One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Rampsation on March 29, 2022, 10:40:32 AM
-
Im going to put up a series of matchups over the year. The topic is who would you trade. This isnt about what we would get in return just if you had to trade one if the two who would it be?
Todays matchup is Kamdyn McIntosh or Marlion Pickett. These polls will run for 5 days only. This is Hypothetical no 1. You can give your reason and what youd expect in return for the player youve selected be swapped.
-
K-Mac
-
Flip a coin - neither would fetch much...probably McIntosh... :shh
-
Im going to try and make difficult matchups just to see what people would do.
-
You'd be lucky to get more than a 4th rounder for either of them. Based on this year it'd be KMac because pickett has been quality thus far
-
Being 30 I dont think you would get much for Pickett plus I think he is better value to the team, would trade Kmac out of the two and hope for a third rounder
-
You'd be lucky to get more than a 4th rounder for either of them. Based on this year it'd be KMac because pickett has been quality thus far
Not really about trade value, just interested to see who supporters rate higher thats all.
-
Pickett because KMac has more years left in him
-
Close vote so far.
-
Kmac if we can get Pickett to 100 for father son. If not trade Pickett.
-
I would not want to trade either of them
-
I would not want to trade either of them
Agree
Workhorses and tough. Doing the work so others can shine.
-
I would not want to trade either of them
If you HAD TO though? As per title.
I don't wanna trade either myself but rather keep KMac if I had to.
-
If some of the cheersquad rejects & dufflecoated dribblers that post online -not necessarily here bar one or two notable exceptions- were in charge of the club, we'd never trade anyone and the AFL would have to force us under threat of sanction and penalties to delist three blokes every year... :shh
-
I expect a few retirements at the end of the year plus a few who will be delisted. So plenty of room to get new blood in.
-
If some of the cheersquad rejects & dufflecoated dribblers that post online -not necessarily here bar one or two notable exceptions- were in charge of the club, we'd never trade anyone and the AFL would have to force us under threat of sanction and penalties to delist three blokes every year... :shh
:lol :shh
-
Boys and any ladies posting ... this series of hypotheticals is just that hypotheticals. Im asking you to select 1 to trade, saying Ill keep both is not a part of this.
You boys will be in uproar next week when I put up scenario number 2 ;D
-
I expect a few retirements at the end of the year plus a few who will be delisted. So plenty of room to get new blood in.
I know youre a lefty but seriously ... read the title of the poll. Youre way off point. You lefties need to grow a pair and put em on the line. Who would you trade out of McIntosh or Pickett. Simple!
-
I expect a few retirements at the end of the year plus a few who will be delisted. So plenty of room to get new blood in.
I know youre a lefty but seriously ... read the title of the poll. Youre way off point. You lefties need to grow a pair and put em on the line. Who would you trade out of McIntosh or Pickett. Simple!
This a forum people can and do say whatever they want. :cheers
-
I'd keep KMac and trade Pickett
-
At 30 Pickett has no trade value what so ever. Still imo he is a far better player than McIntosh and would keep him instead even if its only for a season or two. trading McIntosh well thats a nonsense i ask myself would i trade for him if i was at another club and the answer is a big no.Have always said we need to be looking for better than Kamdyn.
We have Rioli as a potential winger, Ralphsmith, Banks, Brown if none of them can be better than McIntosh then imo our Recruiting would have failed.