One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Ramps on July 23, 2007, 10:04:39 PM

Title: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Ramps on July 23, 2007, 10:04:39 PM
If Sydney or Collingwood offer up a decent pick would you trade him?

Yes or
No.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: mjs on July 23, 2007, 10:09:30 PM
yeah good idea - let's get rid of anybody who is actually any good - Brown and Richo for starters and get a couple of draft picks and we are sure to pick up a champion or two.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Passionfruit on July 23, 2007, 10:10:57 PM
Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Ramps on July 23, 2007, 10:12:18 PM
yeah good idea - let's get rid of anybody who is actually any good - Brown and Richo for starters and get a couple of draft picks and we are sure to pick up a champion or two.

Richmond is 5 to 7 years away from having a side. Brown isnt going to be there in 5 years thats the reality of it.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: bluey_21 on July 23, 2007, 10:24:59 PM
if it is for a high 1st rounder I would def give it some thought
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Passionfruit on July 23, 2007, 10:29:45 PM
Could wallace be included in the deal :lol
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: WilliamPowell on July 23, 2007, 10:41:42 PM
Nope
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: tigersalive on July 23, 2007, 10:43:31 PM
If Sydney or Collingwood offer up a decent pick would you trade him?

Yes or
No.

How high.

I'll say no for now.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Obelix on July 24, 2007, 10:02:05 AM
Top ten pick - Definitely!

10-20 - Maybe, but you might have to add a carrot or two.

Over 20...  Depends what we think'll be there come draft day.  Not sure.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: FooffooValve on July 24, 2007, 10:04:34 AM
Not in this draft.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Gordon Bennett on July 24, 2007, 10:08:56 AM
For pick one - maybe.

Otherwise, no chance.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Beren on July 24, 2007, 05:15:11 PM
No. We can't afford to lose an experienced senior player/mentor. They're very thin on the ground at Punt Road.
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: {X} on July 24, 2007, 06:33:41 PM
Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON

come on jack, give the kids a break and a chance to prove themselves

maybe we should have drafted champions like kepler bradley and johns. yeah , we stuff up always  ::)

tambling will make u eat sh it, and so will jon, who as u know had no preseason what so ever

teall ya what , lets trade jon and tambling for bradley and johns, wow that woudl be a gr8 win 4 us .....not!

for someone who allegedly knows so much u come up with so much tripe at times its not funny

btw, tambling will be a gun, and everyone in the afl would have selected him in the top 4

but typical you, u have to talk sh it

btw, i reckon monfries might be ok, but whats he done this yr, jack sh it!


but sheedy and the bombers always recruit better than us, campo.....mal ........and the re recruit duds they already shipped off,....heffernan

wow the bombers really know their stuff


ahhhhhh i get it, ur time with sheedy is teaching you how do deflect reality!

well done

ps, brittle boy davey wont go far, for someone with a mature body he is weaker than jon! never ever seen a player hurt and stay down like he does, every time he get hit hard he is off the ground and never returns,  brittle fella he is, even a lighter thinne rjon and tambling havve more stregnth than davey

everyone knows daveys body wont stand up in this game, too hard and strong 4 him, sure he will kick a flashy goal here and there, but then get knocked down, he will fall over and lay down for the rest of the game!  fancy recruiting a mature aged brittle boned peanut

talk about reputations being better than reality, wow mcphee is such a gun, been pathetic also

once hird lucas and lloyd are gone so are essendon


Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: bluey_21 on July 24, 2007, 06:49:34 PM
vintage X  :clapping

but very harsh on Alwyn Davey. Will be a gun, his injury was a stuff accident, nothing to do with his body size
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: {X} on July 24, 2007, 08:46:22 PM
vintage X  :clapping

but very harsh on Alwyn Davey. Will be a gun, his injury was a stuff accident, nothing to do with his body size

im nio just talking about the broken arm, but i have seen 4 games this yr , where after a tackle or heavy bump, he has been out 4 the count. and not seen again

lets look at it this way, a joel bowden tackle put him out of business. now joel is a pacifist, and has a soft spot for aboriginals too, but his tackle got him good.

its happened time and time again, he isnt made tough. talent yes, but made of butter

ps, many aboriginal ppl do have a weaker bone density that white man. its common medical fact due to lack of proper nutrition in their early days, and many do suffer from osteoperosis in older age cos of this and some get it at an early stage
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: Passionfruit on July 24, 2007, 09:18:19 PM
Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON

come on jack, give the kids a break and a chance to prove themselves

maybe we should have drafted champions like kepler bradley and johns. yeah , we stuff up always  ::)

tambling will make u eat sh it, and so will jon, who as u know had no preseason what so ever

teall ya what , lets trade jon and tambling for bradley and johns, wow that woudl be a gr8 win 4 us .....not!

