One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on January 03, 2017, 03:49:36 AM
-
Who has the best midfield? We rank every club
AFL.com.au
2 January 2017
It's said more and more often nowadays that games are won in the midfield. Here's how AFL.com.au rates your team in this critical part of the ground.
1. GWS
2. Bulldogs
3. Sydney
4. Collingwood
5. Fremantle
6. Geelong
7. Melbourne
8. Adelaide
9. West Coast
10. St Kilda
11. Hawthorn
12. Port Adelaide
13. Essendon
14. North Melbourne
15. RICHMOND
B: Kamdyn McIntosh, Alex Rance, Dylan Grimes
HB: Bachar Houli, David Astbury, Nick Vlastuin
C: Shaun Grigg, Dustin Martin, Brandon Ellis
HF: Josh Caddy, Jack Riewoldt, Shane Edwards
F: Daniel Rioli, Ben Griffiths, Sam Lloyd
Foll: Shaun Hampson, Trent Cotchin, Dion Prestia
I/C: Anthony Miles, Corey Ellis, Connor Menadue, Jayden Short
Depth
Midfield: Reece Conca, Kane Lambert, Toby Nankervis, Jack Graham, Taylor Hunt, Ivan Maric, Jacob Townsend, Ivan Soldo
Forwards: Ben Lennon, Shai Bolton, Daniel Butler, Mabior Chol, Callum Moore, Tyson Stengle
Defenders: Jake Batchelor, Oleg Markov, Steven Morris, Nathan Broad, Nathan Drummond, Todd Elton, Ryan Garthwaite, Jason Castagna
The off-season arrivals of Dion Prestia and Josh Caddy have been widely lauded, but a substantial question mark remains over the overall depth of the Tigers' midfield. Yes, Dustin Martin is a game changer when he steps into the centre square, but many believe he plays his best footy forward of centre. Trent Cotchin is a good accumulator of the footy, but he needs more support from Anthony Miles et al. The club's ruck stocks don't inspire a lot of confidence, although the Tigers hope Toby Nankervis can step up and claim the No.1 ruck spot. Nor does the club's midfield depth, which is poor.
16. Gold Coast
17. Carlton
18. Brisbane
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-12-31/who-has-the-best-mids
-
I would be sticking all these rankings in the locker room as motivation for 2017
-
Gee all these articles really make you feel good as a Richmond Supporter...not
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck training rankings we will be at the top
EFA
-
Gee all these articles really make you feel good as a Richmond Supporter...not
You weren't already aware ??
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
On question number three its a bit of a mixed bag. Take a look around this forum for instance.
You get alot of measured honest opinions and then you get tripe like:-
- we had a bad year because Houli missed too many games (lead turnover player in the competition).
- player X played a horrific game and should never play another game (when he wasnt playing at all)
- hampson may be terrible but he should be celebrated because hes the best we have got.
- if you havent played at the highest level, you shouldnt criticise the players, only praise them.
Just a procession of absolute claptrap but hey at least its entertaining.
-
The club's ruck stocks don't inspire a lot of confidence, although the Tigers hope Toby Nankervis can step up and claim the No.1 ruck spot.
As long as he trains well and does his jobs the fools who accept mediocrity will praise him
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
On question number three its a bit of a mixed bag. Take a look around this forum for instance.
You get alot of measured honest opinions and then you get tripe like:-
- we had a bad year because Houli missed too many games (lead turnover player in the competition).
- player X played a horrific game and should never play another game (when he wasnt playing at all)
- hampson may be terrible but he should be celebrated because hes the best we have got.
- if you havent played at the highest level, you shouldnt criticise the players, only praise them.
Just a procession of absolute claptrap but hey at least its entertaining.
Don't forget...
- He stuffed the kick cause he was looking at the ball as he kicked it
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
On question number three its a bit of a mixed bag. Take a look around this forum for instance.
You get alot of measured honest opinions and then you get tripe like:-
- we had a bad year because Houli missed too many games (lead turnover player in the competition).
- player X played a horrific game and should never play another game (when he wasnt playing at all)
- hampson may be terrible but he should be celebrated because hes the best we have got.
- if you havent played at the highest level, you shouldnt criticise the players, only praise them.
Just a procession of absolute claptrap but hey at least its entertaining.
Don't forget...
- He stuffed the kick cause he was looking at the ball as he kicked it
Oh yeah - that little gem.
-
On the plus side our autograph signing ranking should be sky rocketing now that Lids has gone
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
On question number three its a bit of a mixed bag. Take a look around this forum for instance.
Is 1/18 most insane???
Most sane would be 18/18
IMO we have been driven to insanity by RFC :banghead
-
Its Ok when they do the ruck rankings we will be at the top
where are we
1. On - Coach rankings ?
2. On - List Management rankings ?
3. On - Most Sane Supporter rankings ?
I think
1. 18/18
2. 18/18
3. 1/18
On question number three its a bit of a mixed bag. Take a look around this forum for instance.
Is 1/18 most insane???
Most sane would be 18/18
IMO we have been driven to insanity by RFC :banghead
Most sane supporter rankings 1st is the most insane? Thats insane!
-
Big 2017 coming up. ;D
Cotchin with his posthumous Brownlow, Prestia with his wooden leg and same game time as Chris Yarran, all the usual Dimmerbots and no Lids or ruckman (lol)
Hardwick has got no hope. Lol. What's he gonna do - come up with another game plan that leaves the squad pondering due to its total lack of depth and a grade talent?
Won't take long for the PEGGY rot to set in
-
Big 2017 coming up. ;D
Cotchin with his posthumous Brownlow, Prestia with his wooden leg and same game time as Chris Yarran, all the usual Dimmerbots and no Lids or ruckman (lol)
Hardwick has got no hope. Lol. What's he gonna do - come up with another game plan that leaves the squad pondering due to its total lack of depth and a grade talent?
Won't take long for the PEGGY rot to set in
Hardwick to call games off circa nab cup 2016 Lmfao
-
Gold :gotigers
-
And the same people who "wanted" Yarran calling the shots. Bwahaha
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
-
And the same people who "wanted" Yarran calling the shots. Bwahaha
And the internal review undertaken to placate the members was not made available to anyone but those within the club calling the shots.
#accountabilityatrichmond
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
Theyre talking about midfield for 2017 not the 2016 midfield
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
Theyre talking about midfield for 2017 not the 2016 midfield
Yep.
Includes Prestia and Caddy.
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
Theyre talking about midfield for 2017 not the 2016 midfield
ah, thats different then. I think Ill wait until at least part way through the season before trying to rank anything.
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
Theyre talking about midfield for 2017 not the 2016 midfield
ah, thats different then. I think Ill wait until at least part way through the season before trying to rank anything.
Nah call it now. If you're right you can just bump it later but if you're wrong no one is going to remember anyway
-
Champion Data ranked us as having 4th best midfield, I think i know who i'd be listening to
Who are these AFL.com.au flogs anyway?
we were rated 16th for clearances, 12th for centre clearances and 16th for clearances from stoppages.
I think our midfield rating would be closer to 4th worst than 4th best
Theyre talking about midfield for 2017 not the 2016 midfield
ah, thats different then. I think Ill wait until at least part way through the season before trying to rank anything.
Nah call it now. If you're right you can just bump it later but if you're wrong no one is going to remember anyway
And if you are wrong and someone does remember just do a Rasputia in Norbit and say it didn't happen
-
or claim it was taken out of context
-
Our midfield has top 4 potential.
Our backline and forward line have top 8 potential.
Ruined by the most pathetic coach in the AFL.. Remove Dimma and we will be fine.