One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on September 08, 2007, 04:17:35 AM
-
On the St Kilda forum Saintsational they are saying the Saints are interested in Pettifer.
On the Sydney forum R&W online some Swannie said Jolly would demand our best player Foley in return.
It's time again for the silly season :whistle
-
have heard this Petts rumour too.
P-train loves being at Richmond. He's made alot of close mates and is well respected within the senior group. You see it when they're out together too. He hangs with Richo and Browny alot.
I suppose out of all our positions on the field HFF is one position that we could afford to fill with someone else but Petts has improved every season. If he had his kicking boots on this year he'd of kicked a fair few more goals.
My only quibble if he was traded would be that we've put a hell of alot into him and have waited for him patiently to develop and now he's starting to finally show something what are we gonna do, trade him?
The answer to that is probobly that the time has come where we have enough potential replacements ready to fill the void and he has enough bargaining power now to get us another potential first round pick. Would mis his high marking talents though.
i hate his defensive talents or should i say lack of. His bobblehead running from behind reminds me of some of my hilarious primary school performances in the 100m, while coming last. But its all about participation right :D
If he was a better defensive player i'd keep him but alas he falls short.
So whats my verdict?
If we get a first round upgrade then i think its worth it. We basically replace a HFF with a KPP :thumbsup
-
It's amazing how this has gathered momentum since Billy rang Finey on SEN :rollin
-
If we get a first round upgrade then i think its worth it. We basically replace a HFF with a KPP :thumbsup
my only qualm is that if we do that we get rid of a HFF who we know can play at AFL level, for a kid KPP who may not even make the grade. Not putting down any of the young talls but that has to be taken into account
-
I am interested in Ryan O'Keefe from the Swans because I reckon he is an absolute gun player
We should start a rumour about the Tiges being interested him :thumbsup
-
Never trade for the sake of it.
Plenty of others to try and trade before Pettifer.
-
I am interested in Ryan O'Keefe from the Swans because I reckon he is an absolute gun player
We should start a rumour about the Tiges being interested him :thumbsup
why stop there WP, I hear Judd, Jono Brown and Pavlich are all keen on richmond :shh :lol
-
Pettifer would be one of the few players who would be worth something. Would not be opposed to this trade but would want something pretty good in return. This is the sort of trade that when played well can set a team up. It is exactly the sort of trade Richmond do not do and would probably stuff up if they did. If we could upgrade our 2nd pick sufficiently to allow us to pick up one of the more fancied Rucks / KPP's in this draft then might be worth it. St. Kilda's 1st pick for Pettifer and our second. Sounds a winner to me but doubt it would happen.
FWIW I quite like Petts and would feel sad to see him go.
-
St. Kilda's 1st pick for Pettifer and our second. Sounds a winner to me but doubt it would happen.
Sounds like us getting shafted to me. :D
We give up a 1st round pick who's playing well plus a 2nd round pick for a first round pick in return.
No thanks.
ps Heard a strong rumour that the pies will be comprehensively knocked out in week 1. Hard to believe something like that could happen but there you go.
-
St. Kilda's 1st pick for Pettifer and our second. Sounds a winner to me but doubt it would happen.
Sounds like us getting shafted to me. :D
We give up a 1st round pick who's playing well plus a 2nd round pick for a first round pick in return.
No thanks.
ps Heard a strong rumour that the pies will be comprehensively knocked out in week 1. Hard to believe something like that could happen but there you go.
Suppose I reckon you've got to give up something to get something. It's a case of looking at what you need and what you've got and not worrying about what other teams have or are likely to get and forgetting about getting screwed or not. It's not a competition (well it is but that's not what I mean :D ), what you're trying to do is build a good list and stuff what other teams are doing. You certainly wouldn't get St Kilda giving up their first round pick for Petts. If we really want an early KPP then we have to give something good for it. Connors could probably be played in his position. I suppose I was thinking an early KPP is more valuable to us than an early HFF. Ok Petts is proven where a draft pick is an uncertainty.
Actually I've just looked and I suppose St Kilda has pick 9 this year wish could be a little to late to make the deal worthwhile for us, so I would say pass. I thought they finished lower. I thought perhaps pick 5 or 6. Oh well.
As I said I like Petts, but he is a HFF without the magic that Browny gives us. Good for 40 - 50 goals a year so no biggy to keep him. I'm happy either way.
-
I hope we don't trade Petts as he's finally starting to payback the time we've spent on him to develop. We'd want a fair bit for him if we were to let him go. A HFF who has kicked almost 40 goals isn't someone you let go lightly. A early first round pick at least.
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
-
so whats the big rumour
-
Kingsley retired too soon :lol.
From the Saints forum:
I reckon Kent Kingsley is the type of player needed as a forward. Pettifer will cost too much and is probably holding out Kingsley at Richmond.
Kent Kingsley is a very good player. Has been unlucky not to get too many games with the bottom side this season. Maybe 2nd or 3rd pick or even just a straight swap with someone like Milne or Baker.
http://www.saintsational.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=453446#453446
-
Kingsley retired too soon :lol.
From the Saints forum:
I reckon Kent Kingsley is the type of player needed as a forward. Pettifer will cost too much and is probably holding out Kingsley at Richmond.
Kent Kingsley is a very good player. Has been unlucky not to get too many games with the bottom side this season. Maybe 2nd or 3rd pick or even just a straight swap with someone like Milne or Baker.
http://www.saintsational.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=453446#453446
:o :o Good Lord.
-
Kingsley retired too soon :lol.
From the Saints forum:
I reckon Kent Kingsley is the type of player needed as a forward. Pettifer will cost too much and is probably holding out Kingsley at Richmond.
Kent Kingsley is a very good player. Has been unlucky not to get too many games with the bottom side this season. Maybe 2nd or 3rd pick or even just a straight swap with someone like Milne or Baker.
http://www.saintsational.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=453446#453446
:o :o Good Lord.
:ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL :ROTFL
-
going by all that nonsense, theres no need for us to upgrade by swapping pets and a pick...just petts for there first pick is on the money ... actually maybe they can chuck in a 2nd rounder to lol.
-
going by all that nonsense, theres no need for us to upgrade by swapping pets and a pick...just petts for there first pick is on the money ... actually maybe they can chuck in a 2nd rounder to lol.
Now in all honesty, why would you want to trade Petts for an unknown quantity???
-
just an opinion that richmond needs to try and fill a bigger need, ie. a key position need.
-
We don't have the mid-late twentysomething KPPs to trade that Hawthorn and Collingwood did to score early picks in a direct swap. There's only Richo who's too old to trade and then a massive gap to Sarge who's 22. Other clubs won't give us a top 10 pick for Petts yet we get shafted if we let go of Petts as well as give up either pick 18 or 19.
-
On the news tonight it said the doggies had a secret meeting with Fevola's manager last night to try and lure him over but they baulked at his asking price and aren't willing to trade pick 5.
-
LMAO if they actually reported a "secret" meeting.
Gee that word is about as misused these days as "Diva" is on Australian Idol ;D
-
;D blx
Apparently the asking price for Fev is $700k per year :o
-
;D blx
Apparently the asking price for Fev is $700k per year :o
Kidding surely? :-\
Should be happy with base $400,000-450,000 with performance based to go higher.
But jeepers $700000 off the bat for a bloke who regularly gives up? :shh
On the other hand I love to see the doggies pay that amount. ;D
-
;D blx
Apparently the asking price for Fev is $700k per year :o
Kidding surely? :-\
Should be happy with base $400,000-450,000 with performance based to go higher.
But jeepers $700000 off the bat for a bloke who regularly gives up? :shh
On the other hand I love to see the doggies pay that amount. ;D
Agree tigersalive it's a ridiculous amount of dough but that's what the news reported. If you were the Blues you'd offload Fev. Imagine them having picks 1, 3 and 5. Kreuzer, Morton and one of Masten, Palmer, Ebert or McEvoy. Set their midfield up for the next 10 years next to Murphy and Gibbs.
Speaking of asking for $$$ the news also said Heath Scotland is asking for $400k in his new deal.
-
;D blx
Apparently the asking price for Fev is $700k per year :o
Kidding surely? :-\
Should be happy with base $400,000-450,000 with performance based to go higher.
But jeepers $700000 off the bat for a bloke who regularly gives up? :shh
On the other hand I love to see the doggies pay that amount. ;D
Agree tigersalive it's a ridiculous amount of dough but that's what the news reported. If you were the Blues you'd offload Fev. Imagine them having picks 1, 3 and 5. Kreuzer, Morton and one of Masten, Palmer, Ebert or McEvoy. Set their midfield up for the next 10 years next to Murphy and Gibbs.
Speaking of asking for $$$ the news also said Heath Scotland is asking for $400k in his new deal.
Living in la la Land those Blues! :lol
-
The latest silly rumour of the week is the Eagles can't afford to keep both Judd and Kerr under their salary cap and one has to go. We can only dream of one of them walking into Punt Rd via the PSD.
-
According the papers this morning, the Crows are after a tall forward as well as a small forward. Schulz?
Didak is the small forward they are after as it's rumoured he wants to return to SA. The Crows are willing to offer McGregor, Perrie and Meesen as trades. Craig said it was useless picking up youngsters and not be sure if they would be good enough for the AFL.
The Doggies are interested in McGregor and have offered Russell Robertson a 3-year deal to move.
Sydney are frontrunners for Cat Kane Tenace who is out of contract.
Darren Jolly has given his manager no indication he wants to leave the Swans. Michael Quinlan said yesterday the only club with which he was negotiating for Jolly was the Swans. Jolly's contract expires at the end of next month. The financial strains of raising a young family in Sydney are believed to be a concern for Jolly and, with at least six Melbourne clubs in the market for a ruckman, a return "home" has been mooted.
-
[ Craig said it was useless picking up youngsters and not be sure if they would be good enough for the AFL.
[/quote]That is why I think three or four picks at the most is enough from the PSD.
They are an unknown quantity at AFL level!
-
Sydney are frontrunners for Cat Kane Tenace who is out of contract.
Meh. Swannies are just going to keep trying to plug those holes arent they??
Living on a sinking ship.
-
A rumour doing the rounds on SEN is that Chris Judd's girlfriend Rebecca Twigley has enrolled at Melbourne Uni next year in a 4 yr course.
-
A rumour doing the rounds on SEN is that Chris Judd's girlfriend Rebecca Twigley has enrolled at Melbourne Uni next year in a 4 yr course.
My guess is that would be a full-fee paying course, where the entrance standards are lower.
-
A rumour doing the rounds on SEN is that Chris Judd's girlfriend Rebecca Twigley has enrolled at Melbourne Uni next year in a 4 yr course.
My guess is that would be a full-fee paying course, where the entrance standards are lower.
Are Carlton trying to cheat around the salary cap again. A $5 million uni course for 4 years.
-
Are Carlton trying to cheat around the salary cap again. A $5 million uni course for 4 years.
The full fee paying courses are quite extravagant for ordinary families, $30,000 a year on average; Ms Brownlow might have got into medicine though if the money is there, which costs a bit more...
-
Adelaide has pick 10 which may still be too late a pick to pick up say a Rance. To upgrade one of pick 18 or 19 we'll probably have to offer say Schulz + pick 19 for Meesen + pick 10 :-\ if we trade with the Crows.
Craig said it was useless picking up youngsters and not be sure if they would be good enough for the AFL.
That is why I think three or four picks at the most is enough from the PSD.
They are an unknown quantity at AFL level!
Did you mean the National draft Mopsy?
-
Are Carlton trying to cheat around the salary cap again. A $5 million uni course for 4 years.
The full fee paying courses are quite extravagant for ordinary families, $30,000 a year on average; Ms Brownlow might have got into medicine though if the money is there, which costs a bit more...
med is 26K a year :banghead
That means I need to get high 99 on my ENTER to get in without paying that sum up front :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
-
read somewhere that GM was/is in Perth a.t.m., perhaps tying up some loose ends. :shh
-
med is 26K a year :banghead
That means I need to get high 99 on my ENTER to get in without paying that sum up front :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
Unless you slip on a little red dress and start dating Judd. :lol
-
According to Huddo on SEN, Judd is more likely than not to come home.
