One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: {X} on September 21, 2007, 05:13:01 PM

Title: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: {X} on September 21, 2007, 05:13:01 PM

judd, mclean and maguire all enter the psd?

i personally think mclean should be our priority.

so i hope we get maguire through a trade deal.

thus if judd and mclean are in the psd, who do we take, imo, i belive mclean would be much better 4 us, and he has family ties to our club

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: Ramps on September 21, 2007, 05:13:55 PM

mclean for me as well

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: wayne on September 21, 2007, 05:18:32 PM

I would strike off Maguire immediately.

Then out of the other two, it's a lot harder...

I'd have to lean towards a fit Judd...

I know it's hypothetical, but is McLean out of contract.. anyone  :pray

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: mightytiges on September 21, 2007, 05:41:32 PM

Agree with getting Maguire through a trade if either of the other two are available for the PSD.

McLean is 2.5 years younger but Judd is the classier footballer and having just turned 24 he's still young enough so I'd go for Judd. Judd's a goalkicking midfielder too.

Mind you if the choice came down to either Judd or McLean I'd be a very very happy Tiger supporter. You can't really lose either way (touchwood no serious injury).

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: bluey_21 on September 21, 2007, 05:43:29 PM

is mclean even out of contract?

for me, Mclean would be better as we need tough nuts

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: Mr Magic on September 21, 2007, 06:21:44 PM

Judd by a freakin' country mile.

He's just as capable of winning the hard ball as Brock.

Judd is the consummate team player as well.

Averages a higher tackle count than anyone on our list by some distance.

JUDD!

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: WilliamPowell on September 22, 2007, 09:28:24 AM

Judd!

Simple you don't knock back on of the best player in the comp for nothing

Besides if after 12 months it's not working - you can trade  ;D

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: wayne on September 22, 2007, 10:34:59 AM

Quote from: WilliamPowell on September 22, 2007, 09:28:24 AM

Besides if after 12 months it's not working - you can trade  ;D

Now that's some good thinking WP  :lol

Get Cotchin and Judd, Lids and Tambling come on and become AA next season, we trade Judd for pick 1 and 2 in the draft, so we have 1,2 and 16  ;)

Title: Re: hypothetical, ....what do we do if?
Post by: Gracie on September 22, 2007, 11:06:41 AM

Win 4 games or less next year we have picks 1,2 and 18  :(