One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: WilliamPowell on March 08, 2016, 01:33:18 PM
-
Richmond v Port Adelaide
Thursday, March 10, 2016
7.10pm, Etihad Stadium
1 Nick Vlastuin
2 Dylan Grimes
3 Brett Deledio
4 Dustin Martin
5 Brandon Ellis
6 Shaun Grigg
7 Ben Lennon
8 Jack Riewoldt
9 Trent Cotchin
10 Shane Edwards
12 David Astbury
14 Bachar Houli
15 Andrew Moore
16 Shaun Hampson
17 Daniel Rioli
18 Alex Rance
21 Jacob Townsend
23 Kane Lambert
24 Ben Griffiths
29 Ty Vickery
30 Reece Conca
33 Kamdyn McIntosh
35 Nathan Broad
37 Connor Menadue
41 Mabior Chol
44 Adam Marcon
46 Jason Castagna
From:
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2016-03-08/nab-3-team-announcement
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
-
Bean must be right out of favour. Is he a lazy bastard of sumfin?
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Most probably
Miles, Maric, C Ellis aren't playing either ;D
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Most probably
hardwicki sitting home in his rocking chair, hands together thinking "my plan is brilliant"
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Not so sure about that. ....
-
Bean must be right out of favour. Is he a lazy bastard of sumfin?
Not sure but FFS I wish they would indicate what is going on with the Bean man, I am hoping he gets a good run at it
-
Port Adelaide's squad:
1. Travis Boak, 3. Jake Neade, 5. Matthew Broadbent, 7. Brad Ebert, 8. Hamish Hartlett, 9. Robbie Gray, 12. Jackson Trengove, 13. Cameron O'Shea, 15. Karl Amon, 16. Oliver Wines, 18. Jimmy Toumpas, 19. Matthew White, 20. Chad Wingard, 22. Charlie Dixon, 23. Matthew Lobbe, 24. Jarman Impey, 27. Alipate Carlile, 28. Jay Schulz, 29. Jasper Pittard, 32. Dougal Howard, 33. Darcy Byrne-Jones, 36. Jack Hombsch, 39. Justin Westhoff, 40. Aaron Young, 41. Brendon Ah Chee, 42. Tom Jonas, 46. Sam Gray
Notable absentees: Jared Polec, John Butcher
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-03-08/nab-challenge-teams-power-tigers-recall-stars-for-final-hitout
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Most probably
Miles, Maric, C Ellis aren't playing either ;D
No Taylor Hunt either ;D.
-
No Yarran. :huh
-
Bean must be right out of favour. Is he a lazy bastard of sumfin?
Currently battling a nasty bout of "Clueless-Coach-Playing-Favourites Syndrome"....
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Most probably
hardwicki sitting home in his rocking chair, hands together thinking "my plan is brilliant"
This^^^^^^
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
-
Notable absentees: Jared Polec, John Butcher
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-03-08/nab-challenge-teams-power-tigers-recall-stars-for-final-hitout
LOL Butcher
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
Are you serious BT? Haven't seen anything that excites about this kid at all. That said I haven't seen a lot of vfl games either. What do you know?
-
With Marcon back this week I now have a feeling his at the top of the list for rookie promotion
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
Are you serious BT? Haven't seen anything that excites about this kid at all. That said I haven't seen a lot of vfl games either. What do you know?
He was playing some pretty exciting attacking footy late last year in the twos before he got injured. I thought he must have been close to getting a senior game but nothing was really said until Choco in his update on him the other day said basically that.
Most kids take 3 or 4 years on a list to play the style of footy this kids does. He takes the game on and he is not afraid of getting caught trying something. It takes big balls for a kid straight out of TAC to do this. He has some work to do obviously but IMO he is one of the most exciting kids on our list.
-
With Marcon back this week I now have a feeling his at the top of the list for rookie promotion
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
-
No Chappy :snidegrin
resting him for r1
Most probably
hardwicki sitting home in his rocking chair, hands together thinking "my plan is brilliant"
Ha ha, let's hope he isn't rocking back and forth in a month sucking his thumb saying "my plan is doomed"
-
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
Harsh on Butler WAT, he hasnt played a game yet, spent most of last year dealing with a knee injury
Will be a very good player
Actually surprised he didn't play NAB 2
Morw upside lomg term than Lambert
Ditto Broad &especialpy Drummond
-
Dan Butler was very good at training on Sunday. Looked very sharp and quick. Will be a very very good player when he gets a reasonable go at it.
-
Butler's a far more talented footballer than Lambert from what I've seen - and a hell of a lot quicker too, definitely not in "the Hardwick Mould" - good tackler too. Broad's a different kind of player - Batchelor's the bloke he should be replacing.
If they decide to go the same route as last year Marcon will get the nod. Pretty much a Lambert clone.
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
Are you serious BT? Haven't seen anything that excites about this kid at all. That said I haven't seen a lot of vfl games either. What do you know?
He was playing some pretty exciting attacking footy late last year in the twos before he got injured. I thought he must have been close to getting a senior game but nothing was really said until Choco in his update on him the other day said basically that.
Most kids take 3 or 4 years on a list to play the style of footy this kids does. He takes the game on and he is not afraid of getting caught trying something. It takes big balls for a kid straight out of TAC to do this. He has some work to do obviously but IMO he is one of the most exciting kids on our list.
At this stage he is probably a slightly better Steve Morris. Not QUITE as good defensively but has way more attacking flair. Too bad he has the kicking skills/decision making of Steve Morris
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
Are you serious BT? Haven't seen anything that excites about this kid at all. That said I haven't seen a lot of vfl games either. What do you know?