The jungle drums are beating.
-
read somewhere that GM was/is in Perth a.t.m., perhaps tying up some loose ends. :shh
do tell lol ... or atleast pm us
-
med is 26K a year :banghead
That means I need to get high 99 on my ENTER to get in without paying that sum up front :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
Unless you slip on a little red dress and start dating Judd. :lol
i don't wanna be a doctor that badly :lol
-
read somewhere that GM was/is in Perth a.t.m., perhaps tying up some loose ends. :shh
do tell lol ... or atleast pm us
It's either ....
Mitch Morton
or Cale Morton
or Chris Judd
or another disgruntled Docker KPP who Freo has stuffed up conditioning-wise
-
According to Huddo on SEN, Judd is more likely than not to come home.
The jungle drums are beating.
They've got Judd heading off to Carlton.
-
According to Huddo on SEN, Judd is more likely than not to come home.
The jungle drums are beating.
They've got Judd heading off to Carlton.
Carlton might have what West Coast want, but does Judd want to play for the Blues??
-
Adelaide has pick 10 which may still be too late a pick to pick up say a Rance. To upgrade one of pick 18 or 19 we'll probably have to offer say Schulz + pick 19 for Meesen + pick 10 :-\ if we trade with the Crows.
Craig said it was useless picking up youngsters and not be sure if they would be good enough for the AFL.
That is why I think three or four picks at the most is enough from the PSD.
They are an unknown quantity at AFL level!
Did you mean the National draft Mopsy?
Yes I do depending upon the position you finish on the ladder.
Last year we finished ninth and took 3. This year with the xtra picks possibly four under the circumstances.
There is no value in judging young players ability without a fair trial at AFL level some take to come good as in the case of Pettifer,Jackson and now Moore showing promise.
We train the likes of Fiora & Rodan, get rid of them and then they come back to bite you on the bumm.
The 2005 draft picks are an example of why I agree with what Craig thinks in that regard
-
i reckon the blues 3rd pick is on the table....was looking at BF cant believe the wankers on that site (got red carded yeasterday) carlton supporters are barring up>
I hope he does go there with his op (it is op) :shh, Richard Pratt can had over the dollars for little return, it would serve the bastards right.
Mind you what is GM doing over in WA a.t.m. :lol
-
Did you mean the National draft Mopsy?
Yes I do depending upon the position you finish on the ladder.
Last year we finished ninth and took 3. This year with the xtra picks possibly four under the circumstances.
There is no value in judging young players ability without a fair trial at AFL level some take to come good as in the case of Pettifer,Jackson and now Moore showing promise.
We train the likes of Fiora & Rodan, get rid of them and then they come back to bite you on the bumm.
The 2005 draft picks are an example of why I agree with what Craig thinks in that regard
Last year we picked up 6 kids but yeah in 2005 we only took three kids. Four if you include Matty White in the PSD. IMO just using three picks in any draft is a poor strategy. You're then relying on all three kids making it which is unlikely and risky.
Fiora was no loss. We still have a abundance of flankers and we gained Simmo from the trade. Whereas the disappointing thing about Rodan is we didn't get anything in return for him because of his knee.
If we keep four picks inside the top 35 this year then IMO we'll use them all on kids. The priority is/was all important. It'll be the 5th pick where we have to decide whether to pick up another kid late in a shallow draft or take a Silvester.
-
Ken McGregor has told the Crows he wants to be traded.
Speaking of Fiora he's signed a new 2-year deal with the Saints.
-
I hope he does go there with his op (it is op) :shh, Richard Pratt can had over the dollars for little return, it would serve the bastards right.
Mind you what is GM doing over in WA a.t.m. :lol
OP can be overcome and managed, Judd needs to be rested. You could almost give him until January off ... and then manage him over the next 12 months.
-
I hope he does go there with his op (it is op) :shh, Richard Pratt can had over the dollars for little return, it would serve the bastards right.
Mind you what is GM doing over in WA a.t.m. :lol
OP can be overcome and managed, Judd needs to be rested. You could almost give him until January off ... and then manage him over the next 12 months.
true, it just annoys me that as a club we should be in the race here, but really at then end of the day i dont think we have a hope in hell.
mind you i believe we should stick to our plan.
-
Pratt and his cash are shaking the tree.....big time
The best thing about all this is that the tigers are going to be big benficiaries.
Stay tuned for some major fireworks from a few fronts :thumbsup :shh
-
Pratt and his cash are shaking the tree.....big time
The best thing about all this is that the tigers are going to be big benficiaries.
Stay tuned for some major fireworks from a few fronts :thumbsup :shh
Judd to the tiges :shh
-
Judd doesn't have OP according to Worsfold.
Pratt and his cash are shaking the tree.....big time
The best thing about all this is that the tigers are going to be big benficiaries.
Stay tuned for some major fireworks from a few fronts :thumbsup :shh
We could be seriously involved in something big come trade week or on the other hand we could be just bluffing and just trying to stuff up other clubs by pushing up the price and cost of these players as well as hoping someone slips through the net to the PSD for "free".
-
who else is out of contract and wants to play for the tigers.
perhaps someone south of perth, any ideas anyone.
who is out of contract or wants to come home.
-
who else is out of contract and wants to play for the tigers.
perhaps someone south of perth, any ideas anyone.
who is out of contract or wants to come home.
P.H. is out of contract
D.M. may want to come home.
-
mundy for mine.
-
Ryan Murphy anyone?
-
Ryan Murphy anyone?
Freo WAFL player on the fringes who is just a mark and kick forward for mine. Pass.
-
Judd doesn't have OP according to Worsfold.
Pratt and his cash are shaking the tree.....big time
The best thing about all this is that the tigers are going to be big benficiaries.
Stay tuned for some major fireworks from a few fronts :thumbsup :shh
We could be seriously involved in something big come trade week or on the other hand we could be just bluffing and just trying to stuff up other clubs by pushing up the price and cost of these players as well as hoping someone slips through the net to the PSD for "free".
Unfortunantely West Coast will not want to lose Judd for nothing hence Carlton will have the frontrunning position due to Sugar Daddy Pratt and his money.This will enable them to snare him. Our only real hope is W Coast not accepting any deals or trying to convince him to stay and I get the feeling that the Eagles do not want to lose an elite midfielder like Judd for nothing and go down the path Port did with Nick Stevens by playing hardball.
Time to be realistic about this and possibly move on to other available players that we may be able to receive through the PSD.
That is not to say that I personally do not want him at Punt Rd next year as like all RFC fans we do but alot of water has to pass under the bridge. :pray
-
Lets go outside the square here for a second.
If Judd wanted to come home and within reason money wasn't an object, would not he prefer the club he barracked for as a kid.
If we were smart we could get Melbourne and Judd together and if WCE play hardball to hard for the dees, Juddy could slip though to the PSD and we have a few more picks and a ready made player from them for our PSD pick.
Or we could reneg on the deal once he is though and take him for nothing :rollin
-
Lets go outside the square here for a second.
If Judd wanted to come home and within reason money wasn't an object, would not he prefer the club he barracked for as a kid.
If we were smart we could get Melbourne and Judd together and if WCE play hardball to hard for the dees, Juddy could slip though to the PSD and we have a few more picks and a ready made player from them for our PSD pick.
Or we could reneg on the deal once he is though and take him for nothing :rollin
CUB, how about Miller goes into the wrong room with 30 seconds to go to the trade deadline and Judd slips through to the PSD :lol.
-
Didn't Sheeds do that to a deal last season or the season before during trade week or something similar in that the time expired and the deal failed to materialise. :rollin :rollin
-
Didn't Sheeds do that to a deal last season or the season before during trade week or something similar in that the time expired and the deal failed to materialise. :rollin :rollin
Miller did it Sheeds in 2004. Agreed to trade Zantuck to the Bombers swapping picks 33 and 36 and then went into the wrong room by "mistake" :wallywink.
-
There's all this talk about Dick Pratt and his money which would guarantee Carlton gets Judd but how would that affect Carlton's salary cap?
-
Ryan Murphy anyone?
Freo WAFL player on the fringes who is just a mark and kick forward for mine. Pass.
Second that :thumbsup
Another Leigh Brown or McDougall
-
Coughlan + Krakouer trade for Judd ;D
-
There's all this talk about Dick Pratt and his money which would guarantee Carlton gets Judd but how would that affect Carlton's salary cap?
Good point - in theory it shouldn't make any difference. All clubs have salary caps and have to fit him in that. It's irrelevant how much money you have in the rest of the club.
That said, Carlton are known serial cheats. They might be able to offer opportunities outside football and after football -
-
There's all this talk about Dick Pratt and his money which would guarantee Carlton gets Judd but how would that affect Carlton's salary cap?
Good point - in theory it shouldn't make any difference. All clubs have salary caps and have to fit him in that. It's irrelevant how much money you have in the rest of the club.
That said, Carlton are known serial cheats. They might be able to offer opportunities outside football and after football -
Spot on. The Salary Cap are player payments. Property/Marketing opportunities etc will all be thrown at Judd and they're placed outside the cap.
Pratt will throw everything at him.
-
There's all this talk about Dick Pratt and his money which would guarantee Carlton gets Judd but how would that affect Carlton's salary cap?
Good point - in theory it shouldn't make any difference. All clubs have salary caps and have to fit him in that. It's irrelevant how much money you have in the rest of the club.
That said, Carlton are known serial cheats. They might be able to offer opportunities outside football and after football -
Spot on. The Salary Cap are player payments. Property/Marketing opportunities etc will all be thrown at Judd and they're placed outside the cap.
Pratt will throw everything at him.
I suppose we'll find out just exactly what sort of guy Judd is. He says money is not important, does he really want to play for the blues? Is he willing to sacrifice himself to ensure West Coast get something good?
-
mundy for mine.
really really like mundy. Can cover a KPP spot, good kicking skills and is a smart footballer, is he out of contract though
-
The latest rumour doing the traps in Dogs give up pick 5 for Fevola and the Blues then ontrade pick 5 with pick 3 (plus maybe a player) to the Eagles for Judd.
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
I heard some stuff tonight on what you and your mates are up to - YET AGAIN ::)
-
do tell, then we will both know ::)
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
I heard some stuff tonight on what you and your mates are up to - YET AGAIN ::)
Well, am still waiting ::)
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
I heard some stuff tonight on what you and your mates are up to - YET AGAIN ::)
Well, am still waiting ::)
Suffer!~
-
The latest rumour doing the traps in Dogs give up pick 5 for Fevola and the Blues then ontrade pick 5 with pick 3 (plus maybe a player) to the Eagles for Judd.
Now that's great - really ;D
Ratten's been coach for how many weeks :-\ and he said when he was appointed "Fev would not be traded while I'm coach" :wallywink Good one Brett ;D
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
I heard some stuff tonight on what you and your mates are up to - YET AGAIN ::)
Well, am still waiting ::)
Suffer!~
Because you heard ZIP!
-
Hey Bull, what about the other ""big"" rumour :shh ;)
I heard some stuff tonight on what you and your mates are up to - YET AGAIN ::)
Well, am still waiting ::)
Suffer!~
Because you heard ZIP!
You're exactly right, Jack, I heard nothing.
But I did read something ;)
-
is the sheedy announcement soon.
-
The latest rumour doing the traps in Dogs give up pick 5 for Fevola and the Blues then ontrade pick 5 with pick 3 (plus maybe a player) to the Eagles for Judd.
That sounds like a fair deal all round.
GO TIGES!!!
-
is the sheedy announcement soon.
yep
he has been retired
-
There's all this talk about Dick Pratt and his money which would guarantee Carlton gets Judd but how would that affect Carlton's salary cap?
Good point - in theory it shouldn't make any difference. All clubs have salary caps and have to fit him in that. It's irrelevant how much money you have in the rest of the club.
