One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 09, 2024, 11:59:08 PM
-
AFLW Round 7
RICHMOND v Geelong
Saturday, 12th October @ the Swinburne Centre, Punt Road Oval.
Start time: 3:05 PM
Broadcast:
* Fox Footy & Kayo (all states & territories)
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/matches/6861
-
Injury List
Player Injury Estimated Return
Maddie Shevlin Ankle Test
Amelia Peck Knee (MCL) Season
Shelby Knoll Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Montana McKinnon Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Katelyn Cox Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/aflw/injury-list
-
We're currently 4th on the ladder.
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GZcXixRaUAAUJsP?format=jpg&name=large)
https://x.com/FOXFOOTY/status/1843968557450949085
-
Crows lost. As long as we keep winning we’ll get top4.
-
Unchanged this week.
RICHMOND
B: Gabrielle Seymour Rebecca Miller
HB: Beth Lynch Isabel Bacon Libby Graham
C: Tessa Lavey Ellie McKenzie Kate Dempsey
HF: Ally Dallaway Katie Brennan Sarah Hosking
F: Caitlin Greiser Emelia Yassir
R: Poppy Kelly Eilish Sheerin Monique Conti
Int: Mackenzie Ford Jodie Hicks Charley Ryan Grace Egan Tamara Luke
Emergencies: Laura McClelland Molly Eastman Jemima Woods
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1675821/richmond-aflw-take-unchanged-line-up-into-week-7
-
Kate Dempsey is playing her 50th game this weekend.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1674534/kate-dempsey-50-games
-
Injury List
Player Injury Estimated Return
Maddie Shevlin Ankle Test
Amelia Peck Knee (MCL) Season
Shelby Knoll Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Montana McKinnon Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Katelyn Cox Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/aflw/injury-list
Sheesh i thought we got rid of Meehan
-
Injury List
Player Injury Estimated Return
Maddie Shevlin Ankle Test
Amelia Peck Knee (MCL) Season
Shelby Knoll Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Montana McKinnon Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Katelyn Cox Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/aflw/injury-list
Sheesh i thought we got rid of Meehan
The AFLW side has its own fitness team
ACL are not the fault of any fitness team no matter how much people want to say otherwise
And as a side note, ACLs in women's sport happen at higher rate than in men's sport. There ate a number of reveiws/studies going on into this
-
Injury List
Player Injury Estimated Return
Maddie Shevlin Ankle Test
Amelia Peck Knee (MCL) Season
Shelby Knoll Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Montana McKinnon Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Katelyn Cox Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/aflw/injury-list
Sheesh i thought we got rid of Meehan
The AFLW side has its own fitness team
ACL are not the fault of any fitness team no matter how much people want to say otherwise
And as a side note, ACLs in women's sport happen at higher rate than in men's sport. There ate a number of reveiws/studies going on into this
Not being as finely tuned and strong would play a part
I saw a highlight the other day of Prespakis.
Now she has been body shamed big time , which is harsh. But I will ask this.
Is someone more likely to do a knee that is unfit? Or someone ripped in an AFL program?
-
Injury List
Player Injury Estimated Return
Maddie Shevlin Ankle Test
Amelia Peck Knee (MCL) Season
Shelby Knoll Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Montana McKinnon Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
Katelyn Cox Knee (ACL) Season (inactive)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/aflw/injury-list
Sheesh i thought we got rid of Meehan
The AFLW side has its own fitness team
ACL are not the fault of any fitness team no matter how much people want to say otherwise
And as a side note, ACLs in women's sport happen at higher rate than in men's sport. There ate a number of reveiws/studies going on into this
They often aren't, but repeat ACL's on the same knee often are.
-
I know I get defensive about the AFLW and when players are body shamed
And I'm using Prespakis as an example here and not potting you Damo but can she not be fit despite her body shape? I'm not disputing that with her body shape too many she doesn't look fit
She is fit, her numbers say that, is she getting unfairly classed as unfit because of her body shape?
-
It works if you say "fit" with a kiwi accent.... :shh
-
I know I get defensive about the AFLW and when players are body shamed
And I'm using Prespakis as an example here and not potting you Damo but can she not be fit despite her body shape? I'm not disputing that with her body shape too many she doesn't look fit
She is fit, her numbers say that, is she getting unfairly classed as unfit because of her body shape?
Didn’t take it as potting me
With what I said , there was no possible way I could be potted as nothing I said was offensive
However, your comments are odd to me saying she is fit ..