for someone who allegedly knows so much u come up with so much tripe at times its not funny

btw, tambling will be a gun, and everyone in the afl would have selected him in the top 4

but typical you, u have to talk sh it

btw, i reckon monfries might be ok, but whats he done this yr, jack sh it!


but sheedy and the bombers always recruit better than us, campo.....mal ........and the re recruit duds they already shipped off,....heffernan

wow the bombers really know their stuff


ahhhhhh i get it, ur time with sheedy is teaching you how do deflect reality!

well done

ps, brittle boy davey wont go far, for someone with a mature body he is weaker than jon! never ever seen a player hurt and stay down like he does, every time he get hit hard he is off the ground and never returns,  brittle fella he is, even a lighter thinne rjon and tambling havve more stregnth than davey

everyone knows daveys body wont stand up in this game, too hard and strong 4 him, sure he will kick a flashy goal here and there, but then get knocked down, he will fall over and lay down for the rest of the game!  fancy recruiting a mature aged brittle boned peanut

talk about reputations being better than reality, wow mcphee is such a gun, been pathetic also

once hird lucas and lloyd are gone so are essendon








Why do your posts always lead back to Essendon ::)
All i said that we chose the wrong draft picks in Tambling and JON.
I would think that 95% of the footy community would agree on that
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: bluey_21 on July 24, 2007, 09:39:54 PM
Blingers and JON are only 3 and 2 years respectively into the AFL careers, way way way too early to be judging them
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: blx on July 25, 2007, 12:24:05 AM
All i said that we chose the wrong draft picks in Tambling and JON.
I would think that 95% of the footy community would agree on that

do you always throw away kids after 2-3 years cause they arent stars?
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: {X} on July 25, 2007, 08:14:08 AM
Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON

come on jack, give the kids a break and a chance to prove themselves

maybe we should have drafted champions like kepler bradley and johns. yeah , we stuff up always  ::)

tambling will make u eat sh it, and so will jon, who as u know had no preseason what so ever

teall ya what , lets trade jon and tambling for bradley and johns, wow that woudl be a gr8 win 4 us .....not!

for someone who allegedly knows so much u come up with so much tripe at times its not funny

btw, tambling will be a gun, and everyone in the afl would have selected him in the top 4

but typical you, u have to talk sh it

btw, i reckon monfries might be ok, but whats he done this yr, jack sh it!


but sheedy and the bombers always recruit better than us, campo.....mal ........and the re recruit duds they already shipped off,....heffernan

wow the bombers really know their stuff


ahhhhhh i get it, ur time with sheedy is teaching you how do deflect reality!

well done

ps, brittle boy davey wont go far, for someone with a mature body he is weaker than jon! never ever seen a player hurt and stay down like he does, every time he get hit hard he is off the ground and never returns,  brittle fella he is, even a lighter thinne rjon and tambling havve more stregnth than davey

everyone knows daveys body wont stand up in this game, too hard and strong 4 him, sure he will kick a flashy goal here and there, but then get knocked down, he will fall over and lay down for the rest of the game!  fancy recruiting a mature aged brittle boned peanut

talk about reputations being better than reality, wow mcphee is such a gun, been pathetic also

once hird lucas and lloyd are gone so are essendon








Why do your posts always lead back to Essendon ::)
All i said that we chose the wrong draft picks in Tambling and JON.
I would think that 95% of the footy community would agree on that

why do u always talk sh it! why do u always bag everything that is richmond
u always bag our recruiting and young kids when they are far better than many incuding the bombers
why always bag tambling , when 100% of the football community would have picked him in the top 4!
why bag jon, when u know he missed a whole preseason and you know he has alot to offer
then you come and and say 95% of teh footy community would agree, u r f fos! next yr, when these 2 are firing, these so called 95% will say, yeah we knew they were worth their pick.


no u know it all, everyone bagged the hawks for getting hodge and not judd! a few yrs ago, everyone was saying what a f up! lok now, everyone is saying hodge was well worthy of his pick and the hawks picked right

jack, take ur anger and vendetta against richmnong anmd their structure elsewhere or jamn so far up ur @rse so it cant get out and constipate u for a very long time.