That said, Carlton are known serial cheats. They might be able to offer opportunities outside football and after football -
And still the AFL reward them with priority picks! Who's the biggest idiot? :banghead
-
For those who went to the B&F last night, was there any trade or PSD goss mentioned or overheard?
-
my rumour which i didnt hear at the b&f is that we are right into this trade period up to our eyeballs.
Judd
McLean
McGuire
How far under the salary cap are we. Can we get one Judd or McLean into the PSD.
McGuire from the saints for our second rounder.
I get the feeling we may trade 2.
all three players may cost less than 1.5 milion. Also been told Judd wont be screwing over his new club $750-800k is where it all fall in the end.
-
if we get Judd McLean and McGuire, i will have an orgasmic fit!
mclean alone would be a big win, add judd and mcguire and we are a top 4 side just like that!
-
mcclean -tigers. :whistle
-
Can someone please say if McLean is contracted or not??
I heard:
If we don't get Judd PSD, we'll get McLean
Maguire for pick 18
-
i believe we are right in the box seat to get 2 out of the 3 done. Doing 3 will be hard, but with luck ... anything could happen, its also possible that these rumours are all crap and we end up with zip. But these 3 players put Ploughs 2011 right on target.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
-
my rumour which i didnt hear at the b&f is that we are right into this trade period up to our eyeballs.
Judd
McLean
McGuire
How far under the salary cap are we. Can we get one Judd or McLean into the PSD.
McGuire from the saints for our second rounder.
I get the feeling we may trade 2.
all three players may cost less than 1.5 milion. Also been told Judd wont be screwing over his new club $750-800k is where it all fall in the end.
Maguire for pick 19 is probably a fair trade but I'd rather hope we could keep our early picks and do a 3-way trade like we did with Fiora and Simmo. Perhaps we could trade a player for another second rounder if we do have to give up pick 19.
Melbourne would want our pick 2 at least for McLean. I rate him but pick 2 should be off limits during trade week. We still need to bring through and develop our own players each year especially when you have top 2 pick. We shouldn't be coughing up too much otherwise we aren't improving our list. We really want trades involving the best players to fall over so we get a freebie in the PSD.
If we get say Maguire for pick 19 and McLean in the PSD then I would say the club has done well. That still leaves us well placed in the National draft to pick our some quality kids.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
I'd be happy to take him with pick 35, or PSD 1 if nothing better on offer. He'd be more than useful.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
I'd be happy to take him with pick 35, or PSD 1 if nothing better on offer. He'd be more than useful.
:o :o
He is worth a late first rounder. No doubt about it. Was extremly unlucky not to get in the AA team imo.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
I'd be happy to take him with pick 35, or PSD 1 if nothing better on offer. He'd be more than useful.
:o :o
He is worth a late first rounder. No doubt about it. Was extremly unlucky not to get in the AA team imo.
I'm not knocking him as a player tigersalive and yes his market value would be very high but you don't pay for a small defender even a very good one with a top 20 pick. Top 20 picks should be for quality onballers and KPPs.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
I'd be happy to take him with pick 35, or PSD 1 if nothing better on offer. He'd be more than useful.
:o :o
He is worth a late first rounder. No doubt about it. Was extremly unlucky not to get in the AA team imo.
I'm not knocking him as a player tigersalive and yes his market value would be very high but you don't pay for a small defender even a very good one with a top 20 pick. Top 20 picks should be for quality onballers and KPPs.
Fair call but I reckon GB's suggestion of 35 is far under market price for him. Would command our priority for sure.
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
Actually spent most of 2007 as a running midfielder and will finish top 5 in lions B&F.. Also kicked four goals in the midfield against Collingwood,
Safe to say that Jed has outgrown the back pocket
-
Brock McLean and Pick 4 -> Richmond
Pick 2, 35 -> Melbourne
Pick 2 and a player -> West Coast
Judd -> Melbourne
Melbourne can't come to terms...we already have McLean...Judd enters PSD
We end up with McLean, Judd and Pick 4, 18, 19 :lol :thumbsup
I can dream :rollin
-
News/rumour around today on SEN and on BF that Lion Jed Adcock wants to come home.
Not the type of player we need and you don't trade for BPs.
Actually spent most of 2007 as a running midfielder and will finish top 5 in lions B&F.. Also kicked four goals in the midfield against Collingwood,
Safe to say that Jed has outgrown the back pocket
You're right bateman. It was wrong calling him just a BP. I would call him more a running defender who can run forward. A bit like Gram from the Saints. In a couple of games each year hurts oppositions on the rebound and snags a few goals. It probably sounds as I don't think much of Adcock when I really do think he's a good footballer. Hey he should have got AA. If he was available in the PSD and there was no Judd then I would wrapt if we got him. That's not what I'm getting at. I just think those roles are more easily replacable than a ballwinning onballer or a KPP and so you don't give away top 20 picks in exchange for running outside players no matter how good they are. Just my opinion.
-
Ruckmen musical chairs in the papers today:
Ruckman Ben Hudson (28 y.o.) wants out of the Crows. The Bulldogs are willing to offer him a 3-year contract as a replacement for Luke Darcy. The Dogs are willing to offer picks and players (Jordan McMahon) if a trade also includes Ken McGregor who also wants out of Adelaide.
Hudson leaving has put pressure on Adelaide to keep young ruckman Meesen who was considered on his way to Carlton.
Another ruckman Lion Cameron Wood (20 y.o.) may also want out. Before Hudson's decision to quit, the Lions wanted Mitch Hahn plus a pick from the Dogs. Now Wood may return home to SA for the Crows first pick (pick 10). The Lions want a top 10 pick or a seasoned player plus a mid-20s pick for Wood.
-
OMG!!1!!
My friends mum is a cleaner at Punt Road and was dusting possum poo from Greg Millers desk and under a fairly large nugget, found this picture!!
(http://i148.photobucket.com/albums/s20/tiger_man_nemesis/brock.jpg)
-
is mclean even out of contract
-
is mclean even out of contract
I don't know. No-one seems to know.
On Demonland forum, someone said he is.
-
This on BF today.
Have heard a rumour through a friend of a Bulldogs player that Bobby Murphy has had a falling out with another player and is considering being traded to Richmond??
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375124
-
This on BF today.
Have heard a rumour through a friend of a Bulldogs player that Bobby Murphy has had a falling out with another player and is considering being traded to Richmond??
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375124
Murphy is best friends with Browny but it's hard to believe so many top players want out all at once and want to come to Richmond. Where's free agency when you need it ;D.
-
It's on and the season isn't even over yet - :rollin
-
What season lol
KB mentioned again the pick 2 for Fraser rumour :wallywink and the others on SEN said they heard that 3 days ago and Richmond wouldn't do it.
-
What season lol
KB mentioned again the pick 2 for Fraser rumour :wallywink and the others on SEN said they heard that 3 days ago and Richmond wouldn't do it.
if we end up with fraser punt road would be burnt down, with GM inside, i reckon the woods are peddling this.
-
What season lol
KB mentioned again the pick 2 for Fraser rumour :wallywink and the others on SEN said they heard that 3 days ago and Richmond wouldn't do it.
if we end up with fraser punt road would be burnt down, with GM inside, i reckon the woods are peddling this.
I'd vomit on the smoldering ruins
-
according to 10, st kilda are thinking of trading pick 9 for fev
-
according to 10, st kilda are thinking of trading pick 9 for fev
Because the Saints forward line is the problem and not their defence and second-tier midfielders ???.
That would enable the Blues to trade picks 3 and 9 (+ player) for Judd but it's rumoured that Judd wants to only go to Carlton if Fevola stays.
September-October = Meat market :juggle
-
What season lol
KB mentioned again the pick 2 for Fraser rumour :wallywink and the others on SEN said they heard that 3 days ago and Richmond wouldn't do it.
if we end up with fraser punt road would be burnt down, with GM inside, i reckon the woods are peddling this.
Save on the demolition costs for the new redevelopment lol.
-
Judd's manager Paul Connors is also Fev's manager. He says Fev won't be traded.
"I am happy to put on record right now that Brendan Fevola will be at Carlton next year, 100 per cent," Connors said. "He will not be entwined in any deal."
-
THE Sydney Swans have offered premiership ruckman Darren Jolly a lucrative four-year contract to stay at the club.
While a number of clubs, including the Western Bulldogs, Carlton, Richmond and St Kilda are in the market for ruckmen, Jolly, whose contract expires in October, has not negotiated with any of them.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22460315-5012432,00.html
-
Judd's manager Paul Connors is also Fev's manager. He says Fev won't be traded.
"I am happy to put on record right now that Brendan Fevola will be at Carlton next year, 100 per cent," Connors said. "He will not be entwined in any deal."
carlton have just lost one big bargaining chip
chances of judd coming to richmond are building :shh
-
I remember in a pre-draft interview with lids he said his fave player and one he aspired to was C Judd. Could you imagine
lids face if C Judd came to us :cheers
-
Judd's manager Paul Connors is also Fev's manager. He says Fev won't be traded.
"I am happy to put on record right now that Brendan Fevola will be at Carlton next year, 100 per cent," Connors said. "He will not be entwined in any deal."
carlton have just lost one big bargaining chip
chances of judd coming to richmond are building :shh
things are startimg to fall into place, big time :cheers
-
Mitch Morton has apparantly stated in WA that he wants to come to us. Good junior who hasnt shown alot yet. Id trade JON for him at this stage.
Anyway the list of potentials is increasing. Ive just done a quick scan of sites These players are linked with us lol.
Judd- West Coast
McLean- Melbourne
Maguire- St Kilda
Morton- West Coast
Wood- Brisbane
R.Murphy- Bulldogs
-
Mitch Morton has apparantly stated in WA that he wants to come to us. Good junior who hasnt shown alot yet. Id trade JON for him at this stage.
i'd do that
hopefully cotchin is still the one for us at 2 :pray
-
mitch and cale just might work 8)
-
mitch and cale just might work 8)
if I'm going to throw a high pick interstate it would only be for masten
-
mitch and cale just might work 8)
mmm :whistle
-
Is Mitch Morton out of contract? On the Eagles forum they aren't sure.
Those who think he is are saying Richmond will ask Cale Morton to nominate for the PSD and not the National draft and then we trade for Mitch Morton, still get Cotchin in the National draft plus Cale Morton in the PSD. Me thinks we can't do this and if we tried we'd be in trouble with the AFL.
Those who think Mitch Morton is out of contract believe we'll pick up Mitch in the PSD and then Cale with pick 2 in the National draft. Personally I'd be disappointed if we did this. Hardly us chasing a big name as alleged and in fact just a fringe player.
Apparently the rumoured reason for Mitch wanting out is because their rookie Jamie McNamara is getting a game ahead of him. Okay it's only innuendo at this stage that he wants out (started by 6PR and posted on BF) but do we want a fringe player with that kind of attitude :help.
http://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=10889
-
Is Mitch Morton out of contract? On the Eagles forum they aren't sure.
Those who think he is are saying Richmond will ask Cale Morton to nominate for the PSD and not the National draft and then we trade for Mitch Morton, still get Cotchin in the National draft plus Cale Morton in the PSD. Me thinks we can't do this and if we tried we'd be in trouble with the AFL.
Those who think Mitch Morton is out of contract believe we'll pick up Mitch in the PSD and then Cale with pick 2 in the National draft. Personally I'd be disappointed if we did this. Hardly us chasing a big name as alleged and in fact just a fringe player.
