One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 01, 2015, 06:11:57 PM
-
Newman in according to Ch 7 news just now.
More later.
-
thats what im hearing too :shh
-
Ridiculous if Newman is getting a game.
-
As an appointed apologist to the cause, I'd like to apologise for this selection (if it's true)
-
Well done Kamdyn & Taylor :clapping
Newy? After heart surgery really, at least give him sometime to recover, unlucky Lambert....
-
Weren't reports saying we were at full strength?? If so, how does Newman get a game?
-
The Run Home @TheRunHome twitter:
Chris Newman named for Richmond.
Kamdyn McIntosh to debut.
No Astbury (stingray), and Vickery not in the 22
https://twitter.com/TheRunHome
-
taylor Hunt also in for Tigers
-
Here's the official team:
Richmond
B: Troy Chaplin, Jake Batchelor, Alex Rance
HB: Bachar Houli, Nick Vlastuin, Dylan Grimes
C: Brandon Ellis, Trent Cotchin, Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Steven Morris, Shane Edwards, Brett Deledio
F: Jack Riewoldt, Ben Griffiths, Sam Lloyd
Foll: Ivan Maric, Dustin Martin, Taylor Hunt
I/C: Shaun Grigg, Chris Newman, Anthony Miles, Nathan Gordon
Emg: Ricky Petterd, Ty Vickery, Kane Lambert
In: No Change
New: Kamdyn McIntosh, Taylor Hunt
http://www.afl.com.au/news/teams
-
No Vickery
Team is good
-
No Vickery
Team is good
Bang!
Fwd line looks alright! Not a huge Morris fan, but if he takes Yarran out I'll be happy!
-
I had the same procedure that Newy did in Dec 2013. Granted that I'm 25 years older than him and nowhere near fit, but I went back to work after a week, which proved to be way too soon. It would have to be a WHS issue to play him without even a pre-season game. Just crazy IMHO.
-
No Vickery
Team is good
Any team with Newman and Batchelor and Gordon and Morris in it is not a good team Jack.
-
I'm smelling ( hoping ) for late change newy out lambert in
-
No Vickery
Team is good
I reckon late change will be Vickery for Newman
-
No Warnock for the Blues.
Carlton's team:
B: Kristian Jaksch, Michael Jamison, Sam Rowe
HB: Sam Docherty, Zach Tuohy, Simon White
C: Kade Simpson, Chris Judd, Dale Thomas
HF: Marc Murphy, Liam Jones, Clem Smith
F: Chris Yarran, Lachie Henderson, Troy Menzel
Foll: Cameron Wood, Bryce Gibbs, Patrick Cripps
I/C: Tom Bell, Andrew Carrazzo, Ed Curnow, Andrejs Everitt
Emg: Levi Casboult, David Ellard, Jason Tutt
In: No Change
New: Kristian Jaksch, Liam Jones, Clem Smith
http://www.afl.com.au/news/teams
-
No Vickery
Team is good
:thumbsup
-
Newman? Lmao the more things change the more they stay the same. No form and a question mark over fitness. Still an auto in just like good ol times.
Congrats to Hunt and McIntosh.
Jeeeeeeeeezuz Vickery shouldn't even being considered as an option to come in. Lets all pray together :pray
-
:gotigers Newman will be resting ;D
-
l think we are in for a good year Jackstar :thumbsup no excuses this year & 100% support ;D
-
:gotigers Newman will be resting ;D
Sleeping, in fact.
-
l think we are in for a good year Jackstar :thumbsup no excuses this year & 100% support ;D
My money is on at 26-1
Tomorrow night is the start of the journey
-
So really the setup will be something like:
Richmond
B: Dylan Grimes, Alex Rance, Bachar Houli
HB: Nick Vlastuin, Troy Chaplin, Jake Batchelor,
C: Brandon Ellis, Trent Cotchin, Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Steven Morris, Ben Griffiths, Brett Deledio
F: Shane Edwards, Jack Riewoldt, Sam Lloyd
Foll: Ivan Maric, Dustin Martin, Taylor Hunt
I/C: Shaun Grigg, Chris Newman, Anthony Miles, Nathan Gordon
Emg: Ricky Petterd, Ty Vickery, Kane Lambert
New: Kamdyn McIntosh, Taylor Hunt
As said, would be very happy with Lambert in and Newman out.
