One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on March 17, 2007, 04:56:10 PM
-
Update from WP at Casey Fields
RFC players playing with Coburg:
Riewoldt, Edwards, Meyer, Jackson, JON, Hyde, Hartigan, Hughes, White, Clingan.
Collins not playing.
The game just started (4.45pm).
-
QT
Coburg 3.2-20
Bendigo 1.1-7
-
Half-time
Coburg 3.2 3.3-21
Bendigo 1.1 8.7-55
RFC Goals: Meyer 1, Hyde 1
RFC Bests:
Meyer best for Coburg by a mile.
Hughes at CHB!
Connors but disposal letting him down
Hyde started well
Hartigan off injured in the 1st quarter
-
WP said Harts hurt his ankle.
Coburg has the breeze in the 3rd. 2 goals to us already.
-
WP said Harts hurt his ankle.
not to worry, harts is useless and wont be around next yr
many bag guys like moore, mguane and jackson......... not sure why cos they have much more to ofer than harts
-
Agree X about Moore and McGuane being in front of Harts as they have shown improvement over summer playing in the backline. Jacko IMO would be on par with Harts. Both struggling to find a definitive position where they can play and our younger guys are already way ahead of both.
-
true mt, but i reckon jacko is just ahead only because harts seems to be far more injury prone than jacko, but a fair call
-
3/4 Time
Coburg 6.5-41
Bendigo 10.9-69
-
imagine what certain ppl will say when the bombers twos beat the burgers
oh no, doom and gloom at punt rd ::)
-
The score could get ugly as Bendigo have the breeze in the last.
true mt, but i reckon jacko is just ahead only because harts seems to be far more injury prone than jacko, but a fair call
True Harts is more injury prone.
-
Final Score:
Coburg 10.7-67
Bendigo 17.10-112
-
WP will give a proper summary of goalkickers and best players later tonight.
In the second half JON, Hyde and Jacko got goals.
JON good off the half-back line.
Riewoldt played CHB and Hughes FB in the second half.
Connors got a fair bit of footy but his disposal let him down.
Edwards was on and off the bench.
Meyer excellent first half but went missing after half-time.
Hyde was so-so.
WP said there was an all-in-brawl just before the end of the game when Matty White shepharded a Bomber off the ball. In the ruckus Jason Cloke allegedly head-butted White.
-
WP also said Collins didn't play but doesn't know why.
The score wasn't a true reflection of the contest. The difference was one bad quarter (second) when Bendigo kicked 7 goals to just 1 point. Bendigo's bigger bodies which were too strong for the young Coburg side. Bendigo had mostly senior VFL players although Nash and Neagle did play for them.
Coburg 3.2 3.3 6.5 10.7-67
Bendigo 1.1 8.7 10.9 17.10-112
-
Thanks WP for the updates :cheers :thumbsup :clapping :bow
I know it's part of their footy education but doesn't Coburg have any other talls that we have to play both Riewoldt and Hughes in defence? ???
In the ruckus Jason Cloke allegedly head-butted White.
What a dill :rollin
-
Coburg -v- Bendigo:
Goalkickers: Joe Gazzo 3, Edwards, Meyer, Jackson, Oakley-Nicholls, Hyde, White and Sewell all 1 each
Best: RFC Boys: Oakley-Nicholls, Connors, Meyer (1st half), White, Clingan Coburg Boys: Gazzo, Anderson, Carnell, Tom Simpson.
Summary:
As I told MT and he has posted:
Meyer: was on fire in the 1st half. All aspects of his game was very good - especially the defensive stuff. Took a beautiful mark in the 2nd and hit the ground running - looked sensational unfortunate the kick was a little off and missed its target. Later in the 2nd took an absolute "speccy". His 2nd half was a bit disappointing - not much impact at all
Reiwoldt: not a good day. Struggled up forward partly becaus ehe always seemed to have 2 defenders on him. Having said that he seemed to lead wide at times and 1 defender was usually filling the hole. Spent the past qtr at CHB I think to improve his defensive game - which is a good idea IMO - at times he didn't work hard enough to keep the ball in the Burger Fwd50.
Edwards: looks very classy when he gets it but not much impact. On and off the bench a fair bit
Jackson: what to do, where to play him these are the questions - hardly noticed him
JON: very pleasing display. Played off the HBF and got better as the game went on. Backed himself a number of times and gave excellent drive through the mid-field. Disposal was very good. His goal in the 3rd was a gem
Hyde: started so well but as the game wore on he flashed in and flashed out. No great impact that you would think a player of his standard would have (think of Paddy Bowden & Tambling last week looking a grade above and you'll get my drift - I hope :P)
Hartigan: went off 10 minutes into the first. Started the game with his knee strapped and I overheard ;D that was the reason he came off - knock to the knee - nothing serious didn't want to take any chances :thumbsup
Hughes: sporting the shorn look - Cleve had a difficult day against young Jay Neagle (talk about looking like your old man :o) - looked better down back as the game went on.
