One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 09, 2022, 07:47:30 PM
-
One forced - Lynch out (hammy).
Fire away with your changes?
:help
-
George for a used packet of mouldy twisties.
-
Sorry but at this stage Castagna out is also forced. The injury's in his brain.
-
Who cares.
-
Play the kids, don't care if we lose.
-
Nank out
Soldo out..
-
Nank out
Soldo out..
yes was just reading that
Nank PCL
Soldo broken thumb......
Def need Balta and Gibbo back in
-
Out
George
Aarts
Lynch
Dow
In
Cotchin
Balta
Gibcus
Vlastuin
Hope Cotch and Balta are g2g
-
Nank out
Soldo out..
yes was just reading that
Nank PCL
Soldo broken thumb......
Def need Balta and Gibbo back in
Here's the tweet from 7news' Andrew McCormack.
After the siren loss gets worse for Richmond…
Toby Nankervis suffered a PCL injury late.
Ivan Soldo broken thumb.
Who rucks for the Tigers next week?
Tom Lynch hamstring on minor end but Damien Hardwick concedes he’ll certainly “miss weeks”
@7NewsMelbourne @7AFL
https://twitter.com/_AMcCormack7/status/1545708076833341440
:( :help
-
Samson Ryan in by the looks of it
-
Cotchin
Vlastuin
Balta
Ross
Gibcus
Ryan
All in
Nank
Lynch
George
Dow
Soldo
Miller sadly
Out
-
Samson Ryan in by the looks of it
Oh gawd!
But in saying that we don't have any other option so he'll have to play :help.
Out: Lynch (hammy), Nank (knee), Soldo (thumb), Aarts, Castagna.
In: Floss, Gibcus, Ryan, Cumberland (into the 22), Ross (if fit)
Sonsie the sub or into the 22 if Ross isn't right.
Ryan and Miller will have to share the ruck duties against Goldstein :help.
-
Out: Lynch, Nank, Soldo, Aarts, Castagna.
In: Vlastuin, Gibcus, Ryan, Balta, Cumberland (into the 22), Ross (if fit)
I'd play Gibcus forward, with either Balta or Ryan occasionally forward, rotating in the ruck.
-
Could be we dont risk Balta, Martin and Cotchin if all three are fit then they play.
Team with and with out them would go for me like the following.
Broad - Tarrant - Grimes
Vlastuin - Miller - D Rioli
Pickett - Bolton - Ralphsmith
Ryan - Ross/Cotchin - Prestia
Sonsie - Riewoldt - Martin
M Rioli - Balta - Gibcus.
Baker - Graham - Short - RC-D - McIntosh
Outs from Lynch inj, Nankervis inj, Soldo inj, Aarts, Castagna, Edwards, Dow, Cumberland.
Ins from Vlastuin, Ross, RC-D,Sonsie, Martin, Gibcus, Balta, Ryan, Cotchin.
-
Out: Lynch, Nank, Soldo, Aarts, Castagna.
In: Vlastuin, Gibcus, Ryan, Balta, Cumberland (into the 22), Ross (if fit)
I'd play Gibcus forward, with either Balta or Ryan occasionally forward, rotating in the ruck.
On the money x2
-
Out: Lynch (hammy), Nank (knee), Soldo (thumb), Aarts, Castagna. Dow ( final qtr pulled put of 2 crucial contests)
In: Vlastuin, Gibcus, Ryan, Cumberland, RCD, Balta with, Ross the sub
-
Out: Lynch, Nankervis, Soldo, Aarts, Castagna, Dow
In: Gibcus, Balta, Vlastuin, Dusty, Cotchin, Lambert
If any or multiple of the last 3 aren’t fit then bring in the 3 best kids from the vfl tomorrow and no that doesn’t mean picking recycled senior players i.e. Parker.
Balta to be primary ruck, rotating with Gibcus through the fwd line.
-
With more injuries...