Apparently the rumoured reason for Mitch wanting out is because their rookie Jamie McNamara is getting a game ahead of him. Okay it's only innuendo at this stage that he wants out (started by 6PR and posted on BF) but do we want a fringe player with that kind of attitude :help.
http://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=10889
I may be wrong, but I think you can't nominate for the PSD without registering for the National Draft. If I'm wrong though, very clever of the Tigers :clapping
-
I may be wrong, but I think you can't nominate for the PSD without registering for the National Draft. If I'm wrong though, very clever of the Tigers :clapping
Fwoy,
my re-collection of these crazy rules is you are a player formerly contracted at a club in the season just finished (2007) you don't have to nominated for the Nat Draft you can just nominate for the PSD - reason being the blokes de-listed by clubs at the last minute
-
As far as i know mitch morton is contracted therefore a trade is required. Cale Morton has to go into a national draft first before being allowed into a PSD, he hasnt been in a national draft before - therefore it looks like if we are going to take his brother- then Cale will be our selection at 2.
-
As far as i know mitch morton is contracted therefore a trade is required. Cale Morton has to go into a national draft first before being allowed into a PSD, he hasnt been in a national draft before - therefore it looks like if we are going to take his brother- then Cale will be our selection at 2.
:help
Thanks fwoy, WP and Ramps. What's with Brad Hardie and 6PR making crap up about Richmond? They also came up with us trading pick 2 for Fraser ::).
-
Right now with all these rumours that have circulated about all clubs, i just hope our club is focused, that they have there strategies in place, there targets worked out and that they just stick to the plan. If the rest of the world wants to stuff around let them, lets just do what we have to do.
-
Schultz to Brisbane in exchange for there bootstudder ::)
-
Schultz to Brisbane in exchange for there bootstudder ::)
Is he any good lol ...
-
Schultz to Brisbane in exchange for there bootstudder ::)
Is he any good lol ...
Fair trade I reckon ;)
-
Maybe we should get their bootstudder and get him to work on Shultz, he may be able to stop him from falling over :shh
-
Schultz has never been and never will be any good.
Thats been Richmond problem for a long time,they fall in love with DUDS who they hope will be the future of the club, I think its call mediaocracy
-
Krak + Cogs for Judd
chuck useless JON in for a sweetner now thats a good deal
-
Krak + Cogs for Judd
chuck useless JON in for a sweetner now thats a good deal
We might need to throw in something else the Eagles would actually want lol.
-
We have very little of trade value.
Handfull at tops
-
sometimes you dont need good cards to win the poker game, this time we have pick 2 and the first pick in the psd thats not a bad hand at all - if they know how to play the game that is ... if not ... then theyll waste the cards they got and we'll get zippo.
-
From the Herald-Sun this morning
Mitch Morton, 20, is out of contract and considering a move to Richmond.
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,22468855%255E19742,00.html
Comments from the Eagles forum on Morton
We (Eagles) have told clubs that we want pick 2 to get Cotchin. The best thing about dealing Mitch Morton to Richmond is that locks them into picking Cale Morton with pick 2. That leaves us Cotchin at pick 3 so that should keep us happy.
After Morton's performance in the WAFL Grand Final - TRADE HIM - was pretty average today!
Asking for Coughlan + pick 35 together or pick 19 for Morton
http://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=10
-
they are delusional Mitch Morton has done nothing at best hes just a 3rd or 4th round trade.
-
Schultz to Brisbane in exchange for there bootstudder ::)
Is he any good lol ...
Fair trade I reckon ;)
I think Brisbane would also want a 4th rounder :lol
-
Can Cale Morton not nominate for anything, and we get him in the rookie draft and elevate him instantly?
-
Can Cale Morton not nominate for anything, and we get him in the rookie draft and elevate him instantly?
Nah he has to nominate for the National draft first.
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum//index.php?topic=5913.msg74903#msg74903
-
Here are a few 'possible' scenarios for next season:
Scenario #1 [My rating out of 10 - 6/10]
In:
McLean
Reid
N. Brown
Maguire
Out:
Pick 2 - for Reid and N. Brown
Pick 18 - for Maguire
Scenario #2 [6/10]
In:
Judd
M. Morton
C. Morton
Out:
Trade for Morton 3rd rounder?
Scenario #3 [3/10 - McLean gets 3 of the rating points]
In:
Fraser
Didak
Maguire
McLean
Out:
Pick 2 - for Fraser and Didak
Pick 18 - for Maguire
-
Krak + Cogs for Judd
chuck useless JON in for a sweetner now thats a good deal
We might need to throw in something else the Eagles would actually want lol.
Ohhhh okay tell them that we will take those trouble makers Kerr and Cousins off their hands but no more!!!! ......Maybe Priddis or Rosa but that is as far as we should be prepared to go on this one!!!!! :lol
-
Scenario #3 [3/10 - McLean gets 3 of the rating points]
In:
Fraser
Didak
Maguire
McLean
Out:
Pick 2 - for Fraser and Didak
Pick 18 - for Maguire
McLean would get more than 3 Fraser and Didak have a negative rating.
-
Here are a few 'possible' scenarios for next season:
Scenario #1 [My rating out of 10 - 6/10]
In:
McLean
Reid
N. Brown
Maguire
Out:
Pick 2 - for Reid and N. Brown
Pick 18 - for Maguire
Scenario #2 [6/10]
In:
Judd
M. Morton
C. Morton
Out:
Trade for Morton 3rd rounder?
Scenario #3 [3/10 - McLean gets 3 of the rating points]
In:
Fraser
Didak
Maguire
McLean
Out:
Pick 2 - for Fraser and Didak
Pick 18 - for Maguire
Scenario #1 would boost our young KPP stocks although I have question marks over the Pies' Brown's kicking though. The Eagles look to have got the better twin.
Scenario #2 is the cheapest option. Judd for "free", a cheap trade and we keep all our picks.
Scenario #3 would give us an instant boost of senior players but it's more a quick fix.
The Pick 2 for Reid and Brown has been doing the rounds but are you allowed to trade new draftees after just one year? Is it simply you can provided you get each kid's permission.
-
Another scenario from the Blues forum is they give us pick 3 for some token fringe player on the promise we let them take Judd in the PSD.
In: Pick 3, McLean, Maguire
Out: Pick 19, fringe Tiger
We'll then have picks 2, 3, 18, 35 + McLean and Maguire. We can dream :whistle.
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
I have him as our #1 PSD pick
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
I have him as our #1 PSD pick
Crikey thats a bit optimistic. I think we would have a better chance of getting the legendary Jim Boogie! I can't see the D's letting McLean go that easily. Would be nice though.
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
I have him as our #1 PSD pick
Crikey thats a bit optimistic. I think we would have a better chance of getting the legendary Jim Boogie! I can't see the D's letting McLean go that easily. Would be nice though.
Who does Jim Boogie play for now?
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
I have him as our #1 PSD pick
Crikey thats a bit optimistic. I think we would have a better chance of getting the legendary Jim Boogie! I can't see the D's letting McLean go that easily. Would be nice though.
Boogie Boogie Boogie .... selection 2 Richmond selects player 123792 Jim Boogie :clapping
-
Who does Jim Boogie play for now?
Anyone with a nose for players can find him.
Careful, he's got a reputation of snotting people. I wouldn't pick him (with anyone knowing).
-
Who does Jim Boogie play for now?
Anyone with a nose for players can find him.
Careful, he's got a reputation of snotting people. I wouldn't pick him (with anyone knowing).
:lol
-
I'm confused....In all these options I can't see how McLean gets to the Tigers?? ???
I have him as our #1 PSD pick
Crikey thats a bit optimistic. I think we would have a better chance of getting the legendary Jim Boogie! I can't see the D's letting McLean go that easily. Would be nice though.
Boogie Boogie Boogie .... selection 2 Richmond selects player 123792 Jim Boogie :clapping
That was funny as!! :rollin I still think there are people over at PRE pondering on another potential wasted talent. I heard he looked to Ben Cousins as his mentor which sent off the rails but he is clean now and looking forward to making a comeback via this years ND! Do you think they would fall for it again?? :rollin If so...state that after a growth spurt he is now a 98kg 204cm ruckman/key forward with all the makings of another Jeff White according to Wisbey! :rollin :rollin
-
pick 2 looks like cale morton more and more each day, with his brother almost a certain to be at tigerland with pick 35 or psd if no deal done during trade week.
-
Another scenario from the Blues forum is they give us pick 3 for some token fringe player on the promise we let them take Judd in the PSD.
In: Pick 3, McLean, Maguire
Out: Pick 19, fringe Tiger
We'll then have picks 2, 3, 18, 35 + McLean and Maguire. We can dream :whistle.
Carlton would be taking a huge risk with that scenario. West Coast would be doing everything to get another trade done. But it would screw Carlton and that wouldn't be all bad :lol
-
Another scenario from the Blues forum is they give us pick 3 for some token fringe player on the promise we let them take Judd in the PSD.
In: Pick 3, McLean, Maguire
Out: Pick 19, fringe Tiger
We'll then have picks 2, 3, 18, 35 + McLean and Maguire. We can dream :whistle.
Carlton would be taking a huge risk with that scenario. West Coast would be doing everything to get another trade done. But it would screw Carlton and that wouldn't be all bad :lol
its great to be optimistic, but lets just be a little bit realistic too
-
Another scenario from the Blues forum is they give us pick 3 for some token fringe player on the promise we let them take Judd in the PSD.
In: Pick 3, McLean, Maguire
Out: Pick 19, fringe Tiger
We'll then have picks 2, 3, 18, 35 + McLean and Maguire. We can dream :whistle.
Carlton would be taking a huge risk with that scenario. West Coast would be doing everything to get another trade done. But it would screw Carlton and that wouldn't be all bad :lol
its great to be optimistic, but lets just be a little bit realistic too
i didn't think MT was being optmistic :rollin
-
Another scenario from the Blues forum is they give us pick 3 for some token fringe player on the promise we let them take Judd in the PSD.
In: Pick 3, McLean, Maguire
Out: Pick 19, fringe Tiger
We'll then have picks 2, 3, 18, 35 + McLean and Maguire. We can dream :whistle.
Carlton would be taking a huge risk with that scenario. West Coast would be doing everything to get another trade done. But it would screw Carlton and that wouldn't be all bad :lol
We promise not to draft him in the PSD ;), then hand over picks 2 and 19 for Judd, Use pick 3 on Cale Morton or Cotchin, trade pick 18 for Goose Maguire, trade pick 35 for Mitch Morton and pick up McLean in the PSD :lol
-
petts is a shocker. the amount of time and money we have spent on that bloke and he constantly underperforms. he reminds of one of the one of the duo from dumb and dummer.
we have too many players like him who just underperform time and time again. They should take a leaf out of richo's book.
that bloke is one of very few that try their guts out for the yellow and black.
-
The Tigers are believed to be interested in West Coast's Mitch Morton, who happens to have a brother, Cale, rated in the top two or three prospective draftees.
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,22483280%255E19742,00.html
-
Brisbane could lose two players during next month's player-exchange period.
Several clubs have expressed keen interest in ruckman Cameron Wood and midfielder Justin Sherman.
Sherman has two years to run on his contract, but it is understood Essendon and the Kangaroos are leading the chase for him to move south.
The 20-year-old from Tasmania has played 55 games for the Lions since making his debut in 2005.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22482634-5012432,00.html
-
petts is a shocker. the amount of time and money we have spent on that bloke and he constantly underperforms. he reminds of one of the one of the duo from dumb and dummer.
we have too many players like him who just underperform time and time again. They should take a leaf out of richo's book.
that bloke is one of very few that try their guts out for the yellow and black.
Almost 40 goals for year isn't bad for a shocker. Petts is the least of our worries. Our forward can be potent if it's given enough supply. The problem this year our midfield didn't given them that supply. We had fewer inside 50s than the opposition nearly every week.
-
Brisbane could lose two players during next month's player-exchange period.
Several clubs have expressed keen interest in ruckman Cameron Wood and midfielder Justin Sherman.
Sherman has two years to run on his contract, but it is understood Essendon and the Kangaroos are leading the chase for him to move south.
The 20-year-old from Tasmania has played 55 games for the Lions since making his debut in 2005.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22482634-5012432,00.html
A mate of mine who follows the Lions says opposition clubs worked Sherman out and he ended up on the outer.
