One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 28, 2023, 04:11:35 PM
-
I'm guessing Floss will be back.
Fire away with your changes?
-
No VFL this week doesn't make it any easier.
In: Floss, Cumberland.
Out: Young :help, Clarke (no more as sub).
Could drop a couple of others but our long list of injuries saves them.
-
It's "FFS just play the kids" time. :shh
-
McQualter was asked post-match if we were getting anyone back next week. Maurice to play some footy but didn't say at what level. No mention of Vlastuin being back.
-
INS: Vlastuin (if fit), Banks
OUTS: Young (sorry just don't see what the coaches see - his was responsible for Lord getting the goal that broke us), Ralphsmith (enough is more than enough :banghead), Clarke (sub)
-
I think there’s a stat somewhere where young is pretty good on the 1 vs 1 ? I think that gives him the potential to be an Astbury replacement?
Re - ralphsmith. I have a visceral disdain whenever I see him put on the jumper for us. To me he is the Aarts of 2023
-
Ralphsmith (enough is more than enough :banghead)
Don’t be like that WP
Far too negative about young Hugo
We most definitely wouldn’t want to point out any deficiencies
-
Out Jack. Time to retire mate. Gave us nothing against Illir. Couldn't even pick up the ball at ground level. Love you but goodbye...
-
Re - ralphsmith. I have a visceral disdain whenever I see him put on the jumper for us. To me he is the Aarts of 2023
Firstly , we aren’t allowed to be negative about young Hugo
Secondly (and this breaks the first one), how can you compare the disdain with that for Aarts?
Aarts was tough and played with HEART. Absolutely limited in the class department, but at least he wasn’t petrified and had a crack. Give me Aarts any time.
There is room in AFL teams for blokes that are scared pooless, but they have to excel in other areas.
-
Jack watched his opponent walk the ball out of forward 50. Was disgraceful. He is a leader that sets standards and he did NOTHING but spectate after he lost most contests. This has happened all year and I have had enough of his lazy efforts. Last game this week please retire. Love you but please retire.
-
Out: Ryan, Riewoldt, Young, Hugo, Clarke
In: Vlas, Cumbo, MRJ, Sonsie, Banks
Kmac and Graham survive only because I don’t see them even making the 5 changes I listed above let alone 7.
-
Out: Ryan, Riewoldt, Young, Hugo, Clarke
In: Vlas, Cumbo, MRJ, Sonsie, Banks
Kmac and Graham survive only because I don’t see them even making the 5 changes I listed above let alone 7.
Add McIntosh & Pickett to that list.
-
Out: Ryan, Riewoldt, Young, Hugo, Clarke
In: Vlas, Cumbo, MRJ, Sonsie, Banks
Kmac and Graham survive only because I don’t see them even making the 5 changes I listed above let alone 7.
Add McIntosh & Pickett to that list.
I would but refer to last sentence of my original comment lol
-
Jack watched his opponent walk the ball out of forward 50. Was disgraceful. He is a leader that sets standards and he did NOTHING but spectate after he lost most contests. This has happened all year and I have had enough of his lazy efforts. Last game this week please retire. Love you but please retire.
Dude he's not lazy, he's absolutely smashed every stuffing week playing 2 out with no other marking option and terrible delivery.
He's 34 and supposed to be getting regular rests, not taking the #1 forward post.
It's absolutely not his fault that he's been beaten black and blue due to our disgraceful list management and team selection.
-
Should have been rested but doing the team thing.
Hoping they give him a rest next week and we will then see how much depth we have in the key forward section
-
Jack watched his opponent walk the ball out of forward 50. Was disgraceful. He is a leader that sets standards and he did NOTHING but spectate after he lost most contests. This has happened all year and I have had enough of his lazy efforts. Last game this week please retire. Love you but please retire.
Dude he's not lazy, he's absolutely smashed every stuffing week playing 2 out with no other marking option and terrible delivery.
He's 34 and supposed to be getting regular rests, not taking the #1 forward post.
It's absolutely not his fault that he's been beaten black and blue due to our disgraceful list management and team selection.
These dumb stuffs should be held to account. Some of us saw it coming what would happen if Lynch went down well its on show this year.
absolute fools the lot of them and Jack is 100% not at fault.
