One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on September 17, 2018, 04:27:09 PM
-
Which Tiger tags Magpies gun Sidebottom?
By SEN
17 SEP 2018
David King hailed Collingwood star Steele Sidebottom after his outstanding performance in their gritty 10-point win over GWS in Saturday night's Semi-Final clash at the MCG.
The Magpies star collected 31 disposals, five clearances, six inside 50s, six score involvements and 446 metres gained in an excellent display against a star-studded Giants midfield.
Ahead of this Friday night’s Preliminary Final blockbuster against Richmond, King is fascinated as to which Tiger will be assigned the role of nullifying the prolific ball-winning ability of Sidebottom.
“I just can’t wait to see what match-up that looks like on Friday night,” King said.
“I’m sure that Steele will go to a wing or if not on-ball, because he has been doing both this year.
“(Kamdyn) McIntosh from Richmond plays that role really well, (Shaun) Grigg can, (Jack) Graham can, so there’s options there.
“That role has become critical to what both Richmond and Collingwood do.”
Nathan Buckley's side contained the potent Giants attack to just 14 scoring shots, with the likes of Jeremy Cameron, Toby Greene and Harry Himmelberg scoring just two goals between them.
King highlighted the enormous work rate of Sidebottom as a key contribution towards a stingy collective defensive effort from the Pies.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/09/17/which-tiger-tags-magpies-gun-sidebottom/
-
Conca could also play this role so we have options.
-
Are there articles about how any one player can stop reigning Brownlow and norm smith medalist Dustin Martin? Or our three time Coleman medalist Jack Riewoldt? Or how to curb the influence of 5 time all Australian Alex Rance? Or how Collingwood has anyone that can stop Brownlow medalist and reigning premiership captain Cotchin? Or if they have anyone that can stop the run of Prestia, Lambert or the menacing Josh Caddy up forward?
-
Are there articles about how any one player can stop reigning Brownlow and norm smith medalist Dustin Martin? Or our three time Coleman medalist Jack Riewoldt? Or how to curb the influence of 5 time all Australian Alex Rance? Or how Collingwood has anyone that can stop Brownlow medalist and reigning premiership captain Cotchin? Or if they have anyone that can stop the run of Prestia, Lambert or the menacing Josh Caddy up forward?
Seen a few about greenwood and/or Maynard going to dusty.
-
Brandon Ellis :shh
-
Brandon Ellis :shh
:shh :rollin
-
Brandon Ellis :shh
:shh :rollin
:shh :shh
-
I reckon we must syop Howe to not let him have a influence in back half as Towner did in rd 19.Maybe a Caddy.
-
Who cares if he gets his one highlight reel moment
-
I reckon we must syop Howe to not let him have a influence in back half as Towner did in rd 19.Maybe a Caddy.
George could be the man to step up in this regard.
-
NO ONE! :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
Anyone at the ground able to tell me if anyone stood near him at stoppages? From TV it looked like he stood behind the pack and mopped up at free will with no pressure.
-
Anyone at the ground able to tell me if anyone stood near him at stoppages? From TV it looked like he stood behind the pack and mopped up at free will with no pressure.
That’s what it looked like live. And to be honest, it didn’t look like he ran hard defensively and was all alone on the turn over when it came his way.
-
Started free as a bird defensive side of the square at a lot of centre bounces. Not tagging him is one thing but having no accountability for him is another. We rarely tag players and often the oppo teams best mid racks up the possessions against us but normally our pressure is so good that their 30+ possessions are inefficient and not damaging. When we played the pies in round 19 or whenever it was and their top 4 mids all had 30+ was an example of this, yesterday was an example of what happens when our pressure is off.
-
Anyone at the ground able to tell me if anyone stood near him at stoppages? From TV it looked like he stood behind the pack and mopped up at free will with no pressure.
That is exactly what happened... all night.
-
Started free as a bird defensive side of the square at a lot of centre bounces. Not tagging him is one thing but having no accountability for him is another. We rarely tag players and often the oppo teams best mid racks up the possessions against us but normally our pressure is so good that their 30+ possessions are inefficient and not damaging. When we played the pies in round 19 or whenever it was and their top 4 mids all had 30+ was an example of this, yesterday was an example of what happens when our pressure is off.
Yep they all had 30 plus and we won. But they also had 2 players down for a half of footy. Might want to think about that when you are accessing not tagging Sidebottom.
Even with hindsight you still find it hard to figure out that it was a mistake not to tag Sidebottom??
-
They played dumb footy too.
Collingwood was coming out of defence in front of me. Kamdyn was minding Sidebottom. Next minute he runs off him to try to cover the short pass to the pocket which he was never going to cut off. The Collingwood back then just spots up Sidebottom on his own and kicks it to him and he just runs off without pressure, Kamdyn chasing him without hope of catching him. Why he chose to leave Sidebottom in the first place is weird as the guy he went to was deep in the pocket and wasn't going to do anything dangerous as long as Sidebottom was covered.
Just very poor decision making which summed up our night to a tee.....
-
Yep, and when you watch a guy like Brandon Ellis, you know he's very smart with his positioning. Very bad decision making at selection and on game night :shh
-
I think we were to arrogant last game him and Pendles got 38 possies each ,but butched the footy to think that was going to happen again to quality players is silly not to tag.
-
Yep, and when you watch a guy like Brandon Ellis, you know he's noy very smart with his positioning and has very bad decision making :shh
e.f.a :shh :shh
-
Started free as a bird defensive side of the square at a lot of centre bounces. Not tagging him is one thing but having no accountability for him is another. We rarely tag players and often the oppo teams best mid racks up the possessions against us but normally our pressure is so good that their 30+ possessions are inefficient and not damaging. When we played the pies in round 19 or whenever it was and their top 4 mids all had 30+ was an example of this, yesterday was an example of what happens when our pressure is off.
Yep they all had 30 plus and we won. But they also had 2 players down for a half of footy. Might want to think about that when you are accessing not tagging Sidebottom.
Even with hindsight you still find it hard to figure out that it was a mistake not to tag Sidebottom??
Hindsight is 20/20. Didn’t hear you complaining all season long when the oppo mids were dominating against us but we won anyway. I’d rather put the loss down to an absolute lack of pressure on the ball carier which allowed their disposals to actually be effective.