One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 27, 2021, 06:17:59 PM
-
In: Cotch, Prestia, Bolton, Caddy.
Source: 7news.
-
In: Trent Cotchin, Dion Prestia, Callum Coleman-Jones, Shai Bolton, Mabior Chol, Josh Caddy, Thomson Dow
Out: Tom Lynch (knee), Patrick Naish (hamstring), Marlion Pickett (suspension), Jack Ross (omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
In: Cotch, Prestia, Bolton, Caddy.
Source: 7news.
And more I reckond. They said in "TV Speak" 4 Premiership Stars returning but we know that doesn't mean the only changes.
-
In: Trent Cotchin, Dion Prestia, Callum Coleman-Jones, Shai Bolton, Mabior Chol, Josh Caddy, Thomson Dow
Out: Tom Lynch (knee), Patrick Naish (hamstring), Marlion Pickett (suspension), Jack Ross (omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
InB4 I could post
-
Richmond team
B: Nick Vlastuin Noah Balta Dylan Grimes
HB: Jayden Short Nathan Broad Bachar Houli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Liam Baker Josh Caddy
HF: Jake Aarts Shai Bolton Jason Castagna
F: Callum Coleman-Jones Dustin Martin Jack Riewoldt
R: Toby Nankervis Trent Cotchin Dion Prestia
Interchange (from): Hugo Ralphsmith, David Astbury, Riley Collier-Dawkins, Mabior Chol, Thomson Dow, Will Martyn, Jack Graham, Daniel Rioli
Richmond will confirm its starting 22 tomorrow night at 5pm AEST.
The Club will then name its medical substitute 60 minutes prior to the bounce.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/945979/richmonds-round-11-squad-named/
-
Adelaide's team for those interested:
B: Doedee, Butts, Murray
HB: Smith, Jones, Brown
C: Sholl, Keays, Seedsman
HF: McHenry, Walker, Berry
F: Rowe, Thilthorpe, Fogarty
FOLL: O’Brien, Laird, Sloane
I/C (from): Schoenberg, Kelly, McAdam, Mackay, Hamill, O’Connor, Frampton, McPherson
IN: Hamill, Frampton, McPherson
OUT: Nil
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2021-round-11-teams-team-news-team-lists-squads-ins-and-outs-changes-injuries-supercoach-news/news-story/929e98aa2e67ac0d7fb2ca8708e03a0a
-
Great ins!
Suspect Dow and one of chol/CJ will miss out.
-
Doubt CCJ will miss seeing as he's been named in the starting 18...like to see both him & Chol in... just hope RCD isn't dropped.... :shh
-
I wonder if they're planning to make a "tough" call on astbury this week?
-
I wonder if they're planning to make a "tough" call on astbury this week?
They should- list him as resting to soften the blow.
-
I wonder if they're planning to make a "tough" call on astbury this week?
They should- list him as resting to soften the blow.
Not against dropping him but I think that leaves us a key defender short.
-
I’m against dropping him.
-
I’m against dropping him.
Think he still plays a role that the others don't.
-
David Astbury (Achilles soreness) has been replaced by Ben Miller in our selected 26-man squad for Sunday's match against Adelaide.
We will announce the final 22 selected at 5pm AEST
https://twitter.com/Richmond_FC/status/1398169101026004997
-
On the AFL website:
(https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/attachments/1622184043107-png.1139349/)
https://www.afl.com.au/matches/3119#line-ups
So if true that's Rioli & Astbury (inj) out for Ralphsmith & Chol on top of the other changes.
-
Ralphsmith played last week
-
Ralphsmith played last week
Doh! I had him dropped already and put him back him lol.
-
Finalised changes:
In: Dion Prestia, Trent Cotchin, Josh Caddy, Shai Bolton, Callum Coleman-Jones, Mabior Chol
Out: Tom Lynch (knee), Patrick Naish (hamstring), Marlion Pickett (suspension), David Astbury (Achilles soreness), Will Martyn (medical sub), Jack Ross, Daniel Rioli (both omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
Finalised Richmond team
B: Nick Vlastuin Noah Balta Dylan Grimes
HB: Jayden Short Nathan Broad Bachar Houli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Liam Baker Josh Caddy
HF: Jake Aarts Shai Bolton Jason Castagna
F: Callum Coleman-Jones Dustin Martin Jack Riewoldt
R: Toby Nankervis Trent Cotchin Dion Prestia
Int: Hugo Ralphsmith Riley Collier-Dawkins Mabior Chol Jack Graham.
Emg: Thomson Dow, Daniel Rioli, Will Martyn, Ben Miller.
Richmond will confirm which player steps into the 23 to serve as the medical substitute 60 minutes before the game.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/946328/round-11-team-announcement/
-
I really like it
-
Really happy with that side
Reckon Rioli will be the medi sub
-
Shake up to the side especially forward line we got the extra tall see how we go have to give it a block of games.Who takes Walker now ? Balta who else they got tall up there.
Now or never for Chol talent there just needs desire and stay involved.
