One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 19, 2014, 05:56:31 PM

Title: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: one-eyed on October 19, 2014, 05:56:31 PM
JON ANDERSON'S TOP THREE PER DRAFT 2000-2010 (PLUS ACTUAL NUMBER ONE)

2010: Dyson Heppell (drafted at 8 ) Tom Lynch (11) Jack Darling (26). No. 1 David Swallow, who this year won Gold Coast’s best and fairest.

2009: Nat Fyfe (20) Jack Gunston (29) Daniel Talia (13). No. 1 Tom Scully.

2008: Dayne Beams (29) Steele Sidebottom (11) Michael Hurley (5). No. 1 Jack Watts.

2007: Patrick Dangerfield (10) Harry Taylor (17) Trent Cotchin (2). No. 1 Matthew Kreuzer

2006: Joel Selwood (7) Travis Boak (5) Robbie Gray (55). No. 1 Bryce Gibbs

2005: Scott Pendlebury (5) Marc Murphy (1) Josh Kennedy (WC, 4).

2004: Lance Franklin (5) Jarryd Roughead (2) Jordan Lewis (7). No. 1 Brett Deledio

2003: David Mundy (19) Adam Cooney (1) Sam Fisher (55).

2002: Brendon Goddard (1) Daniel Wells (2) Andrew Mackie (7).

2001: Chris Judd (3) Luke Hodge (1) Dane Swan (58).

*Doesn’t include father-son selections, such as Gary Ablett jnr.

http://www.news.com.au/national/no-1-afl-draft-pick-traditionally-poisoned-chalice-will-2014-break-status-asks-jon-anderson/story-e6frfkp9-1227094705749

It's no surprise the majority of the best players are found early on in drafts:
22 of the above were selected from the first round of their respective draft.
5 from the second round.
3 late picks. Last one in 2006.




By the way, no Dusty in the top 3 from 2009?
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Phil Mrakov on October 19, 2014, 05:59:21 PM
Gunston and Thalia ahead of Dusty? Jonny Anderson loves trolling RFC fans
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: tony_montana on October 19, 2014, 06:40:08 PM
Now I know lewis has had a cracking year but Lewis infront of Lids over the past 9 seasons - really?
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: YellowandBlackBlood on October 19, 2014, 07:16:30 PM
Gunston and Thalia ahead of Dusty? Jonny Anderson loves trolling RFC fans
Agree Phil. FFS put Dusty in that Hawthorn side and he becomes twice the player he is now!
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Mr Magic on October 19, 2014, 07:18:30 PM
Gunston and Thalia ahead of Dusty? Jonny Anderson loves trolling RFC fans

Just a silly article designed to make a point.
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Yeahright on October 19, 2014, 07:29:18 PM
Now I know lewis has had a cracking year but Lewis infront of Lids over the past 9 seasons - really?

One good year and everyone suddenly thinks he's a beast
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Phil Mrakov on October 19, 2014, 07:29:51 PM
Now I know lewis has had a cracking year but Lewis infront of Lids over the past 9 seasons - really?
lids is 2nd only to Buddy in that group
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Mr Magic on October 19, 2014, 07:41:17 PM
Now I know lewis has had a cracking year but Lewis infront of Lids over the past 9 seasons - really?
lids is 2nd only to Buddy in that group

Can't agree there. Roughead is an absolute star.
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Damo on October 19, 2014, 07:45:45 PM
Now I know lewis has had a cracking year but Lewis infront of Lids over the past 9 seasons - really?
lids is 2nd only to Buddy in that group

Can't agree there. Roughead is an absolute star.

Buddy and the Rough, then Lids.

Agree with you there
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: WA Tiger on October 19, 2014, 07:54:02 PM
Not sure how Harry T rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Yeahright on October 19, 2014, 07:58:13 PM
Buddy and the Rough, then Lids.

Agree with you there

x3

Not sure how Harry O rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.
HAHAHAHAHAHHA Harry O
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Chuck17 on October 19, 2014, 08:11:02 PM
Not sure how Harry O rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.

wtf Harry O isn't even in there
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: WA Tiger on October 19, 2014, 08:36:12 PM
Not sure how Harry O rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.

wtf Harry O isn't even in there

Changed, you know what I meant.
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Hard Roar Tiger on October 20, 2014, 07:47:19 AM
Not sure how Harry O rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.

wtf Harry O isn't even in there

Changed, you know what I meant.

I think WAT means Harry 0'Taylor.
I think Cotch rates ahead of Danger - he is one of the most overrated players in the comp
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Judge Roughneck on October 20, 2014, 09:03:57 AM
Quality hun journalism
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: WilliamPowell on October 20, 2014, 09:44:07 AM
Not sure how Harry O rates above Cotchin and I would have Danger and Coth equal.

wtf Harry O isn't even in there

Changed, you know what I meant.

I think WAT means Harry 0'Taylor.
I think Cotch rates ahead of Danger - he is one of the most overrated players in the comp

I'd certainly have Cotch ahead of Harry Taylor

Actually staggered to see Taylor in the top 3 TBBH
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Hard Roar Tiger on October 20, 2014, 09:58:52 AM
It's actually an old, rehashed article WP
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Dice on October 20, 2014, 12:38:08 PM
So much wrong with that assessment it's not funny. I think Anderson was on his 3rd bottle of red when he drafted it up. Either that or he's sustained brain damage from crashing into that pizza shop.

Here's just a couple >>
I'd still take D.Swallow at number 1 from the 2010 draft.  Anderson has Lynch and Darling ahead of him ? WTF ?
2008 he's got Hurley at 3 ? Actually I think Anderson was on more than just red wine. I'm thinking Lloyd Bridges in Flying high.
Here are a list of players from that draft who are better than Hurley.
Hannebery , Sloane , Ballantyne , S.Hill , Hartlett , Zeibell , Shuey , Motlop. 
2003 - Sam Fisher ?
2002 - Wells at 2 and Mackie at 3 ? Jarred McVeigh is clearly better than both of them.
2001 - lol. How can you remove Hodge from the number 1 spot ?
2007 - Harry Taylor ?
2004 - Jordan Lewis ?

Here's Ando just before he drafted up that article >>

(http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/0d/0d4e26760427d1e94e17ff05bdd683a7e74014542045b08f68fa2bd5e7804a17.jpg)
 
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: tigs2011 on October 20, 2014, 12:51:59 PM
Gray over Riewoldt based on 1 year.  :lol
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: Dice on October 20, 2014, 12:53:12 PM
Gray over Riewoldt based on 1 year.  :lol

Yeh , I missed that one. There's more too
Title: Re: Top 3 players from each draft 2000-2010/ Cotch in best 3 from 2007 (H-Sun)
Post by: tigs2011 on October 20, 2014, 12:55:03 PM
Gray over Riewoldt based on 1 year.  :lol

Yeh , I missed that one. There's more too
Hurley is the stand out stinker in all of it though. Some are in there on 1 good year. What's Hurley done?  :lol