Wood would be a handy pick-up as we still need to find a ruckman somewhere but if we aren't trading picks 18 or 19 then we'd only be a show if he fell through to the PSD.
-
The latest rumour doing the rounds is Hille (contracted) wants to go to Collingwood. On both Bomber and Pie forums.
-
Meesen has told the Crows he wants out. Melbourne are interested in him.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/meesen-tells-crows-he-wants-out/2007/09/27/1190486480826.html
-
:gobdrop Adelaide's massive ruck stocks have taken a MASSIVE tumble. Didnt think meesen would leave after Hudson quit, but wudda-ya-know.
-
Fraser has re-signed with the Pies for 3 years.
-
Fraser has re-signed with the Pies for 3 years.
Thank god for that. Maybe a sign the Pies have heard of the Judd to Melbourne talk and have given up trading for Judd.
-
Fraser has re-signed with the Pies for 3 years.
thank god 4 that
-
Hudson, the Crows' lead ruckman this season, has confirmed he will join the Western Bulldogs on a three-year deal.
Meesen, the Crows' first-round draft pick in 2004, has told the Crows he wants to be traded to Melbourne, which has offered the 21-year-old a contract.
Adelaide football operations manager John Reid said the Crows would now negotiate trades for Meesen and Hudson with both the Western Bulldogs and Melbourne.
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,22501097%255E19742,00.html
-
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,22500896-21544,00.html
we are passing up meesen and hudson even if they enter the PSD.
which means one thing ... or should mean one thing
We already have a player lined up for the PSD ...
-
Eagles supporters are saying West Coast about to offer pick 4 and 13 to Richmond for pick 2. Richmond supporter posted back 4, 13 and M.Brown for 2 and Oakley Nicholls lol.
-
Who would we get at 13?? KPP?
-
after seeing the intencity of Geelong and to a lesser extent Port in the 1st Q ... that its fair to say we are so far of a grand final or winning one its not funny. And recruiting skinny blokes either isnt gonna help.
-
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,22500896-21544,00.html
we are passing up meesen and hudson even if they enter the PSD.
which means one thing ... or should mean one thing
We already have a player lined up for the PSD ...
Judd or McLean ;D
They've got it wrong in that article anyway. We have 1st pick in the PSD; not Carlton.
-
Eagles supporters are saying West Coast about to offer pick 4 and 13 to Richmond for pick 2. Richmond supporter posted back 4, 13 and M.Brown for 2 and Oakley Nicholls lol.
Given Miller rates the top 3 - Kreuzer, Cotchin and Cale Morton - ahead of the rest, so I can't see us trading outside the top 3. Pick 13 won't get us a Rance so pass.
Why do opposition fans think we need to be part of a trade that gifts Judd to a opposition club ::).
-
after seeing the intencity of Geelong and to a lesser extent Port in the 1st Q ... that its fair to say we are so far of a grand final or winning one its not funny. And recruiting skinny blokes either isnt gonna help.
Amen to that Ramps. Geelong's bigger bodies and strong tall spine have smashed Port.
-
Brent Prismall from Geelongs 2 would be worth a go at Punt Rd for mine. Not a bad size for a mid either.
-
if melb is the choice and the weagles get melbournes pick 4. I wouldn't mind getting in on the deal to give them pick 2.
Maybe:
Weagles give up. Pick 4 & 12 (is this their pick) or Schofield/M Brown
Weagles get pick 2 & a steaks knive player or 3rd rounder --> they take morton
We get pick 4 and a young KPP
-
after seeing the intencity of Geelong and to a lesser extent Port in the 1st Q ... that its fair to say we are so far of a grand final or winning one its not funny. And recruiting skinny blokes either isnt gonna help.
Amen to that Ramps. Geelong's bigger bodies and strong tall spine have smashed Port.
I now firmly believe that Ploughs philosophy of how to win grand finals wont work. The Dogs are no where near it, and we are bottom. If we recruit the same as last year and the previous 2 or 3 years then we will be looking for a new coach at the end of 2008.
-
after seeing the intencity of Geelong and to a lesser extent Port in the 1st Q ... that its fair to say we are so far of a grand final or winning one its not funny. And recruiting skinny blokes either isnt gonna help.
Amen to that Ramps. Geelong's bigger bodies and strong tall spine have smashed Port.
I now firmly believe that Ploughs philosophy of how to win grand finals wont work. The Dogs are no where near it, and we are bottom. If we recruit the same as last year and the previous 2 or 3 years then we will be looking for a new coach at the end of 2008.
Correct!
-
hey jacko do you know anything behind the scenes in terms of player trades?
-
Eagles supporters are saying West Coast about to offer pick 4 and 13 to Richmond for pick 2. Richmond supporter posted back 4, 13 and M.Brown for 2 and Oakley Nicholls lol.
Given Miller rates the top 3 - Kreuzer, Cotchin and Cale Morton - ahead of the rest, so I can't see us trading outside the top 3. Pick 13 won't get us a Rance so pass.
Why do opposition fans think we need to be part of a trade that gifts Judd to a opposition club ::).
Exactly Richmond do not need to get involved with the Judd deal
he will never come to Richmond
Whats to say he will ever recover from his injury a operation may backfire the first time
Richmond needs to breed & bond its own players make its own culture
They also need to be from Victoria so they dont get a feel to wanna leave
-
Eagles supporters are saying West Coast about to offer pick 4 and 13 to Richmond for pick 2. Richmond supporter posted back 4, 13 and M.Brown for 2 and Oakley Nicholls lol.
Given Miller rates the top 3 - Kreuzer, Cotchin and Cale Morton - ahead of the rest, so I can't see us trading outside the top 3. Pick 13 won't get us a Rance so pass.
Why do opposition fans think we need to be part of a trade that gifts Judd to a opposition club ::).
Exactly Richmond do not need to get involved with the Judd deal
he will never come to Richmond
Whats to say he will ever recover from his injury a operation may backfire the first time
Richmond needs to breed & bond its own players make its own culture
They also need to be from Victoria so they dont get a feel to wanna leave
how about we just try and draft and sign the best players!
-
This upcoming National draft won't affect any decision on Plough's future next year. First year players usually (exceptions Judd, Selwood) don't make any major impact on the team. It'll be more those in their 3rd-5th years that will decide Terry's fate and who we trade for and/or pick up in the PSD.
With such a shallow draft, how well we and other clubs do in the draft will be determined by the later picks. Who can find those hidden gems past picks 25-30 on top of taking the best kids early on with picks 2, 18 and 19. The main thing is we still need to do is bring through another crop of kids this year and every year. Picking up just 3 kids will be a poor result.
-
hey jacko do you know anything behind the scenes in terms of player trades?
No.
And I wouldnt think the tiges would be very active in trade week due to the fact they havent got much to trade anyway,or should I say, nothing that any other club would really require.
-
Meh, I think we'd be foolish to rule out being a part of any trades. We certainly don't need to be a part of trades, but we could benefit greatly from other clubs' desperation.
-
Other clubs would want our picks 2, 18 and 19 in a shallow draft. It's up to us not to be stupid enough to trade them away.
-
A trade doesn't make us stupid though, just look at the Polak deal. I am sure we'll be at least listening to offers. We have no obligation to trade, but if a deal too good to turn down came along, that's when we'd be stupid if we refused to even think about it. I have no problem with keeping pick 2, but if we got a good young player and a top 6 pick in return, well then maybe.
-
yeah just look at the polak deal
we draft him as a backman & he got a wrap for playing well this year
no wonder he had no opponant most of the time & being played out of position
If Richmond go anywhere near the involvement of the trading for Judd it just shows how effing dumb our culture is
Desperation of the other clubs is right jezza
the other clubs love us come trade time cause we the pooh team always down the botton with the things they want & we always give them away & we receive the duds so next year we dont climb the ladder we are always in trade week
-
Winner for most ridiculous rumour goes to Magpie fans:
My whisper is the Pies are after Polak. He is not happy there and wants out and Pies have already spoken to his manager.
http://www.magpies.net/nick/bb/viewtopic.php?t=39765
-
Winner for most ridiculous rumour goes to Magpie fans:
My whisper is the Pies are after Polak. He is not happy there and wants out and Pies have already spoken to his manager.
http://www.magpies.net/nick/bb/viewtopic.php?t=39765
bartel ling abd gablett are also unhappy and want to be traded to richmond and geelong are after tivendale krak and meyer
-
A trade doesn't make us stupid though, just look at the Polak deal. I am sure we'll be at least listening to offers. We have no obligation to trade, but if a deal too good to turn down came along, that's when we'd be stupid if we refused to even think about it. I have no problem with keeping pick 2, but if we got a good young player and a top 6 pick in return, well then maybe.
It wasn't a top 10 pick but Melbourne traded pick 12 for Moloney for us to get the Ottens trade done with Geelong. Moloney was a highly rated youngster at the time at Geelong but has fallen off the radar since 2004. Sure that pick (Meyer) hasn't come on either so far but who knows if a Reid, Brown or whoever will make it. The other reason why I called it stupid is we want there to be quality out of contract players after the trade deadline. Helping other clubs complete trades is against our interests with first pick in the PSD.
-
[/quote]
Correct!
[/quote]
well suprise suprise
-
hey jacko do you know anything behind the scenes in terms of player trades?
No.
And I wouldnt think the tiges would be very active in trade week due to the fact they havent got much to trade anyway,or should I say, nothing that any other club would really require.
you officially have NFI
the tigers are in it up to their eye balls at the moment Jack
-
hey jacko do you know anything behind the scenes in terms of player trades?
No.
And I wouldnt think the tiges would be very active in trade week due to the fact they havent got much to trade anyway,or should I say, nothing that any other club would really require.
you officially have NFI
the tigers are in it up to their eye balls at the moment Jack
I have alot of idea actually.
If you know, why dont you tell us ::)
Oh yeah, that right Jay Schultz for a first round pick ::) ::) ::)
-
hey jacko do you know anything behind the scenes in terms of player trades?
you officially have NFI
I have alot of idea actually.
If you know, why dont you tell us ::)
Oh yeah, that right Jay Schultz for a first round pick ::) ::) ::)
hahahaha
how true u r
schultz is the biggest joke going around.
i seriously believe he is best off playing down at frankston seconds the dud that he is
-
Schultz is the biggest pretender to put on a yellow and black jumper for a long long time
-
Schultz is the biggest pretender to put on a yellow and black jumper for a long long time
pretender is too nice a word to use on this dud.
i watch him every week and i just wish i could jump the fence like the old vfl park days, so i could go up to him and say dont bother pal u r a dud and will always be one just like lance whitnall, in fact id say schultz is worse
-
Russell Robertson is staying with the Dees. Announced by Dean Bailey at the Dees B&F tonight according to SEN.
-
With Robertson staying with the Dees, the Doggies have switched their attention to Port forward Damon White.
Geelong fringe player Tim Callan is seemingly off to the Bulldogs.
Steven King is out of contract. He doesn't want to leave but the Herald-Sun says he may change clubs if offered a 2-year contract.
Melbourne will offer the Crows their 3rd round pick (#37) for Meesen during trade week or grab him in the PSD at pick 3.
-
Schultz is the biggest pretender to put on a yellow and black jumper for a long long time
question fr you jack
Who is a better footballer
Shultz, Kepler Bradley, or Courtney Johns
-
With Robertson staying with the Dees, the Doggies have switched their attention to Port forward Damon White.
Geelong fringe player Tim Callan is seemingly off to the Bulldogs.
Steven King is out of contract. He doesn't want to leave but the Herald-Sun says he may change clubs if offered a 2-year contract.
Melbourne will offer the Crows their 3rd round pick (#37) for Meesen during trade week or grab him in the PSD at pick 3.
Because they need another small onballer. :shh *confused*
-
I reckon Brent Prismall is the one to get from Geelongs seconds.
-
I reckon Brent Prismall is the one to get from Geelongs seconds.
and davenport and that scarlett lookalike thompson i think is his name
-
i watch him every week and i just wish i could jump the fence like the old vfl park days, so i could go up to him and say dont bother pal u r a dud and will always be one ......