So from now on , any AFL player that is commented on for being unfit , we will just claim it’s the body shape .. or is that excuse just for AFLW players ??
You say she’s fit because she’s good and better than most others .. irrelevant .. if Conti was 15kgs heavier, I guarantee she would still be a gun .. an unfit gun, but a gun nonetheless (side note, she would never let that happen being a complete professional)
She’s unfit Prespakis .. simple .. she’s overweight and it isn’t her “body shape” that causes it .. if she dieted and spent more time in the gym (as much as AFL players), don’t tell me her “body shape” wouldn’t change
Different rules for different genders
We need the AFL to bring in a Middle Aged Straight White Guy Round .. the only group that’s missing
-
I’ll also add .. the bullying she has copped is wrong and if it was my daughter I’d be FUMING
All I’m responding to is your comment that she’s fit because she’s good
She’s good because she clearly has a stack more ability that 90%+ of the others on the ground
As for the body shape comment .. look at her “shape” 5 years ago compared to now
She’s out of shape , and if it was an AFL player there would be no problems pointing it out .. she should be fitter and in better shape .. but that’s her decision and good luck to her
My comments aren’t about her , it means zero to me , it’s about the comments in this thread
-
Think Dusty say 2011 Damo?
-
Think Dusty say 2011 Damo?
#waddler :shh
-
Fair enough Damo
Appreciate your response
There is no doubt that there are AFLW players who are overweight and unfit. Can't disagree with that, can't dispute it
But I think that there are players who look unfit due to their body shape but are fit. They can't all look like Mon Conti, Katie Brennan, Jaz Garner etc.
Would Prespakis dieting and time in the gym change her body shape? Absolutely. But would she end up looking like some of the gun players in the comp? Maybe but no guarantee
Finally can I add you say "different rules for different genders" and you are right in a way.
Clayton Oliver ran around all season unfit, clearly was carrying extra kgs. I don't recall reading one media article where he was called fat or overweight, he was just labelled unfit.
He was not body shamed on social media the way so many AFLW players have since the comp began and as we've seen this week continue to be.
That's why I get angry and defend the women because the same rules aren't being applied IMHO.
Just my take
-
Thanks to Ozempic will be no fat shaming in the future.... :shh
-
Out of the middle from the start and Brennan marks on 50. Goes long and Greiser is pushed in the back 15m out. Shot across the face. Bad miss.
1 - 0
-
Poor defending. Didn't block the leading space. Lucky the Cats miss.
Geelong looks like they have the breeze.
-
Sheerin with the ping from 40 just misses to the right. Breeze appears to be pushing it that way.
2 - 2
-
Dumb by Graham. Gave away a needless free in front of goal and costs us a goal.
2 - 8
-
Thanks to Ozempic will be no fat shaming in the future.... :shh
It’s certainly a thing Dio
-
Really poor so far. Second to the ball plus mistackles. Doesn't look like we've turned up to play.
-
These umps :facepalm.
-
Quarter time
Richmond 0.2-2
Geelong 1.3-9
I know we were kicking into the breeze but that was crap from us. Too many passengers. Ferguson needs to give them a blast to lift the intensity.
-
Stats to QT:
Disposals 65 - 59 .... (contested: 30 - 29) .... overpossessing with more handballs than kicks.
Efficiency% 63 - 63
Marks 5 - 9
Clearances 5 - 8
Inside 50s 6 - 12
Tackles 9 - 16
Frees 2 - 7 ::)
Sheerin 7 possies
Conti 6
Egan 6
McKenzie 6
Ryan 6
Dempsey 4
Hicks 4
Yassir 4
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/matches/6861#player-stats
-
Egan's snap is touched on the line.
3 - 9
-
Higher scoring than normal
Might stuff the tv on
-
Just no defending today. Left space wide open for Geelong forwards to repeatedly lead into. Schoolkid stuff :banghead.
-
Geelong should be 4-5 goals up. Keeping us in it with their misses. Worst we've played for a long time.
3 - 12
-
Finally get forward. Ball-up 30 out. Katie's snap misses.
4 - 12
-
Kelly intercepts on 50. Ball carries and Yassir marks going back with the flight. Goal! :gotigers
Finally!
Rich 1.4-10
Geel 1.6-12
12 min Q2
-
Conti dumped in the tackle after disposal 30 out. Hits the left post. Have to aim for the right post at the end.