He was playing some pretty exciting attacking footy late last year in the twos before he got injured. I thought he must have been close to getting a senior game but nothing was really said until Choco in his update on him the other day said basically that.
Most kids take 3 or 4 years on a list to play the style of footy this kids does. He takes the game on and he is not afraid of getting caught trying something. It takes big balls for a kid straight out of TAC to do this. He has some work to do obviously but IMO he is one of the most exciting kids on our list.
At this stage he is probably a slightly better Steve Morris. Not QUITE as good defensively but has way more attacking flair. Too bad he has the kicking skills/decision making of Steve Morris
Granted his kicking needs work but it's not as bad as some make out. And his decision making will improve just like every other kid that walks through the doors that gets full time training.
So do you think he will be any good? Yes or no? It's pretty easy to sit back and says "this or this" about a player, but from what you have seen of him, what do you think?
-
He's decision making's not that bad, it his execution that's the problem.
-
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
Harsh on Butler WAT, he hasnt played a game yet, spent most of last year dealing with a knee injury
Will be a very good player
Actually surprised he didn't play NAB 2
Morw upside lomg term than Lambert
Ditto Broad &especialpy Drummond
Not having a go WP, just looking at so many players in the "Hardwick mould".
-
Dirty plodders?
-
Batchelor not playing....hasn't really been sighted or done anything so far. Can't see him in the side at all round one, him and Morris.
-
Batchelor not playing....hasn't really been sighted or done anything so far. Can't see him in the side at all round one, him and Morris.
He's done a lot of being terrible
-
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
Harsh on Butler WAT, he hasnt played a game yet, spent most of last year dealing with a knee injury
Will be a very good player
Actually surprised he didn't play NAB 2
Morw upside lomg term than Lambert
Ditto Broad &especialpy Drummond
Not having a go WP, just looking at so many players in the "Hardwick mould".
Except the last three you mentioned are not.....
-
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
Harsh on Butler WAT, he hasnt played a game yet, spent most of last year dealing with a knee injury
Will be a very good player
Actually surprised he didn't play NAB 2
Morw upside lomg term than Lambert
Ditto Broad &especialpy Drummond
Not having a go WP, just looking at so many players in the "Hardwick mould".
Except the last three you mentioned are not.....
Maybe different positions but the same mould.
-
Come on Georgey boy, book your spot for round 1.
Are you serious BT? Haven't seen anything that excites about this kid at all. That said I haven't seen a lot of vfl games either. What do you know?
He was playing some pretty exciting attacking footy late last year in the twos before he got injured. I thought he must have been close to getting a senior game but nothing was really said until Choco in his update on him the other day said basically that.
Most kids take 3 or 4 years on a list to play the style of footy this kids does. He takes the game on and he is not afraid of getting caught trying something. It takes big balls for a kid straight out of TAC to do this. He has some work to do obviously but IMO he is one of the most exciting kids on our list.
:thumbsup
-
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
Harsh on Butler WAT, he hasnt played a game yet, spent most of last year dealing with a knee injury
Will be a very good player
Actually surprised he didn't play NAB 2
Morw upside lomg term than Lambert
Ditto Broad &especialpy Drummond
Not having a go WP, just looking at so many players in the "Hardwick mould".
Except the last three you mentioned are not.....
Maybe different positions but the same mould.
No they're not......Butler is quick, a good kick and has some flair, Drummond is -or was before his injury - extremely quick , Broad is smart & a very good kick....all decidedly non-"Hardwick mould" attributes....
-
With Marcon back this week I now have a feeling his at the top of the list for rookie promotion
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
interesting & this is based on seeing these guys Marcon, Townsend, Broad, Drummond, Butler play how many games ?
-
With Marcon back this week I now have a feeling his at the top of the list for rookie promotion
Yeah and he fits the Hardwick mould. I just hope Hardwick doesn't get hell bent on this mould or we find a Dimond like with Miles. The Hardwick mould IMO is Morris, Marcon, Miles, Batchelor, Lambert, Moore, Townsend, Hunt, Broad, Drummond, Butler......
Mmmm, a lot of the same IMO.
interesting & this is based on seeing these guys Marcon, Townsend, Broad, Drummond, Butler play how many games ?
Zero
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
-
who said we're a far better side than port?
do we sack the coach if we don't win by 10 goals?
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
20 goals min no excuses
-
who said we're a far better side than port?
my guess would be the voices in her head. They must blur into a haze of madness and that becomes reality.
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
Funny. 12 months ago Port was favorite for the flag in many peoples eyes. So I can't see how anyone thinks we are that much better.
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
I don't think anybody here thinks we are so much better than Port. Most of the posters here would put us in a large bunch of teams fighting for 3rd to 12th. Port is in that group too. That doesn't mean we are not confident or don't rate our list, it just means we are realistic and know it's not easy to even get to the finals let alone win one, two, three. I would
love to see a big win but in the end ( apart from some confidence going into the season proper ) it really doesn't make much difference.
Just to answer your question, Tigers by 24
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
Seriously? Stuff me dude. You spend most of your time complaining about people twisting things, telling half truths ect. and then you spend another chunk sprouting this poo.
-
Every one thinks we are a far better side than port so how much should we win by, considering this is close to a dress rehearsal for the season opener for both teams.
If i take into account what i have heard from our supporters we should win by 10 goals NAB game or not.
Seriously? Stuff me dude. You spend most of your time complaining about people twisting things, telling half truths ect. and then you spend another chunk sprouting this poo.
Fair point Claw. Your thoughts?