Yeah, it's a shame the rules of going on the ground were changed and heroic acts like that are hard to perform.
-
Schultz is the biggest pretender to put on a yellow and black jumper for a long long time
question fr you jack
Who is a better footballer
Shultz, Kepler Bradley, or Courtney Johns
None should be on an AFL List
-
Schultz is the biggest pretender to put on a yellow and black jumper for a long long time
question fr you jack
Who is a better footballer
Shultz, Kepler Bradley, or Courtney Johns
None should be on an AFL List
There was a rumour going around today that the Dogs might be interested in Johns :o.
-
Dogs are making critical errors.
Thought their team from 2006 would ascend into a legitimate top 4 team with the acquisition of Aka and McDougall now they want to go down the trade road again with maybes or maybe nots and they still will be short on KPP's.
Let them suffer.
-
What about Jay Schulz for Ryan Murphy?
Similar players. Similar age. Both look like they need a change of scene...
-
Dogs interested so far in Robertson, Johns, Murphy etc. They seem susceptible to a dodgy trade...Schulz and 18 for pick 5.
-
Dogs interested so far in Robertson, Johns, Murphy etc. They seem susceptible to a dodgy trade...Schulz and 18 for pick 5.
I'd doubt they do that sort of trade Ramps - Doogies would want a McGuane I reckon
And at this time I wouldn't be trading McGuane
-
Mail is straight swap, Schultz to Collingwood in return , Straunnie :thumbsup
-
Mail is straight swap, Schultz to Collingwood in return , Straunnie :thumbsup
jack
how are things?
have you still got a job?
;)
-
Mail is straight swap, Schultz to Collingwood in return , Straunnie :thumbsup
jack
how are things?
have you still got a job?
;)
Punt Road next year :thumbsup
-
What about Jay Schulz for Ryan Murphy?
Similar players. Similar age. Both look like they need a change of scene...
I suggested Murphy a couple of weeks ago MM but was shot down.
I think as a straight swap with Schulz he'd certainly be worth a punt.
-
Our club needs to stay focused on getting the best result ... we cant afford stuff ups.
We must get a big name player in the PSD and we must take the best players we can in the national draft.
Richmond supporters are expecting that to be the result if it isnt then the club will be in turmoil coz the supporters wont accept that other clubs can get big names and all we get is jack.
-
as l said before we need to draft bulky kids & breed our own players into big names work them hard
l bet Judd is not as good at his new team as he was when at West Coast because he wont have the same players around him like kerr, braun, embley, fletcher, cousins, & also the most important Ruckmen in Cox & co who are also doing the heavy work his confidence will start to strain as will his ass
he will quickly find being in a team of duds compared to a lot of iced up champions ;D its going to be a long road to the end of his career
-
Dumbest rumour #2 goes to 6PR. Apparently they said Tambling wants to return home to WA in a straight swap for Mitch Morton :rollin.
-
What about Jay Schulz for Ryan Murphy?
Similar players. Similar age. Both look like they need a change of scene...
I suggested Murphy a couple of weeks ago MM but was shot down.
I think as a straight swap with Schulz he'd certainly be worth a punt.
:thumbsup
Murphylooked like he could have been anything in 06 before Tarrant's arrival.
Definitely worth inquiring about.
-
Dumbest rumour #2 goes to 6PR. Apparently they said Tambling wants to return home to WA in a straight swap for Mitch Morton :rollin.
Do WA reckon they own NT? ??? :D Probably do think that.
-
Crow Ken McGregor, 26, re-signed for 2 years with Adelaide rather than consider options at Fremantle, Richmond and the Western Bulldogs.
Port Adelaide forward Damon White, under contract at Alberton next season, says he wants to be considered for a trade but Port say he is a required player, and he will play for Port Adelaide next year unless there is a suitable trade in the mix."
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,22522302%255E19742,00.html
-
Dumbest rumour #2 goes to 6PR. Apparently they said Tambling wants to return home to WA in a straight swap for Mitch Morton :rollin.
Do WA reckon they own NT? ??? :D Probably do think that.
LOL
-
Mail is straight swap, Schultz to Collingwood in return , Straunnie :thumbsup
jack
how are things?
have you still got a job?
;)
Punt Road next year :thumbsup
back pocket?
-
Mail is straight swap, Schultz to Collingwood in return , Straunnie :thumbsup
jack
how are things?
have you still got a job?
;)
Punt Road next year :thumbsup
back pocket?
I heard Knighter saying that he offered Gary Ayres the postion of Opposition Analyst but he declined - so maybe there's a position still available there Jack?
-
Forgot to say Denham on KB this morning mentioned a story out of left field where the Hawks allegedly tested the trade waters with Roughead but his family got wind of it and the Hawks had to promise to them that Roughead will never be traded. Interesting!
-
Forgot to say Denham on KB this morning mentioned a story out of left field where the Hawks allegedly tested the trade waters with Roughead but his family got wind of it and the Hawks had to promise to them that Roughead will never be traded. Interesting!
Imagine all the Hawk fans on BF reactions if Roughead ever ended up at Richmond via the PSD :lol.
-
Trading places:
afl.com.au
Injuries to key big men highlighted the lack of depth in the Tigers’ ruck division which they appear likely to try and address over trade week. Ben Hudson and John Meesen want out of Adelaide but both appear headed elsewhere, while Steven King’s stocks rose considerably after a good Grand Final showing.
South Australians Danny Meyer and Jay Schulz were mentioned as possible parts of a deal when the Crows loomed as a trading partner and they may still find their way home in what figures to be an active trade week, with Eagle Mitch Morton also appealing to the Tigers.
http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=52083
-
Forgot to say Denham on KB this morning mentioned a story out of left field where the Hawks allegedly tested the trade waters with Roughead but his family got wind of it and the Hawks had to promise to them that Roughead will never be traded. Interesting!
Yeah on Sport927 it was suggested by their roving reporter Whitey (I think it is Chris but I'm not sure) that the Bulldogs were interested in one of the Hawks your forwards and it wasn't Franklin - prepared to deal their first round pick he suggested. McGuane said Roughhead? and Whitey said "yeah could be"
Now that would be funny :lol :rollin
-
I heard Knighter saying that he offered Gary Ayres the postion of Opposition Analyst but he declined - so maybe there's a position still available there Jack?
Yeah heard that one too mjs.
Knights said Ayres would be leaving because he doesn't fit into the structure he is putting in place for 2008. Knights also said Dean Wallis was going as well.
Hmmm... all those quality folks at the Bombers are getting the flick ;)
-
ummmmmmmmmmmmmm
-
ummmmmmmmmmmmmm
:rollin :rollin
Seriously, not surprised by the Ayres thing but certainly was surprised when Knights said Wallis didn't fit into his plans and structure either.
Real question Jack not tryng to be a smart alec - is Wallis any good as an assistant?
-
Answer NO!
Anyway, he was gone four weeks ago.
Best mates with Harvey and was always going to Freo.
Gary Ayres runs a bottle shop in middle park and that takes up a fair bit of his time,
-
ummmmmmmmmmmmmm
:rollin :rollin
Seriously, not surprised by the Ayres thing but certainly was surprised when Knights said Wallis didn't fit into his plans and structure either.
Real question Jack not tryng to be a smart alec - is Wallis any good as an assistant?
:rollin Wallis is the LAST person you should ask Jack about WP :rollin
-
Now that Wallis is gone you will be able to go on the books Jack :shh
Dont be surprised to see Chris Bond at Windy Hill next season as an assistant to Knighter.
-
ummmmmmmmmmmmmm
:rollin :rollin
Seriously, not surprised by the Ayres thing but certainly was surprised when Knights said Wallis didn't fit into his plans and structure either.
Real question Jack not tryng to be a smart alec - is Wallis any good as an assistant?
:rollin Wallis is the LAST person you should ask Jack about WP :rollin
Very funny mjs, I might intimidate you if you dont watch out mjs :lol
-
get with it Bull - Bondy has taken up a job at Freo
-
Now that Wallis is gone you will be able to go on the books Jack :shh
Dont be surprised to see Chris Bond at Windy Hill next season as an assistant to Knighter.
Bondy has gone to Freo with Harvey
-
:rollin Wallis is the LAST person you should ask Jack about WP :rollin
Well I don't know the "ins & outs" of the EFC mjs - Jack does ;D
Shouldn't you be at the Dons' B&F Jack :lol :rollin
-
Gary Ayres runs a bottle shop in middle park and that takes up a fair bit of his time,
Gary should open another one - he'll have plenty of time to promote the Penfolds, the Jacobs Creeks, the Yarra Ridges, the Yalumbas et al.
-
Didnt want to go.- Mrs didnt want to go,she is still a tiger and so am i
Midweek isnt my go anyway.- Management meeting all day tomorrow.
At least staff rates are alot cheaper than the RFC offer, lol
-
Bombers will make a counter offer tomorrow, still yet to sign with Freo. :banghead ::)
-
Re Bondy
It's incredibly difficult to land a senior AFL coaching job and you only get a couple of goes at it - if you miss out you just fall away and Bondy appears to have missed his chance - like Royal, Longmire (hot last year, stone cold this year) and I suspect Sumich. There are some great contenders out there - where were they when we managed to jag Spud?
-
There are some great contenders out there - where were they when we managed to jag Spud?
They were there in 1999 (Sheedy, Malthouse, Thompson, etc) but they all rejected us at the time. No surprise as we were up to our 4th coach in 5 years ::). Only Spud and Tony Elshaug wanted the Richmond gig and we chose Spud.
-
Cameron Wood looks likely to be involved in a trade, but Brisbane want a first round draft selection.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/clubs-chase-brisbane-ruckman/2007/10/03/1191091193760.html
-
One of King or Blake could also be looking for a new home. Blake didn't attend yesterday street parade when the club was expecting him to be there.
Blake will have no difficulty finding a suitor, with a complicating factor in both players' contracts being that Richmond and Carlton are among clubs keenest to recruit a ruck and they hold picks one and two in the pre-season draft.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/king-v-blake-round-two/2007/10/04/1191091199290.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1
Sydney are after Demon Brad Miller.
The Swans also had an interest in Geelong's out-of-contract midfielder Kane Tenace and Brisbane defender/midfielder Justin Sherman, who is contracted to the Lions for another two years.
Sydney believe they will hold onto Darren Jolly. Offered him a 4-year contract.
Hasleby and Freo are still at loggerheads over his pay which has been slashed in half by Freo. So Hasleby could finish up in the PSD.
Mitch Hahn, Jordan McMahon and Sam Power are out of contract at the Doggies. Power has requested he wants to be traded.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22526442-5012432,00.html
-
Cameron Wood looks likely to be involved in a trade, but Brisbane want a first round draft selection.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/clubs-chase-brisbane-ruckman/2007/10/03/1191091193760.html
i would give up 18 for Wood. Alternatively Raines or McGuane in a straight swap.
-
egan wasnt atthe parade either at the cattery, but no one is speculating that he is leaving, maybe we should start a rumor that blake and egan are coming our way lol
i dont think we need blake btw, imo, i reckon gus has more upside than graham
-
egan wasnt atthe parade either at the cattery, but no one is speculating that he is leaving, maybe we should start a rumor that blake and egan are coming our way lol
i dont think we need blake btw, imo, i reckon gus has more upside than graham
Blake is average. PASS!
-
egan wasnt atthe parade either at the cattery, but no one is speculating that he is leaving, maybe we should start a rumor that blake and egan are coming our way lol
i dont think we need blake btw, imo, i reckon gus has more upside than graham
Blake is average. PASS!
i agree, blake is just a knobel, a good tap ruckman, then again, he isnt even as good as knobel cos at least knobel wasnt a bad kick and wasnt scared to put his bosy in and take a mark.
blake has been arround 4 a few yrs now and really, was carried by a good team until king was fit.
imo, if we could get king real cheap for a 2 yr contract, i say why not
-
One of King or Blake could also be looking for a new home. Blake didn't attend yesterday street parade when the club was expecting him to be there.