-
Like it!!
Balta v Thilthorpe
Grimes v Walker
Broad v Fogarty
Our tall forwards will stretch them me thinks.
-
I would bring in Ben Miller to cover the Astbury injury.
-
Shake up to the side especially forward line we got the extra tall see how we go have to give it a block of games.Who takes Walker now ? Balta who else they got tall up there.
Now or never for Chol talent there just needs desire and stay involved.
I agree.
Rioli had to go. I like Chol back in but he needs to step up and use his pace I’m hoping I see him use his athleticism to advantage hopefully his pressure is adequate.
Hopefully Tilthorpe doesn’t kick a bag
It’s good to see our mids back and we know we can throw Baker in there too.
-
I would bring in Ben Miller to cover the Astbury injury.
Chol to cover Astbury :shh
-
What must Ben Miller be thinking. Astbury out supposedly injured and we cannot play the one player on the list who has actually been playing as a KPD.
Im laughing at Caddy on a wing. I dont mind them playing him after some good games in the two's. He played as a ball winning mid so why plonk him on a wing again, taking the role of a young player in Ralphsmith who has basically trained for the role this year. If we play the kids lets make sure we give em every opportunity to shine. Enough of the limited time and played out of position crap that goes on.
Good to see them persevere with him i reckon he will reward the faith with more good players around him.
When both JR and TL are fit we dont throw them into the ruck. We bring in CCJ to cover Lynch and we need to play Chol as the second ruck with plenty of time fwd.
Pickett Lynch Naish and Astbury all forced changes my way of thinking the changes should have gone like this
Miller for Astbury ffs why is it so hard to play a like for like when the hell are we ever going to get a game into him if not in these circumstances
CCJ for Lynch again like for like we keep the two tall forward structure.
Caddy for Naish but i disagree we play him on a wing that role should be for a young quick skilled player like Ralphsmith.
Cotchin for Pickett a mid for a mid
Then theres the blokes who needed to be dropped in a big way
Bolton for Rioli with Bolton a big part of midfield rotations
Prestia for Ross a mid for a mid. Ross badly out of touch needed a rest
Chol for Castagna, its two fold he gives Nankervis a decent chop out and he provides an extra tall up forward its some thing we have all been wanting them to try. Would also like to see Baker in Castagna's role with time in the midfield
Dow for Houli imo Houli has been so poor but that would make 8 changes and that is a bridge too far. The six they made is probably giving them kittens.
If the above happened it would remove from the team all those who have been going poor this year
B/ Broad - Miller - Grimes
HB/ Vlastuin - Balta - Short
/C McIntosh - Cotchin - Ralphsmith
R Nankervis - Martin - Prestia
HF/ Bolton - Riewoldt - Baker
F/ Aarts - CCJ - Chol
INT/ Graham - Caddy - RCD - Dow
-
Geez they made 6 changes. Maybe let the game play out before you go on ranting and raving about how they’ve got it wrong again.
-
I am excited to see some of the changes... CCJ and Chol especially.
But I agree re: Astbury and Miller. Miller has been training for what 3 years as a KPF? Astbury couldn't outrun a turtle these days. I'd be playing Miller on Thilthorpe. Balta on Walker. Grimes on Fogarty.
Astbury needs to retire this year so it would be good to get games into Miller while Grimes is still around too.
-
We all know even with the talls coming in unless we look up and hit our forwards it won't work not just blaze away and bomb it.
-
Agree that Caddy should be rotated through the middle / forward line
He can be a marking option that they will need to Man up if he leads to space ,but don’t expect him to be quick enough to be a run down chaser
-
Rioli to be the sub. Dimma wants Dan to focus on using his pace.
Source: Ch 7 news.
-
Miller should have been selected. Team selection is wrong imho.
-
Gez 6 changes and still whinging let's give this team a chance.
-
Caddy as a 3rd tall works well. He crunches and puts that interfered pressure as he did a couple of years ago. If these changes work depends on the bottom 4 of the 22. Can Chol stand up or will those half arsed efforts return? Will the top 6 midfielders return or will the be underdone?
Lots of unanswered questions in a game that defines our season.
-
Miller should have been selected. Team selection is wrong imho.
You would be calling for his head if he had more than 3 kicked on him rampsy :shh
-
My only concern is in defence. The Crows play three tall forwards - Walker (194), Thilthorpe (201) & Fogarty (193). With Astbury injured that leaves it to Balta, Grimes and an undersized Broad to match-up on them. I know some are saying Chol will be sent back but Mabs has been playing as a ruck/forward in the VFL. We can stretch the Crows up our forward end as well but we need our mids to be switched on both offensively and defensively. We can't take the Crows lightly as Melbourne learnt last week.
-
Miller should have been selected. Team selection is wrong imho.
You would be calling for his head if he had more than 3 kicked on him rampsy :shh
Ive always thought Miller would be ok. Even on his draft night I wss backing him in. I see him and Balta beingbour 2 key defenders over the next decade.