One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on June 01, 2008, 05:13:34 PM
-
What changes will/should be made after today's debacle?
Fire away.
-
B: King, Thursfield, Moore
HB: Newman, Schulz, McMahon
C: Richardson, Deledio, Polo
HF: Pettifer, Bowden, Cotchin
F: Brown, Riewoldt, Morton
FOLL: Simmonds, Tambling, Foley
I/C: Pattison, White, Polak, Edwards
EMG: Tuck, Collins, Tivendale
IN:Polo, Polak, Morton
OUT: Hyde, Tuck, Johnson
-
Out
Pettifer, Bowden, Hyde, Tuck, McMahon, Shultz
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Rance, Connors, Raines
-
Out
Pettifer, Bowden, Hyde, Tuck, McMahon, Shultz
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Rance, Connors, Raines
Ok Bowden and Shultz were in the top 5 or 6 players so they are not going anywhere. Rance has not show enough yet, Connors not ready and Raines even said himeslf he needs to get some miles in his legs before ready. The rest I can see. Think we will see Sugar out so there could be up to 4 changes, I still need to think about who exactly.
-
B: McGuane, Thursfield, Moore
HB: Collins, Schulz, Polo
C: Richardson, Deledio, Newman
HF: Tambling, Polak, Cotchin
F: Brown, Riewoldt, Morton
FOLL: Pattison, White, Foley
I/C: Simmonds, Edwards, Oakley-Nicholls, Connors
EMG: Tivendale, Rance, Hughes
IN: Polo, Polak, Morton, Collins, Oakley-Nicholls, Connors, McGuane
OUT: McMahon, Tuck, Pettifer, Bowden, Johnson (injured), Hyde, King
Likely changes though:
Out: Riewoldt, Edwards, White
In: Polak, Tivendale, McGuane
-
Out
Pettifer, Bowden, Hyde, Tuck, McMahon, Shultz
Bit harsh there torch
Don't know what it looked like on the TV but at the crappy SCG Schulz was one of better players yesterday - one of just a handful I might add
-
The game starts with the bouncing of the ball!!!
That's where you should look first,
Our undersized ruckmen are being smashed at the bounce by their taller opponents.
This puts the midfielders under immediate pressure that follows on throught the team
-
Pettifer, Hyde, Johnson,
Morton, Polo, McGaune
-
Pettifer, Hyde, Johnson,
Morton, Polo, McGaune
I agree. Though we would be losing two midfielders - 1 tagger and 1 In & Under type - so Jackson could be in instead of McGuane.
Stripes
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
jack is too slow tigeralive and i agree with TM on one thing especially.
i think its time to blood another ruckman and send patto to Coburg for a few weeks. we need to get some games into someone else other than him.
i mean if one of simmo or patto go down we r screwed and i dont believe he deserves his spot, far from it.
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
jack is too slow tigeralive and i agree with TM on one thing especially.
i think its time to blood another ruckman and send patto to Coburg for a few weeks. we need to get some games into someone else other than him.
i mean if one of simmo or patto go down we r screwed and i dont believe he deserves his spot, far from it.
Jack is always going to be slow. He has a smart football game and has a good crack for a 19yo trying to play CHF in a rubbish side. Should be played till the end of the season.
Pattison is a plodder but we don't have any other real options. Graham is big but a wacko who cant kick. Cartledge got delisted before laycock... IF you want to drop patto play Polak as the 2nd ruck IMO and promote either McGaune or Hughes.
-
Pattison didnt even play in the ruck as a junior did he?
I always thought he was key forward but was thrown in the ruck because we cant develop any true ruckmen. :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
out
Bowden
Petrified
Cap'n Peepee
In
Morton
Chipendale
Jackson
Polak
What a bonus,being able to dump 3 senior self perservationists in one swift swoop. :thumbsup
-
Pattison didnt even play in the ruck as a junior did he?
I always thought he was key forward but was thrown in the ruck because we cant develop any true ruckmen. :banghead :banghead :banghead
another top 20 draft pick we cant develop.
when we will get it right.
patto is not a 2nd ruck option.
play cartledge and/or graham. throw them in there and see how they go.
we need to take some risks and see who can play. who cares if they seem like there not ready.
take some risks for crying out loud, it cant be any worse than playing pathetic pettifer and co.
-
I would make a number of changes but it sounds like we'll only make the forced change for Sugar.