Blake will have no difficulty finding a suitor, with a complicating factor in both players' contracts being that Richmond and Carlton are among clubs keenest to recruit a ruck and they hold picks one and two in the pre-season draft.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/king-v-blake-round-two/2007/10/04/1191091199290.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1
Sydney are after Demon Brad Miller.
The Swans also had an interest in Geelong's out-of-contract midfielder Kane Tenace and Brisbane defender/midfielder Justin Sherman, who is contracted to the Lions for another two years.
Sydney believe they will hold onto Darren Jolly. Offered him a 4-year contract.
Hasleby and Freo are still at loggerheads over his pay which has been slashed in half by Freo. So Hasleby could finish up in the PSD.
Mitch Hahn, Jordan McMahon and Sam Power are out of contract at the Doggies. Power has requested he wants to be traded.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22526442-5012432,00.html
My god. Swannies are still trying to top up.
They are really leading themselves into massive problems. :shh
And then watch them whinge when they do and the AFL come to the rescue. ::)
-
latest news is that if the blues dont cough up pick 1, judd is heading to richmond
fact :thumbsup
bookmark this post ;)
-
Have we found a benefactor to cough up to pay Judds wages lol?
And yes I believe Blaisee that we are a chance. A small chance, but a chance nevertheless.
-
latest news is that if the blues dont cough up pick 1, judd is heading to richmond
fact :thumbsup
bookmark this post ;)
starting rumours Blaisee ;D
its a fight between Pratt & McGuire who have the most to offer Miss Twigley in her career
-
Have we found a benefactor to cough up to pay Judds wages lol?
And yes I believe Blaisee that we are a chance. A small chance, but a chance nevertheless.
i would say we are 50/50 chance
kb this morning made it quite clear that miller made it aware to him off air that "we are working really hard at tigerland"
believe me, i dont know who blaisees mail is , but im with blaisee, judd in black and yellow is looking more promising by the day....the hour....the minute
go tigers do ur stuff
-
because im a pessimist on these things im saying about 10% chance ... at the moment ;D
-
latest news is that if the blues dont cough up pick 1, judd is heading to richmond
fact :thumbsup
bookmark this post ;)
So it should cost those tanking bastards pick 1. Throw in pick 3 to boot.
Judd is a gun & I hope the Weagles stick to theirs.
Otherwise welcome to Richmond Chris Judd. 8)
-
Hasleby has decided to stay at Freo.
http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=52138
-
Hasleby has decided to stay at Freo.
http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=52138
he took a major pay cut, showed some character, now i hope his back degenerates ;D
-
Hasleby has decided to stay at Freo.
http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=52138
he took a major pay cut, showed some character, now i hope his back degenerates ;D
i think the whole salary cap issues is a non issue at punt road because as i look down the list outside of N.Brown no other player would be on a good pay packet.
i say we have plenty of cash up our sleeve dont worry about that..
-
You would certainly think so ......
-
X l be glad if your right l'd get on the Judd wagon as well as long as his fit & plays not sit in the stand for long periods
RFC with money l think its going into the Tigerland Project if ya'll lucky you be in the footpath
-
On top of Judd, Carlton are also chasing after out of contract Saint Steven Baker. They also chased Matt Maguire.
-
On top of Judd, Carlton are also chasing after out of contract Saint Steven Baker. They also chased Matt Maguire.
The Saints have re-signed Baker. A PM told me Milne is staying at the Saints as well.
-
From today's Age and Australian ...
Darren Jolly has re-signed with the Swans on a 4-year deal. We were one of six clubs who showed interested in him but he's off the market.
There's expected to be a frenzy over ruckmen until the end of trade week. Ben Hudson, John Meesen, Cameron Wood plus either Steven King or Mark Blake up for grabs. St Kilda is interested in King.
There's also been a flood of interested for Hawk forward Tim Boyle who is contracted. The Australian says 6 clubs are interested but didn't name them. The Hawks are looking to upgrade their first pick as well as find a key defender.
The Roos have looked for buyers for Leigh Brown (contracted) but have had no takers. Similarly there's been no takers for Demon Travis Johnstone.
-
KB reckons the Pies and us are after Wood.
-
Jolly 4 years! :o
Geez if you were a tall youngster, you'd be looking to become a ruckman in the AFL.
Seems to be a genuine lack of quality rucks around and I'd imagine those that are decent are getting well rewarded financially.
-
Jolly 4 years! :o
Geez if you were a tall youngster, you'd be looking to become a ruckman in the AFL.
Seems to be a genuine lack of quality rucks around and I'd imagine those that are decent are getting well rewarded financially.
Yep these long-term contracts seem to becoming more common for ruckmen. 4-years is probably the only way Jolly was going to stay in Sydney.
-
Crow Marty Mattner likely to be traded to Sydney.
Reported on Fox Sports.
-
Day 1 summary of trade week
* Hudson is seeking a move to the Western Bulldogs, with the Crows wanting the Bulldogs' second round draft pick (No.22) in return, but the `Dogs are unwilling to give that up.
* Adelaide want Melbourne's second round choice (No.21) for Meesen, but the Demons have only offered their third round pick (No.37).
* Brisbane coach Leigh Matthews said several clubs had inquired about Wood, but so far had not offered anything that interested the Lions.
* Sydney expect to secure Adelaide running defender Martin Mattner, possibly in return for their second round pick (No.28)
* The Swans are also keen to acquire Melbourne key position player Brad Miller.
* Hawthorn have opened the door to negotiating on key forward Tim Boyle, after receiving some inquiries, but player personnel manager Chris Pelchen said they would not be "pushing anyone out the door".
* Melbourne have received little interest in silky midfielder Travis Johnstone, despite floating his name in discussions.
* The Bulldogs have expressed interest in Port Adelaide key forward Damon White, but the Power say they expect to keep him.
* Essendon coach Matthew Knights says the Bombers have received some expressions of interest in big man Kepler Bradley and utility Mark Johnson.
http://wwos.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=303337
-
More Day 1 trade talk...
* Kangaroos are after out of contract Lion Troy Selwood.
* The Roos have also offered a 3rd or 4th round pick for Bulldog Sam Power.
* Carlton and Freo have shown an interest Lion Richard Hadley, who is out of contract.
* Melbourne have put both Travis Johnstone and Nathan Carroll up for trade.
* Port's Brad Symes may also be on the move.
* Geelong indicated yesterday that they are prepared to discuss Charlie Gardiner, Henry Playfair and Kane Tenace.
* Mitch Hahn remains out of contract at Whitten Oval and is considering a three-year offer. It is understood the Brisbane Lions have shown interest, but the tough forward is expected to stay put.
* Hawthorn has put a second-round price on the head of forward Tim Boyle.
* Essendon's Kepler Bradley, 21, has what looks to be a prohibitive first-round price attached to his future, with Essendon, who drafted him three years ago with pick six, maintaining that nothing less than a late first-round selection will enable him to move.
* Wingman Ricky Dyson received strong interest, while veteran defender Mark Johnson was being linked with Port Adelaide and Fremantle.
* The Dockers, who fielded interest in forward Ryan Murphy and Byron Schammer, are one of the clubs interested in Dyson.
-
* Essendon's Kepler Bradley, 21, has what looks to be a prohibitive first-round price attached to his future, with Essendon, who drafted him three years ago with pick six, maintaining that nothing less than a late first-round selection will enable him to move.
lol
Keep him then Bumbers! :lol
-
* Essendon's Kepler Bradley, 21, has what looks to be a prohibitive first-round price attached to his future, with Essendon, who drafted him three years ago with pick six, maintaining that nothing less than a late first-round selection will enable him to move.
lol
Keep him then Bumbers! :lol
I was on the floor too wayne when I read that this morning :ROTFL.
I'm surprised Johns isn't listed as a first rounder by the Bombers too :rollin.
-
Thats why West Coast want pick one so they can ontrade it to Essendon with their first pick for Johns and Bradley
-
* Essendon's Kepler Bradley, 21, has what looks to be a prohibitive first-round price attached to his future, with Essendon, who drafted him three years ago with pick six, maintaining that nothing less than a late first-round selection will enable him to move.
lol
Keep him then Bumbers! :lol
I was on the floor too wayne when I read that this morning :ROTFL.
I'm surprised Johns isn't listed as a first rounder by the Bombers too :rollin.
lmao Knighter. :scream
-
Day 2 summary of trade week
* Carlton and Hawthorn are thinking swapping Bret Thorton and Tim Boyle.
* St Kilda has shown interest in Steven King for their pick 26.
* Cameron Wood seems destined for Collingwood, in exchange for the Magpies' first-round selection, pick 14, which the Lions may on-trade to Melbourne for midfielder Travis Johnstone.
* Dockers like Mark Johnson at the right price and fellow Bomber Ricky Dyson.
* Several clubs seeking versatile forward Ryan Murphy.
* Bombers want a late first round pick for Bradley. They will deal Bradley in exchange for the Kangaroos' second-round selection, No. 32, or Fremantle's second-round selection, No. 24. A third-round selection is more likely.
-
* Carlton and Hawthorn are thinking swapping Bret Thorton and Tim Boyle.
Last time I checked, Thornton was the only backman Carlton had??!!
-
* Cameron Wood seems destined for Collingwood, in exchange for the Magpies' first-round selection, pick 14, which the Lions may on-trade to Melbourne for midfielder Travis Johnstone.
?? Weird!
-
* Carlton and Hawthorn are thinking swapping Bret Thorton and Tim Boyle.
Last time I checked, Thornton was the only backman Carlton had??!!
The Blues seem to think O'hAilpin and Jake Edwards can hold down their key defensive posts or least are better options than Thorton. If they get any injuries they'll be stuffed.
-
on bf, in the judd thread , a few posters have claimed a deal has been done. will be announced b4 5pm today. pick 1 , 20 and jk for judd
if this is the case, wce owe us big time
-
Ch 10 says Schneider will be traded from the Swans to the Saints for a second round pick.
-
Ch 7 had something like
Collingwood - Cam Wood
Brisbane - Rhyce Shaw, Travis Johnstone?
Melbourne - Pick 14
Schneider swap for Saint Leigh Fisher
-
Jay Schulz to Port
Pick 16 to Richmond
Source- 3aw
-
Jay Schulz to Port
Pick 16 to Richmond
Source- 3aw
thats ok
-
Jay Schulz to Port
Pick 16 to Richmond
Source- 3aw
thats ok
good result for all concerned, schulz was never gonna make it with us at Port hes a chance and we get a pick at 16.
-
Jay Schulz to Port
Pick 16 to Richmond
Source- 3aw
thats ok
Im not sure thats right.
I heard it was a second rounder but Ill sit on my hands.
1st rounder sounds too good to be true.
-
3aw said the Cam Wood trade is:
Collingwood - Cam Wood
Brisbane - Travis Johnstone
Melbourne - Pick 14, Rhyce Shaw
Pies are desperate for a ruckman giving up pick 14 + a player for one.
-
3aw said Brock McLean has re-signed with the Dees. Nathan Carroll is still uncontracted.
-
We dont wont Nathan Carroll thats for sure
-
3aw said Brock McLean has re-signed with the Dees. Nathan Carroll is still uncontracted.
sh it
-
We dont wont Nathan Carroll thats for sure
Second that!
Pity about McLean.... did they say re-signed or resigned?? :pray
-
Melbourne getting pick 14 is a problem because it means they will definately take Rance at 14 if hes available.
-
Jay Schulz to Port
Pick 16 to Richmond
Source- 3aw
i would've been happy with a 4th round pick 70 for this dud but a 1st round is too good to be true..
-
maybe someone will come on and confirm its 16?
-
3aw said the Cam Wood trade is:
Collingwood - Cam Wood
Brisbane - Travis Johnstone
Melbourne - Pick 14, Rhyce Shaw
Pies are desperate for a ruckman giving up pick 14 + a player for one.
