One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on September 18, 2019, 04:26:22 PM
-
Your club's Brownlow guide
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
18 September 2019
Dustin Martin is expected to poll extremely well in the back half of the season, but an ill-advised elbow in round three resulted in a one-match suspension, ruling him out of contention. Other than Martin, the Tigers will share the votes around, with an inconsistent injury-hit line-up meaning players starred at different times.
Best chance: Dion Prestia
With superstar Martin ineligible, Prestia is Richmond's best hope. Saying that, the midfielder is expected to poll only eight votes, spread fairly evenly throughout his 22-game season. A three-vote game could come in round 21 against Carlton. Bachar Houli is also a chance to top the Tiger eligible-player count, tipped to poll eight.
Three-vote certainty: Bachar Houli (v Essendon, round 10)
Houli's class shone through in atrocious conditions in the Dreamtime match. Finished with 37 disposals (including 28 kicks) and 10 rebound 50s, and he stood firm against both the rain and waves of Bomber attacks.
One-vote wonder: Dylan Grimes
Probably deserving of more than one, but defenders traditionally don't poll well. Grimes had an outstanding season, and should be in line for his first Brownlow vote for his R4 performance against Port where he had 17 disposals, took seven marks (including a game-high five contested), and had six rebound 50s.
2018 leading vote winner: Dustin Martin (19 votes)
Previous winners: Stan Judkins (1930), Bill Morris (1948), Roy Wright (1952, 1954), Ian Stewart (1971), Trent Cotchin (2012), Dustin Martin (2017)
Ineligible players: Dylan Grimes, Dustin Martin, Ivan Soldo
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-09-18/your-clubs-brownlow-guide-best-chance-onevote-wonder-more
-
Dusty is difficult for the umps to miss out on the ground. I could see him come home like a train in the final 10 rounds and get the most votes on the night. That act of frustration off the ball back in round 3 could cost him another Brownlow.
-
Could cost me $7500 as well.
I took a multi at the start of year
Jeremy Cameron Coleman
Dustin Martin Brownlow
Richmond Flag
$30 to win $7500
Im spewing at the moment.
-
Cotch and Brooke.
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/800/2019/09/23/717577.jpg)
Lynch & Olivia Burke.
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/800/2019/09/23/717653.jpg)
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/450/2019/09/23/717618.jpg)
https://www.aflphotos.com.au/galleries/results/?q=collection:AFL%202019%20Media%20-%20Brownlow%20Medal
-
R1 def. Carl
3. Cotchin
1. Nankervis
Total:
Cotchin 3
Nankervis 1
-
R2 lost to Collingwood.
No votes.
-
R3 lost to GWS.
No votes.
-
R4 def. Port
3. Grimes
1. Lynch
Total:
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
-
R5 def. Sydney
3. Martin
2. Prestia
Total:
Martin 3
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Prestia 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
Leaderboard after Round 5:
Cripps 13
Dangerfield 8
Bontempelli 8
Neale 8
Whitfield 8
Kelly 8
Billings 8
-
Clangerflog to win another one
-
R6 def. Melb
3. Vlastuin
2. Lambert
1. Houli
R7 lost to Dogs.
No votes.
Total:
Martin 3
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Lynch 1
Houli 1
Nankervis 1
-
Clangerflog to win another one
Would say Cripps is favourite at the moment. In front with 14 votes already despite Carlton completely sucking under Bolton in the first half of the season.
-
Hope Cripps wins
-
R8 def. Freo
2. Bolton
1. Houli
Ummm we won but Fyfe gets the 3 votes ::).
Total:
Martin 3
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Houli 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
-
R9 def. Hawthorn
3. Martin
2. Houli
Total:
Martin 6
Houli 4
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
-
Kelly taking votes off Dangerfield.
Between Cripps and Neale for mine.
-
Danger and Bont come home like trains
At this stage of the year Kelly was fav to win it
-
R10 def. Essendon
3. Houli
1. Martin
Total:
Martin 7
Houli 7
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
-
Now for our 3 game losing streak before the Bye.
R11 lost to North - No votes
R12 lost to Geelong - No votes
R13 lost to Adelaide - 1. Dusty
R14 Bye
Total:
Martin 8
Houli 7
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
-
R15 def. StK
3. Martin
1. Chol
In our 8 wins so far we've had only one clean sweep.
Total:
Martin 11
Houli 7
Cotchin 3
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Lambert 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
So Ablett is a no show. I wonder if he’s having a sook because of the weekend? Like surely if one of your mates might win it you’d turn up?