Really can't see why not. Gives you the extra midfield runner on the bench. Cannot see any reason why you would take Newman in as strictly a small forward when you have Morris, Deledio, Gordon, Lloyd or Edwards and at least one of Cotchin, Dusty and Hunt coming through there as well.
Unnecessary and limiting, but then Dimma always has to do something left field in selection to justify his existence and thumb his nose at the fans.
-
The more I though about it today I was a bit uneasy about two debuts in such a big game so can understand no Lambert in that regard, but surely even Petterd would have been a better option than Newman given his lack of preparation.
-
Particularly when you have Morris on the HFF. At some stage of the match we will have Morris and Newman as the two HFF's. aaaaargh
-
Unreal. How can you justify Newman in the team, with no preseason over Lambert. stuffing pathetic!
-
I actually think depending on weather Petterd/Lambert may come in for Newman. I hope so.
Vickery will not play which is a plus. :thumbsup
-
Cam wood needs to be chewed up and spat out.
-
Will they play funny buggers and bring in Casboult? I can only see Rowe as their backup ruck but he is named in defense.
-
Newman in is a complete joke. Screams of last year when he was able to just waltz back into the team and re-injure himself. Gordon as well is a pretty poor choice :banghead plenty of players out performed him in the pre seaon
No Vickery :bow
-
So really the setup will be something like:
Richmond
B: Dylan Grimes, Alex Rance, Bachar Houli
HB: Nick Vlastuin, Troy Chaplin, Jake Batchelor,
C: Brandon Ellis, Trent Cotchin, Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Steven Morris, Ben Griffiths, Brett Deledio
F: Shane Edwards, Jack Riewoldt, Sam Lloyd
Foll: Ivan Maric, Dustin Martin, Taylor Hunt
I/C: Shaun Grigg, Chris Newman, Anthony Miles, Nathan Gordon
Emg: Ricky Petterd, Ty Vickery, Kane Lambert
New: Kamdyn McIntosh, Taylor Hunt
As said, would be very happy with Lambert in and Newman out.
Really can't see why not. Gives you the extra midfield runner on the bench. Cannot see any reason why you would take Newman in as strictly a small forward when you have Morris, Deledio, Gordon, Lloyd or Edwards and at least one of Cotchin, Dusty and Hunt coming through there as well.
Unnecessary and limiting, but then Dimma always has to do something left field in selection to justify his existence and thumb his nose at the fans.
lol at that interchange. take miles out and we may as well not have one.
whats the go with batchelor we have chaplin, rance and grimes playing tall we need run pace and carry coming out of the backline and they name batchelor laughable. sheesh newman what a joke typical of what has gone before the favorites play while those like lambert whos actually earnt a game have to play in our vfl graveyard.
what a horrid fwd set up jack will be left to fend for himself when griffiths goes into the ruck, morris named fwd despite the experiment being an outright failure in the nab cup and sam lloyd whos a vfl player at best. what is wrong with those fools in charge.
win lose or draw they have no idea i can see a long long season ahead.why do i say that. simple look at the other options and its is depressing.
i ask just one thing of them. acknowledge the players who as plain as the nose on your face cant take us upwards and play the younger blokes in their stead.
me in my tipping this week im tipping carlton by 20 points.
-
wow Newman... Gordon also lucky, has zero form in nab cup, would play lambert and even butler ahead of both
-
wow Newman... Gordon also lucky, has zero form in nab cup, would play lambert and even butler ahead of both
:clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping and mckenzie knights.