11 - 12
-
Conti intercepts the quick Geelong defensive kick 35 out. Adjust for the breeze and nails it. Goal! :gotigers
We're actually in front! :o
Rich 2.5-17
Geel 1.6-12
1 min to go before HT.
-
Half-time
Richmond 0.2 2.5-17
Geelong 1.3 1.6-12
Goals: Conti, Yassir.
Crap for all but the last 5 mins of the first half. Finally lifted our intensity just before HT and kicked the last 2 goals to grab the lead. Deserved to be 4-5 goals down before that late surge. Lucky the Cats missed their chances.
-
Stats to HT:
Conti 13 possies
Egan 12
McKenzie 10
Lavey 9
Sheerin 9
Kelly 7
Dempsey 6
Ryan 6
Brennan 5
Dallaway 5
Hicks 5
Miller 5
Seymour 5
Graham 4
Greiser 4
Yassir 4
Bacon 2
Hosking 2
Lynch 2
Ford 1
Luke 1
Disposals 116 - 111 .... ( contested: 53 - 49 )
Efficiency% 62 - 62
Marks 11 - 19
Tackles 25 - 24
Clearances 13 - 12 .... ( centre: 3 - 1 )
Inside 50s 15 - 19
In50 marks 3 - 5
In50 tackles 3 - 3
Hitouts 17 - 10
Frees 7 - 9
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/matches/6861#player-stats
-
Can our small forwards get freaking front and square :scream.
-
Brennan's snap holds up into the breeze and is touched through.
18 - 12
-
Terrible Graham. Assumed the ball was going through for a point and allowed her opponent to mark on the line.
18 - 18
-
Another free that no one knows what for :facepalm. Geelong gifted a goal.
18 - 24
-
Hicks intercepts the Geelong defensive kick 45 out. Spears one at Brennan but it goes through everyone to Yassir who snaps and goals :gotigers.
Rich 3.6-24
Geel 3.6-24
13 min Q3
-
How the stuff do the AFL expect fans to take this game seriously when the umpires are stuffen putrid
-
3/4 time
Richmond 0.2 2.5 3.6-24
Geelong 1.3 1.6 3.8-26
Goals: Yassir 2, Conti.
Important goal to Yassir against the breeze. Love to know the number of frees Geelong has got inside their F50 ::).
-
Stats to 3QT:
Conti 18 possies
Egan 18
McKenzie 12
Sheerin 12
Kelly 10
Lavey 10
Hicks 9
Disposals 159 - 172 .... ( contested: 75 - 73 )
Efficiency% 59 - 61
Marks 19 - 25
Tackles 37 - 36
Clearances 19 - 19 .... ( centre: 6 - 2 )
Inside 50s 18 - 29
In50 marks 6 - 7
In50 tackles 4 - 9
Hitouts 36 - 16
Frees 9 - 13 ::) :facepalm
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/matches/6861#player-stats
-
Geelong defenders run over it. Katie gathers and goals ....
Hang on ... it's called touched.
Paid a point.
25 - 26
-
Conti's kick inside 50 carriers over Greiser and her opponent. Bounces and hits the post.
26 - 26
-
OOTF by Geelong. McKenzie from 50 goes to the goalsquare. Rushed.
27 - 26
-
Two different rules ::). Geelong player run down = play on. Now another free to the Cats inside their F50. It was there but it should have been a free to us in the first place. Gifted another goal :banghead.
27 - 32
-
If we don’t make a complaint about the umpires after this game the club can GAGFd
-
Sheerin crumbs off the pack and snaps the goal :gotigers
Rich 4.9-33
Geel 4.8-32
12 min Q4
-
If we don’t make a complaint about the umpires after this game the club can GAGFd
They have been pathetic today.
-
Throw-in 20 out. Luke dragged down but no free. Conti's snap misses.
34 - 32
-
Frees 9 - 17 ::)
-
Again. Geelong player tackled and drops the ball = no free ::).
And they get a goal from the subsequent ball-up.
34 - 38
-
We finally get a free 20 out. Yassir slung in the tackle. Goal! :gotigers
Rich 5.10-40
Geel 5.8-38
3.21 mins left.
-
Point to Geelong,
40 - 39
2.41 left.
-
McKenzie taken high = no free >:(.
-
Kelly long and Brennan gets the free 35 out. Goal! :gotigers
Captain kicks the winner.
