One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 01, 2019, 07:02:06 PM
-
Walsh v Stack: The Rising Star race is on
Jon Ralph,
Herald Sun
1 July 2019
Sam Walsh is footy perfection: the No. 1 draft pick from a perfect family and a perfect AFL pathway destined to play 200 great AFL games.
Sydney Stack has much more rough-and-tumble about him.
He could so easily have fallen through the cracks after a difficult family upbringing, a torturous path to the big time and a draft where every single club ignored him.
Walsh effortly cranks out 16km games while Stack couldn’t stop throwing up all summer on the training track.
Together these polar opposites should be dead even for the Rising Star betting.
Stack’s stunning foray forward saw him dragged in to $4 from $8 last week, then hours later Walsh peeled off another 30-possession, eight-tackle game.
It was the perfect ammunition for the Carlton army who went nuts on Twitter about suggestions Stack might the man to win the increasingly prestigious award.
But in truth nothing Stack does denigrates Walsh’s performance in any way.
It just means it sets up a knock-em-down, drag-em-out contest to the line with eight rounds remaining.
You could use the stats or Champion Data relative ratings to measure them against each other, but they play such different roles you can just use your eye.
Walsh is a phenom, a gifted ball winner who always takes the right option as a surging runner who has barely played a bad game in his 14 matches so far.
He is an elite contested and pressure player with barely a flaw in his game.
But what makes this race so interesting is that Stack’s brilliance combines with a stunning level of consistency for someone so young.
Consider his last four games — 107 ranking points against Geelong (24 possessions at 81 per cent efficiency), 70 ranking points against Geelong, 103 ranking points against Adelaide (22 possessions), then four goals 98 ranking points and eight score involvements against St Kilda.
He was quiet second-up against Port Adelaide — 11 possessions, 40 ranking points, still went at 83 per cent efficiency — yet in every other game he has found a way to shine.
He is hard as a cats head, he barely wastes a possession, he is incredibly versatile, he is a flawless kick, he chooses tough options and he is now a goalkicker.
And if the Rising Star judges have an ounce of theatre about them they could be swayed by his incredible story.
Either would be a worthy winner.
Last year Jayden Stephenson was awarded the most votes ever polled — 52 — in a runaway victory, so regardless of your choice this year’s presentation should be mouth-watering.
For me Stack’s story echoes everything good about this game — a recruiter who refused to quit on him, a coach who took him into his home, a player prepared to do the hard work, a precocious talent unfolding in front of our eyes.
That alone isn’t enough to win the Rising Star, but his week-in and week-out performances are, which is why he is my Rising Star after 15 rounds.
THE STATS
Sam Walsh
Games: 14
Goals: 3
Averages
Disposals: 25.1
Marks: 5.5
Tackles: 3.1
SuperCoach: 89.1
Sydney Stack
Games: 12
Goals: 7
Averages
Disposals: 17.1
Marks: 5.6
Tackles: 3.3
SuperCoach: 81.8
THE ODDS
Sam Walsh $1.30
Sydney Stack $4.50
Connor Rozee $11
Gryan Miers $15
(Odds courtesy TAB)
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/richmond/sam-walsh-or-sydney-stack-why-the-rising-star-race-is-closer-than-you-might-think/news-story/6a7c55f7cf8ea819120399c73df90cda
-
The rising star award is such an overrated award. A footy career is a marathon not a sprint. They had Lewis Taylor winning it over bontempelli and hogan winning it over Cripps and De Goey. And let’s not forget Rhys Palmer over Cotchin!
-
There’s also been some pretty special players win it...
-
By virtue of their respective draft positions Stack has "risen" further than any first year player ever and Walsh is stationary in the same spot
-
Honestly you're comparing a no. 1 pick to everybody's leftovers.
Every single club, including Carlton, is kicking themselves for not taking Stack now...except us.
If out club can do this type of recruiting and development anywhere near consistently then we are in for an era of relative success...
-
Walsh will win because it's already been ordained and has been since the JLT....and Carlton need a trophy.... :shh
-
I agree but they will contrive a close result
-
Honestly you're comparing a no. 1 pick to everybody's leftovers.
Every single club, including Carlton, is kicking themselves for not taking Stack now...except us.
If out club can do this type of recruiting and development anywhere near consistently then we are in for an era of relative success...
especially them. they were the only other club besides us interested in ss