One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 19, 2007, 05:13:44 PM
-
In: McGuane, Riewoldt, Hughes, Graham
Out: Hartigan
-
The selected squad for Round 16 is:
B: J. Bowden W. Thursfield J. King
HB: A. Raines G. Polak C. Newman
C: G. Tivendale S. Tuck S. Edwards
HF: K. Pettifer M. Richardson C. Hyde
F: N. Brown J. Schulz D. Jackson
R: A. Pattison K. Johnson N. Foley
Int (from) : T. Simmonds, C. Hughes, L.McGuane, A. Graham, J. Riewoldt, R. Tambling, C. Howat
-
Port Adelaide's 25-man squad:
B: Jacob Surjan, Alipate Carlile, Michael Wilson
HB: Peter Burgoyne, Toby Thurstans, Domenic Cassisi
C: Nathan Lonie, Shaun Burgoyne, Kane Cornes
HF: David Rodan, Warren Tredrea, Brett Ebert
F: Brendon Lade, Justin Westhoff, Daniel Motlop
R: Dean Brogan, Chad Cornes, Danyle Pearce
Int (from): Greg Bentley, Travis Boak, Troy Chaplin, Robbie Gray, Nathan Krakouer, Michael Pettigrew, Adam Thomson
IN: Chaplin, Gray, Krakouer
-
pretty tough hand dealt to Harts.
Riewoldt needs to be in the senior side for the rest of the season IMO
-
pretty tough hand dealt to Harts.
Riewoldt needs to be in the senior side for the rest of the season IMO
Agreed Bluey on both counts.
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
he should of at least been given 4-5 weeks to show his ware.
the delistment would be more educated rather than basing it on one peformance in an overall shoddy team effort
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
he should of at least been given 4-5 weeks to show his ware.
the delistment would be more educated rather than basing it on one peformance in an overall shoddy team effort
Alternatively the decision on him was probably already made and they played him to see if he could change their minds with a strong showing.
We've brought in 4 talls. Not all will play but Port have a tall forward line. It wouldn't surprise me if Jack and Luke come in and one of Tambo or Howat go out. If Tambo is dropped the media will make a big deal of it.
-
tambo probably does need a run with the burgers.
Seems like a confidence player and is running low on that.
playing in a winning coburg team might be what the doctor ordered
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
he should of at least been given 4-5 weeks to show his ware.
the delistment would be more educated rather than basing it on one peformance in an overall shoddy team effort
Alternatively the decision on him was probably already made and they played him to see if he could change their minds with a strong showing.
It is clearly not based on one performance - it is based on several years of training and matches.
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
he should of at least been given 4-5 weeks to show his ware.
the delistment would be more educated rather than basing it on one peformance in an overall shoddy team effort
Can tell you that Plough has it in for Hartigan.
One of his ""whipping boys""
-
Gee Terry, you really weilded the axe didnt you.
Just goes to prove he is the master of spin doctoring telling the media after the game last week he was going to weild the axe ::)Thats to keep face with the supporters and by the end of the week they will have forgotten.
I actually feel sorry for Haritgan, at least he has a dip. not like some
-
He's wielded the axe but it won't be seen until the end of the season.
There's a premiership for Coburg to win first and draft picks at stake.
-
Harts won't be at Punt Rd next year based on that. No Krak either against the side that is interested in him.
he should of at least been given 4-5 weeks to show his ware.
the delistment would be more educated rather than basing it on one peformance in an overall shoddy team effort
Disagree.
He was absolutely hopeless and needs to go back to the Burger's for it to give other blokes a go if he cant grab it.
If he is committed enough to dominate at Coburg he'll get another crack before the years out. Pretty fair I reckon. :thumbsup
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Once again X, this is a very ignorant comment.
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
-
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
Gee Jack - get real ;D it's a Sunday game and we've named an extended interchange bench (which all teams playing on Sudnay do) - you'll find a few more go out other than Hartigan
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
You are right Birdman - my mail out of Burger land was that Hartigan deserved his chance because he had done everything asked of him over 4-5 week period.
