One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 22, 2020, 10:45:00 PM
-
Touchwood we got through unscathed.
Fire away with your changes?
-
Outs Chol Castanga
Ins Don’t care
-
Out: Stack, Soldo, Houli, Chol
In: Dow, Nank, Caddy, Broad
Lucky: Graham, Lambert, Castagna, Aarts
-
Out:
George
Stack
Chol if Nank fit
In:
Broad
Caddy
Nank if fit
Need some mongrel for WCE and Gee
-
Out:
George
Stack
Chol if Nank fit
In:
Broad
Caddy
Nank if fit
Need some mongrel for WCE and Gee
Perfect
-
INS: Nank (if fit), Broad, RCD
OUTS: Chol, Castagna, Stack
-
In
Nank for a weary Soldo
Broad for Castagna
-
In
Nank for a weary Soldo
Broad for Castagna
Your thoughts on Stack's game, Machine?
-
INS: Nank (if fit), Broad, RCD
OUTS: Chol, Castagna, Stack
No soldo?
Enough is enough with him and Chol too
-
INS: Nank (if fit), Broad, RCD
OUTS: Chol, Castagna, Stack
No soldo?
Enough is enough with him and Chol too
Think we need to play 2 rucks until Nank gets his match fitness up. Don't want to use Balta as a 2nd option as he is growing as defender, don't want to mess with that
While both were poor, Soldo at least laid a few tackles and showed some intensity. Chol tonight, didn't
-
In
Nank for a weary Soldo
Broad for Castagna
Your thoughts on Stack's game, Machine?
Not great. Looks to be still building into the season fitness wise. Playing a different role this year mainly around the ball and resting forward. I admit he seems to have lost some confidence but he is clearly best 22 so we should persist. I know he has had a tough year personally so this is why i cut him some slack. Tonight's heat looked to have stopped him in his tracks in the last.
I would continue to play him at his current average game time of 60%.
-
Who ever mentioned Graham what game were you watching was our best now needs to back it up weekly not once a month.George has to go simple as that.Broad and Nank in as well as Caddy.
-
Who ever mentioned Graham what game were you watching was our best now needs to back it up weekly not once a month.George has to go simple as that.Broad and Nank in as well as Caddy.
Well he has played two in a row now :shh
-
Who ever mentioned Graham what game were you watching was our best now needs to back it up weekly not once a month.George has to go simple as that.Broad and Nank in as well as Caddy.
Graham was ordinary. How many soft free kicks does he give away for holding? He is so slow he needs to scrap his opponent. Some of his passes were good but has been a liability around the contest this year
-
Who ever mentioned Graham what game were you watching was our best now needs to back it up weekly not once a month.George has to go simple as that.Broad and Nank in as well as Caddy.
Graham was ordinary. How many soft free kicks does he give away for holding? He is so slow he needs to scrap his opponent. Some of his passes were good but has been a liability around the contest this year
Your thoughts on Graham’s game is made up before a ball is even bounced.
-
All of stack, rioli, castagna and aarts are in poor form. Honestly wouldn’t know who to drop out of the lot of them. Probably george since he’s been poorest for longest.
Soldo was poor but atleast got involved whereas Chol was mostly anonymous. I wouldn’t play nank as no.1 ruck against nicnat in his first game back. Think you need to give him a couple as second ruck before you then look at the benefits between chol v soldo.
-
Who ever mentioned Graham what game were you watching was our best now needs to back it up weekly not once a month.George has to go simple as that.Broad and Nank in as well as Caddy.
Graham was ordinary. How many soft free kicks does he give away for holding? He is so slow he needs to scrap his opponent. Some of his passes were good but has been a liability around the contest this year
Your thoughts on Graham’s game is made up before a ball is even bounced.
Yep.
The favoritism / whipping boyism on this site is out of hand.
-
Soldo has to play against Natanui. He smashes Nank out of the middle.
I think Caddy comes in for either Castagna or Aarts.
Stack for Higgins.
-
Broad should come back in- Castagna makes way for mine.
Baker to play small forward and he has all the skills required to excel in this position. Rioli, Stack and Baker small forwards. Broad slots back into the backline.
Baker is so clean and neat by foot he could be our answer up forward for the rest of the year.
-
With Lynch unbelievably likely out who comes in for him??
-
With Lynch unbelievably likely out who comes in for him??
Good question. Does Chol play forward all game? Probably not due to our need for someone to compete the whole game in the air. Could Caddy play the role? Complete in the air and don't allow their guys to pick the high ball off. Shame CCJ is injured as he could come in should Lynch not be available. What other option do we have.
Broad to play back and send Balta forward for a game?