Out
Lynch
Nankervis
Soldo
George
Aarts
In
Ryan guess we have no choice
Cotchin
Balta
Gibcus
Vlastuin
Balta or Gibcus will have to go forward and Balta to ruck with Ryan.
Backline still sufficiently tall with Tarrant, Miller, one of Gibcus/Balta, Grimes etc.
-
Outs: team selection panel
Ins: who cares, season over, play kids especially RCD
No more Castagna
-
Out: Lynch, Nankervis, Soldo, Aarts, Castagna, Dow
In: Gibcus, Balta, Vlastuin, Dusty, Cotchin, Lambert
If any or multiple of the last 3 aren’t fit then bring in the 3 best kids from the vfl tomorrow and no that doesn’t mean picking recycled senior players i.e. Parker.
Balta to be primary ruck, rotating with Gibcus through the fwd line.
VFL have a bye this week :banghead
Of all the weeks :help
-
All of a sudden I'm not sure we win this with our injuries and obvious mental fragility
-
Out: Lynch (hammy), Nank (knee), Soldo (thumb), Aarts, Castagna. Dow, Rioli Jnr
In: Vlastuin, Gibcus, Ryan, Cumberland, Sonsie, Ross, RCD
-
Out lynch Nank Soldo Aartz Castagna Dow
In Gibcus Balta Sonsie Banks Clarke Vlastuin
Kids like Banks and Sonsie wont let you down
Play the kids
-
MJ escaping scrutiny, 3 touches
-
Could Miller play in the ruck?
-
MJ escaping scrutiny, 3 touches
Agree maybe he needs a spell too
-
Could Miller play in the ruck?
Golstein would wreck him
-
Could Miller play in the ruck?
Golstein would wreck him
yeah fair but won’t Goldstein wreck Sampson as well?
-
Yes he will but I reckon Miller can hold a kpd post for the next 8 to 10 years. I think Ryan wont be on the list in another 3.
-
MJ escaping scrutiny, 3 touches
Agree maybe he needs a spell too
Already enough forced changes and I thought his pressure was sensational.
Great pass off to Cumberland, very unselfish.
Shame he missed that shot in the last quarter.
-
MJ escaping scrutiny, 3 touches
Least of our problems
His defensive pressure was excellent again. Got ignored a few times when he was free by a couple of blokes who were selfish
-
Out: Dimma and the arrogance, Farts and Cantstandya
In: A new culture and attitude.
-
Out: Lynch, Nankervis, Soldo, Aarts, Castagna, Dow
In: Gibcus, Balta, Vlastuin, Dusty, Cotchin, Lambert
If any or multiple of the last 3 aren’t fit then bring in the 3 best kids from the vfl tomorrow and no that doesn’t mean picking recycled senior players i.e. Parker.
Balta to be primary ruck, rotating with Gibcus through the fwd line.
VFL have a bye this week :banghead
Of all the weeks :help
Probably good as it avoids anymore injuries. They would have had to rest Ryan anyway
-
Cotch unlikely and Balta still another week away according to Jon Ralph just now on Fox Footy.
-
Cotch unlikely and Balta still another week away according to Jon Ralph just now on Fox Footy.
The original plan was to have Balta back for the Norf game. Maybe he's had a setback?
-
Big injuries force Tigers to call on raw ruckman.
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/news/afl-2022-all-the-latest-injury-news-and-updates-for-round-17/news-story/8d0228374748147ad525c6e31351c4ac
----------------------------------------------------------------
They [Richmond] have no known ruck available and might have to fashion a Marlion Pickett (very good again on a wing) as first ruck next week. Suddenly, North next week is a danger game, given the way the Roos played on Saturday.
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/four-points-bombers-keep-on-trucking-rising-suns-wounded-tiger-20220710-p5b0h5.html
-
In deference to a poster from another forum, I'm going with,
Out: Castagna
In: Play with 21.
-
Do we risk broad in the ruck? Didn’t he pinch hit there in 2021 and was actually serviceable? But if Balta is also unavailable I guess it’s Ryan. But speaking of ruck, what’s mate Colina doing next weekend?
