One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on December 01, 2025, 11:24:03 PM
-
Yes, it's that time again for the game that creates controversy each and every year we've done it ;D
Same rules as previous years to control our over-eager posters ;).
* The current playing list has been split into 4 groups. (Not including the newbie draftees)
Group A: Alger, Balta, Clarke, Faull, Green, Lynch, Sonsie, Smith, Taranto.
Group B: Armstrong, Broad, Fawcett, Hayes-Brown, Lalor, Nankervis, Mansell, Ralphsmith, Short.
Group C: Brown, Campbell, Gray, Hopper, Miller, Ross, Smillie, Trezise, Vlastuin.
Group D: Banks, Gibcus, Hotton, Lefau, McAuliffe, Prestia, [/b]Rioli[/b], Ryan, Sims, Trainor.
* For each group, one at a time, we vote in the same manner as before: +1 for one player and -1 for another. No 2's, 5's or 35's.
* The only voting restrictions are there needs to be a gap of 5 posters since you last voted before you can vote again OR a 12 hour gap (whichever comes first).
* Each player will start with 5 points. Players who reach zero points are eliminated. Players who reach 10 points qualify for the final 12. Voting for each group stops when 3 players have qualified and then we move onto the next group.
* When the top 3 from each of the 4 groups are known we'll then vote from the final 12 left to get a final winner who will be crowned OER's favourite player.
-
Starting off with Group A:
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 5
Faull 5
Green 5
Lynch 5
Sonsie 5
Smith 5
Taranto 5
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 5
Faull 6 +
Green 5
Lynch 5
Sonsie 5
Smith 4 -
Taranto 5
;D
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 4 -
Faull 6
Green 5
Lynch 6 +
Sonsie 5
Smith 4
Taranto 5
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Faull 7 +
Green 5
Lynch 6
Sonsie 4 -
Smith 4
Taranto 5
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Faull 8 +
Green 5
Lynch 6
Sonsie 4
Smith 3 -
Taranto 5
-
+1 SMITH
-1 Sonsie
-
After claw's voting
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Faull 8 +
Green 5
Lynch 6
Sonsie 3 -
Smith 4 +
Taranto 5
Going forward it would be appreciated if people updated the complete list after voting
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Faull 9 +
Green 4 -
Lynch 6
Sonsie 3
Smith 4
Taranto 5
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 3 -
Faull 9
Green 4
Lynch 7 +
Sonsie 3
Smith 4
Taranto 5
-
Alger 5
Balta 5
Clarke 3
Faull 10 and through ;D
Green 4
Lynch 7
Sonsie 3
Smith 3 -
Taranto 5
-
Alger 6 +
Balta 5
Clarke 3
Green 3 -
Lynch 7
Sonsie 3
Smith 3
Taranto 5
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4+
Green 3
Lynch 7
Sonsie 2-
Smith 3
Taranto 5
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 3
Lynch 7
Sonsie 2
Smith 2 -
Taranto 6 +
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 3
Lynch 7
Sonsie 1 -
Smith 2
Taranto 7 +
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 3
Lynch 7
Sonsie 1
Smith 1 -
Taranto 8 +
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 3
Lynch 8+
Sonsie 0-
Smith 1
Taranto 8
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 3
Lynch 8
Smith 0 - and goneskis
Taranto 9 +
-
Alger 6
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 2 -
Lynch 8
Taranto 10 + and through
-
Alger 7 +
Balta 5
Clarke 4
Green 1 -
Lynch 8
-
Alger 7
Balta 6 + ;D
Clarke 4
Green 0 - goneskis
Lynch 8
-
Alger 7
Balta 6
Clarke 3 -
Lynch 9 +
-
Alger 8 +
Balta 6
Clarke 2 -
Lynch 9
-
Alger 8
Balta 6
Clarke 1 -
Lynch 10 +
-
On to Group B:
Armstrong 5
Broad 5
Fawcett 5
Hayes-Brown 5
Lalor 5
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 5
Short 5
-
Armstrong 5
Broad 5
Fawcett 6 +
Hayes-Brown 5
Lalor 5
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 5
Short 4 -
-
Armstrong 6 +
Broad 5
Fawcett 6
Hayes-Brown 5
Lalor 5
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 5
Short 3 -
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7 +
Hayes-Brown 5
Lalor 5
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 5
Short 2 -
;D
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 5
Lalor 6 +
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 4 -
Short 2
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 4 -
Lalor 6
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 4
Short 3 +
:rollin
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7 +
Hayes-Brown 4
Lalor 6
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 4
Short 2 -
:eyebrow
-
You know it's a long off-season when we poor tragics have to resort to this game lol
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 3-
Lalor 7+
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 4
Short 2
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 5
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 3
Lalor 8 +
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 4
Short 1 -
-
Armstrong 6
Broad 6 +
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 3
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 3 -
Short 1
-
Armstrong 7+
Broad 6
Fawcett 7
Hayes-Brown 3
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 5
Ralphsmith 3
Short 0-
-
Armstrong 7
Broad 6
Fawcett 8 +
Hayes-Brown 3
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 4 -
Ralphsmith 3
-
Armstrong 8 +
Broad 6
Fawcett 8
Hayes-Brown 3
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 4
Ralphsmith 2 -
-
Armstrong 9 +
Broad 6
Fawcett 8
Hayes-Brown 2 -
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 4
Ralphsmith 2
-
Armstrong 9
Broad 6
Fawcett 9 +
Hayes-Brown 2
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 3 -
Ralphsmith 2
-
Armstrong 10+
Broad 6
Fawcett 9
Hayes-Brown 2
Lalor 8
Nankervis 5
Mansell 3
Ralphsmith. 1-
-
Armstrong through.