-
So really the setup will be something like:
Richmond
B: Dylan Grimes, Alex Rance, Bachar Houli
HB: Nick Vlastuin, Troy Chaplin, Jake Batchelor,
C: Brandon Ellis, Trent Cotchin, Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Steven Morris, Ben Griffiths, Brett Deledio
F: Shane Edwards, Jack Riewoldt, Sam Lloyd
Foll: Ivan Maric, Dustin Martin, Taylor Hunt
I/C: Shaun Grigg, Chris Newman, Anthony Miles, Nathan Gordon
Emg: Ricky Petterd, Ty Vickery, Kane Lambert
New: Kamdyn McIntosh, Taylor Hunt
As said, would be very happy with Lambert in and Newman out.
Really can't see why not. Gives you the extra midfield runner on the bench. Cannot see any reason why you would take Newman in as strictly a small forward when you have Morris, Deledio, Gordon, Lloyd or Edwards and at least one of Cotchin, Dusty and Hunt coming through there as well.
Unnecessary and limiting, but then Dimma always has to do something left field in selection to justify his existence and thumb his nose at the fans.
Jack is going to have to kick 7 goals for us to win I reckon. Its a pretty slow line up. Batchelor and Newman shouldn't play and should have been replaced by Lambert and maybe a kid like Butler.
-
wow Newman... Gordon also lucky, has zero form in nab cup, would play lambert and even butler ahead of both
:clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping :clapping and mckenzie knights.
definitely knights, heard he needed one more hitout, but then so should newman given his preseason but he's different..
McKenzie is not far off, showed some glimpses in the nab challenge but probably hold him off for a few more weeks and get a few runs in the vfl before coming in against a doggies or Brisbane outfit that are light on for key defenders.
-
Unreal. How can you justify Newman in the team, with no preseason over Lambert. stuffing pathetic!
Newman did a pre season, has just missed the last two weeks.
Get your facts right before you post !!
-
actually reckon lennon has been alright this preseason, showing a bit more oomph and urgency in his game.
-
Unreal. How can you justify Newman in the team, with no preseason over Lambert. stuffing pathetic!
Newman did a pre season, has just missed the last two weeks.
Get your facts right before you post !!
facts are he never earns his spot like most of the others.
This year 2 weeks last year he missed longer and waltzed right in.
-
Unreal. How can you justify Newman in the team, with no preseason over Lambert. stuffing pathetic!
Newman did a pre season, has just missed the last two weeks.
Get your facts right before you post !!
He may have done a pre-season but he hasn't player a game and their players who based on form should be in the side before him
Newman in is a complete joke. Screams of last year when he was able to just waltz back into the team and re-injure himself. Gordon as well is a pretty poor choice :banghead plenty of players out performed him in the pre season
Totally agree.
Newman getting a game sends a very poor message (again)
Gordon is incredibly lucky his NAB form was terrible
-
Not happy with that side.
-
actually reckon lennon has been alright this preseason, showing a bit more oomph and urgency in his game.
hed bloody want to. im all for playing the younger blokes and lennon is one id like to see played as well. me i still like think we should have taken others in front of this kid though. im still a big fan of blake acres despite him struggling thus far thru injury. imo hes on a slow burn to being real good.
-
Unreal. How can you justify Newman in the team, with no preseason over Lambert. stuffing pathetic!
Newman did a pre season, has just missed the last two weeks.
Get your facts right before you post !!
Hey Wake up, you knew what I meant!!!!! NO GAME TIME....CLEAR ENOUGH???
-
mckensie wont play a game in the afl this year.. way to roar and one paced at the moment. there was a reason he slipped so far down draft..
i like Gorden in the side, is a live wire and can really take a mark.. played some good games last year..
-
lol at that interchange. take miles out and we may as well not have one.
Agree with that.
I think it's great for the club that there is competition for the CHF spot with Vickery and Griffiths.
Petterd is unlucky but this is life as a recycled player.
