One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 03, 2019, 10:16:46 PM
-
Hopefully we got through unscathed.
Fire away with your changes, if any?
-
Don’t want to see Butler ever again
Chol won’t last either
-
Out Butler, Chol, Ellis
In Nankervis, McIntosh, Naish
-
Haven't seen Q1-3 yet as I was out to dinner.
How bad was Chol. Only 3 possessions. Does he need a rest?
Out:
Butler
Chol
In:
Nank
Mac
Cotch another week of rest minimum.
-
Watched replay again
Butler needs to seek Emma Murray 9am Monday morning
Confidence is shot
Career over ??
Played 7 games this season , no where near the player he was
He brought his C Grade game last night
-
I'd actually drop Rioli for his BEllis type effort (step backwards = pulling out of a contest) but fortunately for him his tackle seconds later means no one is talking about it >:(
I'm a Short fan but his confidence is shot too they did him favours bringing him straight back n AFL from that elbow . Needs to go back to the VFL
A week ago I would have said Choo over Soldo but the last 2 weeks have been Soldo's best
So.....
INS: Nankervis, MacIntosh, Naish
OUTS, Choo, Butler, BEllis
*** if Stack is fit, he comes straight back in, no Nish. But calfs are tricky, think they shpuld conservative
-
Out: Butler, Ellis, Chol
In: Nankervis, MacIntosh, RCD (just want to see him and can’t be worse than Butler)
-
Nank & Slomo in the same side 🐌🐌 :shh
-
Out: Broad, Butler, Soldo
In: McIntosh, Stack, Nank
If Stack is not right yet then bring in Pickett
The following week is
In: Cotch, Ross
Out: Caddy, Baker
-
Soldo, Butler out
Nank, Stack in
Would like to see Ellis make way for McIntosh.
Soldo has played well enough to suggest he has a future with us as has Chol.
-
Do people even pay attention to the 2's?
-
Do people even pay attention to the 2's?
Yes. I know RCD has been poor but was better yesterday. Just saying he’d be no worse than Butler and give us another rotating mid forward for flexibility. Also will stretch their defence.... :shh
-
Do people even pay attention to the 2's?
Yes. I know RCD has been poor but was better yesterday. Just saying he’d be no worse than Butler and give us another rotating mid forward for flexibility. Also will stretch their defence.... :shh
RCD miles off getting a game
-
I'd actually drop Rioli for his BEllis type effort (step backwards = pulling out of a contest) but fortunately for him his tackle seconds later means no one is talking about it >:(
I'm a Short fan but his confidence is shot too they did him favours bringing him straight back n AFL from that elbow . Needs to go back to the VFL
A week ago I would have said Choo over Soldo but the last 2 weeks have been Soldo's best
So.....
INS: Nankervis, MacIntosh, Naish
OUTS, Choo, Butler, BEllis
*** if Stack is fit, he comes straight back in, no Nish. But calfs are tricky, think they shpuld conservative
I worry about Short, I do like him but think he was terrible in the finals pressure last year.
Last night there were a couple of worrying signs inside D50.
Not sure he is best 22 to be honest
-
Do people even pay attention to the 2's?
Yes. I know RCD has been poor but was better yesterday. Just saying he’d be no worse than Butler and give us another rotating mid forward for flexibility. Also will stretch their defence.... :shh
I have watched many VFL games this year and I don't believe RCD has been as poor as some think. He is a genuine inside player who is building a tank throughout the year. He cracks in extremely hard but doesn't yet have the aerobic conditioning to constantly spread on the outside. Alot to like me thinks :shh
-
Do people even pay attention to the 2's?
Yes. I know RCD has been poor but was better yesterday. Just saying he’d be no worse than Butler and give us another rotating mid forward for flexibility. Also will stretch their defence.... :shh
spot on TM
I have watched many VFL games this year and I don't believe RCD has been as poor as some think. He is a genuine inside player who is building a tank throughout the year. He cracks in extremely hard but doesn't yet have the aerobic conditioning to constantly spread on the outside. Alot to like me thinks :shh
-
IN:
Nankervis, Ross/Pickett
OUT:
Chol, Butler
-
IN:
Nankervis, Ross/Pickett
OUT:
Chol, Butler
Ross still under done, only played half a game. Marlion could be a smokey though.
-
Ellis and Broad were really poor against the Demons and should be dropped. Butler at risk. Think Nank needs to come in.
-
Ellis and Broad were really poor against the Demons and should be dropped. Butler at risk. Think Nank needs to come in.
Broad for me is one of the first picked, poor game here and there notwithstanding. He's tough, and a legit competitor. I didn't even think his Melb game was THAT terrible. Astbury is slow and Grimes can't do all the quick stuff himself.
-
In the Mix - Round 21
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
6 Aug 2019
RICHMOND
Get them in: Ruckman Toby Nankervis has done everything possible to get an AFL call-up after two halves and now a full game in the VFL. Usual winger Kamdyn McIntosh continues to play in defence in the seconds, recording 16 disposals and seven marks. Youngster Patrick Naish (26 disposals, nine marks) has continued his strong VFL season, while mid-season recruit Marlion Pickett (20 and a goal) found plenty of the ball in his first match.
Under the pump: Unfortunately it's rinse and repeat for Ivan Soldo, whose stunning soccer goal from a throw-in won't save him if Nankervis returns. Small forward Dan Butler (eight disposals) didn't have a big impact on his return to AFL.
Medical room: Dynamic utility Sydney Stack (calf soreness) is likely to be a test after missing last round, while skipper Trent Cotchin is still a week or two away.
Verdict: Another week in the twos building match fitness for Pickett, while Nankervis should come back at the expense of Soldo. Stack for Butler if fit.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-08-06/in-the-mix-whos-pushing-for-selection-in-round-21
-
Ins- Nank, Stack, McIntosh
Outs- Soldo, Butler, Bellis