One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: mightytiges on November 26, 2005, 04:03:50 PM
-
After a few hours to let our picks sink in, how do you rate how we went?
-
Good.
Considering what was available at the time of our picks, i think we've done very well.
-
considering what was left...i give this a 7.5/10
and thats from someone who doesnt often give praise on draft day. They got what they could. And thats ok. Without Hughes at 24 however...I would have rated this a 5 at best.
-
Without Hughes at 24 however...I would have rated this a 5 at best.
Agree completely. You never know with Miller, but he says we were looking at Casserly with pick 24. This could have been very difficult for some supporter to swallow.
-
will let you know how i rate this yrs draft in 10 months time
-
Just very relieved and glad we ended up taking a "tall"
Will be interesting to see these kids develop. I was away all day yesterday so I haven't seen any tape of any of our recruits but going by the stats (ie their weights in particular) I reckon there's gonna be alot work in the gym over the next 12 months ;)
-
We need to pull an early 90's eagles pre-season! :rollin
-
We need to pull an early 90's eagles pre-season! :rollin
What are you saying Razor, that our boys need to start taking steroids???
:o
-
We need to pull an early 90's eagles pre-season! :rollin
What are you saying Razor, that our boys need to start taking steroids???
:o
I thought they didn't use steroids, only "weights"! :lol ::)
;D
-
Oakley-Nicholls, Hughes and Casserly are pretty good pickups, but Clark, Hughes and Lucy would've been heaps better!
-
Lucy was overrated when he was mentioned as a top 10/1st rounder, but going at 66 is probably a bit of value for the bombers, if not what he was worth anyway!
Guy can't kick and has questionable 1v1 skills, but has nice athleticism and is a alright defender!
-
Lucy was overated and thats why he was taken so late in the draft. Oakley Nicholls, Hughes and Casserley are fine. 3 players who will should be good at the level.
-
Lucy was overrated when he was mentioned as a top 10/1st rounder, but going at 66 is probably a bit of value for the bombers, if not what he was worth anyway!
Guy can't kick and has questionable 1v1 skills, but has nice athleticism and is a alright defender!
Lucy - Sounds like another Richards type, where the bummers swapped a 1st rounder for a 4th rounder.
-
Happy with the type of player drafted, therefore 7.5/10
Will be looking forward to the next 2 years for these guys to see how they develop.
-
whatever comes before over the moon well thats what i think of our draft.
not what i expected but now that i've had time to assess, jeez its not too bad after all.
JON - another F1 motor in the side along wit lids, tambo and meyer.
Hughes - seems a very balanced human being (wow dont believe i just said that about a croweater) sounds like a piggy dunstall type. very quick lead, vice like hands and good attitude.
Travis Casserly - very quick, excellent kick and his marks stick...
pretty sound to me... 9/10
-
Along with guys like weaver there is a guy called Colin Wisbey who does a lot of analysis of young players...
Go http://www.voy.com/51976/ to see how he has rated our picks..
Looks pretty promising going by what he has said , though he is obviously not the last word on rating these kids..