-
Big injuries force Tigers to call on raw ruckman.
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/news/afl-2022-all-the-latest-injury-news-and-updates-for-round-17/news-story/8d0228374748147ad525c6e31351c4ac
----------------------------------------------------------------
They [Richmond] have no known ruck available and might have to fashion a Marlion Pickett (very good again on a wing) as first ruck next week. Suddenly, North next week is a danger game, given the way the Roos played on Saturday.
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/four-points-bombers-keep-on-trucking-rising-suns-wounded-tiger-20220710-p5b0h5.html
It must be Ryan to come in. Has been playing first ruck all year in the VFL and performing ok. I would play Miller as the second ruck this week.
-
We will lose the ruck anyway, may as well throw another midfielder in there
-
Still require a few tall players to contest in the air, and be the target down the line when we need an outlet long kick.
-
Just play Ryan. He's raw but big and can take a mark.
-
Just to rub salt in the wound they'll probably bring in the 'Marvel specialist' Matt Parker this week.
-
Just play Ryan. He's raw but big and can take a mark.
It's a given he will play; only ruck we have available
Who we use to give him a chop out is the big question
Even if Balta plays; doubt they will risk playing him much in the ruck
-
Might be a Samson/Miller combo with Gibcus back in defence
-
As per the Nank thread: A chance to play this weekend.
-
As per the Nank thread: A chance to play this weekend.
Great news!
-
Tom Browne on 7news saying no Dusty this week which is what we already knew.
The RFC website has Nank listed as doubtful along with Ross who is unlikely to return from a medial he did at training last week.
Burge said Balta and Cotch could play this week if both get through training. Cotch also needs the okay from the specialist which they believe he will get.
-
OUT:
Lynch (Inj)
Nankervis (Inj)
Soldo (Inj)
Castagna (Omitted)
Dow (Omitted)
Aarts (Omitted)
IN:
Gibcus
Balta
Ryan
Sonsie
Cotchin
Vlastuin
TEAM:
B: Grimes, Tarrant, Broad
HB: Rioli, Miller, Ralphsmith
C: Pickett, Prestia, McIntosh
HF: Rioli Jnr, Riewoldt, Bolton
F: Sonsie, Gibcus, Balta
R: Ryan, Cotchin, Graham
I: Vlastuin, Baker, Short, Cumberland
S: Edwards
ROTATION PLANS:
Ruck: Ryan - Balta - Pickett - Riewoldt (F50)
CHF/FF: Balta - Gibcus - Riewoldt
HB/B: Baker - Short - Vlastuin - Ralphsmith
CHB/FB: Miller - Balta - Gibcus - Tarrant
HF/F: Sonsie - Cumberland - Graham - Bolton - Short - Rioli Jnr
Midfield:
Baker - Graham - Short - Bolton - Pickett - Vlastuin - Cotchin - Prestia
-
Lots dont want to see hide nor hair of Ryan and i don't get it.
Play him and Nankervis if Nankervis is right. Even if right with his sore knee he will need a decent chop out.
Would still go something like this
FB: Vlastuin# - Tarrant - Grimes
HB: Broad - Miller - Rioli.
C: Pickett - RC-D# - Ralphsmith
R: Nankervis - Cotchin# - Prestia
HF: Sonsie# - Balta# - Bolton
FF: Ryan# - Riewoldt - M Rioli
INT: Baker - McIntosh - Short - Graham - Gibcus#.
Out would go
Lynch inj
Soldo omit/inj
Edwards omit
Castagna omit never to be seen again
Aarts omit
Dow omit not up to it yet
Cumberland
In
Balta
Ryan
Gibcus
RC-D
Cotchin
Sonsie
Hmm changed.
-
Stack is not an option
Will miss a number of weeks with a cheekbone fracture. They couldn't perform surgery on it so it needs to heal naturally. They are saying at least another 2-3 weeks
-
Stack is not an option
Will miss a number of weeks with a cheekbone fracture. They couldn't perform surgery on it so it needs to heal naturally. They are saying at least another 2-3 weeks
Sheesh thats a shame hope he gets back and plays some games before the season runs out.