Broad 6
Fawcett 9
Hayes-Brown 2
Lalor 9 +
Nankervis 5
Mansell 3
Ralphsmith. 0 - ... and out.
-
Broad 6
Fawcett 10 + and through ;D
Hayes-Brown 2
Lalor 9
Nankervis 5
Mansell 2 -
-
Broad 6
Hayes-Brown 2
Lalor 10+
Nankervis 4-
Mansell 2
-
Onto Group C:
Brown 5
Campbell 5
Gray 5
Hopper 5
Miller 5
Ross 5
Smillie 5
Trezise 5
Vlastuin 5
-
Brown 5
Campbell 5
Gray 6 +
Hopper 5
Miller 5
Ross 5
Smillie 5
Trezise 4 - sorry Jimmy ;D
Vlastuin 5
-
Brown 6 +
Campbell 5
Gray 6
Hopper 5
Miller 5
Ross 5
Smillie 5
Trezise 3 -
Vlastuin 5
-
Brown 6
Campbell 5
Gray 6
Hopper 5
Miller 5
Ross 4 -
Smillie 5
Trezise 3
Vlastuin 6 +
-
Brown 6
Campbell 5
Gray 7 +
Hopper 5
Miller 5
Ross 4 -
Smillie 5
Trezise 2 -
Vlastuin 6
-
Brown 6
Campbell 5
Gray 7
Hopper 4 -
Miller 5
Ross 4
Smillie 5
Trezise 2
Vlastuin 7 +
-
Brown 7 +
Campbell 5
Gray 7
Hopper 4
Miller 5
Ross 4
Smillie 5
Trezise 1 -
Vlastuin 7
-
Brown 7
Campbell 5
Gray 8 +
Hopper 4
Miller 5
Ross 4
Smillie 5
Trezise 0 - sorry Jimmy, bye Jimmy
Vlastuin 7
-
Brown 7
Campbell 5
Gray 8
Hopper 4
Miller 5
Ross 3-
Smillie 5
Vlastuin 8+
-
Brown 7
Campbell 5
Gray 9 +
Hopper 4
Miller 4 -
Ross 3
Smillie 5
Vlastuin 8
-
Brown 7
Campbell 5
Gray 9
Hopper 3 -
Miller 4
Ross 3
Smillie 5
Vlastuin 9 +
-
Brown 7
Campbell 5
Gray 9
Hopper 3
Miller 4
Ross 2-
Smillie 5
Vlastuin 10 +
-
Brown 8 +
Campbell 5
Gray 9
Hopper 3
Miller 4
Ross 1 -
Smillie 5
-
Brown 8
Campbell 5
Gray 10 + and through ;D
Hopper 3
Miller 3 -
Ross 1
Smillie 5
-
Brown 8
Campbell 6+
Hopper 3
Miller 3
Ross 0-
Smillie 5
-
Brown 9 +
Campbell 6
Hopper 3
Miller 3
Smillie 4 -
-
Brown 10 + and through
Campbell 6
Hopper 3
Miller 3
Smillie 3 -
-
Onto Group D:
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 5
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 5
Prestia 5
Rioli 5
Ryan 5
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 5
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 6 +
Prestia 5
Rioli 5
Ryan 4 -
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 6 +
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 6
Prestia 5
Rioli 5
Ryan 3 -
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 6
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 6
Prestia 4 -
Rioli 6 +
Ryan 3
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 6
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 7 +
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Ryan 2 -
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 5
Hotton 7 +
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 7
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Ryan 1 -
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 6+
Hotton 7
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 7
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Ryan 0 -
Sims 5
Trainor 5
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 6
Hotton 7
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 8 +
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Ryan 0 -
Sims 5
Trainor 4 -
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 6
Hotton 8+
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 7-
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Sims 5
Trainor 4
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 6
Hotton 8
Lefau 5
McAuliffe 8 +
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Sims 5
Trainor 3 -
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7+
Hotton 8
Lefau 4-
McAuliffe 8
Prestia 4
Rioli 6
Sims 5
Trainor 3
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7
Hotton 8
Lefau 4
McAuliffe 9 +
Prestia 3 -
Rioli 6
Sims 5
Trainor 3
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7
Hotton 8
Lefau 4
McAuliffe 10 + and through ;D
Prestia 3 -
Rioli 6
Sims 5
Trainor 2 -
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7
Hotton 8
Lefau 4
Prestia 3
Rioli 7 +
Sims 5
Trainor 1 -
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7
Hotton 8
Lefau 4
Prestia 2 -
Rioli 8 +
Sims 5
Trainor 1
-
Banks 5
Gibcus 7
Hotton 8
Lefau 3-
Prestia 2
Rioli 9+
Sims 5
Trainor 1
-
Banks 4 -
Gibcus 7
Hotton 9 +
Lefau 3
Prestia 2
Rioli 9
Sims 5
Trainor 1
-
Banks 4
Gibcus 7
Hotton 9
Lefau 2-
Prestia 2
Rioli 10+ go jnr
Sims 5
Trainor 1
-
Banks 4
Gibcus 7
Hotton 10 + and thro7gh you go young man ;D
Lefau 2
Prestia 2
Sims 5
Trainor 0 - bye, bye ;D
