One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 11, 2024, 06:22:00 PM
-
Extended squad.
In: Prestia, Ryan, Dow, Trezise, Green.
Out: Campbell (managed), McAuliffe (omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
RICHMOND squad
B: Ben Miller Nathan Broad Noah Balta
HB: Tom Brown Daniel Rioli Nick Vlastuin
C: Hugo Ralphsmith Dion Prestia Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Rhyan Mansell Liam Baker Tyler Sonsie
F: Jacob Koschitzke Shai Bolton Samson Ryan
R: Toby Nankervis Jacob Hopper Tim Taranto
Int (from): Jack Graham Noah Cumberland Steely Green Sam Banks
Jayden Short Jacob Blight James Trezise Thomson Dow
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1598362
-
Agree on Campbell out.
McAuliffe probably fair he's had two games and has struggled but don't think Dow is a fair replacement. He's clearly better than VFL but needs some more work before he's AFL level. Good exposure for the kid though.
-
LMAO - Dow - tanking hard to keep that first pick.....bloke's like Communism "Real Dow hasn't been tried yet - it'll work this time..." :shh
-
Definitely professional tanking.
-
Lol again its the kids being scrutinised. The senior out of form hacks escape again.
Where the fcuking hell is Smiffy. Stuff Yze not prepared to try players in different roles. Not prepared to drop chronic soft weak as pee underperformers. Not prepared to reward consistent good form.
He is the coach he needs to draw a line in the sand otherwise his coaching career will be gone before it has begun.
-
Smith should have at least been considered.
-
Final 23.
In: Prestia, Ryan, Trezise, Green.
Out: Campbell (managed), McAuliffe (omitted), Blight (omitted), Cumberland (omitted).
Source: RFC twitter.
-
Blight dropped :huh...Trezise is a plodder & Green's a dud... :shh
-
Blight unlucky but I don’t see a backline of balta blight and Miller working.
Good to see trezise and green get a game.
Midfield of Taranto hopper and Prestia isn’t much to be excited about
-
Blight unlucky but I don’t see a backline of balta blight and Miller working.
Good to see trezise and green get a game.
Midfield of Taranto hopper and Prestia isn’t much to be excited about
Add in the pace of Graham
Very speedy midfield
-
Surprised Blight got dropped
But whatever :-\
-
Would have kept Blight in. Give him more experience.
-
Campbell needs to play on ball and find the foot. A lot.
-
LMAO - Dow - tanking hard to keep that first pick.....bloke's like Communism "Real Dow hasn't been tried yet - it'll work this time..." :shh
:lol :rollin :clapping
-
Dropping Blight seems a mistake, better player than Ryan
-
Dropping Blight seems a mistake, better player than Ryan
Doubt we brought in Ryan to play in the back line.... :shh
-
The Richmond way. Bring in mostly underperformers for underperformers. Dont back in the younger blokes don't reward great vfl form.
Seriously are we tanking. Wake up we don't need to tank we need to play and find out what kids are worth keeping asap.
This new coach well start asking questions if he is having a say in these things. because a blind man can see what we are getting wrong all the time.
Can we have a 2016 type review which includes looking at the new coach please.
-
Dropping Blight seems a mistake, better player than Ryan
Doubt we brought in Ryan to play in the back line.... :shh
Team balance then... bollocks
-
Dropping Blight seems a mistake, better player than Ryan
Doubt we brought in Ryan to play in the back line.... :shh
Highly unlikely we bought him in to play ruck either or kpf for that matter. Oh but wait...
He only needs about 6 touches to show improvement. Fmd one contested mark would double what we get in a game.
How the stuff is he even being considered.What the stuff has he even done to be considered this time around.
Ive said it before atm give me Hamspud or McBean.
They obviously see something well its high time he rewarded that confidence.
A spud imo just an okay ruck and just an okay fwd not great at either.
-
Dropping Blight seems a mistake, better player than Ryan
Stunning decision they have to be on drugs.
-
Blight did about as much wrong as Ryan has done right this season,
-
Maybe Nank won’t play
-
Our season has probably sunk to rest the captain levels unfortunately
-
Blight should be playing
-
RICHMOND
B: Ben Miller Nathan Broad Noah Balta
HB: Tom Brown Daniel Rioli Nick Vlastuin
C: Hugo Ralphsmith Dion Prestia Kamdyn McIntosh
HF: Rhyan Mansell Liam Baker Tyler Sonsie
F: Jacob Koschitzke Shai Bolton Samson Ryan
R: Toby Nankervis Jacob Hopper Tim Taranto
Int: Jack Graham James Trezise Steely Green Sam Banks Jayden Short
Emg: Noah Cumberland Jacob Blight Thomson Dow
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1598716/tigers-make-four-changes
-
GWS for those interested ...
