One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: MintOnLamb on April 07, 2015, 01:13:39 PM
-
At thursdays game Kamdyn McIntosh Taylor Hunt and Brandon Ellis looked pretty good.
With Martin, Cotchin, Delidio, Ellis, Miles, Hunt and McIntosh running around on the ball I am thinking it would be hard to shut them all down from an oppositions point of view, our delivery and intensity would be difficult to cover from all 7 of these players.
Now I know it is only round one but I am pretty excited by our team balance and structure. Also looking forward to when Lambert gets a run (hopefully this weekend)
How do you rate our midfield??
Is it a premiership quality midfield?
-
Our midfield was crap apart from Edwards. They killed us in the centre..
They will want to live up to their hype I think before we start comparing them to "Premiership Quality" midfields.
-
At thursdays game Kamdyn McIntosh Taylor Hunt and Brandon Ellis looked pretty good.
With Martin, Cotchin, Delidio, Ellis, Miles, Hunt and McIntosh running around on the ball I am thinking it would be hard to shut them all down from an oppositions point of view, our delivery and intensity would be difficult to cover from all 7 of these players.
Now I know it is only round one but I am pretty excited by our team balance and structure. Also looking forward to when Lambert gets a run (hopefully this weekend)
How do you rate our midfield??
Is it a premiership quality midfield?
Too early to tell. By the end of this year we should have an idea.
I agree that the signs of increased depth are encouraging.
-
Our midfield was crap apart from Edwards. They killed us in the centre..
They will want to live up to their hype I think before we start comparing them to "Premiership Quality" midfields.
Agree that we were well beaten in the center. I would argue that our mids smashed theirs when the ball was in transition though. Hunt, McIntosh and Ellis were allowed way too much space.
-
Our midfield was crap apart from Edwards. They killed us in the centre..
They will want to live up to their hype I think before we start comparing them to "Premiership Quality" midfields.
Agree that we were well beaten in the center. I would argue that our mids smashed theirs when the ball was in transition though. Hunt, McIntosh and Ellis were allowed way too much space.
Yes on the rebound ours were very good, without Cotch, Martin and Deledio really starring. I cant see this same scenario occurring against the Dogs or the better teams though.
-
As someone else has already touched on, I hope Kamdyn isn't Dean Polo MK II.
I'm not too fussed we lost it in the centre because our rebound from defence and our ball movement smashed them on the scoreboard which is the most important stat.
Can't get smashed in the centre against the dogs again though but I think Maric and whomever is tasked to play on ball will be doing his homework to get on top of that.
-
to all you gurus, who from our midfielders, IYHO, would get into the top 22 at hawthorn or sydney?
-
to all you gurus, who from our midfielders, IYHO, would get into the top 22 at hawthorn or sydney?
I'm comfortable in saying that Cotchin, Deledio and Martin would ALL play in the top 22 at either of those clubs, and would perform significantly better with stronger team mates around them.
We need bigger bodies in the midfield. Lids has no legit mongrel, Cotchin too small, Martin too outside, Miles too small, Edwards too small etc etc
We're paying for not replacing Tuck and Jackson. Both 190/90 mids.
-
You need a decent ruckman to have a premiership midfield.
-
to all you gurus, who from our midfielders, IYHO, would get into the top 22 at hawthorn or sydney?
As Andy has mentioned, Cotchin, Deledio, Martin will get walk up starts in Hawthorn or Sydney.
Jordan Lewis only became a great player last year. Career wise he hasn't been particularly exceptional until 2014. Deledio has him covered
Martin could replace any of Hawthorn's outside midfielders
bar Mitchell, I don't rate any Hawk inside midfielder better than Cotch and Mitchell doesn't even play as their extractor full time anymore.
I can find similar scenarios for Sydney but seeing as Hawthorn were the premiers I'd use Hawk players as examples.
-
Exactly.
Only different for Hawthorn mids is that blokes like Hodge, Mitchell and Lewis are proportionally bigger and certainly tougher/meaner.
Otherwise they had the luxury of Franklin + Roughead, Gunston playing cameo, and Hale being a very decent ruck/FWD combo.
Compared to our forward line it's kinda laughable.
If we wanna compete for a flag we need:
1 genuine KPF. Preferably a power forward. ?McKenzie - can he make it?
1 genuine forward/ruck combo. ?Griffiths - can he make it?
1-2 genuine small/mid forwards. Don't think Lloyd is the answer. Shame we didn't grab Garlett.
2 genuine inside/big midfielders.
I'm convinced we have enough 'class' in the midfield, and outside mids too. Backline IMO is solid if it stays injury-free and Rance re-signs.
-
If Astbury comes on and becomes a better player than Chaplin our backline would be in reasonable shape but as of now I reckon its lacking
-
I think the backline needs improvement from Grimes. He has only played 46 games so fingers crossed he plays 22 games he should really start to show some impact on games. We need the talls to grow more mature and id still love a distributor out of full back or the back pocket. Is vlastuin it? Dunno.
-
I remember a few years ago (2012?) he started sloppy dropping a lot of marks but as his confidence grew he started to really deliver and take some grabs only to do his hammy. I'm happy to give him some time
-
Darn good
-
miles
edwards