One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 24, 2023, 10:09:06 PM
-
Maurice a likely out injured.
Broad back from suspension.
Fire away with your changes?
-
Care factor pretty low right now.
-
Out: Mansell, Clarke, Ralphsmith, M Rioli (inj)
In: Broad, Sonsie, Ross, take your pick
Not much else we can do with the injuries we have.
-
Out: Mansell, Clarke, Ralphsmith, M Rioli (inj)
In: Broad, Sonsie, Ross, take your pick
Not much else we can do with the injuries we have.
Agree with this.
-
Would be tempted to drop Vlastiun, been horrendous this year :shh
-
Play Banks.
-
Out: Mansell, Clarke, Ralphsmith, M Rioli (inj)
In: Broad, Sonsie, Ross, take your pick
Not much else we can do with the injuries we have.
This is good.
Pick anyone else really wgaf
-
Chimp out rested.
Hard deck at Marvel won’t be playing
Ross in..
The rest throw a blanket or throw darts at the board.
-
Richmond believes Maurice Rioli tweaked a hammy in that incident late in the game. Jack Graham is ready to go next week off his own hamstring issue so they hoped to shrink their injury list but instead he joins it. Nank back running next week but still a few weeks away
@FOXFOOTY
https://twitter.com/RalphyHeraldSun/status/1650475612614840322
-
Out Rioli In Graham
Out Hugo In Ross
Out Mansell In Broad (Baker up forward)
Out Cotch In Sonsie
-
Would be tempted to drop Vlastiun, been horrendous this year :shh
Agree. Worst start to the season I’ve seen from him.
I’ve never seen him make this many mistakes in all his career.
His form has been terrible.
-
Dimma only confirmed that Broad will be back next week. No mention of Graham.
-
OUTS: MRJ (inj), Young, Cotchin (managed), Hugo (sub)
INS: Broad, Sonsie, Graham (if fit) and Ross as the sub
If Graham isn't right to go, time to debut Banks
-
Dow, Broad and Sonsie in. Dow deserves a chance. Out Rioli(injured) Hugo and Cotchin(managed)
-
Ross plays ahead of Dow IMO. Ross cops it on the chin every time he gets dropped, goes back to the VFL and dominates. That's all he can do. Dow is getting reasonable numbers too, so maybe he gets a go soon.
-
Mansell experiment is over let's not do the same as we did with George.Hugo is not good enough and Clarke needs a spell.Vaustin needs a dressing down.
-
Didn’t Dion hint it’s his turn to get managed?
-
OUTS: MRJ (inj), Young, Cotchin (managed), Hugo (sub)
INS: Broad, Sonsie, Graham (if fit) and Ross as the sub
If Graham isn't right to go, time to debut Banks
Young dropped I think Young plays until Tarrant comes back.
-
Young dropped I think Young plays until Tarrant comes back.
Forget the last qtr
Prior to that Young contributed (cost us) 3 goals. The one in the first was just a basic school boy error. Punching a ball forward rather than punching through for a behind.
It is not surprising that it didn't matter who a Young was on Melbourne directed their forward entries through his opponent
I think he needs a rest and with Broad back he goes out IMHO
-
I'd back him in (Young). It's a learning opportunity and it will get pointed out in the review.
He won't get better playing VFL and has shown enough at AFL level.
-
Agreed, showed he is inexperienced at the level and some of his by-play was a little immature and showed he was affected by his performance. But he looks like he’ll be a decent defender and won’t get better in the 2’s.
-
Agree, he's also playing in an undermanned backline.
I'd keep playing him.
-
Young dropped I think Young plays until Tarrant comes back.
Forget the last qtr
Prior to that Young contributed (cost us) 3 goals. The one in the first was just a basic school boy error. Punching a ball forward rather than punching through for a behind.
It is not surprising that it didn't matter who a Young was on Melbourne directed their forward entries through his opponent
I think he needs a rest and with Broad back he goes out IMHO
I think with rucks out, he has to play especially given that the coaching panel will explore Balta flexibility. Which I don't agree with.
Personally think Young and Balta need to play maximum game time down back as KP they are our future KP defenders. Most clubs now have 2 monster forwards and we can't afford to play Vlastuin or Grimes on big bodies as they aren't capable. Broad is best when he runs out of the backline. His errors didn't stand out to me anywhere near as much as our players slipping over which cost us more goals than anything else I thought, Young being one of them.
-
In the Mix: Round 7
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
26 April 2023
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=952)
Given the Tigers only played on Monday night, the extent of Maurice Rioli jnr's hamstring injury is not yet known.
Tyler Sonsie was the hold-over emergency in case of injury, and did not play at either AFL or VFL level, while Jack Graham (hamstring) is closing in on a return against Gold Coast.
Nathan Broad is available for selection after a stuff suspension for a sling tackle, and while Tylar Young performed fairly steadily in his month-long period at the top level, he may be the one to give way – or substitute Hugo Ralphsmith – to allow Broad to return to the 23.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/911917/in-the-mix-r7-who-s-under-the-pump-pushing-for-selection-
-
My outs at this stage. Thought Prestia was just starting to show a bit so im happy to rest Cotchin this week although Cotchin did some nice things.,
Any way one of them, McIntosh, R/Smith, Rioli, Vlastuin, with Grimes again on notice.