I think people are getting a little over excited about Taylor Hunt. Naming him as first rover would be a nice confidence booster for him, but I am trying my best to keep expectations low. He should remain as a back up option only for centre square sets.
Morris in the forward line, don't like it, but if we are hatching a plan to go after the Burgoynes and Hodges of the world that get too much easy footy against us, then I suppose it's worth a try.
-
The side is not to bad.I'm with people newy keeps getting easy games that's the wrong message.Lambert should have come in for the extra runner and maybe Knights as sub.My concern is the forward line a we one tall short.Must say tho both Vickery and Mcbean showed bugger all preseason.
-
don't understand Hardwick's decisions?
Newman in the team is clearly a message of "Hardwick's Untouchables".
Gordon? Lennon showed more and to give a player like Lennon experience tonight would improve him quicker than Gordon.
understand Vickery's situation, however he isn't a forward.
Conca is interesting, a bit harsh and would have Conca over Newman.
just play Conca in the midfield Hardwick and if you want a half back flanker you should have recruited one.
-
smells of hardwick playing funny buggers to me.
newman should be a late out and one of vickery lambert or pet - turd will come in.
Malthouse also playing funny buggers - surely casboult will play?
Listening to SEN this morning and they made a comment about going smaller to catch us out with speed. If this is their plan and we aren't ready we will be in big trouble.
-
Hopefully 2 late changes, Newman and Gordon out for Petterd and Lambert.
Apart from that pretty happy with the side. Would have like Knights in there but think he had a slight setback after NAB 1?
-
don't understand Hardwick's decisions?
Newman in the team is clearly a message of "Hardwick's Untouchables".
Gordon? Lennon showed more and to give a player like Lennon experience tonight would improve him quicker than Gordon.
understand Vickery's situation, however he isn't a forward.
Conca is interesting, a bit harsh and would have Conca over Newman.
just play Conca in the midfield Hardwick and if you want a half back flanker you should have recruited one.
you realise conca played plenty at hb as a junior. in fact i considered him more a flanker than a mid it was one of my gripes in us taking him where we did. its a legit complaint about taking types of players and playing them elsewhere we have done it with so many and mainly failed. with conca at hb im not sure its a legit complaint this time around.
-
The side is not to bad.I'm with people newy keeps getting easy games that's the wrong message.Lambert should have come in for the extra runner and maybe Knights as sub.My concern is the forward line a we one tall short.Must say tho both Vickery and Mcbean showed bugger all preseason.
there is another way around the tall fwd problem, trouble is people wont like it. we keep griffiths and riewoldt as permanent fwds. then wait for it!!!!! we could rotate maric with hamspud off the bench, if we want to go a bit taller we then at least have the option of resting resting one of em fwd.
just a thought :help
-
The side is not to bad.I'm with people newy keeps getting easy games that's the wrong message.Lambert should have come in for the extra runner and maybe Knights as sub.My concern is the forward line a we one tall short.Must say tho both Vickery and Mcbean showed bugger all preseason.
there is another way around the tall fwd problem, trouble is people wont like it. we keep griffiths and riewoldt as permanent fwds. then wait for it!!!!! we could rotate maric with hamspud off the bench, if we want to go a bit taller we then at least have the option of resting resting one of em fwd.
just a thought :help
Hampson can't mark though therefore he will be useless up forward. Let's not forget his set shot at goal either.
-
The side is not to bad.I'm with people newy keeps getting easy games that's the wrong message.Lambert should have come in for the extra runner and maybe Knights as sub.My concern is the forward line a we one tall short.Must say tho both Vickery and Mcbean showed bugger all preseason.
there is another way around the tall fwd problem, trouble is people wont like it. we keep griffiths and riewoldt as permanent fwds. then wait for it!!!!! we could rotate maric with hamspud off the bench, if we want to go a bit taller we then at least have the option of resting resting one of em fwd.
just a thought :help
Would rather lump McBean or McKenzie in as stay at home forward than play a man down by paying Hampson.