One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Ox on November 10, 2007, 07:05:27 PM

Title: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Ox on November 10, 2007, 07:05:27 PM
You got me excited earlier when u said Johnson would retire.

Story ??
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: mightytiges on November 10, 2007, 07:36:25 PM
There were rumours with 2-3 rounds left that Sugar was perhaps going to retire but he would have announced it by now if he was. There was another rumour saying he may step down as captain in favour of Newy but that's most likely crap also.

Sugar also needs just 2 more games to reach his 100th game with Richmond. Make sure we're eligible for any Father-Sons.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Ox on November 10, 2007, 08:34:56 PM
There were rumours with 2-3 rounds left that Sugar was perhaps going to retire but he would have announced it by now if he was. There was another rumour saying he may step down as captain in favour of Newy but that's most likely crap also.

Sugar also needs just 2 more games to reach his 100th game with Richmond. Make sure we're eligible for any Father-Sons.

lol.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: blx on November 11, 2007, 01:03:50 AM
The good part is he might just play his hundredth then retire.

The bad part is the AFL will probobly reset the number of games to 150 the year we don't want them to.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Francois Jackson on November 11, 2007, 04:08:47 PM
one can only hope.


if richmond had half a brain they would take the captaincy away from him and give it to bowden or someone.

this guy can play but the added presure of a captaincy has taken away the skills he once had at adelaide
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Mini Tiger on November 11, 2007, 07:04:35 PM
So some really think the Captaincy has hindered KJ so much that it takes away from his footy

 :rollin

Anyways, I hope he plays next year out as non captain and retires after that.

Bowden for Captain, 2008. Actually, Brown suits the number 17, maybe give it to him. Actually, I think the pressure of the captaincy would be too much for both of these guys, give it to someone that has no pressure, like, Richo or Newman or Tuck...  :P
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Francois Jackson on November 11, 2007, 07:45:08 PM
to some extent i do yes but i really think he is just a average player at punt road and one who needs to give it away next year if we are any chance to progress with youth.

seriously all these younger guys on our list how do you think they feel when they see their captain kick it straight into the arms of josh drummond or fev or whoever else he did it to this year.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: wayne on November 12, 2007, 09:16:54 AM
One thing that sticks out from KJ was against the Pies, in a tight spot, drew a couple of Pies players and threaded a handball through to Foley I think and he was miles in the clear.

That was brilliant footy, and shows he has a great footy brain. Maybe he just had a bad year. 
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: richmondrules on November 12, 2007, 11:11:51 AM
One thing that sticks out from KJ was against the Pies, in a tight spot, drew a couple of Pies players and threaded a handball through to Foley I think and he was miles in the clear.

That was brilliant footy, and shows he has a great footy brain. Maybe he just had a bad year. 

That's what I'm hoping.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Francois Jackson on November 12, 2007, 03:58:07 PM
thats all good and well but these young kids need a leader. a guy who can lift them when there down.

he aint the one for that. no where near what a captain should be. thats why i want to see without the captaincy and i bet you will see a different KJ
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: retygas on November 12, 2007, 04:21:55 PM
I for one don't think that I would want any offspring from a dud like Kane Johnson. So let him retire before the father and son rule can come into affect. Leave him on 99 games. I think he is the most worthless player on our list and to have that as a captain no wonder we finished where we did. But I don't place all the blame on him as its a team sports but in that we need a good leader and he is far from that and I to would like to see Browny with it or Bowden.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: mightytiges on November 12, 2007, 05:41:37 PM
If there is a change in the captaincy then I'd like to see a generational change. Someone outside the four Plough originally chose the captain from.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: Francois Jackson on November 12, 2007, 08:00:53 PM
I for one don't think that I would want any offspring from a dud like Kane Johnson. So let him retire before the father and son rule can come into affect. Leave him on 99 games. I think he is the most worthless player on our list and to have that as a captain no wonder we finished where we did. But I don't place all the blame on him as its a team sports but in that we need a good leader and he is far from that and I to would like to see Browny with it or Bowden.

here here

team sport it maybe but it doesnt help when ur leader is useless and kicks it the opposite way a few times a game.

cant wait till someone bags me for writing this but ill fight this argument till the cows come home. this guy is not a leader and if u want to move forward it must be without him..FACT

Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: mightytiges on November 13, 2007, 01:47:45 PM
We're not exactly overflowing with obvious on-field leaders to choose from though :-\.
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: {X} on November 13, 2007, 04:03:14 PM
keep sugar as captain for 1 more yr

i dont rate him as a captain but i think sugar should remain captain

i wanna see deledio be a vc next yr and do a leadership apprenticeship then be captain the following yr
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: WilliamPowell on November 13, 2007, 04:06:28 PM
Well I can report  ;D that Sugar appears in the 2008 membership brochure twice (including the front cover) so I think it safe to assume that he aint retiring  :thumbsup

Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: tiga on November 13, 2007, 04:13:53 PM
Question: Can you be a captain whilst sitting on the bench permanently for a season? If so I'd be in favour
of Captain Splenda having one more year. Give him a megaphone (supplied by Dick Smith of course) to bark instructions, and only send him on if someone suffers a game ending injury.  :thumbsup
That way he will be able to spur on the boys without us having to endure the sideshow that is Kane Johnson's deplorable disposal skills.  :pray
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: {X} on November 13, 2007, 05:15:40 PM
Question: Can you be a captain whilst sitting on the bench permanently for a season? If so I'd be in favour
of Captain Splenda having one more year. Give him a megaphone (supplied by Dick Smith of course) to bark instructions, and only send him on if someone suffers a game ending injury.  :thumbsup
That way he will be able to spur on the boys without us having to endure the sideshow that is Kane Johnson's deplorable disposal skills.  :pray

our last premiership captain played on the bench lol
Title: Re: Sugar retiring or what Jak ?
Post by: mightytiges on November 13, 2007, 07:07:20 PM
Question: Can you be a captain whilst sitting on the bench permanently for a season? If so I'd be in favour
of Captain Splenda having one more year. Give him a megaphone (supplied by Dick Smith of course) to bark instructions, and only send him on if someone suffers a game ending injury.  :thumbsup
That way he will be able to spur on the boys without us having to endure the sideshow that is Kane Johnson's deplorable disposal skills.  :pray

our last premiership captain played on the bench lol
;D