and uncompromising attack on the ball. I'm hoping the bigger ground suits our spread and helps players like Vickery and Griffiths. :pray
Not very confident....God I hate Carlton :banghead
-
What the stuff is this the Barossa Valley thread? I am drowning in whine!
-
Matty Donut, very stiff!
Pettard please...... :pray
-
Doomsayers are really getting their licks in after a loss. Good on em.
-
Foley. ;D
Wtf.
add S Edwards ;D
Edwards and Newman what a formidable duo.
-
Rance's omission is huge. He is our best backman. I'm worried Henderson will towel us up now. I'm pleased to see King back in as he is a huge presence in the forwardline and creates goals through his aggression, pressure and uncompromising attack on the ball. I'm hoping the bigger ground suits our spread and helps players like Vickery and Griffiths. :pray
Not very confident....God I hate Carlton :banghead
I agree Rance being out of the side is a big loss. I am glad King is back in the side. Need people of character in the team. Thank god no more Eddy Betts but need to watch Gibbs. He killed us last year and will do it again if not taken care of. Given it is going to rain today would like to see them make a late change and bring in Biscuit. How Petterd survived stuns me. It shows weakness by the selection panel.
-
Petterd has the photos
-
I'm pretty disappointed with these selections, but not really surprised. There were a lot worse than McDonough last week, but he gets scapegoated. Case in point: watch Dimma's dissection last week, and he refers to Grigg's "lack of defensive accountability" ( I am paraphrasing him word for word here.) It may only be one incident, but it's a quote which defines that particular squib.
Pet Turd is another one who just flabbergasts me. He brings absolutely NOTHING to the team, yet is an automatic selection every week. "Cameo" Vickery had better be on notice too. At the very least I'd expect Dimma to have told him that if he keeps playing from behind like he did last week he'll be running around in the 2's next week.
I'd really liked to have seen the likes of Lloyd and Gordon in the side.
-
the club should pay the fine and bring in Gordon. Its crap weather and we need an extra hard nut in the middle.
-
rancer out is huge. bugger...
Agree 100% with the a.edwards over pettard calls.
Foley - good opportunity to show hardwick he's a nuffer for cutting you from the final last year.
The fact that we lost last week has taken some of the excitement away, and it's basically all nerves now.
gee i hope we beat the scum ... cant handle another loss to these narks. My hand has only just recovered after belting the poo out of that seat at the end of last years elim final.
Wet weather hopefully turns it in our favor - i think we have a good record in the wet? :pray
-
My 'sources' tell me Kruezer will not be playing tonight.....
-
My 'sources'
The internet?
-
My 'sources'
The internet?
Every news outlet?
-
My 'sources' tell me Kruezer will not be playing tonight.....
Probably an advantage for them. Hope we don't go in top heavy if it's belting down.
Anyhow , it's usually hacks like Duigan , Robinson and McLean who play their one good game for the year against us. We make 'em look like superstars.
-
My prediction for this match's "saved their best for Richmond" Carlton player is Garlett....will make amends for his misses last year.
-
Big boost for Carlton with Watson out
-
My 'sources' tell me Kruezer will not be playing tonight.....
Probably an advantage for them. Hope we don't go in top heavy if it's belting down.
Anyhow , it's usually hacks like Duigan , Robinson and McLean who play their one good game for the year against us. We make 'em look like superstars.
Kruzer kills us ...
-
My 'sources' tell me Kruezer will not be playing tonight.....
Probably an advantage for them. Hope we don't go in top heavy if it's belting down.
Anyhow , it's usually hacks like Duigan , Robinson and McLean who play their one good game for the year against us. We make 'em look like superstars.
Exactly - one game a year wonders ::). At Waite to that list as well.