I didn't see last weeks RFC game because I was at Coburg enjoying the mud etc but I have to say I am surpsied he only got one week to show his wears
-
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
Gee Jack - get real ;D it's a Sunday game and we've named an extended interchange bench (which all teams playing on Sudnay do) - you'll find a few more go out other than Hartigan
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
You are right Birdman - my mail out of Burger land was that Hartigan deserved his chance because he had done everything asked of him over 4-5 week period.
I didn't see last weeks RFC game because I was at Coburg enjoying the mud etc but I have to say I am surpsied he only got one week to show his wears
WP, i already know the ins and outs
-
WP, i already know the ins and outs
Perhaps I do too Jack ;)
-
WP, i already know the ins and outs
Perhaps I do too Jack ;)
I dont.
-
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
Gee Jack - get real ;D it's a Sunday game and we've named an extended interchange bench (which all teams playing on Sudnay do) - you'll find a few more go out other than Hartigan
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
You are right Birdman - my mail out of Burger land was that Hartigan deserved his chance because he had done everything asked of him over 4-5 week period.
I didn't see last weeks RFC game because I was at Coburg enjoying the mud etc but I have to say I am surpsied he only got one week to show his wears
WP, i already know the ins and outs
Well cough up then Mr know it all, 1965 and X are right about you.
All talk. :shh
-
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
Gee Jack - get real ;D it's a Sunday game and we've named an extended interchange bench (which all teams playing on Sudnay do) - you'll find a few more go out other than Hartigan
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
You are right Birdman - my mail out of Burger land was that Hartigan deserved his chance because he had done everything asked of him over 4-5 week period.
I didn't see last weeks RFC game because I was at Coburg enjoying the mud etc but I have to say I am surpsied he only got one week to show his wears
WP, i already know the ins and outs
Well cough up then Mr know it all, 1965 and X are right about you.
All talk. :shh
Now there's an interesting comment.
Not too subtle though.
I thought you could do better than that.
-
I am waiting on a confimration email from my sauce Chutney :rollin
-
I think the Footy Show starting in a minute may be very good timing.
-
I think the Footy Show starting in a minute may be very good timing.
;D
No Chutney's email will be waiting for me at work tomorrow morning as always
-
No dramatic axes WP.
-
No dramatic axes WP.
Jack I think 2 more will go out
-
Correct!
-
why do you guys want changes, no changes for me, no changes = no wins = priority pick which will be vital for us coz we are a rabble.
-
I agree with Ramps we are a rabble at the moment and if we cannot come up with a committed wholehearted effort for the great man in the number 12 guernsey then there is absolutely no passion at the football club either. It will be an indictment on the great man as we are playing for very little in terms of status and end of season ladder position. Giving a good account of ourselves and possibly winning can only boost morale give us an injection of pride something we have been lacking all year.
DO IT FOR RICHO.
-
If I had to pick ins and out to go on tomorrow it'd be.
IN: Jack, McGuane/Graham
Out: Simmo(Something not right?), Howat/Bling
-
yeah i would think Riewoldt In for Hartigan ...
hopefully we do it for Richardson obviously ... deserves to be carried from the ground with "Tigerland" in the background !!! ... v Port 05 again !!! ...
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Once again X, this is a very ignorant comment.
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
birdbrain, dont call me ignorant. i have seen harts play for the burgers, he has not shown enough! plain and simple. if u base your standards on harts' peformances u have low standards.
moore has shown much more that hartigan, so has connors and meyer has done great jobs as a stopper! even KK has shown much more, and KK has been gr8 in his forward leadership
dont give me this ignorant bs when i know much more than you
hartigan will never make , pure and simple
now go and peck on soem sunflower seeds
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Have just got last mondays herald sun here and he states QUOTE. We need to wield the axe at selection this week.