how can u f say the tigers picked wrong after 2 yrs, wait 5 yrs you fool

michael long took forever to become a good player, did essendon f pick wrong when getting him on board! and this michael long and marice rioli both said tambling will be th ebest aboriginal player going around. now who do i believe you, the grumpy old man with a vendetta, or long and rioli, the 2 best indiginous players of all time

i know who i believe, jack, go on a holiday!
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: {X} on July 25, 2007, 08:17:03 AM
Blingers and JON are only 3 and 2 years respectively into the AFL careers, way way way too early to be judging them

Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON

come on jack, give the kids a break and a chance to prove themselves

maybe we should have drafted champions like kepler bradley and johns. yeah , we stuff up always  ::)

tambling will make u eat sh it, and so will jon, who as u know had no preseason what so ever

teall ya what , lets trade jon and tambling for bradley and johns, wow that woudl be a gr8 win 4 us .....not!

for someone who allegedly knows so much u come up with so much tripe at times its not funny

btw, tambling will be a gun, and everyone in the afl would have selected him in the top 4

but typical you, u have to talk sh it

btw, i reckon monfries might be ok, but whats he done this yr, jack sh it!


but sheedy and the bombers always recruit better than us, campo.....mal ........and the re recruit duds they already shipped off,....heffernan

wow the bombers really know their stuff


ahhhhhh i get it, ur time with sheedy is teaching you how do deflect reality!

well done

ps, brittle boy davey wont go far, for someone with a mature body he is weaker than jon! never ever seen a player hurt and stay down like he does, every time he get hit hard he is off the ground and never returns,  brittle fella he is, even a lighter thinne rjon and tambling havve more stregnth than davey

everyone knows daveys body wont stand up in this game, too hard and strong 4 him, sure he will kick a flashy goal here and there, but then get knocked down, he will fall over and lay down for the rest of the game!  fancy recruiting a mature aged brittle boned peanut

talk about reputations being better than reality, wow mcphee is such a gun, been pathetic also

once hird lucas and lloyd are gone so are essendon








Why do your posts always lead back to Essendon ::)
All i said that we chose the wrong draft picks in Tambling and JON.
I would think that 95% of the footy community would agree on that

these post are just proof that jack really does not know as much about football and developing players as he makes out he does just because he works in the industry

jack get over , ur bs is really getting on my nerves now.

wanna pick on players, pick on serial f ups like richo, joel, sugar and tiv. not kids still in their nappies
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: blaisee on July 25, 2007, 01:32:57 PM
Real problem is we usually pick the wrong players. eg Tambling ,JON

come on jack, give the kids a break and a chance to prove themselves

maybe we should have drafted champions like kepler bradley and johns. yeah , we stuff up always  ::)

tambling will make u eat sh it, and so will jon, who as u know had no preseason what so ever

teall ya what , lets trade jon and tambling for bradley and johns, wow that woudl be a gr8 win 4 us .....not!

for someone who allegedly knows so much u come up with so much tripe at times its not funny

btw, tambling will be a gun, and everyone in the afl would have selected him in the top 4

but typical you, u have to talk sh it

btw, i reckon monfries might be ok, but whats he done this yr, jack sh it!


but sheedy and the bombers always recruit better than us, campo.....mal ........and the re recruit duds they already shipped off,....heffernan

wow the bombers really know their stuff


ahhhhhh i get it, ur time with sheedy is teaching you how do deflect reality!

well done

ps, brittle boy davey wont go far, for someone with a mature body he is weaker than jon! never ever seen a player hurt and stay down like he does, every time he get hit hard he is off the ground and never returns,  brittle fella he is, even a lighter thinne rjon and tambling havve more stregnth than davey

everyone knows daveys body wont stand up in this game, too hard and strong 4 him, sure he will kick a flashy goal here and there, but then get knocked down, he will fall over and lay down for the rest of the game!  fancy recruiting a mature aged brittle boned peanut

talk about reputations being better than reality, wow mcphee is such a gun, been pathetic also

once hird lucas and lloyd are gone so are essendon








Why do your posts always lead back to Essendon ::)
All i said that we chose the wrong draft picks in Tambling and JON.
I would think that 95% of the footy community would agree on that

but jack, you ahve alos said that tambling will be better than deledio.

Which one is it?
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: torch on July 25, 2007, 02:35:59 PM
no ... wouldn't trade Nathan Brown is a "decent pick" ...

you know ... if Tambling and whoever else where picked up at another club would probably be different players ...

that is no proof ... but just seems Richmond has a bad culture ... which i think Terry is trying to change ...

to me that is this "direction" he is talking about !!!
Title: Re: Would you trade Nathan Brown for a decent pick
Post by: mightytiges on July 29, 2007, 11:04:11 PM
I would say we need to hold onto a class player like Browny to show the level of skill all our youngsters need to strive for.