-
Group stages all done.
Onto the Final 12:
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 5
Fawcett 5
Gray 5
Hotton 5
Lalor 5
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 5
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 5
Fawcett 5
Gray 4 -
Hotton 6 +
Lalor 5
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 5
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 5
Fawcett 5
Gray 4
Hotton 6
Lalor 6+
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 4-
Rioli 5
Taranto 5
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 6 +
Fawcett 5
Gray 4
Hotton 6
Lalor 6
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 4
Rioli 5
Taranto 4 -
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 6
Fawcett 5
Gray 5 +
Hotton 6
Lalor 6
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 4
Rioli 5
Taranto 3 -
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 6
Fawcett 4 -
Gray 5
Hotton 7 +
Lalor 6
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 4
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 5
Faull 6
Fawcett 4
Gray 5
Hotton 7
Lalor 7+
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 3-
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 4 -
Faull 6
Fawcett 4
Gray 6 +
Hotton 7
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 3
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 4
Faull 6
Fawcett 4
Gray 6
Hotton 8+
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 2-
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 3 -
Faull 6
Fawcett 4
Gray 7 +
Hotton 8
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 2
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
Vlastuin 5
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 3
Faull 6
Fawcett 4
Gray 7
Hotton 9+
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 1-
Rioli 5
Taranto 3
C'mon WP, finish him!
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 3
Faull 7 +
Fawcett 4
Gray 7
Hotton 9
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 1
Rioli 5
Taranto 2 -
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 2 -
Faull 7
Fawcett 4
Gray 8 +
Hotton 9
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 1
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 2
Faull 7
Fawcett 3-
Gray 8
Hotton 10+
Lalor 7
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 1
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 2
Faull 7
Fawcett 3
Gray 8
Lalor 8+
Lynch 5
McAuliffe 0-
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 10
****sabretooth..this is the final 0 drop out but everyone one keeps going. The last man standing is the winner
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 1 -
Faull 7
Fawcett 3
Gray 9 +
Lalor 8
Lynch 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 10
-
Armstrong 5
Brown 0 - bye, bye
Faull 7
Fawcett 3
Gray 10 +
Lalor 8
Lynch 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 10
-
Armstrong 6 +
Faull 7
Fawcett 3
Gray 10
Lalor 8
Lynch 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 1 -
Hotton 10
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 2 -
Gray 10
Lalor 8
Lynch 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 2 + Timmy's rebirth :rollin
Hotton 10
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 1 -
Gray 10
Lalor 8
Lynch 5
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 11 +
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 1 -
Gray 11 +
Lalor 8
Lynch 4 -
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 11
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 1
Gray 11
Lalor 9 +
Lynch -3
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 11
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 1
Gray 12 +
Lalor 9
Lynch 2 -
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 11
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Fawcett 0 -
Gray 12
Lalor 9
Lynch 2
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 12 +
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 13 +
Lalor 9
Lynch 1 -
Rioli 5
Taranto 2
Hotton 12
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 8 +
Gray 13
Lalor 9
Lynch 1
Rioli 5
Taranto 1 - (Walk that thar plank Timmy). :)
Hotton 12
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 8
Gray 13
Lalor 9
Lynch 1 - ... sorry Tiger Tom.