Gee way to screw Brisbane over. :lol
-
Summary of Day 3 of trade week...
* Carlton wanted pick 12 off Hawthorn for Bret Thorton. Hawks said they would like to get Thorton but not at that price.
* Freo may offer pick 40 for Kepler Bradley.
* Kangaroo Brad Moran might walk after offer of one-year deal. Interest from Melbourne and Adelaide. The Crows flew him over this week for a medical.
* Roos are likely to give up pick 48 for Bulldog Sam Power.
* Saints want both Adam Schneider and Sean Dempster from the Swans. Leigh Fisher and pick 26 may be used to get them. The Saints may also get Demon Chris Johnson.
* Crow ruckman John Meesen to Melbourne for pick 37.
* Both Adelaide teams interested in Docker Byron Schammer.
* Pies have cut ruckman Guy Richards now that the Cameron Wood trade is close to completion.
Collingwood - Cam Wood (+ maybe swapping pick 31 for the Lions pick 25)
Brisbane - Travis Johnstone
Melbourne - Pick 14, Rhyce Shaw
-
and richmond remain "active"
we better draft well this yr
-
and richmond remain "active"
we better draft well this yr
with what lol...we are gonna give away 2nd rounders for morton maybe mcmahon and god knows what else.
-
and richmond remain "active"
we better draft well this yr
with what lol...we are gonna give away 2nd rounders for morton maybe mcmahon and god knows what else.
hey ramps, no offence , but what p[art of draft well didnt you understand?
i never said we better trade well
i said we better "draft " well, as in pick the right kids and be smart in the national draft
-
and richmond remain "active"
we better draft well this yr
with what lol...we are gonna give away 2nd rounders for morton maybe mcmahon and god knows what else.
hey ramps, no offence , but what p[art of draft well didnt you understand?
i never said we better trade well
i said we better "draft " well, as in pick the right kids and be smart in the national draft
no offence either X but if a club gives away picks under 30 in trades this year in this draft its going to be mighty hard to draft well. I would have thought it goes hand in hand but maybe Im wrong on that.
-
we must not trade away draft picks full stop, we should trade players for better picks, or trade players for players.
we must keep our picks and draft good kids and make no mistakes on national draft day
but miller is out to destroy us
-
I agree thats what I was advocating last night, we should walk away but we wont.
-
I agree thats what I was advocating last night, we should walk away but we wont.
we wont cos miller has an ego and is out to kill us
-
Some caller on SEN reckons another Eagle will end up at the Blues. Ox said is the 3rd letter of his surname "b" and the caller said yep. This would be Embley. Swann said today that despite getting Judd the Blues still have room in their salary cap to pick someone up in the PSD.
-
if they get embly ass well as judd, miller better quit
-
i'd take embley
-
i'd take embley
i would too, but its rumored he will join judd at the blues.
ffs, visy must make alot of money , esp when their proucts are crap!
-
the weird thing was that Judd said he wanted to play in a side that would make the finals soon.
uhhhh, why did you going Carlton then?
Oh that's right Pratt has given you money to wipe your ass with :chuck
-
Collingwood got Cameron Wood for pick 14. One thing Id say about them is that they know what they need and go out and do it. We could have made a play for him as well by offering 18 and seeing if Wood could get Brisbane to hand him over for that. Anyway, what can we say, we'll wait until tomorrow and see what the football department can do.
-
Collingwood got Cameron Wood for pick 14. One thing Id say about them is that they know what they need and go out and do it. We could have made a play for him as well by offering 18 and seeing if Wood could get Brisbane to hand him over for that. Anyway, what can we say, we'll wait until tomorrow and see what the football department can do.
wood should have been our main target :banghead
talented ruckman don't grow on trees :banghead
-
Collingwood got Cameron Wood for pick 14. One thing Id say about them is that they know what they need and go out and do it. We could have made a play for him as well by offering 18 and seeing if Wood could get Brisbane to hand him over for that. Anyway, what can we say, we'll wait until tomorrow and see what the football department can do.
wood should have been our main target :banghead
talented ruckman don't grow on trees :banghead
14 beats 18 any way you look at it. We were never in the hunt if Scumwood were willing to use that pick.
-
the weird thing was that Judd said he wanted to play in a side that would make the finals soon.
uhhhh, why did you going Carlton then?
Oh that's right Pratt has given you money to wipe your ass with :chuck
i agree with u but the blues now will play finals.
it hurts me to say that believe me but i just want one thing and one thing only from now on.
a victory in round 1. thats the only thing that could ease this sour taste in my mouth.
miller couldnt land whitnalls mrs in a dark alley let alone embley.
get rid of him
-
dont worry guys , miller is remaining "active" ::)
-
Collingwood got Cameron Wood for pick 14. One thing Id say about them is that they know what they need and go out and do it. We could have made a play for him as well by offering 18 and seeing if Wood could get Brisbane to hand him over for that. Anyway, what can we say, we'll wait until tomorrow and see what the football department can do.
wood should have been our main target :banghead
talented ruckman don't grow on trees :banghead
14 beats 18 any way you look at it. We were never in the hunt if Scumwood were willing to use that pick.
thats actually true, we have to admit that, but the initial mistake is Wood should have been taken back in 2004. Just disappointing that it seems we cant address some fundamental needs thats all.
-
hey guys latest rumour going around.
miller is in talks with whitnall's manager about offering him a new 3 yeard deal.
would it surprise u if i wasnt kidding..
useless he is
-
the weird thing was that Judd said he wanted to play in a side that would make the finals soon.
uhhhh, why did you going Carlton then?
Oh that's right Pratt has given you money to wipe your ass with :chuck
i agree with u but the blues now will play finals.
it hurts me to say that believe me but i just want one thing and one thing only from now on.
a victory in round 1. thats the only thing that could ease this sour taste in my mouth.
miller couldnt land whitnalls mrs in a dark alley let alone embley.
get rid of him
carlton are dreaming ::)
-
My mail is that Lance will get delisted if not traded ;)
-
My mail is that Lance will get delisted if not traded ;)
and you with such a good track rcord for predictions mail etc.
:thumbsup
-
On Channel 10 news tonight, they said Carlton has offered Lion Josh Drummond one million over the next three years. Another uncontracted player.
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=9152173&postcount=346
-
how much stuffing money do carlscum have in their cap???
what a load of sh it
and btw, is adcock still out of contract
-
how much stuffing money do carlscum have in their cap???
what a load of sh it
and btw, is adcock still out of contract
miller get to work
adcock is a GUN
-
According to someone on Bigfooty 6PR reporting that Mitch Morton could come to us in the PSD. That deserves a tick at this stage. Free player- and havent given up anything.
-
According to someone on Bigfooty 6PR reporting that Mitch Morton could come to us in the PSD. That deserves a tick at this stage. Free player- and havent given up anything.
i thought he was contracted
-
hopefully tomorrow is a good day for RFC and we keep our picks and stuff. Been a long day for me today. Cyas tomorrow.
-
Summary of Day 4 of Trade week
* Lion Richard Hadley may head to Carlton for a late pick.
* Lion Jared Brennan 23-year-old is effectively estranged from the club and the Dons are keen to winkle him out of Brisbane for nothing through the pre-season draft according to the Age. Herald-Sun says the Dogs are also after Brennan but he may remain at Brisbane.
* St Kilda will gets Swans Adam Schneider and Sean Dempster for pick 26.
* Cat Henry Playfair will become a Swan for pick 44.
* Kangaroo Brad Moran seems destined for Adelaide. The 21-year-old agreed to join the Crows yesterday for a two-year contract, subject to a trade being struck. If the Kangaroos do not accept Adelaide's offer of a third-round draft pick, 21-year-old Moran will nominate for the PSD in December when the Crows can claim him at No. 9 pick.
* Fremantle put a three-year offer to Essendon wingman Ricky Dyson. Bombers want pick 24. They are also interested in Kepler Bradley for a late pick or the PSD.
* Adelaide will need to give one of its three 2nd round picks 22, 27 or 28 for Port's Brad Symes.
-
Summary of Day 4 of Trade week
* St Kilda will gets Swans Adam Schneider and Sean Dempster for pick 26.
BARGAIN. Well done Saints. :clapping
* Cat Henry Playfair will become a Swan for pick 44.
About right but not much hope in him.
* Kangaroo Brad Moran seems destined for Adelaide. The 21-year-old agreed to join the Crows yesterday for a two-year contract, subject to a trade being struck. If the Kangaroos do not accept Adelaide's offer of a third-round draft pick, 21-year-old Moran will nominate for the PSD in December when the Crows can claim him at No. 9 pick.
I hope we're onto this.
* Fremantle put a three-year offer to Essendon wingman Ricky Dyson. Bombers want pick 24. They are also interested in Kepler Bradley for a late pick or the PSD.
Lol all at Essendon call him delist material and now they want pick 24. :lol :lol :lol
-
how much stuffing money do carlscum have in their cap???
what a load of sh it
Yes, and why aren't the AFL investigating.
-
how much stuffing money do carlscum have in their cap???
what a load of sh it
Yes, and why aren't the AFL investigating.
maybe like judd, the6y are all becoming "environmental embassodors" for visy :banghead :banghead
-
how much stuffing money do carlscum have in their cap???
what a load of sh it
Yes, and why aren't the AFL investigating.
ill tell u why cause demetriou has his hand up his date trying to find out ways to make more money for himself.
ill tell u what he is the biggest rot on our game that ugly f.ukwit
never admits he was wrong and will never investigate those cheating pricks cause the tanking issue will come up again and according to him..thats not a issue
-
Well I'm not as eloquent as you but yep you've nailed it on the head.
-
My mail is that Lance will get delisted if not traded ;)
Read todays paper
-
My mail is that Lance will get delisted if not traded ;)
Read todays paper
Don't get the paper delivered for another hour, fill me in.
;)
-
Funny 1965, we cancelled our delivery due to them being delievered too late, go down and get it now.
Lance got delisted last night
-
Funny 1965, we cancelled our delivery due to them being delievered too late, go down and get it now.
Lance got delisted last night
everyone makes fun and jokes about lance, but he was a damn good player.
its a shame he had all those weight issues, but if and i know it is a big if, but if he got his body right , he would be a gr8 aquisition. can play fwd, back, and is a very smart footballer
shame his body is rooted
-
Funny 1965, we cancelled our delivery due to them being delievered too late, go down and get it now.
Lance got delisted last night
everyone makes fun and jokes about lance, but he was a damn good player.
its a shame he had all those weight issues, but if and i know it is a big if, but if he got his body right , he would be a gr8 aquisition. can play fwd, back, and is a very smart footballer
shame his body is rooted
sounds like you sympathise with the weight issue a bit?
:weights
-
Funny 1965, we cancelled our delivery due to them being delievered too late, go down and get it now.
Lance got delisted last night
everyone makes fun and jokes about lance, but he was a damn good player.
its a shame he had all those weight issues, but if and i know it is a big if, but if he got his body right , he would be a gr8 aquisition. can play fwd, back, and is a very smart footballer
shame his body is rooted
sounds like you sympathise with the weight issue a bit?
:weights
not the weight, my weight is fine, but the knees yes, my knees are cactus, had 3 recos already
-
not the weight, my weight is fine, but the knees yes, my knees are cactus, had 3 recos already
[/quote]
Too much Netball can do that to you.
;D
-
Lance was at his best when McDonalds sponsored the match day balls. :lol When they took the golden arch off the ball , he was lost, he lost his appetetite :lol
-
Lachlan Hansen on his way to Punt Rd in 12 months lol...just a rumour Ill start now.
-
Lachlan Hansen on his way to Punt Rd in 12 months lol...just a rumour Ill start now.
I'm sure Supertiger on BF will start that rumour soon and SEN will run with it come trade week 2008 :lol.
-
Supertiger likes to pinch my material lol ... If I find out who he is Ill be sending him for a consultation to the psychologists as well. We're gonna be one big happy family there lol. Does anyone know if they do bulk billing?