I was talking with friends about who should come in for Sugar and we all came to conclusion it isn't obvious. Tivs is in-form at Coburg but bringing him back is going back to the past especially is Joel and Petts remain in the side. Jacko's disposal is iffy. Connors isn't match fit. Collo is a show but he didn't do much against Bendigo after coming back into the Coburg seniors. I wouldn't mind seeing Polo come in on the back of 3 decent games in a row in the VFL. Give Deano a role and say go for it.
-
I would make a number of changes but it sounds like we'll only make the forced change for Sugar.
I was talking with friends about who should come in for Sugar and we all came to conclusion it isn't obvious. Tivs is in-form at Coburg but bringing him back is going back to the past especially is Joel and Petts remain in the side. Jacko's disposal is iffy. Connors isn't match fit. Collo is a show but he didn't do much against Bendigo after coming back into the Coburg seniors. I wouldn't mind seeing Polo come in on the back of 3 decent games in a row in the VFL. Give Deano a role and say go for it.
Why not play Morton in the midfeild/wing/HBF and see how he goes.
It's hard to make an impact in a forward pocket in a poor side.
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
l just put down who they could pick from
if you want 4 here they are
Tivendale, replaces Johnson
Morton, replaces Edwards
Graham, replaces Simmonds
Polak replaces Rewoldt
problem with you saying l dont watch football :lol you be surprised, l watch every game & attend several games every week. yes l watched half a Richmond game cause they are ugly l have always said if they display ugly football l would stop watching that game & leave the venue to attend the other or if on the screen change channels cause l been watching the same ugly stuff for years
While you sit in Tassie dribbling on the screen watching Rewoldt ;D thinking his going to become a future star for Richmond :lol let me know when he breaks out. l will come over to Tassie & we can go to a game all on me drinks included & then maybe after that we go across the road & into the gardens & see the monkeys sucking coins l often throw them when going over :rollin
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
-
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
That is absolute garbage. Did you see him as a junior? He was standing out in VFL matches as a 17 y/o. He dominated as an underage player in the U18 champs. He is a different player to Nick and the RFC knew that. He was picked on his own ability. He may not end up at Nick's level but Jack will be a solid AFL footballer by the time he's 22, mark my words.
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
l just put down who they could pick from
if you want 4 here they are
Tivendale, replaces Johnson
Morton, replaces Edwards
Graham, replaces Simmonds
Polak replaces Rewoldt
problem with you saying l dont watch football :lol you be surprised, l watch every game & attend several games every week. yes l watched half a Richmond game cause they are ugly l have always said if they display ugly football l would stop watching that game & leave the venue to attend the other or if on the screen change channels cause l been watching the same ugly stuff for years
While you sit in Tassie dribbling on the screen watching Rewoldt ;D thinking his going to become a future star for Richmond :lol let me know when he breaks out. l will come over to Tassie & we can go to a game all on me drinks included & then maybe after that we go across the road & into the gardens & see the monkeys sucking coins l often throw them when going over :rollin
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
Tiger Monk...take a happy pill...I do not think I have read one post of yours (I am sure you have posted one somewhere) that is positive. Turn the glass is half empty into half full...and to link a young footballer to the Port Arthur tragedy is quite frankly reprehensible.
If you dont like the tigers crap style of play and crap team and crap coach and crap administration...why on earth do you bother to post things about the tigers on here?...or anywhere for that mattr...You sure your not a collingwood supporter in disguise?
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
l just put down who they could pick from
if you want 4 here they are
Tivendale, replaces Johnson
Morton, replaces Edwards
Graham, replaces Simmonds
Polak replaces Rewoldt
problem with you saying l dont watch football :lol you be surprised, l watch every game & attend several games every week. yes l watched half a Richmond game cause they are ugly l have always said if they display ugly football l would stop watching that game & leave the venue to attend the other or if on the screen change channels cause l been watching the same ugly stuff for years
While you sit in Tassie dribbling on the screen watching Rewoldt ;D thinking his going to become a future star for Richmond :lol let me know when he breaks out. l will come over to Tassie & we can go to a game all on me drinks included & then maybe after that we go across the road & into the gardens & see the monkeys sucking coins l often throw them when going over :rollin
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
Ok well at least we have a 22 and I think most are plausible but I'd rather throw young Andrew Collins in than Tiv.