-
Lots dont want to see hide nor hair of Ryan and i don't get it.
Ryan is taller and physically heavier than Xerri though less physically developed. NM started putting games into Xerri at around the stage Ryan is at now.Give him a go against the second stringer and lets see where he is at.From what i can gather Ryan is developing and it cannot hurt at this stage to get some games into him.
Play him and Nankervis if Nankervis is right. Even if right with his sore knee he will need a decent chop out.
Would still go something like this
FB: Vlastuin# - Tarrant - Grimes
HB: Broad - Miller - Rioli.
C: Pickett - RC-D# - Ralphsmith
R: Nankervis - Cotchin# - Prestia
HF: Sonsie# - Balta# - Bolton
FF: Ryan# - Riewoldt - M Rioli
INT: Baker - McIntosh - Short - Graham - Gibcus#.
Out would go
Lynch inj
Soldo omit/inj
Edwards omit
Castagna omit never to be seen again
Aarts omit
Dow omit not up to it yet
Cumberland
In
Balta
Ryan
Gibcus
RC-D
Cotchin
Sonsie
Hmm changed.
-
Hmm changed.
Agree with most of that - what did you think of Cumberland though? I'm annoyed he only managed 2.3 from 5 shots, but at least he found the pill near the sticks and looked a damned sight more likely than George or Aarts.
I'd be giving him another go personally.
-
Team Tips:
Richmond will need to rethink its ruck setup for the clash with North Melbourne.
Toby Nankervis (knee) is in a race to prove his fitness while Ivan Soldo (thumb) and Tom Lynch (hamstring) have been ruled out through injury. Marlion Pickett could provide a back up ruck option if the Tigers didn’t want to go with another tall.
Noah Balta, Trent Cotchin and Josh Gibcus could all return from injury/illness.
Noah Cumberland could also be promoted to the starting side, after playing as the medi sub in the loss to the Gold Coast.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-teams-round-18-2022-team-tips-news-predicted-squads-lineups-injuries-changes-ins-and-outs-supercoach-analysis/news-story/7e8e121433b98e3872930ef636a077d7
-
Vlastuin coming back through twos after suspension fox? ::)
-
Vlastuin coming back through twos after suspension fox? ::)
No chance. This is a must win game including a % boost
-
Cotch and Balta trained fully today.
No Nank though.
Go to 1:10 min mark: https://twitter.com/7NewsMelbourne/status/1546780602950885377
-
Vlastuin coming back through twos after suspension fox? ::)
No chance. This is a must win game including a % boost
I was being sarcastic as fox sports forgot to mention it
-
In the Mix: Round 18
Howard Kimber
afl.com.au
13 July 2022
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=952)
The Tigers had injuries added to insult from the round 17 loss, with Tom Lynch (hamstring), Ivan Soldo (thumb) and Toby Nankervis (knee) all on the sidelines as the Suns stormed home. Nankervis is a chance to face North Melbourne but the other two will miss.
Nick Vlastuin and Josh Gibcus will return to bolster the backline, with Ben Miller the most likely to make way.
Trent Cotchin and Noah Balta are also expected to be available, putting last-man-in Thomson Dow in the gun.
Last round's medical sub Noah Cumberland made the most of his opportunities, putting pressure on the small forwards.
Maurice Rioli jnr is averaging just five disposals and 1.5 tackles through the last month, while Jason Castagna or Jake Aarts could pay the price for costly final-quarter misses.
Verdict: Vlastuin, Cotchin, Balta, Gibcus come in with Cumberland moving into the starting 22, replacing Lynch, Soldo, Miller, Dow and Castagna
https://www.afl.com.au/news/798389/in-the-mix-r18-who-s-pushing-for-selection-who-s-under-the-pump-
-
According to Dimma today:
Cotch got the all clear from the doc. So he'll train today and be available.