Rich 6.10-46
Geel 5.9-39
33 secs to go.
-
Won by 7 :gotigers
-
That’s a good win :thumbsup
-
Final Score
Richmond 0.2 2.5 3.6 6.10-46
Geelong 1.3 1.6 3.8 5.9-39
Goals: Yassir 3, Brennan, Conti, Sheerin.
Hard fought win given we played poorly for large periods of the game especially in the first half. Our stars stood up in the moments that mattered to get us over the line.
-
The umps today proved WP's point about the standard of umpiring being woeful in the AFLW (it's crap in the men's too). It's Russian roulette whether you get a free or not. Two different HTB rules today and frees 11 - 19 with about half of Geelong's being paid in their F50 almost cost us the game.
-
Captain kicks the winner.
Katie's winning goal.
https://x.com/aflwomens/status/1844981975917965382
-
If we don’t make a complaint about the umpires after this game the club can GAGFd
They have been pathetic today.
I have seen some bad displays of umpiring but that takes the cake.
Tiger girls weren’t up to it today, Geelong were harder at it and wanted the win more.
Lucky to get up in the end
-
Plus next time we play them can we shut down Georgia P, she smashes it every time she plays us
-
Tigers overpower Cats at the death to keep top four in sight
A late Katie Brennan goal seals a seven-point win for Richmond over Geelong
By Phoebe McWilliams
afl.com.au
12 October 2024
RICHMOND 0.2 2.5 3.6 6.10 (46)
GEELONG 1.3 1.6 3.8 5.9 (39)
GOALS
Richmond: Yassir 3, Conti, Sheerin, Brennan
Geelong: Parry 2, Surman, A.Moloney, Darby
BEST
Richmond: Conti, McKenzie, Sheerin, Brennan, Yassir
Geelong: A.Moloney, Crockett-Grills, Emonson, Parry, Prespakis
INJURIES
Richmond: Nil
Geelong: Kearns (concussion)
Reports: Nil
Crowd: 2,455 at the Swinburne Centre
----------------------------------------
RICHMOND has kept its place in the top four with a thrilling seven-point win against Geelong in windy but sunny conditions at a sold-out Swinburne Centre on Saturday afternoon.
Despite the fact that these sides sit at opposite ends of the ladder, it was an action-packed contest before Richmond came away with the four points from the 6.10 (46) to 5.9 (39) victory.
The lead see-sawed throughout a frantic final quarter, with the winner decided only in the final minute of the game when Tigers captain Katie Brennan kicked a goal to seal the win.
Geelong started the match with the breeze, but were only able to score one goal for the term despite doubling Richmond in inside 50s.
The goal came 10 minutes into the term when small forward Kate Surman, who returned to the side this week, converted from a free kick for high contact from Richmond defender Libby Graham.
Julia Crockett-Grills (18 disposals, five inside 50s) and Chantel Emonson (18 disposals, 455m gained) continued to propel the Cats forward into the wind in the second quarter, but once again, these forays forward didn't result in goals.
The Cats' inability to score kept the Tigers in the game and when Richmond's Emilia Yassir and Mon Conti scored goals in the second term, the home side went into the half-time break with a five-point lead.
It was only a matter of time until dangerous Geelong forward Aishling Moloney (23 disposals, eight score involvements) hit the scoreboard, with the Irish woman marking on the goal line before snapping her first.
Fellow forward Jackie Parry followed shortly after giving the Cats back the lead.
However, a quick response from Yassir kept Richmond in the game when she scored her second, with Geelong going into the final break with a two-point lead.
It was goal-for-goal to start the final term with Geelong's Parry kicking her second from a free kick, followed shortly by an Eilish Sheerin left foot snap from the boundary for the Tigers.
Veteran Geelong tall Kate Darby scored the next, but again Richmond responded when Yassir got her third.
As she has done all season, Katie Brennan stood up when her team needed, her kicking the sealer for the home side to give Richmond the win.
The hero
On a windy day when both teams were struggling to score majors, Richmond small forward Emilia Yassir kicked three goals straight. Goals were worth their weight in gold, and Yassir made the most of every opportunity that came her way. The sharp shooter kicked half of the Tigers' goals today, in what was her best game so far in season nine.