-
I wasn't paying attention fully but did I just see Bill Morris' photo wrongly used for Des Rowe during the memorial piece? :huh
-
R16 def. Suns
3. Cotchin
2. Castagna
1. Lambert
Total:
Martin 11
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Grimes 3
Lambert 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Castagna 2
Bolton 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
R17 def. GWS
3. Bolton
1. Lambert
Total:
Martin 11
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Lambert 4
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Prestia 2
Castagna 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
Freo kick just 7 goals in a 6 goal loss to Hawthorn (so a thumping) and Fyfe still gets the 3 votes :huh3.
The umps are sure loving Fyfe this year.
-
Freo kick just 7 goals in a 6 goal loss to Hawthorn (so a thumping) and Fyfe still gets the 3 votes :huh3.
The umps are sure loving Fyfe this year.
He deserved 3
-
R18 def. Port
3. Martin
2. Prestia
Total:
Martin 14
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Prestia 4
Lambert 4
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Castagna 2
Lynch 1
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
R19 def. Collingwood
3. Martin
2. Lynch
1. Prestia
Total:
Martin 17
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Prestia 5
Lambert 4
Grimes 3
Vlastuin 3
Lynch 3
Castagna 2
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
Freo kick just 7 goals in a 6 goal loss to Hawthorn (so a thumping) and Fyfe still gets the 3 votes :huh3.
The umps are sure loving Fyfe this year.
He deserved 3
One starring quarter where he kicked those 3 goals isn't 4 qtrs.
Worpel had 33 disposals and 9 clearances.
-
R20 def. Melb.
3. Martin
1. Vlastuin
Total:
Martin 20
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Prestia 5
Lambert 4
Vlastuin 4
Grimes 3
Lynch 3
Castagna 2
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
-
Now that was a deserving 3 votes to Fyfe. 27 disposals, 11 clearances & 2 goals.
Hand him the medal.
-
R21 def. Carl.
3. Prestia
1. Graham
Total:
Martin 20
Prestia 8
Houli 7
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Lambert 4
Vlastuin 4
Grimes 3
Lynch 3
Castagna 2
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
Graham 1
-
Fyfe wins it.
-
R22 def. West Coast
3. Martin
2. Houli
Total:
Martin 23
Houli 9
Prestia 8
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Lambert 4
Vlastuin 4
Grimes 3
Lynch 3
Castagna 2
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
Graham 1
-
Fyfe wins it.
Champion
Great result
-
R23 def. Bris
2. Houli
Final Richmond tally:
Martin 23
Houli 11
Prestia 8
Cotchin 6
Bolton 5
Lambert 4
Vlastuin 4
Grimes 3
Lynch 3
Castagna 2
Nankervis 1
Chol 1
Graham 1
-
Final Leaderboard:
Fyfe 33
Dangerfield 27
Cripps 26
Neale 26
Kelly 24
Dusty 23
Grundy 23
https://www.afl.com.au/brownlow-medal/live-count
-
Fyfe wins it.
Champion
Great result
No doubt he is a champion and he deserves multiple Brownlows over his footy career. He's been a stuff.
I just rate impact over the entire game and result. Take our round 23 game. Neale gets 51 disposals so the umps give him the 3 votes but Dusty with far less possies had more impact on the game and result.
-
Just caught the end - would've liked to have taken the odds on Reece Conca being singled out in a Brownlow acceptance speech.. :shh
-
The umps hate us and it shows
Load of crap this award let's be honest.
We got a few more votes than north and hawks to name 2 lol yet we are playing off in a granny
-
Club by club Brownlow votes
Brisbane 90
Geelong 90
GWS 84
Coll'wood 81
W.Bulldogs 81
West Coast 74
Richmond 72
Fremantle 69
North Melb 68
Hawthorn 67
Port Adel. 66
Carlton 60
Essendon 58
Adelaide 53
St Kilda 53
Sydney 53
Melbourne 47
Gold Coast 22
-
Prestia 8 and Edwards 0 is absolutely laughable!
-
R23 def. Bris
2. Houli
This is laughable. How did Dusty not get 1 vote? He was clearly the BoG. I’d say umps/afl were worried he might have had the most votes. Which would engage a lot of conversation over his report and why Ablett didn’t get any weeks for worse indiscretions.
-
Our lack of votes just emphasises how brilliant our system is. Everyone does their role. Team first mentality.
Let the minnows have the scraps. Let's load up on premiership cups.
-
Personally I think Grundy would have been a more worthy winner. Their hot and cold midfield had basically been reliant on him not just covering ground and winning the taps but he follows up with tackles and wins contested footy. Which would make it super hilarious if he leaves to Adelaide
-
Dusty now has the most Brownlow votes by a Tiger.
Dusty 179
KB 160
Richo 140
St Francis 139
Cotch 133
He's 5th highest out of the current players behind Ablett (most ever with 261), Dangerfield, Selwood & Pendlebury
And, he’s in 16th place overall for the most Brownlow votes in AFL/VFL history.
https://afltables.com/afl/brownlow/totals0.html