-
It's "FFS just play the kids" time. :shh
;). Wont happen though.
-
No ressies but Sonsie, Banks, Cumberland and Bradtke all had good games the week before and Vlastuin will be back as well. Would also look at playing one of mrj or even Campbell.
Im hoping we go with the changes i wanted this week.
My outs would be from
Young - thought he looked out of his depth too often.There is a touch of comedy capers about him.
Mansell- please please just play a genuine small fwd instead.
Ross - laughable that we just don't learn. What are they seeing playing him on a wing.
Ryan - i know conditions did not suit him but he looks awfully undersized and wet or not he had little competition up fwd and struggled
Miller - similar to Ryan just did not impact where we needed him to and that was in the air.
Cotchin - he is limping to 300 maybe time for another rest.
Graham - yes Graham back to his non productive worst imo.
Ralphsmith - just lacks any sort of physicality.
McIntosh - just did not do enough and despite hitting a couple of targets i50 he is not clean enough by foot.
Ins - Banks, Cumberland, Sonsie, Bradtke, Vlastuin Bauer.
Play the kids and play smart.
Vlastuin - Miller - Grimes
Broad - Balta - Rioli
Banks - Martin - Pickett
Nankervis - Taranto - Sonsie
Bolton - Riewoldt - Clarke
Ryan - Bradtke - Cumberland
Baker - Short - Bauer - Prestia.
Cotchin/Graham/McIntosh
-
Vlastuin, Maurice & Biggie all listed as "test" this week. So possible ins.
-
Jack watched his opponent walk the ball out of forward 50. Was disgraceful. He is a leader that sets standards and he did NOTHING but spectate after he lost most contests. This has happened all year and I have had enough of his lazy efforts. Last game this week please retire. Love you but please retire.
Dude he's not lazy, he's absolutely smashed every stuffing week playing 2 out with no other marking option and terrible delivery.
He's 34 and supposed to be getting regular rests, not taking the #1 forward post.
Agree. Jack has put his body on the line for this club on repeated occasions, The delivery to him has been appalling and you can't expect a 34 year old to be your primary forward. Poor planning by the club. Jack is not at fault.
It's absolutely not his fault that he's been beaten black and blue due to our disgraceful list management and team selection.
These dumb stuffs should be held to account. Some of us saw it coming what would happen if Lynch went down well its on show this year.
absolute fools the lot of them and Jack is 100% not at fault.
-
I just hope the rest Jack . He’s playing with concrete boots .
Even the greenest of full forward options is better at this stage .
-
In the Mix: Round 12
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
31 May 2023
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=952)
The Tigers may need to make room for two inclusions, with Nick Vlastuin (corked leg) and Maurice Rioli (hamstring) named as tests for this week.
Inclusion Tylar Young did fairly well covering for Vlastuin, but it may come down to him and Hugo Ralphsmith in the backline.
Judson Clarke has struggled to get regular gametime, and may need a full match in the VFL under his belt, allowing for Rioli to return.
Jack Riewoldt is overdue for a break, if the Tigers wanted to go for a smaller forward line and include both Rioli and Clarke, with Samson Ryan and Ben Miller as the talls.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/940364/in-the-mix-r12-who-s-under-the-pump-pushing-for-selection-
-
Definitely time to give Biggie a bank of games to see how he goes, got to make decisions on these guys
Young I see something in, but agree he is raw and needs some development at VFL level.
Give Banks a run on the wing, maybe give Macca a rest or play as the sub
In Biggie, Vlaustin, Banks
Out: Young, Macca, Hugo & Clarke
Could give Bradkte a run and rest Ryan if he needs a spell too
-
Banks debut confirmed
-
Banks debut confirmed
Have searched far and wide and can't find anything about it.
**Not doubting you Willy just looking for the story
-
Banks debut confirmed
Have searched far and wide and can't find anything about it.
**Not doubting you Willy just looking for the story
My mistake. A friend sent me something that I thought was official but it wasn’t.
-
Banks debut confirmed
Have searched far and wide and can't find anything about it.
**Not doubting you Willy just looking for the story
My mistake. A friend sent me something that I thought was official but it wasn’t.
It is now albeit just an extended squad.