I didnt say he is not setting anything on fire did I, didnt say he played a great game?? :whistle ::)
but he is far from soft. He bashes packs even with his light 19 year old frame.
The only two players I keep an eye on is Birch and Hislop of the Taswegians, I couldn't give a eff about those bloody southerners, wouldnt GAF about Riewoldt if he was at another team. ;D
Lol, the monkey park, I'd like to put Scott Wade in there. He'd fit right in. :rollin
-
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
That is absolute garbage. Did you see him as a junior? He was standing out in VFL matches as a 17 y/o. He dominated as an underage player in the U18 champs. He is a different player to Nick and the RFC knew that. He was picked on his own ability. He may not end up at Nick's level but Jack will be a solid AFL footballer by the time he's 22, mark my words.
SNAP ;D Rewoldt got slammed dunked at the selection table, open your eyes
-
Tiger Monk...take a happy pill...I do not think I have read one post of yours (I am sure you have posted one somewhere) that is positive. Turn the glass is half empty into half full...and to link a young footballer to the Port Arthur tragedy is quite frankly reprehensible.
If you dont like the tigers crap style of play and crap team and crap coach and crap administration...why on earth do you bother to post things about the tigers on here?...or anywhere for that mattr...You sure your not a collingwood supporter in disguise?
Dont see anywhere l wrote about the Port Arthur tragedy in my post, so dont know why you brought it up
Port Arthur is a tourist attraction long before mass murderer Martin Bryant arrived there in fact long before he was born
Go down there have a look for yourself it quite a nice place with a history, The ghost ride has nothing to do with the tragedy there but getting back on track jack got his ass kicked at the selection table last night & wont be long now before you see him down there selling them tickets cause his not a AFL footballer ;D his a good VFL footballer maybe
-
Out
Rewoldt (fragile), Edwards (fragile), Johnson (inj knee) Simmonds (inj knee)
In
Polo, Hughes, Morton, Tivendale, McGuane, Polak, Jackson, Graham (201cm)
Didnt know we could play with a team of 26. :lol
And if you think Jack is fragile then you clearly didnt watch the game, or at least half of it we already know. ::)
l just put down who they could pick from
if you want 4 here they are
Tivendale, replaces Johnson
Morton, replaces Edwards
Graham, replaces Simmonds
Polak replaces Rewoldt
problem with you saying l dont watch football :lol you be surprised, l watch every game & attend several games every week. yes l watched half a Richmond game cause they are ugly l have always said if they display ugly football l would stop watching that game & leave the venue to attend the other or if on the screen change channels cause l been watching the same ugly stuff for years
While you sit in Tassie dribbling on the screen watching Rewoldt ;D thinking his going to become a future star for Richmond :lol let me know when he breaks out. l will come over to Tassie & we can go to a game all on me drinks included & then maybe after that we go across the road & into the gardens & see the monkeys sucking coins l often throw them when going over :rollin
My look on Rewoldt ;D is he was drafted for his name not his talent in hope he would be like cousin Nick which he will never be half, he is fragile & l think he is a average footballer & has that sulky look about him, something footballers like me always liked to play on & smack around. seeing him feeling sorry for his cousin Nicky after the game nearly crying really turned my guts.
ReWoldt will end up at Port Arthur selling tickets for the ghost rides ;D
Ok well at least we have a 22 and I think most are plausible but I'd rather throw young Andrew Collins in than Tiv.
I didnt say he is not setting anything on fire did I, didnt say he played a great game?? :whistle ::)
but he is far from soft. He bashes packs even with his light 19 year old frame.
The only two players I keep an eye on is Birch and Hislop of the Taswegians, I couldn't give a eff about those bloody southerners, wouldnt GAF about Riewoldt if he was at another team. ;D
Lol, the monkey park, I'd like to put Scott Wade in there. He'd fit right in. :rollin
hearing ya Tigersalive, yes he plays well at VFL level & does go for the grab with courage on occassions but its other parts of his game l dont like which l picked up on, his constant walking & give up easy attitude is his problem.
but l beleive he is damaged goods by not being coached properly & its showing out greatly from what he was mocked up to be as a junior, who fault is that l give ya one guess ;D but the axe fell on him & should have a few weeks ago.
Tivs well his a good lad, been here in my home, his been doing the work & deserves to be promoted rightly.
now who is this Scott Wade who you like to put in with the monkeys ;D