One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 10, 2021, 07:32:59 PM
-
Robbo’s Top 50: Christian Petracca, Marcus Bontempelli headline Mark Robinson’s top 50 AFL players for 2021
HeraldSun
October 10, 2021 - 4:30PM
Mark Robinson is back - and so is his top 50.
And there are a number of big surprises as the next generation takes over. See the full list for 2021 and vote on every player.
1. Christian Petracca
2. Marcus Bontempelli
3. Clayton Oliver
4. Toby Greene
5. Max Gawn
6. Ollie Wines
7. Sam Walsh
8. Jack Steele
9. Tom Stewart
10. Touk Miller
11. Jack Macrae
12. Darcy Parish
13. Nic Naitanui
14. Jake Stringer
15. Tom Hawkins
16. Bayley Fritsch
17. Steven May
18. Aliir Aliir
19. Zach Merrett
20. Jake Lever
21. Luke Parker
22. Jacob Weitering
23. David Mundy
24. Dayne Zorko
25. Tom Mitchell
26. Travis Boak
27. Christian Salem
28. Sean Darcy
29. Daniel Rich
30. Harry McKay
31. Lance Franklin
32. Sam Taylor
33. Jarryd Lyons
34. Josh Kelly
35. Rory Laird
36. Tom Liberatore
37. Hugh McCluggage
38. Bailey Dale
39. Jack Henry
40. Charlie Cameron
41. Tom Papley
42. Callum Mills
43. Karl Amon
44. Jacob Hopper
45. Taylor Walker
46. Zac Bailey
47. Paul Seedsman
48. Dylan Grimes
49. Brandon Starcevich
50. Bailey Smith
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FBUVUZeVEAMIGxV?format=jpg&name=large)
https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/robbos-top-50-christian-petracca-marcus-bontempelli-headline-mark-robinsons-top-50-afl-players-for-2021/news-story/7ed6696ecbf10be983e2f284523aa735
-
Even when we were winning flags we weren't that well representated
-
Care factor zero
But pretty silly Dusty doesnt make a top 50 list
-
lol let the haters hate,
-
It's Robbo, so he briefly considered the top 10 in between hangovers and put down 40 other names he remembered. He probably spent 99% of his time debating Petracca/Bont.
-
WAW, Vlastuin, Bolton, Graham are chopped liver??
-
Ah yes...better to have guys like Starcevich and Karl Amon than Dustin Martin hahahahahahahahhahahahaha
-
Taylor Walker lol
-
Max Gawn is an overrated yob with hydro encephalitus and crap beard
-
I haven't read today's HUN yet will do tonight
But in fairness to Robbo, he has had a tendency in the past to not include players who have long term injuries which I reckon Dusty would qualify as having
I know this time last year he didn't include Buddy because he hadn't played for nearly 12 months
-
The first ever top 50 done from the grave?
-
It's Robbo, so he briefly considered the top 10 in between hangovers and put down 40 other names he remembered. He probably spent 99% of his time debating Petracca/Bont.
:lol :rollin
-
I haven't read today's HUN yet will do tonight
But in fairness to Robbo, he has had a tendency in the past to not include players who have long term injuries which I reckon Dusty would qualify as having
I know this time last year he didn't include Buddy because he hadn't played for nearly 12 months
Well I've read it no explanation of why there is no Dusty. Just that a number of big names missed out
Blah, blah, blah
-
You guys do realise that his end of year lists are based on performances during the season right?
I’m not gonna argue who should and shouldn’t be included from other clubs or the exact order but in terms of Richmond players, I think we are lucky to have even grimes included. We were that bad this season and maybe it’s because I rate him so highly but I also thought grimes had an avg year.
-
I'm not surprised - very ordinary year by Richmond.
Our stars were all injured for large chunks .
-
You guys do realise that his end of year lists are based on performances during the season right?
I’m not gonna argue who should and shouldn’t be included from other clubs or the exact order but in terms of Richmond players, I think we are lucky to have even grimes included. We were that bad this season and maybe it’s because I rate him so highly but I also thought grimes had an avg year.
Yep we're lucky we even got one under Robbo's top 50 'criteria'. He goes mainly on stat winners and awards (eg: B&F) to compare players. Reckon Robbo simply included Grimesy because he won our B&F. He's included every club B&F winner except the bottom clubs North and Collingwood.
-
It's not often the "comedic stylings" of Big Footy are worthy of a repost but hats off to this one:
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/the-tan-78-strictly-no-politics-in-here.1240759/page-273#post-72605512
:shh