White: despite the howls from the crowd (well the folks in front of me) who were calling for him to be reported for charging in the last minute of the game (more on that shortly) Matty had an OK game. Did alot of run and carry.
Connors: another of the shorn brigade. Would have been BOG if it wasn't for his disposal which at times let him down badly. Tough and great attack on the ball - needs to improve the kicking
Clingan: I was impressed - didn't really notice him the previous week but this week I did and thought he did some nice things - disposal good! Needs to bulk up though
The last minute: now as I said the folks in front of me reckon Matt White should have been reported for charging. Now as far as I know a "hip 'n' shoulder" is not a charge but these days who knows ::) But Matt's bump was probably a fraction (and its debatable) more than 5 metres from the ball but none the less a mellee that took place after wards - you know pushing and shoving but Jason Cloke :wallywink what can I say - it happened in front of me and well let's just say I'd be surprised if he aint in some trouble - and right in front of the camera too double :wallywink think Phil Carmen way back when and you'll get the drift (all alledgedly of course ;D)
-
An umpire??
-
An umpire??
Yes an umpire and forward head movement ;D (all alegedly of course - although I know 4 people willing to give evidence and I am not one of them ;) ;D)
-
An umpire??
Yes an umpire and forward head movement ;D (all alegedly of course - although I know 4 people willing to give evidence and I am not one of them ;) ;D)
:wallywink :rollin :wallywink
-
An umpire??
Yes an umpire and forward head movement ;D (all alegedly of course - although I know 4 people willing to give evidence and I am not one of them ;) ;D)
No guys.
White reported after the game for charging a Bendigo player but from all reports it was a hip and shoulder after the umpire called play on to a JON free.
Jason Cloke reported for head-butting White in the melee that followed. White has black nose and cheek probably scans today.
But I wasn't there, just got the info from one of the players.
-
Thanks for the report, WP.
-
Thanks for the report, WP.
Ditto. :)
So, a head-butt from a butt-head?
-
An umpire??
Yes an umpire and forward head movement ;D (all alegedly of course - although I know 4 people willing to give evidence and I am not one of them ;) ;D)
No guys.
White reported after the game for charging a Bendigo player but from all reports it was a hip and shoulder after the umpire called play on to a JON free.
Jason Cloke reported for head-butting White in the melee that followed. White has black nose and cheek probably scans today.
But I wasn't there, just got the info from one of the players.
ST - my reference to an umpire was in connection to Phil Carmen all them years ago head butting - apologies to anyone who thought I meant Cloke head-butted an unmpire my bad cryptic clues.
Good to see Cloke get reported it was pathetic and unneccessary there was only pushing and shoving up until that point ::)
The White Report: JON had the kick moved off the line and the umpire played on, Matty White then hit the bloke who was on the mark with a hip 'n' shoulder (like I said last night) seemed to be within 5 metres but I didn't have my tape measure with me so cannot guarantee that, may have been fractionally off outside 5 mtrs but it certainly wasn't a charge - no head high contact.
Cloke's action was stupid plain and simple
So, a head-butt from a butt-head?
:thatsgold
yep ;D
-
Good report WP. I knew what you meant but wanted to clarify it for everyone else.
Collo believes White will get off.
-
Is White okay?
He better not have a depressed/fractured cheekbone or anything because of that hack >:(.
-
Any latest news of Matty White's cheekbone?
-
Any latest news of Matty White's cheekbone?
Bruising only it seems.
CLOKE isn't strong enough to bust our new White Tiger.
I wonder if CLOKE busted his own forehead. :lol
Apparently the video shows JON in close proximity to White when the shepherd was made and no head contact.
Tribunal is tommorrow night apparently so lets keep our fingers crossed for young Whitey getting off and CLOKE getting a few weeks.
-
Any latest news of Matty White's cheekbone?
Bruising only it seems.
Cheers for the good news ST :thumbsup
-
White cleared.
Cloke still in there and probably will get at least 2 weeks.
-
Thanks for that ST. Great news about Matty.
-
Jason Cloke copped 6 weeks from the VFL tribunal last night :wallywink :rollin
-
Jason Cloke copped 6 weeks from the VFL tribunal last night :wallywink :rollin
:rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :cheers :cheers :clapping :whistle :whistle
-
Jason Cloke copped 6 weeks from the VFL tribunal last night :wallywink :rollin
Excellent! :clapping :cheers :cheers :cheers
Just goes to show God does have a sense of humour :lol
-
Hate to rain on everyone's parade but...
Jason Cloke received a 2 match suspension
SEN last night got it very wrong indeed
-
Hate to rain on everyone's parade but...
Jason Cloke received a 2 match suspension
SEN last night got it very wrong indeed
Aww damn... oh well, still better than nothing ;)
-
Hate to rain on everyone's parade but...
Jason Cloke received a 2 match suspension
SEN last night got it very wrong indeed
Sorry guys :-[, WP is correct.
http://vfl.footballvic.com.au/default.aspx?s=genericnewsdisplay&kw=54&aid=115483