One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 24, 2014, 06:25:22 PM
-
The Round 6 Tiger squad
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Newman, Morris
C: Grigg, Jackson, Conca
HF: Martin, Griffiths, Lloyd
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Petterd
R: Hampson, Ellis, Cotchin
IC (from): Helbig, Vlastuin, Arnot, Gordon, Batchelor, McDonough, Lennon
In: Helbig, Batchelor, McDonough, Lennon
Out: Thomas (inj – knee)
New: Ben Lennon, a 188cm, 77kg utility, taken by Richmond at pick 12 in the 2013 AFL National Draft.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-04-24/round-6-richmond-squad
-
How many do we have to cut tomorrow ?
-
How many do we have to cut tomorrow ?
3
-
How many do we have to cut tomorrow ?
3
Hrm.. I'd go with Helbig (spud), Batchelor and Lemmon. Give Matty Mcdonut a game
-
We will know early tomorrow seeing the VFL are playing around 2pm. ;D
Though I reckon they will keep one out of the VFL as an emergency
Also, wouldn't have been surprised if Thomas was dropped if he wasn't injured, was poor last week
-
Hawthorn squad for this interested ...
B: Burgoyne Gibson Stratton
HB: Suckling Birchall Hodge
C: Smith Mitchell Hill
HF: Gunston Rioli
F: Hale Roughead Breust
Foll: McEvoy Langford Lewis
I/C from: Duryea Hallahan Simpkin Cheney Lake Schoenmakers Hartung
In: B.Lake , R.Schoenmakers , B.Hartung
http://www.hawthornfc.com.au/news/2014-04-24/round-6-squad
-
The Round 6 Tiger squad
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Newman, Morris
C: Grigg, Jackson, Conca
HF: Martin, Griffiths, Lloyd
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Petterd
R: Hampson, Ellis, Cotchin
IC (from): Helbig, Vlastuin, Arnot, Gordon, Batchelor, McDonough, Lennon
In: Helbig, Batchelor, McDonough, Lennon
Out: Thomas (inj – knee)
New: Ben Lennon, a 188cm, 77kg utility, taken by Richmond at pick 12 in the 2013 AFL National Draft.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-04-24/round-6-richmond-squad
pretty handy side just quietly , McDonough or Lennon to get Thomas spot, depends on weather
-
8 point game
-
8 point game
:clapping
-
not sure where hes at but id have a edwards in for petterd, lennon for s edwards, and helbig for houli. such a shame elton isnt ready because id be looking to stretch em with 3 tall forwards as well.
so let me get this straight. we play griffiths and riewoldt as kpps but we do what we lament all last yr and the start of this byr we play griffiths in the same role / way we did with vickery. wasnt it uber impottant to play vickery permanently at home but this sort of structure goes out the window with vickery it seems.
rabble thats what the r stands for.
-
W stands for wabbit
-
Has cclaw ever not complained?
-
In: Lennon, McDonough Miles, Rance, Lids, Maric
Out: S.Edwards, petterd, Newman, Grigg, Thomas, Grimes
Then give the side with lennon, Miles, McDonough, Lloyd, Gordon, Arnott time to gel, also continue to get games into Griffiths and Astbury. By seasons end we'll have a pretty good indication of who we think will make it and wont. Enough with giving games to the same retreads who continually let us down, except for when they dominate against the likes of Brisbane of course woahh
-
In: Lennon, McDonough Miles, Rance, Lids, Maric
Out: S.Edwards, petterd, Newman, Grigg, Thomas, Grimes
Then give the side with lennon, Miles, McDonough, Lloyd, Gordon, Arnott time to gel, also continue to get games into Griffiths and Astbury. By seasons end we'll have a pretty good indication of who we think will make it and wont. Enough with giving games to the same retreads who continually let us down, except for when they dominate against the likes of Brisbane of course woahh
Maric, Rance and Lids are injured!
-
The trouble with this side for me is I'd like to see everyone on the bench get a game. The three outs should be Grigg, Petterd and Shane Edwards. To name all these fresh faces and then not play them is just one big tease.