-
rewind to 2017 for a game...Jack + 5 smalls
-
Would be loathed to move Balta forward, even for just one game
He is going so well down there. And this week is another great challenge for him against either Kennedy or Darling want to see how he goes
-
Nank available to play on Thursday according to Jack just now :thumbsup.
-
Stack in doubt apparently.
Syd was shown on Ch10 news with a sore right side/abdomen at training today and barely did anything.
-
Didn't the club say Cotchin won't play three games in a row? :shh
-
That was in relation to the first footy frenzy when we had a four day break and had to fly to Adelaide to play Port.
-
Cotch on MMM just now:
If Nank doesn't play this week then it will be in the next week or two.
Astbury was moving well at training today.
Caddy in good form in the scratch matches.
-
Good to hear about Dave to moving well.Nank will play I reckon.
-
I think now we know more the following will happen.
In Nank - Caddy - Higgins - Broad
Out Chol - Stack - Aarts - Castagna
Lot of changes but good ins.
-
Got to make McGovern accountable not let him dictate give him a matchup.Eagles like to be pricise with there kicks etc.We need to lower eyes and hit our forwards low and delivery in our 50 not high.Keep it a scrubby game eagles don't like that ball on deck etc smalls super important.
-
Think they're ranked first for marks and last for ground ball gets so grubbers should the order of the day... Castagna might actually be useful this week and Pickett & McIntosh should have blinders..... :shh
-
Bring in the daisy cutter Chaos ball!!!
-
Dimma said Nank is in as well as Dow. Stack out.
-
Hoping its:
Out:
Chol
Stack
George
Aarts
In:
Nank
Dow
Broad
Caddy
-
Dimma said Nank is in as well as Dow. Stack out.
Also said Chol out (I think)
-
Dimma said Nank is in as well as Dow. Stack out.
RCD overlooked again. :rollin
It would good to see Dow play.
-
Dimma said Nank is in as well as Dow. Stack out.
RCD overlooked again. :rollin
It would good to see Dow play.
RCD out for 2 games with a shoulder injury :shh
Stack injured also and will miss.
-
I think now we know more the following will happen.
In Nank - Caddy - Higgins - Broad
Out Chol - Stack - Aarts - Castagna
Lot of changes but good ins.
il take that, but how do you know about casatgna?
-
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/
-
Stack has a hip flexor injury according to Ch10 news.
-
Where's Broad?
-
Where's Broad?
I mentioned this in a couple of different threads but they’re only ever going to name 7 defenders in the 22. Balta, grimes, vlas, Houli, short and baker make 6 and then it seems that atleast for now markov has taken the last spot. Astbury will take that spot from markov when he’s back from injury so unless they plan on moving one of the others I think broad will find it tough to win his place back.
-
Dimma said Nank is in as well as Dow. Stack out.
RCD overlooked again. :rollin
It would good to see Dow play.
RCD out for 2 games with a shoulder injury :shh
Stack injured also and will miss.
Didn’t hear that. Thanks TM :thumbsup
-
Where's Broad?
I mentioned this in a couple of different threads but they’re only ever going to name 7 defenders in the 22. Balta, grimes, vlas, Houli, short and baker make 6 and then it seems that atleast for now markov has taken the last spot. Astbury will take that spot from markov when he’s back from injury so unless they plan on moving one of the others I think broad will find it tough to win his place back.
I'm shocked personally. Broad one of the first in for me
-
Where's Broad?
I mentioned this in a couple of different threads but they’re only ever going to name 7 defenders in the 22. Balta, grimes, vlas, Houli, short and baker make 6 and then it seems that atleast for now markov has taken the last spot. Astbury will take that spot from markov when he’s back from injury so unless they plan on moving one of the others I think broad will find it tough to win his place back.
I'm shocked personally. Broad one of the first in for me
If you substitute astbury in for markov, which one of the other 6 players currently playing in the backline would you substitute for broad? I think he’d be well suited to a defensive wing position honestly.
-
Where's Broad?
I mentioned this in a couple of different threads but they’re only ever going to name 7 defenders in the 22. Balta, grimes, vlas, Houli, short and baker make 6 and then it seems that atleast for now markov has taken the last spot. Astbury will take that spot from markov when he’s back from injury so unless they plan on moving one of the others I think broad will find it tough to win his place back.
I'm shocked personally. Broad one of the first in for me
If you substitute astbury in for markov, which one of the other 6 players currently playing in the backline would you substitute for broad? I think he’d be well suited to a defensive wing position honestly.
Maybe later, but Astbury isn't fit yet.
Markov could move up the wing a bit? Interchange...