Axed Hartigan ::)
jack on this u r 100% correct
it pees me right off that terry comes out and says he has had enough of the turnovers we create and wil weild teh axe, then he does not drop the clanger kings
u r correct, and it seems tambling will be used as the scapegoat. tamblings problem is that he is too good for our team , pure and simple. he has a poor game sure, but he isnt played in his rightful position and he is prob depressed cops he knows he is too good 4 us.
this is why i am convinced we are tanking
playing tuck all yr is a sign of this , he gets the ball 30 times and turns it over 20 times times.
tivendale plays 1 good quarter a game and then is a total f up
same as hyde and harts was so pathetic when he was obv told last chance.
why are all our clanger kings dropped................cos we are tanking.
but terry like all coaches cannot come out and admit that because that is an offence, it would be admitting to match fixing if u came out and said we are tanking.
dont u understand sir know it all jack
jack be nimble
jack be quick
jack burned off
his lil .......!
how about u just stop bagging terry and all around him. they obv have a plan which u r not privvy too!
-
A plan, like blind mice perhaps? becuase thats what its look like when rebounding out of D 50
-
A plan, like blind mice perhaps? becuase thats what its look like when rebounding out of D 50
but seriously jack, u r no longer in the loop so u dont really know what and why terry and the tigers are doing as they are doing
iirc, the bombers were nothing last yr compared to this yr
same as the hawks and the pies and cats
so next yr is a fresh start and u have no idea what terry has planned
oh yeah of course u do , u live and hide everywhere , my mistake ::)
u will tell me know that u are in all tiger team meetings and attend all closed sessions. :lol
-
xXx
If you want to find out anything about a football club, just ask the players, they cant help themselves.
keep in mind also that all have friends who play at other clubs.
The clubs try and protect the players by sending sms to there mobile phones ,details of venues for closed session , which are usually text late at night the night before.
-
xXx
If you want to find out anything about a football club, just ask the players, they cant help themselves.
keep in mind also that all have friends who play at other clubs.
The clubs try and protect the players by sending sms to there mobile phones ,details of venues for closed session , which are usually text late at night the night before.
Yawn
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Once again X, this is a very ignorant comment.
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
birdbrain, dont call me ignorant. i have seen harts play for the burgers, he has not shown enough! plain and simple. if u base your standards on harts' peformances u have low standards.
moore has shown much more that hartigan, so has connors and meyer has done great jobs as a stopper! even KK has shown much more, and KK has been gr8 in his forward leadership
dont give me this ignorant bs when i know much more than you
hartigan will never make , pure and simple
now go and peck on soem sunflower seeds
Once agan another attempt to show some football knowledge.
Stick to the round ball and telling us how many chicks you have shagged.
-
xXx
If you want to find out anything about a football club, just ask the players, they cant help themselves.
keep in mind also that all have friends who play at other clubs.
The clubs try and protect the players by sending sms to there mobile phones ,details of venues for closed session , which are usually text late at night the night before.
Yawn
Is that the most intelligent thing you can post 1965 ::)
You have no idea what happens at football clubs do you.
-
hartigan never deserved a game in the first place, and terry will weild the axe , when the time is right
Once again X, this is a very ignorant comment.
Have a look at the 3-4 weeks prior to Hartigan coming into the team and he was a very good contributor in each game.
Ask anyone who is at Coburg and they will tell you that his leadership and attitude has been second to none.
I agree that he had a shocker last week, but he deserved more than one week.
birdbrain, dont call me ignorant. i have seen harts play for the burgers, he has not shown enough! plain and simple. if u base your standards on harts' peformances u have low standards.
moore has shown much more that hartigan, so has connors and meyer has done great jobs as a stopper! even KK has shown much more, and KK has been gr8 in his forward leadership
dont give me this ignorant bs when i know much more than you
hartigan will never make , pure and simple
now go and peck on soem sunflower seeds
Once agan another attempt to show some football knowledge.
Stick to the round ball and telling us how many chicks you have shagged.
1 i dont play the round ball game!
2. the round ball game is called football/soccer
3 i sense racial overtones in ur post, lets get together and discuss this face to face and see who walks aways laughing!
4 about the ladies, my luck, just added another to my list yesterday, nice policewoman to brag about too! too bad some of us have the gr8 life!
5. back to the topic birdbrain, u r the ignorant one, and if you belive harts is good enough at this level it just shows u r the ignorant one!
-
Enough with the chest-beating and slanging matches! >:( :banghead