It was over when…
As she has done many times before, Richmond captain Katie Brennan stood up when her team needed her. The Richmond captain sealed the game when she slotted a long-range set shot in tricky conditions. Tigers senior coach Ryan Ferguson said the 32-year-old has been trying to shift her focus away from being the hero, but in doing so has found herself ironically doing heroic things. "She's (Brennan) got so much better at understanding she doesn't need to be the hero as such. She's taken that anxiety away from 'I must do something special' and the funny thing is more special things have happened that way," Ferguson said post-match. We're enjoying watching her doing special Katie Brennan things.
Cats' tough run home
It's nearly mathematically impossible for the Cats to make finals following Saturday's loss. To make things worse they have one of the toughest draws to finish the season. Next week they play reigning premier Brisbane at home, they then travel to Perth to play West Coast, and in their final game they have Adelaide at home again. You can bet the Cats will throw everything at these games, but the travel to Perth plus coming up against the two most dominant teams in the AFLW era, will certainly make things tough.
Up next
Richmond will play the Demons in a Saturday afternoon clash at Casey Fields, while Geelong plays Brisbane at GMHBA Stadium on Sunday.
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/news/1242722/richmond-tigers-overpower-geelong-cats-at-the-death-to-keep-top-four-in-sight
-
Team stats:
Disposals 219 - 217 .... ( contested: 107 - 98 ; uncontested: 104 - 112 )
Efficiency% 59 - 59
Kicks 115 - 125
Handballs 104 - 92
Turnovers 42 - 40
Marks 23 - 38 .... ( contested marks: 6 - 4 )
Tackles 55 - 66
Clearances 32 - 25 .... ( centre: 8 - 5 ; stoppages: 24 - 20 )
Inside 50s 29 - 33
In50 Eff.% 52 - 52
In50 marks 6 - 7
In50 tackles 7 - 14
Hitouts 49 - 23
Bounces 2 - 0
One %ers 26 - 26
Frees 11 - 19 ::) :facepalm
Individual possies:
Conti 27 .... (13 contested) plus 7cl (4cc), 5t, 3in50, 311m gained, 6 score inv & a goal.
Egan 23 .... (9 contested) plus 5cl, 8t, 4 score inv.
Sheerin 17 .... (10 contested) plus 5cl, 204m gained, 4 score inv & a goal.
McKenzie 16 .... (7 contested) plus 4in50, 288m gained.
Dempsey 15 .... (6 contested) plus 4in50, 248m gained, 5ints, 4 score inv.
Kelly 15 .... (11 contested) plus 3m (all contested), 39ho, 4ints.
Brennan 11 .... plus 5m, 4t, 251m gained, 6 score inv & a goal.
Lavey 11
Hicks 11 .... plus 3m & 6ints.
Greiser 8
Lynch 8 .... plus 8t, 5 ints.
Ryan 8
Seymour 8 .... (7 contested) plus 4ints.
Dallaway 7
Graham 7
Miller 7 .... plus 263m gained.
Yassir 7 .... plus 3in50 & 3 goals.
Hosking 6 .... plus 4t.
Bacon 3
Ford 3
Luke 1
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/matches/6861#player-stats
-
(https://resources.richmondfc.com.au/photo-resources/2024/10/12/3a207fbc-3f1a-4b2d-a33a-5b8e7bc56926/l3Gjk323.jpg?width=451&height=268) (https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1677260/aflw-week-7-ferguson-post-match)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1677260/aflw-week-7-ferguson-post-match
-
(https://resources.richmondfc.com.au/photo-resources/2024/10/12/81665067-3279-416a-86ef-5fce38bf6537/iDm01eus.jpg?width=860&height=484) (https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1677531/aflw-week-7-match-highlights)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1677531/aflw-week-7-match-highlights
-
Coaches' votes
Richmond v Geelong
10 Aishling Moloney (GEEL)
6 Monique Conti (RICH)
6 Emelia Yassir (RICH)
4 Poppy Kelly (RICH)
3 Rebecca Webster (GEEL)
1 Eilish Sheerin (RICH)
LEADERBOARD
71 Ebony Marinoff (ADEL)
62 Ashleigh Riddell (NMFC)
59 Jasmine Garner (NMFC)
53 Ally Anderson (BL)
49 Monique Conti (RICH)
47 Eliza West (HAW)
43 Ella Roberts (WCE)
40 Charlie Rowbottom (GCFC)
38 Ellie McKenzie (RICH)
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/news/1244927/coaches-votes-w7-adelaide-crow-ebony-marinoff-among-seven-perfect-10s-to-charge-into-lead