Floss back from suspension obviously.
Balta to play forward. Dimma said we see him primarily as a defender but given Noah gives us the flexibility of playing him back, mid or forward and us being skinny up the front end at the moment, he'll play "out of position".
Nank a chance. We'll see how he goes at training today. We've got to weigh up the benefits of playing him this week versus waiting until next.
Soldo to miss a week with is thumb.
Dusty - we're reasonably confident he'll push for next week but he's still in the doubtful category. We thought it was on the relative minor scale but it hasn't responded to the level we would like. That's not to say he won't play next week but being an important player we'll likely err on the conservative side.
As mentioned in the Ryan thread, Samson likely to play from what Dimma said today.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1171523/hardwick-previews-north-melbourne
-
Hmm changed.
Agree with most of that - what did you think of Cumberland though? I'm annoyed he only managed 2.3 from 5 shots, but at least he found the pill near the sticks and looked a damned sight more likely than George or Aarts.
I'd be giving him another go personally.
Never been a fan of two small fwds who play nowhere else. Think Cumberland while he did get a bit of ball in good spots is like Castagna with his disposal not as bad of course.
For me it comes down to either Maurice or Cumberland and while im worried about juniors offensive output id like to see him get one more week.
Have basically named Sonsie to give us a bit of rotation thru the middle and some genuine class and ball use up fwd.
With Edwards there who won't get dropped no matter how poor he goes Bolton, Junior, with Graham and Baker able to perform the small role as well i just don't see a reason why we have to play another dedicated small fwd. In doing so we we limit our options and become too small imo.
What i wouldnt give for us to discover a small/medium fwd who has pace great skills a good goal sense who tackles well who can go thru the middle if need be.
-
Nank will play :shh
;D
-
If Castagna and Aarts are in the team I will be disgusted but also not surprised unfortunately
-
As per Sonsie thread - he's in for his debut.
-
Nank will play :shh
;D
Nice scoop WP :cheers. Hopefully Nank gets through the game okay :pray.
Interesting to see if Ryan comes in for Soldo or we roll Balta as 2nd ruck?
Does Gibcus come back in for Miller to give us more flexibility in we need to switch Balta back and Gibcus forward?
Could be up to six changes to maintain our same structure (?).
In: Sonsie, Cotch, Balta, Ryan, Floss, Gibcus.
Out: Aarts, Castagna, Lynch (inj), Soldo (inj), Dow, Miller.
Bolton moves forward and Baker goes into the midfield.
B: Gibcus Tarrant Vlastuin
HB: D.Rioli Grimes Broad
C: Pickett Cotchin McIntosh
HF: Bolton Balta Sonsie
F: M.Rioli Riewoldt Edwards
R: Nankervis Prestia Baker
Int: Ryan Graham Short Ralphsmith
Sub: Cumberland
-
OUT:
Lynch (Inj)
Nankervis (Inj)
Soldo (Inj)
Castagna (Omitted)
Dow (Omitted)
Aarts (Omitted)
IN:
Gibcus
Balta
Ryan
Sonsie
Cotchin
Vlastuin
TEAM:
B: Grimes, Tarrant, Broad
HB: Rioli, Miller, Ralphsmith
C: Pickett, Prestia, McIntosh
HF: Rioli Jnr, Riewoldt, Bolton
F: Sonsie, Gibcus, Balta
R: Ryan, Cotchin, Graham
I: Vlastuin, Baker, Short, Cumberland
S: Edwards
ROTATION PLANS:
Ruck: Ryan - Balta - Pickett - Riewoldt (F50)
CHF/FF: Balta - Gibcus - Riewoldt
HB/B: Baker - Short - Vlastuin - Ralphsmith
CHB/FB: Miller - Balta - Gibcus - Tarrant
HF/F: Sonsie - Cumberland - Graham - Bolton - Short - Rioli Jnr
Midfield:
Baker - Graham - Short - Bolton - Pickett - Vlastuin - Cotchin - Prestia
4/5 ain’t bad :snidegrin