One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Diocletian on May 29, 2015, 11:11:55 PM
-
So it's pretty obvious they'll be having a clean out at season's end , so anyone worth targeting? The key to me would be to see if we can exploit their desperation and get some decent players for unders that would add to our list.
Already said I think Rowe would be handy if Rance nicks off and maybe Henderson as a swingman -wouldn't want to pay too much for him though. Would consider Rowe. Would only consider Henderson if Rance leaves and we missed out on others and even then probably not all that seriously.
Tom Bell's a big goal kicking midfielder who can take a mark and play forward, which are always handy and we need bigger mids, still looks like a bit of an unco hack at times though. Would consider though not strongly - not entirely convinced he'd add value to the list
Yarran of course fills several needs - speed and skill can play forward, back & flanks - but is inconsistent. Would consider dependent on cost. Would definitely add to our list though IMO.
Gibbs & Murphy of course would be great quality additions whatever you think of them, but reckon they'd cost way too much and are probably among the few that won't be on the table along with the likes of Menzell, Docherty and Simpson who's probably been their best player over the last two seasons.
Then there's Cotchin's best mate Kruezer - talented player who would help our ruck depth, restricted free agent this year but massively injury prone, missed a hell of a lot of footy and potential Chris Knights Mk.II except likely a lot more expensive salary wise. Pass for me.
Anyone else?
-
I'd definitely go after yarran quick , skilled, breaks lines , as would a few others like hawthorn . Would part with r2 , they'd want r1 ...not sure,,,, maybe he s only 24 yo
-
Kruezer is the only one although huge risk
Continually breaks down
-
Want:
Gibbs
Yarran
Cripps
Jamison
Menzel
Would consider:
Henderson
Walker
Bell
Rowe
Kreuzer hasn't done anything to suggest he's more than a B-grader IMO.
-
Simpson ,, Yarran
-
To be honest no player really jumps out at me.
I guess Yarran would be an improvement...maybe......but meh
-
Id take Yazz but would prefer Motlop.
Cripps menzel etc won't go anywhere
If Francis Hackson finally started to find us diamonds out of the draft we wouldn't need to look at these monkeyball type recruits
-
LMAO ROWE
-
Id take Yazz but would prefer Motlop.
Cripps menzel etc won't go anywhere
If Francis Hackson finally started to find us diamonds out of the draft we wouldn't need to look at these monkeyball type recruits
Yarran half back & Motlop half forward & another decent ruck/forward and I might just start dancing along with BJ at our premiership prospects. :dancing :highclap :dogdance
-
I'd only take Menzel or a fit Kreuzer. The rest would quickly become whipping boys.
-
kreuzer
-
LMAO ROWE
Franklin got away from him in the end but he stopped him in his tracks for good part of the game after he towled up White early. If Rance leaves he would be handy depth in defence if we could get him on the cheap. Who else do we have really? Astbury & Chaplin? How's Elton going today in the McGoos? Perhaps we'll start making Grimes play on key forwards? Move Griffiths back again? Good luck relying on that.
-
LMAO ROWE
Franklin got away from him in the end but he stopped him in his tracks for good part of the game after he towled up White early. If Rance leaves he would be handy depth in defence if we could get him on the cheap. Who else do we have really? Astbury & Chaplin? How's Elton going today in the McGoos? Perhaps we'll start making Grimes play on key forwards? Move Griffiths back again? Good luck relying on that.
no rance, no richmond
you would want to aim higher than rowe ffs
-
They won't give yarran away, if a r2 or astbury swap couldn't do it, I'd take walker , although prob getting on isn't he
-
kruzer would be perfect, but yarren would be pretty handy too. as much as a flog as he is
you would need to look elsewhere rather than carlton for a rance replacment. unless its jamison for a short term soulution
-
LMAO ROWE
Franklin got away from him in the end but he stopped him in his tracks for good part of the game after he towled up White early. If Rance leaves he would be handy depth in defence if we could get him on the cheap. Who else do we have really? Astbury & Chaplin? How's Elton going today in the McGoos? Perhaps we'll start making Grimes play on key forwards? Move Griffiths back again? Good luck relying on that.
no rance, no richmond
you would want to aim higher than rowe ffs
Was only a suggestion from looking at Carlton's list, I'm not that hot on it.
kruzer would be perfect, but yarren would be pretty handy too. as much as a flog as he is
you would need to look elsewhere rather than carlton for a rance replacment. unless its jamison for a short term soulution
Unless we can entice someone like McKenize from GC doubt were going to find anyone who will go even halfway to matching what Rance brings....
-
LMAO ROWE
Franklin got away from him in the end but he stopped him in his tracks for good part of the game after he towled up White early. If Rance leaves he would be handy depth in defence if we could get him on the cheap. Who else do we have really? Astbury & Chaplin? How's Elton going today in the McGoos? Perhaps we'll start making Grimes play on key forwards? Move Griffiths back again? Good luck relying on that.
If Rance leaves we need to throw some big coin at someone good. Who? I'm not sure but Rowe won't bridge any of the gap left. If we got him cheap though then eh but the cheap option doesn't tend to work
-
LMAO ROWE
Franklin got away from him in the end but he stopped him in his tracks for good part of the game after he towled up White early. If Rance leaves he would be handy depth in defence if we could get him on the cheap. Who else do we have really? Astbury & Chaplin? How's Elton going today in the McGoos? Perhaps we'll start making Grimes play on key forwards? Move Griffiths back again? Good luck relying on that.
If Rance leaves we need to throw some big coin at someone good. Who? I'm not sure but Rowe won't bridge any of the gap left. If we got him cheap though then eh but the cheap option doesn't tend to work
where is the famous claw list of KPP that are better than rance?
that would be good to cheak
-
Don't want any of them pretend footballers
-
What about Caboult as a ruck rotating forward role? He can mark and if he can help out maric that would be good. Put pressure onto Griffs or TV to perform. Hed probably be relatively cheap because he cant kick for goal.
I should add i think more of him as a backup ruck.
-
:o
-
casboult is a cad of a kick. stay right away.
-
do they have any outside runners who are quick?
-
do they have any outside runners who are quick?
garlett , betts
-
:lol
-
i really want pimple face
-
They are looking for a priority pick apparently, cheating scum
-
They are looking for a priority pick apparently, cheating scum
:facepalm :facepalm
-
Several players on their list that could improve ours. If Rance leaves we should have a red-hot crack at Jamison and/or Henderson.
Yarran and Gibbs would be nice too. Maybe even Bell.
-
haha what a surprise Carlton tanking again
-
can we not use this thread this week. No-one cares about the scum players :thumbsdown
-
can we not use this thread this week. No-one cares about the scum players :thumbsdown
you would not take any?
-
Are Carlton just plain crap......., or are the Hawks just awesome? Both, aye? After that Sydney game last week, and now this, why not just hand the flag over now and everyone can take an early holiday.
-
can we not use this thread this week. No-one cares about the scum players :thumbsdown
you would not take any?
Only player worth getting would be Kruz