-
The trouble with this side for me is I'd like to see everyone on the bench get a game. The three outs should be Grigg, Petterd and Shane Edwards. To name all these fresh faces and then not play them is just one big tease.
:yep
I agree with those outs and ins.
I would rather see us lose (if we do?) With these kids giving it everything rather than the usual suspects gifted games and not giving 100%
-
pretty handy side just quietly , McDonough or Lennon to get Thomas spot, depends on weather
Just quietly the side is garbage compared to where we need it to be.
3 of our absolute key players are missing in Rance, Lids and Maric just for a starting point.
Just quietly
-
Whilst the team still has Newman and Grigg in it we're no good.
-
In: Lennon, McDonough Miles, Rance, Lids, Maric
Out: S.Edwards, petterd, Newman, Grigg, Thomas, Grimes
Then give the side with lennon, Miles, McDonough, Lloyd, Gordon, Arnott time to gel, also continue to get games into Griffiths and Astbury. By seasons end we'll have a pretty good indication of who we think will make it and wont. Enough with giving games to the same retreads who continually let us down, except for when they dominate against the likes of Brisbane of course woahh
Maric, Rance and Lids are injured!
Yeah I know, Im looking ahead a few weeks :)
-
Going by Loui in the VFL thread, it'll be McDonough in for Thomas you would think. Helbig now down at Frankston either but I don't see him coming in unless we have a late out.
-
My thinking was play Helbig and move either Vlaustin or Newman forward
-
My thinking was play Helbig and move either Vlaustin or Newman forward
You could still do the same with McDonough as he's been playing well at half-back in the ressies this year. He was stiff to be dropped after round 1 in the first place.
-
Reckon Petterd might play forward with Martin more time in middle
Think they will go with Helbig
See at 5pm today
-
Helbig is a spud
-
Reckon Petterd might play forward with Martin more time in middle
Think they will go with Helbig
See at 5pm today
I don't think Helbig will make it sadly after 4 years on our list and still yet to break into the seniors. McDonough is the more naturally talented footballer for mine.
-
Reckon Petterd might play forward with Martin more time in middle
Think they will go with Helbig
See at 5pm today
I don't think Helbig will make it sadly after 4 years on our list and still yet to break into the seniors. McDonough is the more naturally talented footballer for mine.
Agreed, like helbigs grunt but think he lacks polish. Would love to see him get one more crack at it as a lockdown tagger.
-
The trouble with this side for me is I'd like to see everyone on the bench get a game. The three outs should be Grigg, Petterd and Shane Edwards. To name all these fresh faces and then not play them is just one big tease.
:yep
I agree with those outs and ins.
I would rather see us lose (if we do?) With these kids giving it everything rather than the usual suspects gifted games and not giving 100%
Agree completely.
-
Remember Shane Tuck at his worst - Helbig is a poor man's version of that. Still prefer him to McGoo Medalist Thomarse though.
-
Sanity prevailed McDonough in.
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Newman, Morris
C: Grigg, Jackson, Conca
HF: Martin, Griffiths, Lloyd
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Petterd
R: Hampson, Ellis, Cotchin
IC: McDonough, Vlastuin, Arnot, Gordon
Em: Lennon, Batchelor, Helbig
In: McDonough
Out: Thomas (inj – knee)
-
Sanity prevailed McDonough in.
B: Chaplin, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Houli, Newman, Morris
C: Grigg, Jackson, Conca
HF: Martin, Griffiths, Lloyd
F: S. Edwards, Riewoldt, Petterd
R: Hampson, Ellis, Cotchin
IC: McDonough, Vlastuin, Arnot, Gordon
Em: Lennon, Batchelor, Helbig
In: McDonough
Out: Thomas (inj – knee)
Who will be sub
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
-
Depends on wether the replacements are better or not.
-
How did we beat Hawks with big o playing
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
When you put it like that Al I am surprised we didn't get pumped by 10 goals
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
You took the words right out of my mouth :shh
-
:lol
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
SHeesh i hope your not taking the mickey out of my gran, GOD BLESS HER SOULLLLLL. IF SHE SEES THIS YOU CAN BE SURE SHE WILL COME AND RIP YOUR FREAKIN ARMS OUT OF THE SOCKETS.