Miller to defense and Young forward lets at least try it.I just dont see it with Young. I don't think there is much improvement left in him to be honest. Why Miller was subbed out last week is beyond me. Bauer into the team as a tall fwd and Banks to a wing. Vlastuin dropped bring in Dow or Ross. Ross only if he is played as a ball winning mid.
Team lets see.
Grimes - Miller - Mansell. FFS play Mansell in his right role if he fails then so be it.
Rioli - Balta - Broad.
Banks - Martin - Pickett. We get best value out of Dusty as a mid by some margin.
Ryan - Taranto - Prestia
Sonsie - Riewoldt - Bolton
Bauer - Young - Cumberland
Hopper - Baker - Short. from Dow - Clarke - Ross - McIntosh.
Last we can rest Ryan with either Balta or Miller and role Young back while Ryan is resting.
-
Meanwhile, ruck Ivan Soldo could return this Sunday to face Gold Coast after recovering from plantar fasciitis.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1316827/injury-report-round-7-2023
-
How about giving Bauer a run? Hasn't he beaten some good players down back in the ressies as well as taking plenty of grabs to go along with near on 20 touches.. I'd be bringing him in.
-
Miller to defense and Young forward lets at least try it.I just dont see it with Young. I don't think there is much improvement left in him to be honest. Why Miller was subbed out last week is beyond me. Bauer into the team as a tall fwd and Banks to a wing. Vlastuin dropped bring in Dow or Ross. Ross only if he is played as a ball winning mid.
I have trouble picking up on sarcasm but this is sarcasm right?
-
How about giving Bauer a run? Hasn't he beaten some good players down back in the ressies as well as taking plenty of grabs to go along with near on 20 touches.. I'd be bringing him in.
Good idea
Bauer for Young
-
We need to start playing players in there natural positions.
OUT: Young, Ralphsmith, M.Rioli, Mansell, McIntosh (SHOULD BE DROPPED BUT WE KNOW HE WON’T BE)
IN: Broad, Bauer, Sonsie, Ross, Graham (IF FIT)
Round 7 v Gold Coast
B: Grimes (C) Balta Baker
HB: D.Rioli Miller Vlastuin
W: Pickett Prestia Graham/McIntosh
HF: Bolton Bauer Short
F: Cumberland Riewoldt Martin
R: Ryan Taranto Hopper
I: Broad Ross Sonsie Cotchin
S: McIntosh/Ralphsmith
-
RICHMOND is hopeful of regaining Jack Graham for the Round 7 game against Gold Coast.
Graham is set to return from a hamstring injury, while gun defender Nathan Broad has now served his four-match suspension.
Maurice Rioli jnr suffered a hamstring injury late in the loss to Melbourne.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-team-news-whispers-updates-for-round-6-2023-team-whispers-selection-latest-squads-injuries-supercoach/news-story/945d810c020abb5ded3f4c2d81885c1f
-
Miller to defense and Young forward lets at least try it.I just dont see it with Young. I don't think there is much improvement left in him to be honest. Why Miller was subbed out last week is beyond me. Bauer into the team as a tall fwd and Banks to a wing. Vlastuin dropped bring in Dow or Ross. Ross only if he is played as a ball winning mid.
I have trouble picking up on sarcasm but this is sarcasm right?
No sarcasm here mate unlike others just thinking outside the box. And not that far outside the box.
Miller has played his best footy as a defender and would be a better fit than young imo of course.Why the hell dimwit did not just swap Balta and Miller last week is beyond belief. And it bit him on the arse.
Young is a battler down back and just filling a hole till blokes come back from injury.
We clearly drafted Bauer as a tall fwd. Yes he has played a couple of good games down back in the two's because of injuries.
He also showed a fair bit of promise as a fwd for most of his games.
D o we throw Bradtke back and if he goes okay stop developing him as a fwd.
Do we suddenly stop developing the few young tall fwds we have when we are in our greatest need to find a few because of a few good games in defence. Apparently so.
Its funny the biggest single list deficiency we have and no one wants to try anything to fix it is tall fwd or lack there of.
People don't want to see Balta tried there or Miller now Bauer and Young and i won't be surprised to see em play Bradtke down back as well. Its as if they are blind to the glaring key fwd problems we have problems that have been there for ages.
If Soldo is fit then he will play ruck and Ryan will play mostly fwd. Even with those two id want to see Bauer play fwd drop Young and play Miller down Back.
If Soldo is not right to go then Young fwd, yeah a stretch but why not find out if he can offer us something there, if he is poor a simple swap with Miller will solve the problem. Atm with the lack of talls all young would have to do is present and compete.
(http://Edit: Fixed quoting)
-
Prestia out managed/soreness.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1317182/prestia-to-miss-suns-clash
:P
-
Why are we "managing" players to miss winnable games directly after they play in games against top sides we were likely to lose to and did lose to anyway?
We played Jack against the Pies then manage/rest him to miss the Dogs game. We end up losing both games. The latter by a kick.
We played Prestia against the Dees then manage/rest him to miss the Suns game. We lost to the Dees anyway and now weaken our side against Gold Coast.
Why match committee why? :huh3
-
Apparently soldo in.... has he even had any gametime at all ?