Rioli 5
Hotton 13 +
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 8
Gray 14 +
Lalor 9
Rioli 4 -
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7 -
Gray 14
Lalor 9
Rioli 4
Taranto. 2 + (correct me if I'm wrong, tim was lowered to "1" three posts ago not zero) #BringBackTheTim
Hotton 13
Please delete if your not happy with me Adding him back. :cheers
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7 -
Gray 14
Lalor 9
Rioli 4
Taranto. 2 + (correct me if I'm wrong, tim was lowered to "1" three posts ago not zero) #BringBackTheTim
Hotton 13
Please delete if your not happy with me Adding him back. :cheers
All good Wazza...you're spot on
-
Lol. Don't tell me that, I rarely get things right at home. I better not start a trend :banghead :rollin
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 13 -
Lalor 10 +
Rioli 4
Taranto 2
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 14 +
Lalor 10
Rioli 3 -
Taranto 2
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 13 -
Lalor 10
Rioli 3
Taranto 3 +
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 12 -
Lalor 11 +
Rioli 3
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 7
Gray 13 +
Lalor 11
Rioli 2 -
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 8 +
Gray 12 -
Lalor 11
Rioli 2
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 9 +
Gray 11 -
Lalor 11
Rioli 2
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 6
Faull 10 +
Gray 10 -
Lalor 11
Rioli 2
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 5 -
Faull 10
Gray 10
Lalor 12 +
Rioli 2
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 9 -
Gray 11 +
Lalor 12
Rioli 2
Taranto 3
Hotton 13
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 9
Gray 11
Lalor 12
Rioli 2
Taranto 2 -
Hotton 14 +
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8 -
Gray 12 +
Lalor 12
Rioli 2
Taranto 2
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 11 -
Lalor 12
Rioli 2
Taranto 3 +
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 12 +
Lalor 12
Rioli 1 -
Taranto 3
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 13 +
Lalor 12
Rioli 0 - sorry Jnr
Taranto 3
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 12 -
Lalor 12
Taranto 4 +
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 13 +
Lalor 12
Taranto 3 -
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7 -
Gray 14 +
Lalor 12
Taranto 3
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7 -
Gray 14
Lalor 13 +
Taranto 2 -
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7
Gray 13 -
Lalor 13
Taranto 3 + c'mon timmy
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7
Gray 12 -
Lalor 13
Taranto 3
Hotton 15 +
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7
Gray 13 +
Lalor 13
Taranto 3
Hotton 14 -
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 7
Gray 13
Lalor 14 +
Taranto 2 -
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8 +
Gray 13
Lalor 14
Taranto 1 -
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 5
Faull 8
Gray 14 +
Lalor 14
Taranto 0 - sorry Tim
Hotton 14
-
Armstrong 4 -
Faull 8
Gray 14
Lalor 14
Hotton 15 +
-
Armstrong 4
Faull 8
Gray 13 -
Lalor 14
Hotton 16 +
-
Armstrong 4
Faull 8
Gray 12 -
Lalor 15 +
Hotton 16
-
What the heck is wrong with Armstrong? lol
Aside from having a short neck, the guy was great in his debut season IMO.
Armstrong 5+
Faull 8
Gray 11- Talk about overrated, you'd think this guy was an AA KPD coming off the LTI
Lalor 15
Hotton 16
-
Armstrong 4 -
Faull 8
Gray 12 + ****
Lalor 15
Hotton 16
btw Gray was never on the LTI, and it's not best player but favourite player. Ripper bloke who went above and beyond with my disabled bro-in-law last year. ;)
-
Armstrong 4
Faull 7 -
Gray 13 +
Lalor 15
Hotton 16
-
Armstrong 3 -
Faull 7
Gray 13
Lalor 15
Hotton 17 +