NOT TO MENTION THE NASTY BITS.
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
HMM. Lets see. have we gained or lost with the following
mcguane - replaced with who exactly. vickery griffiths.
white - replaced with who- hmm banfield, lloyd.
tuck - replaced by thomas. at least in thomas case when compared to so many others he at least competes. has been better than much of tucks 2013.
foley - remains way below what hes produced in the past.
stephenson - replaced by hampson so why keep him. is that a win.
rance - a poor mans 1v1 yet we miss him. what does that say about those who have replaced him??? loose man chaplin and softie grimes. at least astbury plays 1v1.
deledio - we miss his run and skills just one man. who did we replace him with ????????
maric - well his big body and competetivness is greatly missed even the 2013 ivan.
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
You took the words right out of my mouth :shh
Written and authorized by the Mediocrity and Pansy Appreciation Society of OER.
-
From Lukey D on BF:
"Petterd has a test tomorrow and if he fails it, Helbig comes in."
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/rnd-4-v-frankston-frankston-oval-frankston-april-25-2-00pm.1059989/page-8#post-32742802
-
From Lukey D on BF:
"Petterd has a test tomorrow and if he fails it, Helbig comes in."
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/rnd-4-v-frankston-frankston-oval-frankston-april-25-2-00pm.1059989/page-8#post-32742802
Well, if thats the case theres alot on the line for Helbig. 4 years in the system and injury prone. Needs to show 'something' as a mid sized player beyond 1 or 2 tackles a game.
-
From Lukey D on BF:
"Petterd has a test tomorrow and if he fails it, Helbig comes in."
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/rnd-4-v-frankston-frankston-oval-frankston-april-25-2-00pm.1059989/page-8#post-32742802
Well, if thats the case theres alot on the line for Helbig. 4 years in the system and injury prone. Needs to show 'something' as a mid sized player beyond 1 or 2 tackles a game.
speaking of injury prone how injury prone is the turd, very rarely strings more than 3 games together. What with him and Knights its two spots we could have been developing some other kids.
-
Weak Team selection. Should have taken greater risks.
-
surely this side is a better one than that what beat the hawks last year.
missing from that team are;
mcguanne - complete dud who could easily be replaced by claws grandma
white - glass half full type easily replaced by a plethora of state league players
tuck - a player who the opposition let get the ball because he turned it over all the time.
foley- injury hack past his short lived best
stephenson - old man hack
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
deledio - too easily tagged out of the game. no great loss
maric - well to be honest his 2013 output was way down from 2012.
Surely we are better side without these blokes playing?
HMM. Lets see. have we gained or lost with the following
mcguane - replaced with who exactly. vickery griffiths.
white - replaced with who- hmm banfield, lloyd.
tuck - replaced by thomas. at least in thomas case when compared to so many others he at least competes. has been better than much of tucks 2013.
foley - remains way below what hes produced in the past.
stephenson - replaced by hampson so why keep him. is that a win.
rance - a poor mans 1v1 yet we miss him. what does that say about those who have replaced him??? loose man chaplin and softie grimes. at least astbury plays 1v1.
deledio - we miss his run and skills just one man. who did we replace him with ????????
maric - well his big body and competetivness is greatly missed even the 2013 ivan.
Not so sure.
White: have definitely missed his pace this year. Last year played well against the Hawks. Would not see Lloyd as his replacement.
Rance: Provided enormous drive from backline last year. Really missing that drive.
Maric: solely missed.
Deledio: solely missed
Tuck: played well against Hawks last year. Very good mark. Could kick goals. Thomas not got this.
Even McGuane played okay against the Hawks last year.
-
rance - overrated hack who has a plethora of negatives
Harsh, we have had no run out of the backline, admittedly his kamikaze style gets us into trouble sometimes but I'd much rather that than the way we 'switch', which takes 4 kicks, with a pause in between to check the results from R6 at Caulfield, before we start to try and move it forward.
-
Surely Al was taking the pee with that post?
-
Sammy Mitchell's 250th tomorrow
Hahaha how many do we cop
Add another 5 goals to the margin now