One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Stalin on October 25, 2015, 01:02:43 PM
-
point of reference:
Who's ahead of him regarding those 12 players? After our top 7 or 8, it gets very thin very fast.
We can rate Lennon/C Ellis as prospects all we like but Yarran atm is far superior.
Here's 11 and I didn't even consider Lennon, ellis C or McIntosh
1. Rance
2. Lids
3. Martin
4. Jack
5. Cotchin
6. Maric
7. Edwards
8. Miles
9. Vlastuin
10. Grimes
11. Houli
Houli :lol not even close
Based solely on output and those currently around him, Houli is in our best dozen players.
Is that good thing or bad thing? Is that a poor reflection on our depth?
That's a separate discussion altogether a valid one no doubt but a different / separate one to this
Question was where do you rate Yarran in our top 25?
Based solely on output for their respective sides in 2015, Houli was miles ahead of Yarran
If Yarran (who I am happy to have BTW) extracts the digit and plays to his absolute best then he'd goes past Houli very quickly (obviously) but until he does I'd have Houli in front of him
:gotigers
:shh
-
Got him for pick 70 so who cares?
-
We cant make a call on this guy yet. Yarran is easier to make a call on, he has a proven track record. How do you put this kid anywhere at the moment?
Gee Stalin, go get a r... or build a yacht until the season starts will you.
-
Better than Treloar..... :shh
-
If he can bring that tackling intensity weekly, well we will have some.
-
If he was townsend the guitarist,I'd happily put him in 1-10
-
If he was Townsend with the dog Woodrow I'd have him number one.
-
AAAGGGHHH it is going to be great, High pressure game no time to think under the pump every time you go near it and there we have poos his pants houli and jumping at shadows Yarran . to top it of the man who gets pushed around by midgets on a regular basis Grimes just behind them.Yep its gunna be great in those tough games in the Richmond back half.
-
to top it of the man who gets pushed around by midgets on a regular basis Grimes just behind them.
:gobdrop How can anyone compare Grimes to Houli and Yarran. Scrawny but the dudes got cahonies
-
What a crock of bs Craw, Saw Grimes go flat out into a player and do a mid air cartwheel land pretty poo then get up and keep playing. The bloke doesn't balk it so don't make poo up.
-
yeah na mate grimes goes allright. If only some others did.
-
AAAGGGHHH it is going to be great, High pressure game no time to think under the pump every time you go near it and there we have poos his pants houli and jumping at shadows Yarran . to top it of the man who gets pushed around by midgets on a regular basis Grimes just behind them.Yep its gunna be great in those tough games in the Richmond back half.
AAAGGGHHH , Did you even watch the elimination final.? Houli and Grimes did stand up , unlike their more high profile team mates
-
http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/afl-finals-2015-dylan-grimes-shaun-higgins-collide-in-richmond-north-melbourne-elimination-final/story-e6frf3e3-1227525177167
anyone see the other leaders like Cotch do this? Feel free to show me the link.
-
to top it of the man who gets pushed around by midgets on a regular basis Grimes just behind them.
:gobdrop How can anyone compare Grimes to Houli and Yarran. Scrawny but the dudes got cahonies
Plus one
Grimes has balls of steel
Genuinely bizarre Clawski comment
-
We cant make a call on this guy yet. Yarran is easier to make a call on, he has a proven track record. How do you put this kid anywhere at the moment?
Gee Stalin, go get a r... or build a yacht until the season starts will you.
Using a process of elimination we have some idea as to the answer
Chances are the lad won't be playing first ruck in place of Maric. Or in rance spot