B: C.Idun, J.Buckley, H.Himmelberg
HB: L.Whitfield, L.Aleer, H.Perryman
C: C.Ward, T.Green, I.Cumming
HF: B.Daniels, J.Riccardi, A.Cadman
F: T.Greene - C, J.Hogan, T.Bedford
FOLL: K.Briggs, S.Coniglio, F.Callaghan
I/C: J.Fonti, J.Peatling, H.Thomas, D.Jones, T.McMullin
EMG: L. Aleer, X.O’Halloran, J.Wehr
IN: L.Ash
OUT: L. Aleer (Omitted)
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-teams-round-18-2024-team-news-and-lineups-for-round-18-full-squads-ins-and-outs-injuries-benches-fixture-latest-news/news-story/303f3a01d8f4ae0b59d954dfa6dc6554
-
Blight dropped :huh...Trezise is a plodder & Green's a dud... :shh
Don’t disagree but may as well play Trezise and Green to make the case compelling
-
The Richmond way. Bring in mostly underperformers for underperformers. Dont back in the younger blokes don't reward great vfl form.
Seriously are we tanking. Wake up we don't need to tank we need to play and find out what kids are worth keeping asap.
This new coach well start asking questions if he is having a say in these things. because a blind man can see what we are getting wrong all the time.
Can we have a 2016 type review which includes looking at the new coach please.
3 kids in mate you on the same page ,Green ,Trezise and Ryan .Back to your point play the kids to see who sticks around.
-
Why is it we can't play three talls up forward.
If Bauer is fit i would have liked them to throw him forward as a replacement for Cumberland.
If they want to Play Ryan then play him from the bench with Nankervis. For now keep Balta forward and keep Blight in the team.
Very odd that they pick an underperformer in Ryan who has not played for two weeks. Its not as if we are rushing in Lynch or someone.
At worst keep Balta forward play kossie and Ryan the obvious problem with that is Ryan makes that forward half very slow and he is a statue when the ball is on the ground. So Blight cops it having not done a lot wrong and Balta goes back to accomodate playing Ryan forward.
Find a way to play both Blight and Ryan and Bauer as well.
Good to see good form rewarded with Trezise im shocked they cant give Smith a few games and reward consistent good form.
Would it be dumb to give Nankervis a rest and play Ryan as the ruckman. Why not.
How about he try some players in different roles which would allow kids to play in their right roles and actually drop a few underperformers.
Why not Rioli to a wing its worth trying. If not him why not see how Tom Brown would go on a wing. Free the kid up a bit, out with McIntosh he aint the future thats for sure.
I know McAuliffe has struggled a bit and probably deserved to be dropped. i would have liked them to give him one more week though.
If Sonsie plays it is time to play him midfield and see what he can produce.
This week something like this
Vlastuin - Miller - Broad. Broad has been poor lately he is another who could be dropped based on poor form.
Rioli - Blight - Trezise. Kept Rioli back for the extra experience with Blight and Trezise there.
Brown - Taranto - Ralphsmith. Browny gets freed up a bit and gets to use his footskills in say a short type role.
Ryan - Hopper - Sonsie. Its a slow midfield. It will be slow regardless of who we play there. Look at the options. Sonsie freed up.
Bauer - Balta - Mansell. Bauer a quicker mobile tall rather than a kp instead of NC. Gives us flexability and an ability to keep structure if Balta is needed back.
Bolton - Kossie - ####. Pick a small forward its slim pickings atm.
McAuliffe - Baker - Prestia - Smith.
Banks.
-
Claw every week players are in different roles. You say rest nank and let Ryan play ruck but in other threads you’ve said how useless Ryan is. I think you just like to go against whatever the club does. Don’t take this as me trying to start something but it’s true, all you post about is how the club has got it wrong.
-
So tresize IS sub. WAFJ.
-
Claw every week players are in different roles. You say rest nank and let Ryan play ruck but in other threads you’ve said how useless Ryan is. I think you just like to go against whatever the club does. Don’t take this as me trying to start something but it’s true, all you post about is how the club has got it wrong.
Nope my preference has been to not play Ryan at all.
Once they picked him and moved Balta back and dropped Blight it was a reaction to his selection trying to find a way to play Ryan, Blight and Bauer. Thats what the question of, why cant we play three tall forwards? was about. and the remainder of the post was finding a way to make it work.The only way i could see playing all three was what i said.
the only way i could see Ryan gets a game is if he plays ruck so give Nank a rest.
We should have kept Blight and we should have added Bauer as a third tall option which is what i said
Still think Balta should have played forward along with Bauer if he was fit to play. Still think Blight should have started in defense
The team i prefered us to play was with trezise, Smith, Blight, Prestia, and Bauer all in the team. As well as the captain.
I only went down the Ryan path after he was selected.
Most weeks ive wanted McIntosh to be given the arse.
Most weeks i have commented on playing Rioli on a wing dropping shortsteps thus allowing Smith and Trezise a game.
I have certainly said my piece about Ryan and why we should not pick him. Been very consistent on all of this.
Any way hope that explains things. Next week i won't be reacting to selections i will just stick to what i think they should be doing.
-
Hugo seems to have found his spot. Good on him
-
I very rarely buy into arguments about selection
Find it near impossible to go into bat for Claw
But FFS, how did Blight get dropped
Should have got a game on merit .. then can add the fact the playing group genuinely like him from what it seems
Comes in for a game , cops it up the arse
Smith in for a game , cops it just as hard
Steely Green , cops it, back today and kicks a few
Just play the stuffing kids .. why not ???